X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Shortstop ADPs - Overvalued and Undervalued

Now that the first day of spring has passed, we are now entering the prime season for fantasy baseball drafts.

Before you enter your draft room this year, it would behoove you to check out our ADP analysis pieces here at RotoBaller. This will ensure that you have a good working knowledge of how players are being viewed, when to grab your targeted guys, and when to let your league mates jump on a guy going too early. In the end, you will look like a genius.

There is not much going on in 2017 fantasy drafts that I absolutely hate in regards to shortstop ADP. I can make the argument that Francisco Lindor is going too early, but once that shortstop run starts, I know from experience the feeling of desperation to get one of the studs. Plus, he presents such a safe floor of all around production. Other than that, not much is happening that I disagree with. But there is a lot of production at the position that is going much too late in drafts, so keep scrolling and be enlightened.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and resources:

 

Overvalued Shortstops

Addison Russell, CHC

2017 ADP: 123, SS9

Two full seasons in the MLB and Addison Russell is still going to hurt your teams BA while only providing decent power numbers (21 HR, 95 RBI). His 2016 performance ranked him as the 17th shortstop in standard roto leagues. He's not even the best hitting shortstop-eligible guy on his team, as Javier Baez flashed more fantasy potential in 450 PA, especially with the added value of SB. The power seems to be maturing nicely, but no ones expecting him to hit over 25 HR. His 2016 BABIP of .277 (career BABIP is .299) does lead me to believe the BA will rise, but we're optimistically looking at .250.

Bottom line: you've waited this long to draft a shortstop, might as well build up your rotation/bullpen and wait a bit longer for a safer guy here. I prefer a couple of the guys listed below, and would also rather have Aledmys Diaz for similar stats with a better BA, Jose Peraza for the SB, or Javier Baez for a little bit of everything. Don't hurt your BA until you absolutely have to, or if you're getting elite numbers in alternate categories from the same hitter.

 

Dansby Swanson, ATL

2017 ADP: 170, SS17

Drafting Swanson before the plethora of veterans falling behind him is a classic rookie-hype move, one in which I would certainly recommend in a dynasty/keeper format. But in standard leagues, let's pump the brakes a bit. Swanson has all of 145 PA at the MLB level, in which he hit three HR with a .302 BA, adding three SB. The BA came with a ridiculous .383 BABIP, and came after hitting .261 in 371 PA at Double A. The common realistic projections I seem to see for Swanson are 13 HR, nine SB, with a BA around (usually below) .260. This sounds a lot like another shortstop who was hyped up in Atlanta, but ended up being much better in real life than in fantasy. Y'all remember Andrelton Simmons? Obviously Simmons wasn't a number one overall pick like Swanson, but both are highly touted for their defensive prowess.

Considering his draft position, Swanson is being drafted as a MIF, which I don't have too much quarrel about. If he does hit his projections, he would rank around the 15-17th among fantasy shortstops. But the fact that he is being drafted in the 15th round means those MIF drafters are passing on proven bats like Logan Forsythe, Neil Walker, and even his teammate Brandon Phillips. That's also passing on less-proven guys that I feel have more realistic upside in 2017 like Devon Travis, Hernan Perez, and Marcus Semien.

 

Undervalued Shortstops

Trevor Story, COL

2017 ADP: 35, SS7

I've been talking up Trevor Story all offseason (50 HR candidates, Bold Predictions, Tier One SS Keepers). I have grown tired of praising his power, but just in case you've missed it: 27 HR in 415 PA, second best ISO and Hard% in the league, and top five flyball percentage. This is the player they had in mind when Coors Field was created. I have and will continue to draft Story before Francisco Lindor, Jonathan Villar, and Xander Bogaerts. They are all great fantasy shortstop options, but none have 40/20 potential like my boy. Villar has the rare speed value but I am going to take the Coors Field inhabitant when I have the choice. The run scoring stats will be there, as he was well on his way to 90 R and 90 RBI after scoring 67 and 72 in his 415 PA. Once Ian Desmond and David Dahl are healthy, Colorado will have one of the highest scoring offenses in the league. Story will be in the thick of it, hitting bombs and stealing bases (and my heart).

Here at RotoBaller, we rank Story 23rd overall. That is ahead of both Lindor and Villar. He is currently being drafted behind all of the stud shortstops, and sliding into the late third round/early fourth round. This is too late for the upcoming production. I love the value so much that I have drafted him, as my MIF, two rounds after picking Carlos Correa in TWO drafts already. If you can get him this late, congratulations. But if you miss out on a historic season because you wanted Francisco Lindor's safe floor, at least I warned you.

 

Eduardo Nunez, SF

2017 ADP: 130, SS10

Nuni caught everyone by surprise right out the gate in 2016, exploding for 12 HR and a .836 OPS heading into the mid summer classic. The second half was less-than-stellar, but he still finished with a cool .288 BA, 16 HR, 40 SB, and also found himself on a championship contender out in San Francisco. Don't let the second half woes fool you into thinking AT&T Park sapped his fantasy value away. In just 21 games in the bay, he hit .307 with two HR.

The 16 HR seem just somewhat of an overachievement for Nunez, even though he owned a HR/FB% that was less than one point higher than 2015. However, the speed is real and I think the spacious AT&T Park will play to his strengths very well as he owns a top 25 contact percentage. Speed is valuable this season, and even though CBS and NFBC leagues are getting it right, Yahoo and ESPN users are still taking Nunez after Addison Russell. Don't do it.

 

Marcus Semien, OAK

2017 ADP: 248, SS22

Even on a much less potent offense, Semien finished 2016 ranked higher than Addison Russell among fantasy shortstops. He hit six more HR, stole five more bases, and hit the same putrid BA. He is still only 26 years old, so why is there more than a 100 pick difference in their ADPs? Both experienced a jump from a 9% HR/FB rate to 14%, and both suffered from significant BABIP decreases. For what it's worth, Steamer, Zips, and CAIRO all project Semien to again beat out Russell in both HR and SB while hitting roughly the same BA. If it's the RBI you are worried about, the Athletics added Rajai Davis to the top of their lineup, now get a full season out of stud Ryon Healy, and will also roll out OBP-machine Matt Joyce against RHP to give Khris Davis and Semien plenty of run-plating opportunities.

In every draft that I do not grab two shortstops in the first four rounds (it looks better than it sounds...kind of), I end up with Marcus Semien as my MIF and I love the value. Obviously you shouldn't take Semien in Addison Russell territory, but passing on the Cubbie and getting Semien nine to 10 rounds later allows for a much more rounded-out roster.

 

Jorge Polanco, MIN

2017 ADP: 382, SS32

Here's a hot take for you. Jorge Polanco will finish the 2017 season ranked ahead of Dansby Swanson in standard fantasy leagues. Yet, for some reason the 23-year-old seems to be forgotten on draft day. Between Triple A and 69 games with the big league crew in 2016, Polanco hit 13 HR and stole nine bases. He doesn't have the skillset to eek out many more long balls than that, but he did total 20 SB in 2015. His line drive percentage was the highest among all shortstops last year, and he showed good plate discipline for a player of his age. Polanco should be the Twins everyday shortstop, and could easily beat out Byron Buxton for the second spot in the lineup. Surrounded by Brian Dozier, Joe Mauer, Miguel Sano, and Max Kepler, Polanco will be a serious sleeper for runs in 2017.

Thanks to the line drives and good plate discipline, Polanco will have a higher BA than Dansby Swanson. He has the chance to score just as many runs, and produce roughly the same HR/SB. The only difference? You can get Polanco 17 rounds later.

 

More Undervalued & Overvalued Picks




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Jamie Benn

Makes Season Debut Tuesday
Stephon Castle

Sidelined 1 to 2 Weeks
Evgenii Dadonov

on Track to Return Tuesday
Dougie Hamilton

a Game-Time Call Tuesday
Anthony Cirelli

Expected to Return Against Devils
Victor Hedman

Questionable for Tuesday
LeBron James

Aims to Make Season Debut Tuesday
Auston Matthews

to Miss at Least Two More Games
Grayson Allen

Sidelined on Tuesday
Gabe Vincent

Set to Suit Up Tuesday
C.J. Stroud

Expected to Return in Week 13 Against Colts
C.J. Stroud

to Miss Another Game
Jonathan Kuminga

Remains Out Tuesday
Keegan Murray

Could Make his Season Debut This Week
Caris LeVert

Liston as Out on Tuesday
Tobias Harris

Could Return Thursday
Ausar Thompson

Questionable Again on Tuesday
Joe Mixon

Uncertainty Remains Around Joe Mixon's Return Timeline
Cade Cunningham

is Questionable Tuesday in Atlanta
Jaylen Warren

Mike Tomlin Optimistic About Jaylen Warren's Availability for Week 12
C.J. Stroud

Not Expected to Play on Thursday Night
Aaron Rodgers

Won't Need Surgery on Fractured Wrist, Could Play in Week 12?
Davis Mills

Prepping for Third Straight Start in Week 12?
CFB

Sam Leavitt Set to Enter Transfer Portal?
Mason Rudolph

Could Make His First Start of 2025 in Week 12
Brock Wright

Sets Career-High in Targets; Lined Up for More Work?
Stephon Castle

Out Against Grizzlies
Kimani Vidal

Struggles Again and Faces Role Uncertainty After Bye
Dak Prescott

in Full Command Monday Night With Four Touchdown Passes
Quentin Johnston

Posts Zero Catches During Offensive Collapse
George Pickens

Erupts for 144 Yards, Touchdown in Monday Night Win
Jrue Holiday

Unlikely to Play Tuesday
CeeDee Lamb

George Pickens Benched for First Drive
LeBron James

Officially Listed as Questionable for Tuesday
Jose Altuve

Undergoes Foot Surgery
Giannis Antetokounmpo

Exits Monday's Game With Groin Injury
Julian Strawther

Out on Monday
Cameron Johnson

Cleared for Action Monday
Nikola Jokić

Nikola Jokic Available Against Bulls
Zaccharie Risacher

Considered Questionable for Tuesday's Game
Onyeka Okongwu

Iffy for Tuesday
Kristaps Porzingis

May Miss Another Game Tuesday
Jalen Suggs

Listed as Questionable for Tuesday
Alex Singleton

Broncos Optimistic Patrick Surtain, Alex Singleton Will Return After the Bye
Trey Hendrickson

Doubtful Again in Week 12
Shedeur Sanders

Expected to Make First Career Start in Week 12
Josh Jacobs

Dealing With Knee Contusion
Mikael Granlund

Unavailable Monday
Alex Bregman

Red Sox Going for Either Alex Bregman or Pete Alonso?
Conor Garland

Misses Monday's Game
Eetu Luostarinen

Out on Monday
Drake London

Considered "Week-to-Week"
Drew Doughty

Listed as Week-to-Week
Ja'Marr Chase

Being Suspended for One Game for Unsportsmanlike Conduct
John Carlson

a Game-Time Call Monday
Viktor Arvidsson

Out Week-to-Week
Charlie McAvoy

Out Against Hurricanes
CFB

James Franklin to be Virginia Tech's Next Head Coach
Brandon Aiyuk

49ers Won't Open Brandon Aiyuk's Practice Window This Week
CFB

Fernando Mendoza the Clear Heisman Trophy Favorite?
CFB

Beau Pribula Has Chance to Face Oklahoma on Saturday
Mitchell Marner

Establishes Vegas Record Sunday
Mats Zuccarello

Logs Two Assists in Overtime Victory
Lucas Raymond

Leads Red Wings to Victory at MSG
Quinn Hughes

Delivers Four Assists in Sunday's Win
Conor Garland

Limited to Handful of Minutes Sunday
Ryan Hartman

Suffers Lower-Body Injury
Adrian Kempe

Agrees to $85 Million Extension With Kings
Jack Della Maddalena

Gets Dominated
Islam Makhachev

Claims UFC Welterweight Belt
Zhang Weili

Gets Outclassed
Valentina Shevchenko

Wins Unanimous Decision At UFC 322
Sean Brady

Suffers First-Round TKO Loss
Michael Morales

Remains Unbeaten
Leon Edwards

Suffers Second-Round Knockout Loss
Leon Edwards

Carlos Prates Becomes The First Man To Knock Out Leon Edwards
Beneil Dariush

Suffers Brutal First-Round Knockout Loss
Beneil Dariush

Benoit Saint Denis Knocks Out Beneil Dariush In 16 Seconds
Josh Naylor

Mariners Finalizing Five-Year Contract
Scott Mayfield

Available Sunday
CFB

Jeremiah Smith, Carnell Tate Not Dealing With Long-Term Injuries
CFB

Virginia Tech Close To Naming James Franklin As Head Coach
CFB

Garrett Nussmeier Doubtful vs. Arkansas On Saturday
Edwin Díaz

Blue Jays Interested in Signing Edwin Diaz?
Jacob deGrom

Named AL Comeback Player of the Year
Ronald Acuña Jr.

Ronald Acuna Jr. Wins NL Comeback Player of the Year Award
Aroldis Chapman

Named AL Reliever of the Year
Edwin Díaz

Edwin Diaz Named NL Reliever of the Year
Justin Thomas

Will Miss Start Of 2026 After Undergoing Back Surgery
Islam Makhachev

Set For UFC 322 Main Event
Jack Della Maddalena

Set For His First Title Defense
Zhang Weili

Can Become The New Women's Flyweight Champion
Valentina Shevchenko

Set For UFC 322 Co-Main Event
Michael Morales

Looks To Remain Undefeated
CFB

Mario Craver a Game-Time Decision for Week 12
Sean Brady

Set For Title Eliminator Bout
Carlos Prates

A Favorite At UFC 322
Leon Edwards

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Benoît Saint Denis

Benoit Saint Denis Set To Open Up UFC 322 Main Card
Beneil Dariush

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
CFB

Virginia's Chandler Morris Trending Toward Facing Duke on Saturday
Edwin Díaz

Edwin Diaz Says There's a "50-50" Chance he Returns to Mets
Shohei Ohtani

Wins his Fourth MVP Award
Aaron Judge

Wins AL MVP Award Again
Raisel Iglesias

Dodgers Interested in Signing Raisel Iglesias
Pete Alonso

Orioles Could be in the Mix to Sign Pete Alonso
Félix Bautista

Felix Bautista Could Return in Second Half in 2026
Kodai Senga

Attracting Trade Interest, Will the Mets Move him?
Yordan Alvarez

Expected to be Ready for Spring Training
Byron Buxton

Could Waive his No-Trade Clause
Paul Skenes

the Unanimous NL Cy Young Winner
Tarik Skubal

Wins AL Cy Young for Second Straight Year

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP