TAP FOR 6 MONTHS OF PREMIUM FREE 💰
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Overrated/Underrated Week 4: First Basemen

Week three has come and gone. Whatever dread you may have felt about your team's standing has either tapered off or multiplied, the latter of which feels especially horrible so early in the season. Remember that we all get off to slow starts sometimes. Anthony Rizzo is batting .185 thanks to a .128 batting average on balls in play (BABIP). David Price's ERA is almost a full four runs higher than his FIP. These kinds of issues can drag down every category, and until your player snaps out of it, it's painful to watch.

But when he snaps out of it -- when he regresses to the mean, that is, and stops suffering bad luck -- boy, that'll be fun to watch. And when your team shoots up the leaderboard in June, it will feel much more gratifying than the lead you held for six hours on April 12. The painfully panicked transactions some owners make in April are exacerbated further by the transactions they don't make -- the brand-name players of whom they should let go, or the nobodies off to hot starts that can't possibly sustain their performance through May.

Continuing a weekly segment, I will identify some of the market inefficiencies in ownership rates for players who qualify at the same position. Here are some overrated and underrated first basemen for your consideration.

 

Overvalued First Baseman

Mitch Moreland, TEX 1B
51% owned, via Fleaflicker

Moreland doesn't have colossal upside or anything. He's of the WYSIWYG variety of hitter, having produced at generally the same level for pretty much the entirety of his 6-year career. He's good for 20-homer power but not much else, his lukewarm plate discipline eating into his triple-slash line pretty severely.

Things have taken a turn for the worst in the early goings for Moreland. His strikeout rate (K%) has ballooned to a career-worst frequency (and it's not even close), forcing his career-best BABIP to carry his batting average barely beyond the Mendoza Line. Contact skills are to blame -- he's making the least amount of contact of his career, unsurprisingly -- but his plate approach has been poor, too, as evidenced by his career-worst chase rate (and, again, it's not even close).

Moreland simply doesn't provide much value, regardless of format, thanks to a low-ceiling, one-tool profile. You can do better, even in deep leagues.

 

Undervalued First Baseman

Chris Carter, MIL 1B
27% owned in Fleaflicker Leagues

Carter left a bad taste in a lot of mouths last year after hitting only a buck-99 in part-time duty. His power is massive, but the strikeout rate poses a huge threat to his value, especially when he's riding the BABIP yo-yo. Indeed, that's exactly what he did last year, his BABIP representing not only a career-low for him but also the 6th-lowest mark in MLB for anyone with as many plate appearances as him.

The outlook is a little sunnier right now for Carter, having hit five home runs and lofting his batting average north of .280. All of it is unsustainable -- despite the power, few hitters can make a HR/FB (home runs per fly ball) rate of 29.4% stick for a full season without a good deal of luck -- but it doesn't mean it's not worth investing in. There's no doubting that, in a full season's worth of playing time, Carter can hit 30 home runs. It's primarily a matter of his BABIP, as aforementioned, which has been prone to violent swings (no pun intended) throughout his career. But the fact that he did, once, post a full-season BABIP of .311 (back in 2013) offers the hope that, indeed, this whole not-terrible-batting-average thing is something Carter can pull off.

Meanwhile, his 27.9 K%, while obscenely high, is about the best we'll ever see from Carter, and it doesn't seem too fluky, either. Unlike Moreland, Carter cut down his chase rate big-time, and he's making far more contact on pitchers when he does chase, making him a much more imposing threat than a free-swinging, highly volatile slugger. If he can sustain these gains through, say, June, Carter will be much closer to universally owned than universally unowned. Thirty homers and a .250 average isn't too crazy -- that's what Mark Teixeira (72% owned) gives you, right? (I guess that would make Teixeira overvalued, too, wouldn't it?) And, to boot, he has not only batted in every start (except one), but he has started every game for the Brewers, too. The team doesn't plan to contend, and with no real prospects to force him out of a job, Carter has first base all to himself, day in and day out.

 

BONUS: Joe Mauer, MIN 1B
33% owned

This is definitely more of a deep-league play than anything else. Mauer is a shell of his former self, but as long as he's walking twice as often as he strikes out, he will be an OBP monster and points-league darling. As with all April accomplishments, I must invoke the Unwritten Law of the Small Sample Size. Mauer won't do this forever. But hitters do tend to improve their plate discipline with age, and Mauer's already ranks among the game's best. More walks than strikeouts à la Jose Bautista or Victor Martinez would be a boon to his batting average, and he has the batted ball skills to float a .350 BABIP again without any of us thinking twice.

An empty .300 batting average at first base might be the unsexiest type of value in fantasy baseball. But in a points league, where all points are created equal, or in an OBP format, it doesn't matter how you get there -- get there as in create value -- as long as you get there. Mauer will get there. It just won't be that flashy.

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Joel Embiid

Expected to Play Monday
Christian Braun

Downgraded to Out
Jamal Murray

Cleared to Face Thunder
Nikola Jokić

Nikola Jokic Active Against Thunder
Craig Porter Jr.

Returns From One-Game Absence
Harrison Barnes

Rejoins Starting Lineup Against Magic
Victor Wembanyama

Good to Go Sunday
Blake Wesley

Back in Trail Blazers Lineup
Robert Williams III

Active Sunday
Kobe Sanders

Returns to Starting Unit Sunday
Stephon Castle

Out Sunday Against Magic
Josh Green

Listed as Probable for Monday
John Konchar

Unavailable Monday
Santi Aldama

Ruled Out for Monday
Jaren Jackson Jr.

Iffy for Monday
Julius Randle

May Miss First Game of the Season
Anthony Edwards

Dealing With Back Spasms, Questionable for Monday
Austin Reaves

Still Out Sunday
Kevin Durant

Won't Play Monday
Jalen Green

Out Against Clippers
James Harden

Unavailable Sunday
Eugenio Suárez

Eugenio Suarez Signs One-Year Deal With Reds
San Francisco 49ers

49ers Set to Name Raheem Morris Their Defensive Coordinator
Las Vegas Raiders

Raiders Close to Naming Klint Kubiak the Next Head Coach
Arizona Cardinals

Cardinals Finalizing Deal to Make Mike LaFleur the Next Head Coach
Breece Hall

Jets Want to Re-Sign Breece Hall, Could Use Franchise Tag
Shohei Ohtani

Won't Pitch in the World Baseball Classic
Luis Arraez

Signs One-Year Deal With Giants
Troy Terry

Ready to Return Sunday
Victor Hedman

Set to Return Sunday
Connor McMichael

Out Week-to-Week
Kris Letang

Out for Four Weeks
Nico Hischier

a Game-Time Call Saturday
Jack Hughes

Won't Play Saturday
Linus Ullmark

Returns to Action Saturday
Blake Snell

Dodgers Plan to Have Blake Snell Ready for Opening Day
Shohei Ohtani

Will be Ready to Pitch to Start the 2026 Season
Francisco Lindor

Won't Play in WBC After Elbow Surgery
Charlie Coyle

Pots Second Career Hat Trick
Filip Hronek

Expected to Play Saturday
Pavel Zacha

Not Traveling With Bruins
Elias Lindholm

to Miss at Least Two More Games
William Nylander

on Track to Return Saturday
Kris Letang

Misses Practice, Uncertain for Saturday
Evgeni Malkin

Iffy for Saturday
Vinnie Pasquantino

Royals Agree on Two-Year Contract
Jacob Wilson

Signs Seven-Year Extension
Diego Lopes

An Underdog At UFC 325
Alexander Volkanovski

Set For UFC 325 Main Event
Benoît Saint Denis

Benoit Saint Denis Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Dan Hooker

Set For UFC 325 Co-Main Event
Mauricio Ruffy

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Rafael Fiziev

Returns At UFC 325
CFB

Texas Lands Wake Forest Transfer Sterling Berkhalter
Samuel Ersson

Sustains Lower-Body Injury Thursday
Pavel Zacha

Exits Early Thursday
Charlie Lindgren

Hurt Versus Red Wings
Jack Hughes

Exits With Lower-Body Injury Thursday
Brad Marchand

Suffers New Injury Blow
Patrick Kane

Becomes NHL's Highest-Scoring U.S-Born Player
Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen

Expected to Miss a Week
Tommy Edman

Will Have Delayed Start to Spring Training, Could Miss Opening Day
Kirk Cousins

Falcons Expected to Release Kirk Cousins
Chase Brown

Working on Extension With Bengals
Michael Penix Jr.

Hopes to be Ready for Week 1
Isaac Paredes

Not a Lock for Opening Day Lineup?
Dalton Kincaid

Doesn't Need Offseason Surgery
Josh Allen

Undergoes Foot Surgery
Josh Allen

on Crutches, Wearing Walking Boot
Corbin Carroll

a Top Fantasy Outfielder After Joining 30-30 Club
Jonah Tong

Won't Pitch in the World Baseball Classic
CFB

Michigan RB Bryson Kuzdzal Withdrawing from Transfer Portal
Aaron Judge

Appears to be Past his Elbow Issues
Bo Nix

Expected to Resume Training in 4-6 Weeks
Michael Penix Jr.

Thinks he'll be Ready by April
Evan Carter

Establishes a Goal to Steal 30 Bases
Edouard Julien

Traded to the Rockies
Cleveland Browns

Browns Hiring Todd Monken as Next Head Coach
Sahith Theegala

Off to Much Better 2026 Start
Gary Woodland

an Intriguing Option at Torrey Pines This Week
CJ Abrams

Giants Offer "Aggressive Pitch" for CJ Abrams
Andrew Putnam

Hopes to Keep Momentum Rolling This Week
Matthieu Pavon

Seeks to Return to 2024 Form at Torrey Pines
Luke List

Still Looking For Birdies at Torrey Pines
Jake Knapp

Faces Stiff Challenge at Farmers Insurance Open
Rasmus Hojgaard

Needs to Play Better at Torrey Pines
Christiaan Bezuidenhout

Could Struggle at Farmers Insurance Open
J.J. Spaun

A Steady Option At Farmers Insurance Open
Andrew Novak

Looking For More Success At Torrey Pines
Denny McCarthy

A Wild Card At Farmers Insurance Open
Max Homa

Looks To Keep Resurgence Going At Torrey Pines
Joe Highsmith

Struggling Heading Into Torrey Pines
Wyndham Clark

Looks To Carry Momentum Into Farmers Insurance Open
Tony Finau

Aims To Turn Things Around At Torrey Pines
Akshay Bhatia

Looks to Bounce Back at Torrey Pines
Paul Goldschmidt

Yankees Expressing Interest in Re-Signing Paul Goldschmidt
Bo Bichette

Won't Play in World Baseball Classic
NFL

Bill Belichick Won't be First-Ballot Hall of Famer
Carlos Correa

Won't Play for Puerto Rico in World Baseball Classic
Si Woo Kim

Looks to Continue Incredible Run at Torrey Pines
Jason Day

has a Good Chance to Keep Momentum This Weekend
Keegan Bradley

has Good Course History at Torrey Pines
Billy Horschel

Isn't a Great DFS Option at Torrey Pines
Aaron Rodgers

Mike McCarthy Says he Wants Aaron Rodgers to Return
Will Zalatoris

Has a Shot to Challenge at the Farmers Insurance Open
Drake Maye

Expected to be Fine for Super Bowl
Tennessee Titans

Titans Set to Hire Brian Daboll as New Offensive Coordinator
Buffalo Bills

Bills Promote Joe Brady to Head Coach
CFB

Quarterback Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi Signs with Michigan
CFB

Darian Mensah Reaches Settlement with Duke, Expected to Land at Miami

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP