Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Player Comparisons
News and Alerts

2024 NFL Draft - Potential Busts In First-Round Fantasy Football Rookie Drafts

Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

The fantasy football offseason is an interesting time for dynasty players. With the combine behind us and the NFL Draft just ahead, we have collected nearly every bit of information we need aside from landing spots. This year's class brings in a new wave of gifted athletes primed to impact the NFL and our fantasy squads off the rip.

If you're insane like I am, you've completed a few rookie drafts already. Normal people might have theirs on the horizon, pending the NFL Draft. If you're the latter, I need to say something you don't want to hear- some of these guys will bust. It's an inconvenient truth, but an inevitable one at that. Not all these players will be hits -- it's just a fact. We've seen it play out repeatedly in the NFL and fantasy. N'Keal Harry, anyone? Even worse, sometimes the players are great, but their situation makes them a bust if you sink a high enough pick into them.

So, if you haven't drafted your rookies yet -- you're in luck! Below will outline a few players to steer clear of in the first round of your rookie drafts. It's worth mentioning that these players might turn out as fine contributors for both the NFL and fantasy. With this in mind, we're not looking for a flex option or back-end WR2 in the first round.

Featured Promo: Looking for some fantasy football action? Join a dynasty startup league over at FFPC. Sign up today and get $25 off any FFPC league. FFPC is the leader in dynasty leagues and has standard, superflex and best ball formats. Dynasty not your thing? No worries, FFPC has Best Ball leagues as well. Join A League Today!


2024 First-Round Rookies To Avoid

J.J. McCarthy, Michigan

J.J. McCarthy wasn't tasked with doing too much during his tenure as a starter under Jim Harbaugh. He didn't exceed 332 passing attempts or 22 touchdowns, as Michigan ran the ball 60.57% of the time. That was good for 117 out of 133 teams in pass rate. Yikes.

McCarthy is currently being taken ninth in Superflex rookie drafts according to FFPC ADP, and I've seen him go as high as sixth. I understand that quarterback can be scarce in this format, but this feels like a reach. At the back end of the first round, we're typically looking for upside. McCarthy projects as more of an average NFL starter, and maybe that's his ceiling. On a surface level, his 2023 completion percentage is encouraging (72.3%). If we dig deeper, we find some concerning data.

After watching his tape, McCarthy leaves the ball behind his receiver more than you like to see. I'm not sure if it's because of the windup in his delivery, but his ball placement can falter at times. Derrik Klassen of Reception Perception charted McCarthy's throws in 2023, and the sample is far from inspiring.

Green is good, and McCarthy was near-perfect when throwing behind the line of scrimmage. The further we go, the scarier it gets. If green is good, red is not -- and there's more of it. McCarthy was actually pretty decent when attempting throws of 10-20 yards to the right side of the field. I suspect that his success there is due to his scrambling ability. If that's the case, McCarthy's heat chart is deeply concerning. He was just OK when throwing downfield. We just saw the 2023 rookie phenom C.J. Stroud carve defenses up in the intermediate game -- an area McCarthy is severely lacking.

Xavier Worthy, Texas

One pick after McCarthy in ADP is Xavier Worthy, a speedster out of Texas. Perhaps calling him a speedster is a bit of an undersell if we consider that he set the record at the combine for the fastest 40-yard dash in history -- a blazing fast 4.21 seconds.

While there is no question that Worthy can flat-out run, I'll be running the other way in rookie drafts. Jameson Williams marked the last time I'll get burned by a burner. I took him over Garrett Wilson in some spots a few years ago -- you can imagine I want that one back. This analysis is clearly not a question of talent but more so passing on this player archetype...especially at this spot in the draft.

It'd be nice to hit on the next Tyreek Hill, but Hill is a 1/1 type of player, and that is the best-case scenario for Worthy. If he does not become a high-volume receiver -- which I doubt he will -- we could be looking at a big-play role-player, and that's not the type of asset I'm betting on in fantasy, especially in round one. Particularly because his former Longhorn teammate Adonai Mitchell was a far superior route runner against man and press -- and he's still on the board.

A few receivers are going after Worthy in ADP that I prefer over him in a vacuum and project to be higher target gainers. He's also one of the more slight receivers in this class, weighing 165 pounds. His weight isn't a problem if he's outrunning everyone before he catches the ball, but it does put a damper on his yards after contact. Worthy isn't one to break through arm tackles, and he also didn't excel in contested catch situations. He had such an instance on 14.9% of his targets and came away with just 18.2% of those.

In recent mock drafts, I've seen Worthy go to the Bills. Admittedly, it will be difficult for me to hold this stance if that is the case -- the prospect of Josh Allen as his quarterback would force me to reconsider. At this time, I'd be willing to take a shot on Worthy in the middle of the second round of rookie drafts, but he won't fall that far.

Troy Franklin, Oregon

Troy Franklin is a better route runner than Xavier Worthy and had a better 2023 season as far as statistics go. Franklin compiled 81 catches for 1,383 yards and 14 touchdowns, leading the Ducks in the latter two categories. Akin to Worthy, speed is Franklin's superpower. He may not be as fast, but currently, no one is. I like Franklin quite a bit more than Worthy, but there are still some warts in his profile.

Franklin lined up primarily as an X receiver at Oregon. 85.2% of his snaps came outside, and 79.9% were on the line. If Franklin's new coaching staff pigeonholes him in this role, it would spell trouble for him. Franklin has good height at 6-foot-2, but at his weight (176 pounds) and with his below-average strength, he will struggle with physical corners. When tasked with press coverage, Franklin had poor marks per Reception Perception. His 58.5% success rate against the press is in the 26th percentile, and that's over a large sample -- nearly 30% of his routes.

His skill set projects him to be more of an option at the flanker spot, and Franklin could do some real damage from there on post routes- one which he runs exceptionally well. He was better on contested catches than Xavier Worthy but still came away with just a 42.9% success rate. He needs to be much higher at this metric for his game to evolve into a reliable big-play option.

Franklin will eventually be a productive NFL player and someone we can expect some spike weeks from in fantasy. I would be more inclined to spend a first-rounder on him in a Best Ball league, but his route running needs to improve overall so he can become a high target earner as a secondary option on an NFL squad.

Caleb Williams, USC

This one hurts. To be clear -- I do not believe Caleb Williams will be an outright bust. I do think that the hype has gotten out of control, though. Williams has been a much-touted prospect for a while now and the consensus first pick off the board in the NFL and rookie Superflex drafts. We've seen some wild misses on quarterbacks in past drafts and even some great ones that we're still displeased with.

Let's take the 2021 draft class as an example. Trevor Lawrence was in the exact same position that Williams is in now. Lawrence went with the first pick in the NFL Draft, and in turn, the same in rookie drafts. It's fair to say that Trevor Lawrence has not been a bust. But if you used your rookie 1.01 to seal the deal, you're far from happy at this point in his career.

In the same year (2021), two other quarterbacks got drafted in rookie drafts over Ja'Marr Chase -- Justin Fields and Trey Lance. Lawrence has been the best of that bunch by far, and you would need to add to Trevor Lawrence to acquire Chase in a trade. Lawrence was graded by the NFL as a perennial All-Pro in his prospect profile, earning a grade of 7.40. Williams, on the other hand, is a few tiers down at 6.74.

The Chicago Bears have set Williams up for success, mitigating the rookie's transition to the pros with perhaps one of the most impressive arsenals of weapons in the NFL. Call me crazy, but I'm happy to take Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze over him in drafts. No, I'm not that low on Williams -- I'm just incredibly high on the three wideouts.

In recent years, the NFL has done a much better job getting the receivers right, and I'm more willing to view them as a sure bet. Caleb Williams will have at least a solid career as an NFL starter, but if he comes out and throws 3,000 yards and 20 TDs in year one, we'll wish we had one of those receivers.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!

Win More With RotoBaller

Be sure to also check out all of our other daily fantasy football articles and analysis to help you set those winning lineups, including this new RotoBaller YouTube video:

More Fantasy Football Analysis


Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Player Comparisons
News and Alerts


Carter Verhaeghe48 mins ago

Stretches Point Streak To Four Games
Matthew Tkachuk57 mins ago

Picks Up Two Assists On Sunday
Sam Reinhart1 hour ago

Scores Twice For Panthers In Game 3 Loss
Barclay Goodrow1 hour ago

Enjoys Two-Goal Outing On Sunday
Alexis Lafrenière1 hour ago

Alexis Lafreniere Nets Two Goals In Game 3 Victory
Alexander Wennberg2 hours ago

Ends Goal Drought With Game-Winner In Overtime
Josh Berry2 hours ago

Hangs On To Tenth At Charlotte
Denny Hamlin2 hours ago

Grinds Out Top Five Result At Charlotte
Kyle Anderson2 hours ago

Provides Timely Buckets In Game 3
Karl-Anthony Towns2 hours ago

Continues To Struggle In Western Conference Finals
Anthony Edwards2 hours ago

Leads Timberwolves With 26 Points In Game 3
Mike Conley2 hours ago

Produces 16 Points With Four Triples
Derrick Jones2 hours ago

Jr. Perfect From Three-Point Range In Game 3
Luka Doncic3 hours ago

Posts Unique Line Against Minnesota In Game 3
Kyrie Irving3 hours ago

Notches 33 Points In Game 3 Win
Kyle Bradish10 hours ago

Tosses Seven No-Hit Innings Against White Sox
Ronald Acuña Jr.13 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr. Diagnosed With Full ACL Tear
Dereck Lively13 hours ago

II Injured In Game 3
Hunter Renfrow15 hours ago

Browns Considering Adding Hunter Renfrow?
Cristian Javier16 hours ago

Misses Bullpen Session
Tyrese Haliburton16 hours ago

Officially Questionable For Game 4
Luka Doncic16 hours ago

Available On Sunday Night
Luke Kornet18 hours ago

Questionable For Monday Evening
Jrue Holiday18 hours ago

Questionable For Game 4
Kristaps Porzingis18 hours ago

Remains Out For Game 4
LeBron James18 hours ago

Considering Phoenix In Free Agency?
Ronald Acuña Jr.19 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr. Says He Is Heading To Injured List
Julio Rodríguez19 hours ago

Julio Rodriguez Has Massive Day Against Nationals
José Urquidy19 hours ago

Jose Urquidy To Be Re-Evaluated On Tuesday
Brent Rooker20 hours ago

Out Of Sunday's Lineup
Kyle Larson21 hours ago

Will Miss Start of Coca-Cola 600 at Charlotte; Do Not Pick Him in DFS
Ronald Acuña Jr.21 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr. Leaves Sunday’s Game With Left Knee Soreness
Nikita Okhotiuk21 hours ago

Moves To KHL
Jamie Benn22 hours ago

Pushes Point Streak To Three Games
Ronald Acuña Jr.22 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr. Leaves Sunday’s Game Early With Apparent Knee Injury
William Byron22 hours ago

a Strong Contender for the Coca-Cola 600
Martin Truex Jr22 hours ago

Looking for First Win of the Season at Charlotte
Denny Hamlin22 hours ago

Should Contend for Coca-Cola 600 Win
Wyatt Johnston22 hours ago

Ends Scoring Drought With Two Assists
Triston Casas22 hours ago

On Track To Start Hitting Next Week
Leon Draisaitl22 hours ago

Nullified For First Time In 2024 Playoffs
Blake Snell22 hours ago

Reinstated From Paternity List, Starting Monday
Mika Zibanejad22 hours ago

On The Cusp Of Making History
Jordan Beck22 hours ago

Officially Placed On Injured List
Jimmy Vesey22 hours ago

Out Week-To-Week
Ronel Blanco22 hours ago

Starting Sunday Against Athletics
Kristaps Porzingis22 hours ago

No Update On Kristaps Porzingis For Monday Night
Byron Buxton23 hours ago

Absent From Sunday's Lineup
Tyrese Haliburton23 hours ago

Unlikely Back For Game 4
Tyler O'Neill23 hours ago

Planning To Return Tuesday
Oneil Cruz23 hours ago

Getting The Day Off
Austin Riley24 hours ago

Sitting Out Series Finale
Jeimer Candelario24 hours ago

Sitting Against Dodgers
Shohei Ohtani24 hours ago

In Sunday's Lineup
Derrick Henry1 day ago

Will Be Involved In Passing Attack
NASCAR1 day ago

Bubba Wallace Will Start 12th In The Coca-Cola 600
Tyler Reddick1 day ago

Why Tyler Reddick Is Not A Core Play This Weekend At Charlotte
Joey Logano1 day ago

What Should You Do With Joey Logano This Weekend At Charlotte Motor Speedway?
Carson Hocevar1 day ago

Is Carson Hocevar A Value Play At Charlotte?
Ty Gibbs1 day ago

Will Start On The Pole In Sunday's Coca-Cola 600
Ryan Blaney1 day ago

a Strong DFS Play at Charlotte
Chase Elliott1 day ago

Is Chase Elliott A Core Play In Sunday's Coca-Cola 600?
Kyle Busch1 day ago

a Value DFS Play at Charlotte
Alex Bowman1 day ago

Why Alex Bowman May Be The Best Contrarian Play In The Coca-Cola 600
Noah Gragson1 day ago

Should Be Better Than Record at Charlotte
Christopher Bell1 day ago

Why You Should Limit Your Exposure To Christopher Bell At Charlotte Motor Speedway
Chase Briscoe1 day ago

Likely Looking at a Mediocre Run at Charlotte
Ricky Stenhouse Jr1 day ago

Don't Be Afraid to Roll the Dice with Ricky Stenhouse Jr at Charlotte
Kyle Larson1 day ago

Could Miss Coca-Cola 600 at Charlotte
Josh Berry1 day ago

Isn't a Great DFS Option at Charlotte
Jaylen Brown1 day ago

Helps Boston Claim Game 3
Jayson Tatum1 day ago

Leads Boston To A Comeback Win
Mike Conley2 days ago

Questionable Again For Game 3
Luka Doncic2 days ago

Back On The Injury Report For Sunday
Shohei Ohtani2 days ago

Dealing With A Bruised Hamstring
Joe Burrow2 days ago

No "Special Pitch Counter" For Joe Burrow
Joe Mixon2 days ago

Dameon Pierce Viewed As A "One-Two Punch"
Brandon Aiyuk2 days ago

Reportedly Looking To Double Annual Salary
Jrue Holiday2 days ago

Available For Game 3
Grayson Murray2 days ago

PGA Tour Player Grayson Murray Passes Away At 30
Michael Massey2 days ago

Held Out Saturday
Artturi Lehkonen3 days ago

Doubtful For Training Camp
Roope Hintz3 days ago

In Contention To Return To Action On Saturday
Sergei Bobrovsky3 days ago

Looks To Continue Hot Streak In Game 2 Against Rangers
Igor Shesterkin3 days ago

Attempts To Turn Around Form On Friday
Filip Chytil3 days ago

An Option To Join Top Line Friday
Kaapo Kakko3 days ago

In Danger Of Being Scratched For Game 2
Pat Freiermuth3 days ago

Developing Chemistry With New QB
Russell Wilson3 days ago

Looking Good At OTAs
Caleb Williams3 days ago

Has Struggled At OTAs
Christian Watson3 days ago

Hoping To Move Past Hamstring Issues
Anthony Richardson3 days ago

Won't Change His Playing Style
Blake Corum3 days ago

Rams Seeking Three-Down Role From Blake Corum
Javonte Williams3 days ago

Newcomers Threatening Javonte Williams' Role
Samaje Perine3 days ago

Jaleel McLaughlin Facing Threat To Workload
Courtland Sutton4 days ago

Not At OTAs
Travis Etienne Jr.4 days ago

Jaguars Plan To Ease Travis Etienne Jr.'s Workload
Derrick Henry4 days ago

Ravens Not Putting A Cap On Derrick Henry's Workload
Rome Odunze4 days ago

Expected To Practice Next Week
Marvin Harrison Jr.4 days ago

Cardinals Sign Marvin Harrison Jr. To Rookie Deal
Jameson Williams4 days ago

A "Man On A Mission"
Darren Waller4 days ago

Absent At OTAs
Daniel Jones4 days ago

Has No Doubt He'll Be Ready For Week 1
Si Woo Kim6 days ago

Misses First Cut In 2024
Nicolai Hojgaard6 days ago

Debuts At Charles Schwab Challenge
Harry Hall6 days ago

Returns To Charles Schwab Challenge
Grayson Murray6 days ago

Looks To Continue Playing Well At Colonial
Garrick Higgo6 days ago

Struggling For Form Heading To Colonial
Scottie Scheffler6 days ago

A Favorite To Win At Colonial
Rafael Campos6 days ago

A Risky Play At Charles Schwab Challenge
Lucas Glover6 days ago

A Healthy Option At Charles Schwab Challenge
Hayden Springer6 days ago

Can Hayden Springer Turn Things Around At Colonial?
Tyson Alexander6 days ago

Needs More Than A Putter At Colonial
PGA6 days ago

J.T. Poston Is Risky But Has A Lot To Like At Charles Schwab Challenge
Mark Hubbard6 days ago

Trending Up Ahead Of Charles Schwab Challenge
Alejandro Tosti6 days ago

Headed For Trouble At Colonial
Chan Kim6 days ago

A Potential Value At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA6 days ago

S.H. Kim A Sneaky Option At Colonial
Justin Suh6 days ago

A Player To Avoid At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA6 days ago

Matthi Schmid Looks To Regain Form At Colonial




Brian Thomas Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football Wide Receivers You Must Draft in 2024 - Part III

This series continues moving on with our third edition, which looks at three new receivers that fantasy managers must draft this season. We've already identified six incredibly attractive receivers at their current ADPs. We're starting to move down the wide receiver ranks, which will have us focusing on several rookie receivers. Selling rookie receivers can... Read More

Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

Which Rookie QB Can Turn Their Franchise Around? (2024)

A record-tying six quarterbacks were selected in the first round of the 2024 NFL Draft, and we all know how great the last draft that had six QBs in the first round turned out to be. The 1983 NFL Draft is still regarded as one of the greatest drafts of all time, having produced three... Read More

Cooper Kupp - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, Draft Targets

Fantasy Football Wide Receivers You Must Draft in 2024 - Part II

In 2024, fantasy football managers are all about wide receivers, but we’re also about value. With prices skyrocketing everywhere else, we don’t want to pay above market value for a player. We also don’t want to pay for a player at the cost of their 90th-percentile outcome. We need the potential to get a positive... Read More

Ty Chandler - Fantasy Football Rankings, Waiver Wire Pickups, Draft Sleepers

Aaron Jones, Ty Chandler - Fantasy Football Outlook for Minnesota Vikings RBs in 2024

The Minnesota Vikings offense will look a little different in 2024. Quarterback Kirk Cousins left in free agency, and the team replaced him with first-round pick J.J. McCarthy. McCarthy or free-agent signing Sam Darnold will start the year as the Vikings quarterback. Even the running position has changed for Minnesota this offseason. They released Alexander Mattison -- who started the 2023 season... Read More

George Pickens - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Fantasy Football Wide Receivers You Must Draft in 2024 - Part I

Running backs are so 2010, am I right? Fantasy football has completely moved on. Now, all we want are the receivers. How many receivers are too many? That’s not actually a thing. You cannot have too many receivers. Who’s my No. 2 running back going to be? I don’t care, but check this out, Jameson... Read More

Ezekiel Elliott - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Five Fantasy Football Risers on New Teams in 2024

With free agency and the draft now complete and OTAs heating up, NFL roster outlooks are looking a lot more clear than they were at the end of the 2023 season. Some players who switched teams will see a boost to their fantasy football value, while others will take on lesser roles in their new... Read More

Sophomore Disappointments? 2024 Fantasy Football Second-Year Wide Receiver Fallers

We're working around the clock at RotoBaller in preparation for the upcoming fantasy football season! With early best ball drafts already getting underway, we're taking a look at some notable fantasy football players for the 2024 campaign. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into three second-year wide receivers who could be facing a rocky road in 2024.... Read More

Breakout Potential? 2024 Fantasy Football Rookie Tight End Analysis

How do you spend the offseason? Here at RotoBaller, we're working around the clock to prep for the coming NFL campaign. With early best ball drafts already underway, we're taking a look at some potential breakout rookies for the 2024 season. RotoBaller's David Rispoli dives into three rookie tight ends who could turn into fantasy... Read More


UFL Fantasy Football Rankings for Week 9: QB, RB, WR, TE Rankings and Analysis (2024)

With Week 8 in the books, the UFL playoff matchups are set despite two weeks of regular season play remaining. There has been no shortage of parity between the top and bottom teams in the league's first season. This week's rankings are likely to be more of a crapshoot than past rankings. Playoff teams have... Read More


Free UFL Betting Picks - Best Bets, Odds, Predictions for Week 9

Well, that was not a good week. As has been the pattern--these things happen, especially when Arlington whiffs so bad as the underdog in the week after a 47-point explosion for their first win in what has become a miserable season. As of now, as far as stakes for the 2024 regular season are concerned,... Read More

Rashee Rice - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL wr, Draft Sleepers

Sophomore Slump: Can Rashee Rice, Jordan Addison, and Jayden Reed Meet Expectations in Year Two?

Each year, a new, promising crop of rookies enters the NFL. A number of these rookies meet or exceed expectations as first-year players and establish themselves as rising stars in the professional ranks. Many then proceed to ascend further in subsequent seasons. However, not all of these young talents continue on their upward trajectories; some... Read More

Ladd McConkey - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 Dynasty Rookie Rankings For Superflex Leagues: 20-11

Now that we’re coming off our rookie fever, it’s time to see where the newest NFL players stack up against the veterans. That’s right, we’re talking rookies and dynasty rankings. My name is Ellis Johnson and this is my sixth year writing NFL content with RotoBaller. I also contribute to FantasyPros Expert Consensus Rankings and... Read More

Khalil Herbert - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

D'Andre Swift, Khalil Herbert, Roschon Johnson - Fantasy Football Outlook for Chicago Bears RBs in 2024

The Chicago Bears were extremely active this offseason and will head into the 2024-2025 season trending up. Despite finishing last in the NFC North with a 7-10 record last year, the Bears are surely in a better spot now in the division. That's because of their successful offseason. Chicago traded for veteran wide receiver Keenan Allen and signed... Read More