X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Updated Starting Pitcher Rankings - 5x5 Roto (Mixed Leagues)

We're back up on the bump for this edition of our mixed rankings analysis, and not a moment too soon. The 2019 baseball season is already here! RotoBaller writers Nick Mariano, JB Branson, Bill Dubiel, Pierre Camus, and Scott Engel want to make sure you are prepared for last-minute drafts, so they have given their preseason rankings a final update. Check out our fantasy baseball rankings dashboard for a current list any time.

Starting pitching may be one of your first priorities on draft day, as there can be a pretty significant drop-off after the first few true aces. That doesn't mean there aren't great values to be found in later rounds--in fact, if you decide to wait on starting pitcher there are enough mid-tier options to round out a pretty competitive staff.

Without any more delay, let's break down the 2019 starting pitcher rankings for March.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:

 

Starting Pitcher Tiered Ranks - 5x5 Mixed Leagues (March)

In case you missed it, our very own "Big Pick Nick" Mariano was recently named the #1 overall most accurate industry expert ranker for the 2018 season. You can see his secret sauce below! Additionally, industry legend Scott Engel recently joined the RotoBaller team and provides his insights as well. Scott is an FSWA Hall Of Famer and award winner.

Rank Tier Player Position Nick Pierre Bill JB Scott Auction $
1 1 Max Scherzer SP 6 3 6 5 10 37
2 1 Chris Sale SP 14 7 12 9 14 37
3 1 Jacob deGrom SP 9 12 14 11 11 33
4 2 Justin Verlander SP 19 24 21 25 23 32
5 2 Corey Kluber SP 33 32 19 23 24 28
6 2 Aaron Nola SP 37 21 22 20 31 27
7 2 Gerrit Cole SP 23 28 27 29 28 27
8 2 Blake Snell SP 38 34 35 31 32 26
9 2 Noah Syndergaard SP 35 27 44 40 33 26
10 2 Trevor Bauer SP 21 36 37 27 58 24
11 2 Carlos Carrasco SP 34 46 41 44 34 23
12 3 Walker Buehler SP 44 48 55 34 56 23
13 3 Stephen Strasburg SP 53 38 58 54 70 21
14 3 Zack Greinke SP 54 57 62 60 41 19
15 3 James Paxton SP 50 83 53 57 52 19
16 3 Patrick Corbin SP 51 71 54 52 68 17
17 3 Mike Clevinger SP 57 54 73 59 59 17
18 3 Jameson Taillon SP 63 76 71 63 74 17
19 4 Clayton Kershaw SP 91 86 28 74 71 15
20 4 Luis Severino SP 79 98 60 89 53 15
21 4 Jose Berrios SP 73 49 88 78 100 14
22 4 Jack Flaherty SP 78 79 77 76 80 14
23 4 Zack Wheeler SP 64 135 72 67 54 14
24 4 David Price SP 87 64 70 81 97 14
25 4 Miles Mikolas SP 90 58 83 95 112 13
26 4 German Marquez SP 74 118 87 85 122 13
27 4 Masahiro Tanaka SP 106 87 75 126 114 13
28 4 Mike Foltynewicz SP 124 126 97 127 98 13
29 5 Kyle Hendricks SP 95 116 130 150 115 12
30 5 Yu Darvish SP 126 88 144 135 116 11
31 5 J.A. Happ SP 115 150 109 131 125 10
32 5 Charlie Morton SP 127 146 162 90 107 10
33 5 Madison Bumgarner SP 174 120 136 97 113 10
34 5 Luis Castillo SP 133 121 125 156 154 10
35 5 Robbie Ray SP 134 108 149 154 149 10
36 5 Eduardo Rodriguez SP 148 100 167 139 141 9
37 5 Chris Archer SP 146 129 163 152 134 9
38 5 Nick Pivetta SP 142 122 151 158 162 9
39 5 Cole Hamels SP 155 134 171 177 136 9
40 6 Rich Hill SP 131 235 157 175 123 8
41 6 Shane Bieber SP 179 137 231 160 128 7
42 6 Kyle Freeland SP 153 262 126 141 173 7
43 6 Jon Gray SP 192 124 166 182 196 6
44 6 Carlos Martinez SP 233 151 132 184 #N/A 6
45 6 Nathan Eovaldi SP 143 294 155 148 167 6
46 6 Rick Porcello SP 137 240 193 168 172 6
47 6 Hyun-Jin Ryu SP 160 173 173 201 207 5
48 6 Sean Newcomb SP 241 138 259 188 159 5
49 6 Andrew Heaney SP 211 190 210 162 216 5
50 6 Ross Stripling SP 159 225 134 192 293 5
51 6 Joey Lucchesi SP 217 130 238 227 191 5
52 6 Jake Arrieta SP 182 140 250 206 230 5
53 6 Tyler Glasnow SP 205 214 185 170 250 5
54 6 Jon Lester SP 214 273 156 209 225 4
55 6 Kevin Gausman SP 227 186 228 240 197 4
56 7 Jose Quintana SP 190 234 184 198 273 4
57 7 Zack Godley SP 235 145 243 238 249 4
58 7 Kenta Maeda SP 161 293 212 219 228 4
59 7 Yusei Kikuchi SP 185 268 302 211 169 4
60 7 Brad Peacock RP/SP 201 477 400 322 #N/A 4
61 7 Joe Musgrove SP 208 442 269 239 198 4
62 7 Dallas Keuchel SP 313 317 209 189 174 3
63 7 Steven Matz SP 276 203 251 241 261 3
64 7 Michael Fulmer SP #N/A #N/A 224 #N/A 281 3
65 7 Alex Reyes SP/RP 262 441 94 214 #N/A 3
66 7 Collin McHugh SP 152 444 192 229 285 2
67 7 Tyler Skaggs SP 203 438 183 220 268 2
68 8 Jimmy Nelson SP 252 238 292 256 294 2
69 8 Anibal Sanchez SP 167 331 284 303 #N/A 2
70 8 Alex Wood SP 219 439 241 212 271 2
71 8 Chris Paddack SP 213 341 #N/A 352 201 2
72 8 Trevor Williams SP 290 266 293 271 #N/A 2
73 8 Julio Urias SP 256 456 289 244 #N/A 2
74 8 Jesus Luzardo SP 309 326 317 261 200 1
75 8 Josh James SP 357 437 188 233 264 1
76 8 Marcus Stroman SP 380 319 239 251 #N/A 1
77 8 Jhoulys Chacin SP 275 464 262 269 222 1
78 9 Marco Gonzales SP 187 454 321 248 290 1
79 9 Reynaldo Lopez SP 274 469 304 281 181 1
80 9 Kyle Gibson SP 264 453 282 253 284 1
81 9 Matthew Boyd SP 246 462 254 292 296 1
82 9 Luke Weaver SP 342 265 362 320 289 1
83 9 Dereck Rodriguez SP 298 466 245 255 #N/A 1
84 9 Mike Minor SP 243 472 290 262 #N/A 1
85 9 Carlos Rodon SP 283 448 283 286 #N/A 1
86 9 Forrest Whitley SP 350 458 340 277 203 1
87 9 Freddy Peralta SP 339 310 314 341 #N/A 1
88 10 Mike Soroka SP 370 450 221 279 #N/A 1
89 10 Vince Velasquez SP 327 323 346 340 #N/A 1
90 10 Seth Lugo SP/RP 310 338 311 407 #N/A 1
91 10 Dylan Bundy SP 286 449 348 295 #N/A 1
92 10 Corbin Burnes SP/RP 314 376 381 321 #N/A 1
93 10 Matt Strahm RP/SP 296 485 298 339 #N/A 1
94 10 Julio Teheran SP 360 459 326 289 #N/A 1
95 10 Mike Fiers SP 365 348 368 358 #N/A 1
96 10 Sonny Gray SP 336 452 366 291 #N/A 1
97 10 Jose Urena SP 325 389 388 376 #N/A 1
98 10 Derek Holland SP 285 524 299 381 #N/A 1
99 10 Brandon Woodruff SP 248 499 387 357 #N/A 1
100 10 Caleb Smith SP 284 480 375 367 #N/A 1
101 10 Chase Anderson SP 502 451 229 334 #N/A 1
102 10 Michael Wacha SP 387 460 385 288 #N/A 1
103 11 Trevor Richards SP 334 478 373 338 #N/A 1
104 11 Zach Eflin SP 423 525 453 329 184 1
105 11 Danny Duffy SP 355 473 363 355 #N/A 1
106 11 CC Sabathia SP 396 479 312 387 #N/A 1
107 11 Trevor Cahill SP 337 503 386 353 #N/A 1
108 11 Jake Junis SP 404 471 403 307 #N/A 1
109 11 Martin Perez SP 399 #N/A #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
110 11 Jeff Samardzija SP 373 474 371 388 #N/A 1
111 11 Touki Toussaint SP 527 427 300 356 #N/A 1
112 11 Michael Pineda SP 363 440 486 324 #N/A 1
113 11 Wily Peralta SP/RP 465 535 429 397 239 1
114 11 Sandy Alcantara SP 384 505 365 399 #N/A 1
115 11 Lucas Giolito SP 369 487 372 432 #N/A 1
116 11 Jake Odorizzi SP 398 493 413 365 #N/A 1
117 11 Tanner Roark SP 417 470 402 383 #N/A 1
118 11 Diego Castillo RP/SP 408 #N/A 396 456 #N/A 1
119 11 Brad Keller SP 401 527 364 389 #N/A 1
120 11 Tyler Anderson SP 385 481 434 406 #N/A 1
121 11 Lance Lynn SP 411 509 397 398 #N/A 1
122 12 Aaron Sanchez SP 364 500 578 317 #N/A 1
123 12 Clay Buchholz SP 444 538 405 396 #N/A 1
124 12 Framber Valdez SP 422 533 384 447 #N/A 1
125 12 Mike Leake SP 415 394 460 524 #N/A 1
126 12 Pablo Lopez SP 353 530 380 538 #N/A 1
127 12 Robbie Erlin SP 414 550 #N/A 422 #N/A 1
128 12 Wade Miley SP 376 607 #N/A 413 #N/A 1
129 12 Domingo German SP 421 397 592 452 #N/A 1
130 12 Ryan Yarbrough SP 573 513 450 327 #N/A 1
131 12 Anthony DeSclafani SP 501 504 497 368 #N/A 1
132 12 Adam Conley SP/RP 477 369 484 570 #N/A 1
133 12 Matt Harvey SP 490 566 485 359 #N/A 1
134 12 Wei-Yin Chen SP 375 556 389 581 #N/A 1
135 12 Danny Salazar SP #N/A 483 415 532 #N/A 1
136 12 Drew Smyly SP #N/A 484 523 446 #N/A 1
137 12 Dinelson Lamet SP #N/A 489 325 640 #N/A 1
138 13 Gio Gonzalez SP 559 571 445 364 #N/A 1
139 13 Yonny Chirinos SP #N/A 510 512 433 #N/A 1
140 13 Alex Cobb SP 532 508 431 471 #N/A 1
141 13 Felix Pena RP/SP 410 #N/A 442 614 #N/A 1
142 13 Merrill Kelly SP 395 532 598 436 #N/A 1
143 13 Luiz Gohara SP 519 506 476 487 #N/A 1
144 13 Ivan Nova SP 506 564 409 513 #N/A 1
145 13 Nick Kingham SP #N/A 528 439 528 #N/A 1
146 13 Kyle Wright SP 524 #N/A #N/A 477 #N/A 1
147 13 Drew Pomeranz SP #N/A 507 #N/A 498 #N/A 1
148 13 Wade LeBlanc SP 491 553 443 530 #N/A 1
149 13 Matt Shoemaker SP 542 576 467 439 #N/A 1
150 13 Jason Vargas SP 425 583 418 601 #N/A 1
151 13 Chris Devenski SP/RP 458 514 449 609 #N/A 1
152 13 Joe Ross SP #N/A 590 482 453 #N/A 1
153 13 Jordan Montgomery SP 581 534 411 #N/A #N/A 1
154 13 Andrew Suarez SP #N/A 516 527 488 #N/A 1
155 13 Jaime Barria SP 535 559 530 418 #N/A 1
156 13 Brent Honeywell SP 580 490 452 523 #N/A 1
157 13 Jeremy Hellickson SP 528 #N/A 416 593 #N/A 1
158 13 Justus Sheffield SP 504 543 602 401 #N/A 1
159 14 Thomas Pannone SP #N/A #N/A 517 #N/A #N/A 1
160 14 Marco Estrada SP 390 551 587 542 #N/A 1
161 14 Dylan Cease SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 518 #N/A 1
162 14 Dylan Floro SP/RP 517 #N/A 519 #N/A #N/A 1
163 14 Jon Duplantier SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 519 #N/A 1
164 14 Daniel Mengden SP #N/A 558 535 474 #N/A 1
165 14 Taijuan Walker SP #N/A 494 454 627 #N/A 1
166 14 Fernando Romero SP #N/A #N/A 494 560 #N/A 1
167 14 Jerad Eickhoff SP #N/A 549 526 509 #N/A 1
168 14 Zach Davies SP 441 577 555 546 #N/A 1
169 14 Eric Lauer SP 553 536 #N/A 511 #N/A 1
170 14 Tyson Ross SP 488 620 559 478 #N/A 1
171 14 Tyler Mahle SP #N/A 531 586 495 #N/A 1
172 14 Felix Hernandez SP 583 552 432 610 #N/A 1
173 14 Jake Faria SP #N/A 498 615 526 #N/A 1
174 14 A.J. Puk SP 551 569 520 #N/A #N/A 1
175 14 Logan Allen SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 547 #N/A 1
176 14 Jonathan Loaisiga SP 520 580 561 527 #N/A 1
177 14 Mitch Keller SP #N/A 606 #N/A 490 #N/A 1
178 14 Max Fried SP 531 #N/A 516 605 #N/A 1
179 14 Matt Moore SP 554 #N/A 552 #N/A #N/A 1
180 14 Adam Wainwright SP 537 601 455 626 #N/A 1
181 14 Robert Gsellman SP/RP 495 614 510 602 #N/A 1
182 14 Dan Straily SP 566 603 446 615 #N/A 1
183 14 Ervin Santana SP #N/A 567 630 480 #N/A 1
184 14 Stephen Gonsalves SP #N/A 565 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
185 14 Jharel Cotton SP #N/A #N/A 566 #N/A #N/A 1
186 14 Bartolo Colon SP #N/A #N/A 567 #N/A #N/A 1
187 14 Nick Tropeano SP #N/A #N/A 576 #N/A #N/A 1
188 14 Ryan Borucki SP #N/A 611 574 549 #N/A 1
189 14 John Gant SP #N/A 604 583 554 #N/A 1
190 14 Mike Montgomery SP/RP #N/A 599 532 612 #N/A 1
191 14 Daniel Norris SP #N/A #N/A 547 616 #N/A 1
192 14 Andrew Cashner RP/SP #N/A #N/A 584 #N/A #N/A 1
193 14 Daniel Poncedeleon SP #N/A #N/A 594 575 #N/A 1
194 14 Steven Wright SP #N/A 652 522 #N/A #N/A 1
195 14 Amir Garrett SP 507 605 550 696 #N/A 1
196 14 Brandon Finnegan SP #N/A 645 536 #N/A #N/A 1
197 14 Chris Stratton SP #N/A 609 472 691 #N/A 1
198 14 Jordan Zimmermann SP #N/A 618 564 597 #N/A 1
199 14 Joe Biagini SP/RP #N/A #N/A 597 #N/A #N/A 1
200 14 Sean Reid-Foley SP #N/A #N/A 631 576 #N/A 1
201 15 Francis Martes SP #N/A 628 582 #N/A #N/A 1
202 15 Robert Stephenson SP #N/A #N/A 607 #N/A #N/A 1
203 15 Antonio Senzatela SP 585 #N/A #N/A 630 #N/A 1
204 15 Dylan Covey SP #N/A 646 575 #N/A #N/A 1
205 15 Nate Karns SP #N/A 598 #N/A 632 #N/A 1
206 15 Ian Kennedy SP #N/A 642 540 667 #N/A 1
207 15 J.C. Ramirez SP #N/A #N/A 618 #N/A #N/A 1
208 15 Luis Perdomo SP #N/A 629 609 #N/A #N/A 1
209 15 Brock Stewart SP #N/A #N/A 624 #N/A #N/A 1
210 15 Andrew Triggs SP #N/A 624 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
211 15 Adam Plutko SP #N/A 625 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
212 15 Junior Guerra SP #N/A #N/A 585 668 #N/A 1
213 15 Francisco Liriano SP #N/A 627 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
214 15 Griffin Canning SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 628 #N/A 1
215 15 Tyler Chatwood SP #N/A 570 #N/A 694 #N/A 1
216 15 Shelby Miller SP #N/A 660 #N/A 611 #N/A 1
217 15 Liam Hendriks SP #N/A 639 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
218 15 Jimmie Sherfy SP #N/A 641 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
219 15 Erick Fedde SP #N/A 633 #N/A 656 #N/A 1
220 15 Sixto Sanchez SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 646 #N/A 1
221 15 Adalberto Mejia SP #N/A #N/A 628 670 #N/A 1
222 15 Taylor Widener SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 649 #N/A 1
223 15 Dillon Peters SP #N/A 651 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
224 15 Edubray Ramos SP #N/A 653 #N/A #N/A #N/A 1
225 15 Scott Oberg SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 654 #N/A 1
226 15 Austin Gomber SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 655 #N/A 1
227 15 Jalen Beeks SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 657 #N/A 1
228 15 Triston McKenzie SP #N/A 656 #N/A 659 #N/A 1
229 15 Frankie Montas SP/RP #N/A #N/A #N/A 658 #N/A 1
230 15 Jordan Lyles SP #N/A #N/A #N/A 684 #N/A 1

 

Rankings Analysis - Top Tiers

Tier One

I am a huge fan of waiting on starting pitching, particularly with so many elite bats to be had in Round 1 and early Round 2. I haven't wound up with any of these three starting pitchers in any of my drafts this year, and I promise you I won't own them come Opening Day. That doesn't mean they aren't absolutely outstanding. Scherzer in particular is one of the safest picks you can make. Averaging his last six seasons, you get one of the most impressive stretches in baseball history; he's averaged 218 innings pitched, 270 strikeouts and just a shade under 18 wins per year. Chris Sale is still a strikeout/ERA machine and he'll get plenty of wins as well, but he did only throw 158 innings last season. Jacob deGrom was an incredibly worthy Cy Young Award-winner last season, although his SIERA indicates it's probably too much to expect a 1.70 ERA again this year. Just because I won't own any of these three doesn't mean you shouldn't, particularly if you get to Round 2 and they're available.

Tier Two

This is where I wind up taking my first pitchers of each draft. These are for the most part younger guys or veterans who have established themselves but still have plenty of upside to push into Tier 1. I find myself coming away with Carlos Carrasco most often out of this group; Carrasco had a terrific 2018 season, striking out batters at a 29.5% clip and posting the highest K-BB% of his career. While his BABIP was fairly normal, his SIERA (3.03) indicates that his stellar 3.38 ERA could have been even higher with a little help. He's a perennial candidate for 200+ strikeouts and on an Indians team in the worst division in baseball (IMO) he'll get at least 14 wins if he stays healthy all season. Non-zero chance that Carrasco returns the most value out of any Indians starter this year.

Tier Three

I thought I was going to be lower than most on James Paxton, but my colleagues have even less faith in him than I do, and with good reason. Paxton has undeniable upside--his 32.3 K% last season was absolutely nuts. Unfortunately, his 160.1 IP from a year ago represent a career high, which is pretty concerning for a 30-year-old. Paxton has lost time over the last few seasons to forearm, pectoral and finger strains, and back inflammation. He's theoretically healthy heading into this season, but it's incredibly difficult to find a path to 200 IP this season give his history. Even more concerning than the injury history is his change in ballpark. Last year T-Mobile Park in Seattle ranked 27th as far as runs scored were concerned, while Yankee Stadium was seventh--and it gets worse when you adjust for home runs. He's coming off the worst HR rate of his career (1.3/9 IP) and now heads to one of the worst stadiums in the majors for ceding the long ball. It doesn't take a professor of sabermetrics to figure out why Paxton could have plenty of issues this year even if he remains healthy.

 

Rankings Analysis - Middle Tiers

Tier Four

My affinity for Jack Flaherty is well-established (see my Bold Predictions for this year) so I won't waste more typing on that subject. German Marquez is a trendy sleeper that our good friend @Jon_DenzlerRB has written about here. I want to talk about a guy that hasn't been getting very much love this offseason instead--Miles Mikolas. The 30-year-old was on hiatus from the MLB from 2015-2017, opting instead to pitch in Japan. When he returned last season he made an immediate impact on the Cardinals' rotation, going 18-4 with a 2.83 ERA across 200.1 IP. There was likely a bit of luck there, as his SIERA was more than a full run higher (3.93), but the 2019 Opening Day starter still showed plenty of promise for this year. His 3.6% BB-rate was particularly impressive--if you keep runners off the bases they can't come around to score, and his 0.72 HR/9 is certainly admirable as well. The main knock against his SIERA is the lack of strikeouts; he posted a modest 18.1 K%. Mikolas is one of those picks that will impress nobody on draft day, but he'll hold down a valuable spot in your rotation all season.

Clayton Kershaw has tumbled down draft boards, and with good reason. There are major, major concerns that can't be ignored. He's averaging just over 160 IP over the last three seasons, and he's coming off the lowest K% since his rookie year (23.9%). That last stat can likely be attributed to the fact that his average fastball velocity (91.4) plummeted to nearly two full MPH from his career average (93.7). Thanks to that drop-off, Kershaw has begun to lean on his slider more and more, and he actually threw more sliders than fastballs last year. This all still led to a 2.73 ERA (with a 3.45 SIERA to back it up), which is my main reason for optimism. If there is any pitcher who can re-establish his dominance by nibbling corners and keeping batters off-balance with breaking balls, it's Kershaw. He'll have to re-invent himself to stay relevant, and I think he can do it. My ranking here may be a bit optimistic, but to think Kershaw is "done" seems foolish.

Tier Five

I am lowest on Yu Darvish, and I'm not quite sure what some of my colleagues are seeing to give them hope. Darvish peaked in his sophomore season (2013) with a 13-9 record, 277 strikeouts and a 2.83 ERA. Since then, he's averaged 120 IP per season, and his career ERA is now at 3.49. Simply stated, Darvish is nowhere close to the phenom that he entered the league as. This is not to say my colleagues are ranking him as such--they're not. But the upside here is just so limited. The only thing Darvish truly has working in his favor is his strikeout ability. His 29.5 career K% is a terrific mark, and when he's healthy Darvish should still have that nasty stuff. He hasn't lost anything off his fastball, and his slider is still a devastating put-away pitch. However, with that nastiness comes a dangerously high BB%. Darvish has walked over 9% of the batters he's faced in his career, which leaves the door open for a lot of trouble if he's not "on". If you can only count on him for maybe 150 innings and an ERA around 3.50-4.00, how is he inside the top 120?

I'm also lowest on Eduardo Rodriguez, so I guess this is my Hater Tier. I see the upside here, don't get me wrong--Rodriguez has improves his K% every season he's been in the majors, resulting in a healthy 26.4% last season across 129.2 IP. Once again though, concerns about innings pitched have me wary. Rodriguez has suffered from knee, hamstring and ankle injuries in the past, and it's kept him from realizing his full potential. Is this the year he finally puts it all together? Simply put, I'm not willing to be the one who drafts him to find out. I could be completely wrong here, and Rodriguez could toss 180 innings of terrific ball. I just don't want to be the one who wastes a pick on him when I could have a guy with more upside like Luis Castillo or a sturdy veteran like J.A. Happ instead.

 

Rankings Analysis - Lower Tiers

Tier Six

I'm highest on Jake Arrieta, and honestly in this case it's me trusting a guy's floor more than his upside. Arrieta has been declining steadily since 2014-2015, it's true. His K% is down, his SIERA is up. However, he's not losing a ton of velocity off his fastball and he's starting to lean more on his cutter, which was what earned him a good deal of his success in that 2014-2015 high point. The Phillies will be one of the more competitive teams in the National League this year, and with some slight adjustments Arrieta can take a step back towards the success that earned him a Cy Young Award in 2015.

Tier Seven

Kenta Maeda could be a rock-solid third or fourth starter if only the Dodgers would give him a full season in the rotation. As it stands it looks like Maeda will at least begin the season in the rotation, and if he's able to hold down the spot he could be a top-40 starter in mixed league formats. In his three seasons in the majors he's boasted an above-average 26.2 K%, and outside of a sub-par 2017 he's kept his homers allowed down as well. He's been consistent and has stayed relatively healthy for most of his major league career, so it's literally all about opportunity for Maeda.

Tiers Eight and Nine

The Marcus Stroman hate has gone too far. Very few people realize just how much of his atrocious 2018 campaign was based in luck (or lack thereof). Stroman suffered in most non-controllable statistics--his BABIP shot up to .326, his LOB % was a laughable 60.5%. All of this resulted in an abysmal 5.54 ERA, up from his 3.09 in 2017. However, if you look at the underlying metrics you'll see that he didn't actually pitch much worse. His SIERA only rose from 3.85 to 4.04, he still forced a crazy-high ground ball percentage, and his strikeout percentage dropped just a bit. He's never been a strikeout pitcher, so don't expect him to help you out there, but he's one of the best candidates for a bounce-back season on this list, and I'm banking on it.

Speaking of hate going too far, did everyone forget what Dereck Rodriguez did as a rookie last year? 6-4 with a 2.81 ERA and a 1.13 WHIP in 19 starts.--that's downright terrific in fantasy if you project it out over a full season. I am no fool here--there are a TON of signs that indicate Rodriguez will regress in 2019. His BABIP was a ridiculously low .257, that low ERA was backed up by a 4.58 SIERA and his 18.3 K% isn't a recipe for overcoming any of the forthcoming WHIP regression. Even if Rodriguez's ERA levels out to a 3.50-4.00 range and he picks up 10 wins, isn't that worthy of more than barely a top-300 ranking, or even into the 400s? Give Rodriguez a shot later in your draft and you won't be disappointed on the return.

More Fantasy Baseball Rankings Analysis




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Ricky Stenhouse Jr4 mins ago

Don't Be Afraid to Roll the Dice with Ricky Stenhouse Jr at Charlotte
Kyle Larson15 mins ago

Could Miss Coca-Cola 600 at Charlotte
Josh Berry22 mins ago

Isn't a Great DFS Option at Charlotte
Justin Haley33 mins ago

Looking to Keep Momentum Rolling at Charlotte
Ryan Preece36 mins ago

Not On Fire But Improving For Charlotte
Todd Gilliland41 mins ago

Has DFS Place Differential Upside at Charlotte
Erik Jones42 mins ago

Still Mending From Injuries
Daniel Hemric48 mins ago

Trying To Right Things At Charlotte
Michael McDowell54 mins ago

Could Surprise With Another Top 10 at Charlotte
Austin Dillon56 mins ago

Looks To Charlotte For Good Results
Austin Cindric1 hour ago

Not Consistent In Good Way At Charlotte
Harrison Burton2 hours ago

Needs To Survive To Thrive
Shane Van Gisbergen3 hours ago

Shane van Gisbergen Making Non-Drafting Oval Debut at Charlotte
NASCAR3 hours ago

Daniel Suarez May Benefit From Trackhouse's Intermediate Speed, but Don't Count On It
Zane Smith3 hours ago

Charlotte Might be Zane Smith's Best Shot for a Solid Run
John Hunter Nemechek3 hours ago

Still Struggling to Figure Out Next Gen Car on Intermediates
Jaylen Brown8 hours ago

Helps Boston Claim Game 3
Jayson Tatum8 hours ago

Leads Boston To A Comeback Win
Mike Conley8 hours ago

Questionable Again For Game 3
Luka Doncic8 hours ago

Back On The Injury Report For Sunday
Shohei Ohtani9 hours ago

Dealing With A Bruised Hamstring
Joe Burrow10 hours ago

No "Special Pitch Counter" For Joe Burrow
Joe Mixon10 hours ago

Dameon Pierce Viewed As A "One-Two Punch"
Brandon Aiyuk10 hours ago

Reportedly Looking To Double Annual Salary
Jrue Holiday12 hours ago

Available For Game 3
John Collins12 hours ago

Jazz Reportedly Expected To "Shop" John Collins
Kentavious Caldwell-Pope12 hours ago

Nuggets May Not Re-Sign Kentavious Caldwell-Pope
Luke Kornet13 hours ago

Won't Play In Game 3
Grayson Murray14 hours ago

PGA Tour Player Grayson Murray Passes Away At 30
Jrue Holiday14 hours ago

Remains Questionable For Game 3
Tyrese Haliburton17 hours ago

Out For Game 3
Michael Massey19 hours ago

Held Out Saturday
Edwin Díaz19 hours ago

Edwin Diaz "One Of Our Options" For Saves
Josh Lowe19 hours ago

Rays Place Josh Lowe On 10-Day Injured List
Bryan Ramos20 hours ago

Reinstated And Starting Saturday
Cedric Mullins20 hours ago

Sitting Against White Sox
Braxton Garrett1 day ago

Fires Complete-Game Shutout Friday
José Ramírez1 day ago

Jose Ramirez Leaves Yard Twice Friday
Patrick Bailey1 day ago

Grand Slam Sinks Mets Friday
Jonathan India1 day ago

Mashes Grand Slam In Win
Edward Cabrera1 day ago

Shut Down For 5-7 Days
Gavin Williams1 day ago

Will Begin Rehab Assignment Next Week
Nolan Jones1 day ago

A Few Days Away From Swinging
Nathan Eovaldi1 day ago

Throws Another Bullpen, Close To Returning
Steven Kwan1 day ago

Will Begin Rehab Assignment Saturday
Karl-Anthony Towns1 day ago

Struggles Again In Game 2
Anthony Edwards1 day ago

Struggles In Game 2
Kyrie Irving1 day ago

Has Another Stellar Performance
Luka Doncic1 day ago

Seals The Deal In Game 2
MLB1 day ago

Cubs-Cardinals Postponed On Friday Night
Luke Kornet2 days ago

Doubtful On Saturday
Tyrese Haliburton2 days ago

Questionable For Game 3 On Saturday
Zach Neto2 days ago

Hopefully Avoids Serious Injury
Donovan Mitchell2 days ago

"Happy" In Cleveland
Artturi Lehkonen2 days ago

Doubtful For Training Camp
Roope Hintz2 days ago

In Contention To Return To Action On Saturday
Robbie Ray2 days ago

To Face Hitters Saturday
Sergei Bobrovsky2 days ago

Looks To Continue Hot Streak In Game 2 Against Rangers
Austin Riley2 days ago

Unlikely To Return Until Monday
Igor Shesterkin2 days ago

Attempts To Turn Around Form On Friday
Triston Casas2 days ago

To Take Ground Balls
Filip Chytil2 days ago

An Option To Join Top Line Friday
Royce Lewis2 days ago

To Start Rehab Assignment On Saturday
Kaapo Kakko2 days ago

In Danger Of Being Scratched For Game 2
Pat Freiermuth2 days ago

Developing Chemistry With New QB
Russell Wilson2 days ago

Looking Good At OTAs
Caleb Williams2 days ago

Has Struggled At OTAs
Christian Watson2 days ago

Hoping To Move Past Hamstring Issues
Anthony Richardson2 days ago

Won't Change His Playing Style
Julius Randle2 days ago

Knicks Not Actively Looking To Trade Julius Randle
Blake Corum2 days ago

Rams Seeking Three-Down Role From Blake Corum
Javonte Williams2 days ago

Newcomers Threatening Javonte Williams' Role
Samaje Perine2 days ago

Jaleel McLaughlin Facing Threat To Workload
Mike Conley2 days ago

Questionable For Friday Evening
Tyrese Haliburton2 days ago

Dealing With Left Hamstring Soreness
Tyrese Haliburton2 days ago

Won't Return On Thursday Night
Courtland Sutton3 days ago

Not At OTAs
Travis Etienne Jr.3 days ago

Jaguars Plan To Ease Travis Etienne Jr.'s Workload
Derrick Henry3 days ago

Ravens Not Putting A Cap On Derrick Henry's Workload
Rome Odunze3 days ago

Expected To Practice Next Week
Marvin Harrison Jr.3 days ago

Cardinals Sign Marvin Harrison Jr. To Rookie Deal
Jameson Williams3 days ago

A "Man On A Mission"
Darren Waller3 days ago

Absent At OTAs
Daniel Jones3 days ago

Has No Doubt He'll Be Ready For Week 1
Dameon Pierce3 days ago

Texans Still Have Plans For Dameon Pierce
Deshaun Watson3 days ago

Throwing Every Other Day
Si Woo Kim4 days ago

Misses First Cut In 2024
Nicolai Hojgaard4 days ago

Debuts At Charles Schwab Challenge
Harry Hall4 days ago

Returns To Charles Schwab Challenge
Grayson Murray4 days ago

Looks To Continue Playing Well At Colonial
Garrick Higgo5 days ago

Struggling For Form Heading To Colonial
Scottie Scheffler5 days ago

A Favorite To Win At Colonial
Rafael Campos5 days ago

A Risky Play At Charles Schwab Challenge
Lucas Glover5 days ago

A Healthy Option At Charles Schwab Challenge
Hayden Springer5 days ago

Can Hayden Springer Turn Things Around At Colonial?
Tyson Alexander5 days ago

Needs More Than A Putter At Colonial
PGA5 days ago

J.T. Poston Is Risky But Has A Lot To Like At Charles Schwab Challenge
Mark Hubbard5 days ago

Trending Up Ahead Of Charles Schwab Challenge
Alejandro Tosti5 days ago

Headed For Trouble At Colonial
Chan Kim5 days ago

A Potential Value At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA5 days ago

S.H. Kim A Sneaky Option At Colonial
Justin Suh5 days ago

A Player To Avoid At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA5 days ago

Matthi Schmid Looks To Regain Form At Colonial
Filip Chytil6 days ago

Appears Ready To Rock For Eastern Conference Finals
Jani Hakanpaa6 days ago

Still Not Practicing
Roope Hintz6 days ago

Skates Monday, Still Day-To-Day
Sam Lafferty6 days ago

And Ilya Mikheyev Drawing Into Game 7 Lineup
Thatcher Demko6 days ago

Unavailable For Game 7, Arturs Silovs Will Start
Brock Boeser6 days ago

Out Indefinitely With Blood Clots
Joey Logano6 days ago

Dominates All-Star Race
Ryan Fox6 days ago

Continues Up-And-Down 2024
Denny Hamlin6 days ago

Falls Short Of Victory At The All-Star Race
Ryan Blaney6 days ago

Rallies For Fifth-Place Finish At North Wilkesboro
Patton Kizzire6 days ago

Showing Improvement The Past Month
Kyle Busch6 days ago

Ricky Stenhouse Jr Punches Kyle Busch After Lap 2 Crash at All-Star Race
Kyle Busch6 days ago

Wrecked Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. at All-Star Race, Then Said He "Sucks"
Christiaan Bezuidenhout6 days ago

Likely To Bounce Back This Week
Edson Barboza6 days ago

Lerone Murphy Dominates To Defeat Edson Barboza
Carlston Harris6 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Vegas 92
Khaos Williams6 days ago

Scores Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 92
Luana Pinheiro6 days ago

Loses Second Fight In A Row
Angela Hill6 days ago

Scores First Submission Win
Vinicius Salvador6 days ago

Winless In The UFC
Adrian Yanez6 days ago

Returns To Win Column In A Big Way
Ramiz Brahimaj6 days ago

Doesn't Do Much In UFC Vegas 92 Loss
Themba Gorimbo6 days ago

Wins Lackluster Decision At UFC Vegas 92
Edson Barboza6 days ago

Falls Short At UFC Vegas 92
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
Ty Chandler - Fantasy Football Rankings, Waiver Wire Pickups, Draft Sleepers

Aaron Jones, Ty Chandler - Fantasy Football Outlook for Minnesota Vikings RBs in 2024

The Minnesota Vikings offense will look a little different in 2024. Quarterback Kirk Cousins left in free agency, and the team replaced him with first-round pick J.J. McCarthy. McCarthy or free-agent signing Sam Darnold will start the year as the Vikings quarterback. Even the running position has changed for Minnesota this offseason. They released Alexander Mattison -- who started the 2023 season... Read More


Ezekiel Elliott - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Five Fantasy Football Risers on New Teams in 2024

With free agency and the draft now complete and OTAs heating up, NFL roster outlooks are looking a lot more clear than they were at the end of the 2023 season. Some players who switched teams will see a boost to their fantasy football value, while others will take on lesser roles in their new... Read More


Sophomore Disappointments? 2024 Fantasy Football Second-Year Wide Receiver Fallers

We're working around the clock at RotoBaller in preparation for the upcoming fantasy football season! With early best ball drafts already getting underway, we're taking a look at some notable fantasy football players for the 2024 campaign. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into three second-year wide receivers who could be facing a rocky road in 2024.... Read More


Breakout Potential? 2024 Fantasy Football Rookie Tight End Analysis

How do you spend the offseason? Here at RotoBaller, we're working around the clock to prep for the coming NFL campaign. With early best ball drafts already underway, we're taking a look at some potential breakout rookies for the 2024 season. RotoBaller's David Rispoli dives into three rookie tight ends who could turn into fantasy... Read More


UFL RANKINGS, FANTASY FOOTBALL,

UFL Fantasy Football Rankings for Week 9: QB, RB, WR, TE Rankings and Analysis (2024)

With Week 8 in the books, the UFL playoff matchups are set despite two weeks of regular season play remaining. There has been no shortage of parity between the top and bottom teams in the league's first season. This week's rankings are likely to be more of a crapshoot than past rankings. Playoff teams have... Read More


UFL RANKINGS, FANTASY FOOTBALL,

Free UFL Betting Picks - Best Bets, Odds, Predictions for Week 9

Well, that was not a good week. As has been the pattern--these things happen, especially when Arlington whiffs so bad as the underdog in the week after a 47-point explosion for their first win in what has become a miserable season. As of now, as far as stakes for the 2024 regular season are concerned,... Read More


George Pickens - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Fantasy Football Wide Receivers You Must Draft in 2024 - Part I

Running backs are so 2010, am I right? Fantasy football has completely moved on. Now, all we want are the receivers. How many receivers are too many? That’s not actually a thing. You cannot have too many receivers. Who’s my No. 2 running back going to be? I don’t care, but check this out, Jameson... Read More


Rashee Rice - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL wr, Draft Sleepers

Sophomore Slump: Can Rashee Rice, Jordan Addison, and Jayden Reed Meet Expectations in Year Two?

Each year, a new, promising crop of rookies enters the NFL. A number of these rookies meet or exceed expectations as first-year players and establish themselves as rising stars in the professional ranks. Many then proceed to ascend further in subsequent seasons. However, not all of these young talents continue on their upward trajectories; some... Read More


Ladd McConkey - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 Dynasty Rookie Rankings For Superflex Leagues: 20-11

Now that we’re coming off our rookie fever, it’s time to see where the newest NFL players stack up against the veterans. That’s right, we’re talking rookies and dynasty rankings. My name is Ellis Johnson and this is my sixth year writing NFL content with RotoBaller. I also contribute to FantasyPros Expert Consensus Rankings and... Read More


Khalil Herbert - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

D'Andre Swift, Khalil Herbert, Roschon Johnson - Fantasy Football Outlook for Chicago Bears RBs in 2024

The Chicago Bears were extremely active this offseason and will head into the 2024-2025 season trending up. Despite finishing last in the NFC North with a 7-10 record last year, the Bears are surely in a better spot now in the division. That's because of their successful offseason. Chicago traded for veteran wide receiver Keenan Allen and signed... Read More


Second-Year WR Breakouts? 2024 Fantasy Football Wide Receiver Risers

The fantasy football action never sleeps at RotoBaller! With early best ball drafts already getting underway, we're taking a look at some potential breakout fantasy football players for the 2024 campaign. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into three second-year wide receivers who could turn into fantasy stars in 2024. These sophomore WRs showed flashes of brilliance... Read More


Michael Florio's Football Show - Podcast RotoBaller Network

Florio's Football Show: Love for Levis, Fade Rodgers and Sneaky Targets!

Michael F. Florio is back going over a number of topics this week! Why is he warming up to both Calvin Ridley and Will Levis? He also talks why he is so concerned with Aaron Rodgers, why he loves targeting Kyler Murray and Justin Fields and tries to make sense of the Broncos backfield. All... Read More


Great Value? Five Currently Underrated Players in 2024 Fantasy Football Drafts

We're bringing the fantasy football heat 365 days a year at RotoBaller! With early 2024 best ball drafts already underway, we're looking into the ADP of fantasy football's most impactful players. NFL Network contributor and RotoBaller analyst LaQuan Jones dives into the early ADP of some popular fantasy options. While these players aren't perfect, they... Read More