👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE SPRING
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 50% Now
Import Your Leagues
Props Tool
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

2017 Keeper Values: Catcher Rankings - Tier Three

What's up RotoBallers. Welcome back to my series on keeper leagues. Today I'll be taking a look at catcher keeper values for fantasy baseball (tier three), for those of you deciding what players to keep for your teams.

Keeper Value Rankings are intended for Keeper Leagues in which a fantasy owner must forfeit a designated draft round in order to keep a player into the up-coming season. These rankings are based on Keeper "Values". In the marketing world, Value can be defined as: the extent to which a good or service (player) is perceived by its customer (fantasy owner) to meet his/her needs or wants.

For these specific rankings, 12 team, 5x5 scoring, 23 man roster, Rotisserie league settings were used. If you play in a custom league with non-standard configurations, are thinking of keeping a player not on this list, or want to compare players on your team, follow me on Twitter @RowdyRotoJB or contact me via the RotoBaller Chat Rooms.

Editor's note: Be sure to also check out our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. It's already loaded up with tons of great rankings articles and draft analysis. Aside from our tiered staff rankings for every position, we also go deep on MLB prospect rankings, impact rookies for 2017, and dynasty/keeper rankings as well. Bookmark the page, and win your drafts.

 

How My Keeper Valuation Formula Works

The Keeper Values are derived from my 15 step Keeper Valuation Formula. The product is a quanitative depiction of a players ability to meet/exceed fantasy owners needs based on the cost they payed for the player in the previous season (2016 ADP). The higher the score, the higher the return the fantasy owner will receive from the player, keeping him at his associated cost. Approaching Keeper selections with this "value" based attitude, will greatly increase the effectiveness of a fantasy owner's draft in a Keeper League.

TIER SCORE EXPLANATION
1 >75 Finders Keepers! These are the Elite Keeper Values. MUST BE KEPT.
2 50-75 Great Keeper values. Unless you have a full load of Tier 1 players, these guys need to be kept.
3 25-49 You are gaining value with these players, but not as much as your opponents are, potentially. Consider if your options are limited.
4 0-24 Break even point. Minimal value. Only consider if you have a large quantity of Keeper selections.
5 -99-0 Keeping these players will hurt your overall draft, as you are not adding any value. Dont waste a Keeper selection here.
6 <-100 The associated costs make it impossible to return any value, these players will ruin your draft. Stay far away.

 

2017 Top Catcher Keeper Values: #3-7

7. Kyle Schwarber, CHC (Fourth Round ADP) Keeper Valuation Formula Score: 21.31

Technically, Schwarber falls slightly into Tier Four, but how can you leave the man out? In just 69 games during his rookie season in 2015, the Hoosier hit 16 HR and 43 RBI, while scoring 52 runs. His extremely-hyped 2016 campaign was shortened to just five PA due to a gruesome knee injury suffered in the outfield, but as we saw during the Cubs magical postseason run, the dude can still swing the stick. The fantasy gods have granted us the gift of another year of catcher eligibility for Schwarbs, which greatly increases his value.

I was personally surprised Schwarber scored as well as he did in the formula due to his high ADP from last season. But I guess when you can have a projected Top 20 outfielder with 30+ HR potential hitting in front of Kris Bryant and Anthony Rizzo sitting in your catcher position on your roster, you can certainly receive dividends. There have even been reports this offseason of Schwarber leading off in 2017 against RHP.

This is going to be fun.

 

6. Evan Gattis, HOU (19th Round ADP) Keeper Valuation Formula Score: 26.74

Its great to see Gattis receiving catcher eligibility again after going all of 2015 without squatting behind the plate. We can all thank Jason Castro's offensive ineptness. Along with seeing 55 G at catcher, Gattis also broke the 30 HR crest for the first time in his career. El Oso Blanco led the position with 32 HR, .257 ISO, and a .508 SLG. His 24.1 HR/FB% was a career high, however, with his LD% increasing every season since 2013, he's clearly not getting lucky hitting bloopers.

The main issue with Gattis in 2017 will be consistent playing time. With the acquisitions of Brian McCann, Carlos Beltran, and Josh Reddick, it won't be the norm to see Gattis in the starting lineup. However, Gattis hit .288/.341/.545 against LHP in 2016, while McCann and Reddick struggled mightily versus the southpaws slashing .218/.317/.345 and .155/.212/.155 respectively. So there seems to be plenty of hope Gattis gets playing time on the weak side of some platoons at the least. I mean when he posts the second highest WAR among catchers over the second half of last season, it's got to be tough to keep the man on the pine.

 

5. Yasmani Grandal, LAD (19th Round ADP) Keeper Valuation Formula Score: 42.43

Despite making his first All-Star Game appearance in 2015, Yasmani Grandal had his true break out last season after smacking 27 HR and 72 RBI for the Dodgers. The switch-hitter carries over a putrid BA (.228), but redeemed himself in OBP leagues thanks to the second highest BB% among catchers. Like Gattis, Grandal experienced a major hike in his HR/FB%, but somewhat justified the rise with a 9% increase in his Hard Hit Percentage. He also might have helped his cause by his sheer ability to destroy fastballs.

Untitled                                                                                                                                       

(Fangraphs.com)

Grandal's all-around production potential is lower than that of Gattis, especially considering the BA, but Grandal is a much safer bet due to playing time with only youngster Austin Barnes behind him. Enjoy the power from the only other catcher to eclipse the 25 HR plateau, and expect much of what we saw in the second half of last season to reappear for Grandal in 2017. Keep throwing this dude the cheese!

 

4. J.T. Realmuto, MIA (19th Round ADP) Keeper Valuation Formula Score: 44.19

As you can see, the 19th round was a popular one for catchers last season. My favorite, and the formula's favorite from this group is J.T. Realmuto. The only catcher to join the 10/10 club (maybe less than a club, maybe 10/10 affiliation is more accurate), JT hit 10 HR, stole 12 bases, and slashed a sexy .303/.343/.428 in 2016. He suffers from a strange reverse split, .617 OPS vs LHP/ .806 vs RHP, and understandably mashes away from the spacious Marlins Park (72 wRC+ Home/ 141 Away). Despite the splits, Realmuto earned the third highest WAR among catchers last season after being drafted as a #12 catcher.

Hitting at the bottom of the order really caps Realmuto's counting stats, and after boasting the highest BABIP (.357) among qualified catchers, one can reasonably expect a dip in his terrific BA falling somewhere close to his .281 career average. But those SB and a respectable BA are still valuable at the catcher position, espcially if you can gain over five rounds of value. RotoBaller's Expert Rankings project Realmuto right outside the top 150, placing the 25 year old around round 13 in 2017 drafts.

 

3. Jonathan Lucroy, TEX (Ninth Round ADP) Keeper Valuation Formula Score: 49.65

Finishing the 2016 as the top ranked fantasy catcher, Jonathan Lucroy seemed to fit in just fine on his new team in Arlington. The two time All Star hit a career high 24 HR, knocked in a position-leading 81 RBI, and hit over .290 for the third time in his career. The power was a sight for sore eyes after a seven HR display in 2015, as he nearly doubled his ISO last season.

Untitled

 

Untitled

 

Lucroy will continue to hit in the heart of the Rangers lineup, which scored the seventh most runs last season. The added DH option will only help his case for at-bats as he creeps over the 30 year mark. He is currently the second ranked catcher for 2017, and even presents a case for the number one spot over Buster Posey in his new uniform. Giving up a top ten pick to keep a catcher never seems easy, but with the elite offensive ability, Lucroy still rolls into the season as the third best keeper value behind the plate.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 50% Now
Import Your Leagues
Props Tool
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Isaiah Bond

Dynasty Value Fading Following NFL Draft
James Cook

Can James Cook Continue to Ascend in 2026 and Beyond?
Lamar Jackson

Remains an Elite Dynasty Quarterback Despite Injury-Marred 2025
Kyle Williams

' Dynasty Value Limited by Uncertain Role in New England
Luis Robert Jr.

Officially Placed on Injured List
Isaac TeSlaa

Still a Dynasty Depth Piece Worth Holding
Pat Bryant

Still a Quality Buy-Low Despite Crowded Broncos Receiver Room
Luis Robert Jr.

Likely to Land on the Injured List
Troy Franklin

Dynasty Expectations Low for Troy Franklin
Trevor Lawrence

Dynasty Value Remains High Despite Quiet Jaguars Offseason
Courtland Sutton

Dynasty Value Unaffected by NFL Draft
Clayton Keller

Sets Up Two Goals Wednesday Night
Pavel Dorofeyev

Nets Special Hat Trick in Game 5 Win
Dan Vladar

Backstops Flyers to Series-Clinching Win
Leon Draisaitl

Oilers to Use Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl on Same Line Thursday
Brady Tkachuk

Remains Committed to Senators
Arttu Hyry

Could Be Available Thursday
James Harden

Contributes in All Areas Wednesday
Dennis Schröder

Dennis Schroder Plays Key Role in Game 5 Win
RJ Barrett

Records First Double-Double of the Season
Austin Reaves

Contributes 22 Points Off the Bench in Game 5 Loss
LeBron James

Regains Scoring Touch Wednesday
Paolo Banchero

Scores 45 Points in Game 5 Loss
New York Jets

Jets Pick Up Will McDonald's Fifth-Year Option
Azeez Al-Shaair

Texans, Azeez Al-Shaair Agree to Three-Year Extension
KC Concepcion

Looking to Build Chemistry With Second-Year QB
Deshaun Watson

"Looks Great," Leading QB Battle After First Minicamp?
George Pickens

Signs the Franchise Tag on Wednesday
Cade Cunningham

Helps Pistons Survive With 45-Point Effort
Jock Landale

to Remain Unavailable in Game 6
Peyton Watson

to Remain Out Thursday
Austin Reaves

Cleared to Return Wednesday
Luka Dončić

Luka Doncic Remains Without Timetable for Return
Brandon Nimmo

Leaves Wednesday's Game With Hamstring Tightness
Brandon Ingram

Won't Play in Second Half Wednesday
Aaron Gordon

Questionable for Game 6
Josh Hart

Iffy for Game 6
Joel Embiid

Likely to Play in Game 6
Bones Hyland

Could Miss Game 6
Kevin Huerter

Not Available for Game 5
Jonathan Isaac

Remains Out for Game 5
Franz Wagner

Won't Play in Game 5
MLB

Phillies-Giants Postponed on Wednesday Due to Rain
Nils Lundkvist

to Remain Out Thursday
Jonas Brodin

Uncertain for Game 6
Matvei Michkov

Expected to Rejoin Flyers Lineup Wednesday
Noah Ostlund

Set to Miss "a Period of Time"
Viktor Arvidsson

Doubtful for Game 6 Against Sabres
Barrett Hayton

Close to Returning
Charle-Edouard D'Astous

a Game-Time Call Wednesday
Brandon Aiyuk

Decision Could Come in Late May
Bryce Young

Panthers Pick Up Bryce Young's Fifth-Year Option
MLB

Orioles-Astros Game Postponed Due to Inclement Weather on Wednesday
Gary Woodland

Riding Momentum Into Cadillac Championship
Jordan Spieth

Brings Boom-or-Bust Potential to Cadillac Championship
Adam Scott

Looks Poised for Another Strong Finish at Doral
Maverick McNealy

Needs Approach Game to Click at Doral
George Springer

Being Activated From Injured List, Won't Start on Wednesday
Wyatt Langford

Expected to be Activated on Saturday
Garrett Crochet

Goes on Injured List With Shoulder Inflammation
CFB

Jameson Williams Files Lawsuit Against NCAA, SEC, Big Ten
Junior Caminero

Back in Wednesday's Lineup After Injury Scare
Harry Hall

Volatility Continues at Cadillac Championship
Tommy Fleetwood

Looks to Rebound at Trump National Doral
Pierceson Coody

a Risky Value Play at Cadillac Championship
Deebo Samuel Sr.

Will Deebo Samuel Sr. Find a New Team Before Training Camps Open?
Jalen Johnson

Collects Second Playoff Double-Double
Akshay Bhatia

Offers Upside with Risk at Cadillac Championship
Elic Ayomanor

Dynasty Stock Way Down After NFL Draft
Jalen Brunson

Pours 39 Points on Hawks in Game 5
Darius Slayton

Dynasty Value Fading After Busy Giants Offseason
David Njoku

With the NFL Draft Over, David Njoku Could Soon Find a Team
Tyler Warren

a Major Offseason Winner
Connor McDavid

Extends Multi-Point Streak Tuesday
Justin Thomas

a Scary Proposition at Cadillac Championship
Nikolaj Ehlers

Hurricanes Hope to Have Nikolaj Ehlers Back for Second Round
Alexander Nikishin

Could Be Available in Round 2
Victor Hedman

Logs Full Practice
Scottie Scheffler

The Leading Favorite at Cadillac Championship
Noah Ostlund

Likely to Miss Time Due to Lower-Body Injury
Arttu Hyry

Unlikely to Play Thursday
Collin Morikawa

Still a Smash Play at Cadillac Championship
Jonas Brodin

Spotted Using Crutches After Game 5
Viktor Hovland

Showed at Augusta He Can Finish Well
Sepp Straka

Attempting to Finish Better in Miami
PGA

J.J Spaun Enduring Roller Coaster Start to 2026
Min Woo Lee

Seeks to Make Adjustments at Cadillac Championship
Max Homa

May Struggle at Old Doral This Weekend
Ben Griffin

Rebounds From Rough Stretch as Miami Looms
Shane Lowry

Searching For Answers at Cadillac Championship
Russell Henley

Daunting Test at Doral Likely Not a Place For Russell Henley
Justin Rose

Returns to Action After Finishing Third at Masters Tournament
Hideki Matsuyama

Has The Approach Game to Win at Cadillac Championship
Junior Caminero

Suffers Jaw Contusion on Tuesday, Considered Day-to-Day
Pete Fairbanks

Going on Injured List With Nerve Irritation
Spencer Strider

to Make Season Debut This Weekend
Roope Hintz

Likely to Miss Entire First-Round Series
Luis Robert Jr.

Out on Tuesday With Back Tightness
Juan Soto

Dealing With Forearm Tightness, Serving as DH on Tuesday
CFB

Brendan Sorsby Facing Potential Permanent Loss of Eligibility
Manny Machado

Departs Early With Undisclosed Injury on Monday
Philadelphia Phillies

Phillies Fire Manager Rob Thomson
Elmer Rodríguez

Yankees to Promote Top Pitching Prospect Elmer Rodriguez
Pete Fairbanks

Pulled on Monday With "Unusual Sensation" in his Thumb
Giancarlo Stanton

Heading to Injured List With Calf Strain
Travis Bazzana

Guardians Calling Up Former First Overall Pick Travis Bazzana
Will Smith

Back in Action in Series Opener Against Marlins
Carson Hocevar

Scores his First Career NASCAR Cup Series Victory at Talladega
Chris Buescher

Misses out on Winning at Talladega by Finishing Second
Alex Bowman

Earns First Top-Five Finish at Talladega Since Returning From Injury
Chase Elliott

Scores A Fourth-Place Finish at Talladega
Zane Smith

Nabs First Top-Five Finish of the 2026 Season at Talladega
CFB

Texas Tech Quarterback Brendan Sorsby Enters Rehab
Youssef Zalal

Suffers Unanimous-Decision Loss
Aljamain Sterling

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Norma Dumont

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 116
Joselyne Edwards

Scores Upset Win
Alexander Hernandez

Gets Dominated
Alexander Hernandez

Rafa Garcia Dominates Alexander Hernandez
Adrian Luna Martinetti

Unsuccessful In His UFC Debut
Davey Grant

Gets Back In The Win Column
Denny Hamlin

Is Denny Hamlin Worth Rostering for Talladega?
NASCAR

Is Bubba Wallace Playable in Talladega DFS Lineups?
Tyler Reddick

Stay Away From Tyler Reddick at Talladega
Ryan Blaney

Can Ryan Blaney Shake Off The Bad Luck at Talladega?
Austin Cindric

Could Contend For Another Talladega Win
Kyle Busch

an Easy DFS Pick at Talladega
Ricky Stenhouse Jr

. a High-Risk, High-Reward Pick at Talladega
Todd Gilliland

a Sleeper to Watch at Talladega
Brad Keselowski

Is Brad Keselowski Worth Rostering for Talladega Lineups?
Chase Briscoe

Could Chase Briscoe be A Sneaky Tournament Play for Talladega Lineups?
Christopher Bell

Should DFS Managers Trust Christopher Bell at Talladega?
Ty Gibbs

Is A DFS Risk for Talladega Lineups
Youssef Zalal

Set For UFC Vegas 116 Main Event
Aljamain Sterling

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 116
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF