X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

AL Starting Pitchers: Overvalued and Undervalued

In my pitching strategy article, I laid out my case for drafting three high-floor, high-ceiling starters and then waiting until late for lottery ticket pitchers. I also advised against paying for the pitchers in between, who either lack the ceiling or the floor to justify the price.

In this piece, I'll lay out some top end and lottery ticket pitchers in the American League who are undervalued, and then some overvalued arms to avoid.

Keep in mind, however, that you may not always be able to get the pitchers you need at a discount; sometimes you must pay full price to abide by my strategy. Nonetheless, keep an eye out for these values:

Featured Promo: Get any MLB Premium Pass FREE ($119 value) AND up to a $200 deposit match when you sign up with Rival Fantasy. Rival offers 6 and 12-team Best Ball, weekly and daily contests, for as little as $3 per entry. No roster management, just draft and Rival sets your best lineup automatically. Playing fantasy baseball has never been easier! Sign Up Today!

 

Undervalued AL Starting Pitchers

High End

Justin Verlander

ADP: 43, SP11
MY RANK: 38, SP7

Browsing the ADP charts, I realized it is hard to find value on top starting pitchers. So, Verlander going later than my valuation of him makes him a good target as one of your top three pitchers. I laid out the case for him last year as a pitcher who had been dominant when not affected by his 2014 core surgery and his 2015 triceps injury. In 2016 he was healthy and proved dominant as a top five starter: 16 wins, 3.04 ERA, 1.00 WHIP, and 254 strikeouts. Who knows how long he can keep performing, but he’s worth riding for at least one more year.

 

Borderline High End

Lance McCullers  

ADP: 171, SP42
MY RANK: 137, SP29

If you have two strong top pitchers and a strong closer or two, you can stomach the risk of McCullers as your third high-floor, high-ceiling pitcher. If you don’t, his elbow injury that ended his 2016 and his control/WHIP issues could make him too risky. However, last year he posted a whopping 13.0% swinging strike rate. In 36 career starts, he has a 3.22 ERA (3.16 FIP and 3.32xFIP), 10.23K/9, and a 1.33 WHIP. Only 23 years old and in front of a great offense, McCullers will perform if healthy and could easily be a top 10 pitcher if he controls the WHIP.

 

The Lottery Tickets

Dylan Bundy    

ADP: 271, SP72
MY RANK: 167, SP42

You can read my full opinion of Bundy here, https://www.rotoballer.com/dylan-bundy-fantasy-baseball-breakout-candidate/364618. Since that piece, Bundy has begun throwing his cutter/slider in games. While he has noted issues controlling the pitch, and it has not been the plus pitch it used to be, it is still a fourth pitch batters have to look for. Whether it improves, stays the same, or he scraps it altogether, his other three pitches give him a shot a top-25 first half performer, before likely wearing down as the season progresses.

 

Eduardo Rodriguez

ADP: 300, SP81
MY RANK: 195, SP48

Eduardo Rodriguez is another former Orioles’ top prospect ready to shine. After being traded to the Red Sox, he excelled with the change of scenery and had Orioles’ fans screaming “Jake Arrieta” again. But after his hot start, he faced some struggles and injuries. In the second half of last year, the 23 year-old posted a 3.24 ERA, 9.2K/9, a 1.13 WHIP and a 3.48 FIP. This upside and his age make him a perfect late flier.

 

Francisco Liriano

ADP: 315, SP85
MY RANK: 243, SP60

Say what you want about the importance of pitch-framing and catcher ERA, but make no mistake that Liriano has done well pitching to Russell Martin. In 248 career innings pitching to Martin, he has a 2.94 ERA, 9.2k/9 and an OPS against of .621. Last year, he pitched more than two innings to five catchers. He had a 3.04 ERA and 9.3k/9 with Martin; he had ERAs of 5.97, 5.52, 5.02, and 4.58 with the other catchers. Reunited with Martin in Toronto, Liriano has the upside to strike out a batter per inning with an ERA around 3.00, making him a great lottery ticket.

 

Daniel Norris

ADP: 288, SP77
MY RANK: 245, SP61

Daniel Norris is a former top prospect who has battled through a lot the past couple seasons. Nevertheless, here are selected MLB stats from his last three MLB seasons:

IP ERA K/9 BB/9 SWINGING STRIKE %
2014 6.2 5.40 5.40 6.75 7.3
2015 60.0 3.75 6.75 2.85 9.2
2016 69.1 3.38 9.22 2.86 10.5

 

He is trending upward, has shown the ability to get strikeouts, and has prospect pedigree. As a pitcher who is going undrafted in most standard leagues, he is exactly the type of lottery ticket we want to bet on in the last round or two as a breakout candidate.

 

Overvalued AL Starting Picthers

Corey Kluber      

ADP: 24, SP6
MY RANK: 44, SP8

Corey Kluber is great. However, he has enough red flags that he should not be a second-round pick when similar players can be had two rounds later (Verlander) or one round later (Darvish). The red flags? Kluber’s K/9 has declined each of the past three years: (10.27, 9.93, 9.50). His 2016 walk rate was the highest since 2012. Not surprisingly, his FIP and xFIP both rose for the second straight year. His average fastball went from 93.2 in 2014, to 92.6 in 2015, to 92.1 last year. Most likely he will have another great season; but these risks make him less valuable than similar players going later.

 

Rick Porcello     

ADP: 111, SP26
MY RANK: 146, SP32

Porcello falls outside the range of my top three pitchers I target, but he still costs you a high pick. Is that justified? He did win the “Cy Young”, although Kate Upton was none too pleased about that. However, that he ate innings isn’t necessarily a good thing in standard formats. That he won a lot of games reflected a lot of luck, and his offense now lacks last season’s OPS leader (David Ortiz). While his ERA was lower than 2015, he struck out fewer batters (7.63K/9), did not improve his swinging strike rate (8.2%), and induced a career low 43.1% groundballs. Nothing in his 2016 batted ball profile screams that he was a meaningfully different pitcher, and his FIP and xFIP didn’t view him much differently than 2012-2014. Thus, Porcello is likely to be a middle of the road fantasy pitcher, the type of which I like to avoid.

 

Felix Hernandez

ADP: 139, SP31
MY RANK: 266, SP69

King Felix is a good example of a player that someone who has not followed baseball closely for the past couple years will take far too high. Sure, there are some reasons for hope; Hernandez was battling injuries last year, and this year he has added muscle to try to avoid that. But, even his 2015 was a major disappointment by his standards: his K/9 fell significantly, his BB/9 rose significantly, and his ERA shot up almost a point and a half: 3.53 ERA, 8.52K/9, 2.59 BB/9, 1.18WHIP. Last year, he posted a 3.82ERA, 7.16 K/9, 3.82 BB/9, 1.32 WHIP. Remove the name, and this is the profile of a lottery ticket bounceback candidate who should go at the end of drafts, not someone to be drafted in the middle.

Check back tomorrow for my overvalued/undervalued NL pitchers, and follow @rotonails to be alerted of future articles.

 

More Undervalued & Overvalued Picks




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Garrett Whitlock2 hours ago

Still Not Cleared For Mound Work
Max Scherzer2 hours ago

Serves Up Two Homers In Rehab Start
John Means2 hours ago

Could Start Sunday
Alec Marsh2 hours ago

X-Rays Come Back Negative On Alec Marsh
Francisco Lindor2 hours ago

Comes Alive With Two Long Balls
Shohei Ohtani3 hours ago

Three Doubles For Shohei Ohtani
Mike Trout3 hours ago

Cracks MLB-High 10th Homer
Corey Seager4 hours ago

Removed From Game After Being Hit By Pitch
Naz Reid4 hours ago

Named Sixth Man Of The Year
Mitchell Robinson4 hours ago

Questionable For Game 3
Joel Embiid4 hours ago

Questionable For Game 3
DJ LeMahieu4 hours ago

To Be Shut Down For A Week
Zack Gelof5 hours ago

Likely Heading To Injured List
Alec Marsh5 hours ago

Leaves Game After Being Hit By Comebacker
Bam Adebayo5 hours ago

Looks Good In Win Over Boston
Ozzie Albies5 hours ago

Runs The Bases Wednesday
Kristaps Porzingis5 hours ago

Struggles Offensively In Game 2
Jayson Tatum5 hours ago

Has A Decent Showing On Wednesday
J.P. Crawford5 hours ago

Dealing With Oblique Soreness
Jaylen Brown5 hours ago

Leads The Way In Game 2
A.J. Puk5 hours ago

Rejoining Bullpen When Healthy
Zack Gelof5 hours ago

Nursing Abdominal Soreness
Tyler Herro5 hours ago

Gets It Done On Wednesday Night
Thairo Estrada5 hours ago

Experiencing Hamstring Tightness
Manny Machado6 hours ago

Expected To Return Friday
Sean Murphy6 hours ago

Hasn't Resumed Swinging
Cristian Javier6 hours ago

Plays Catch Wednesday
Christian Yelich6 hours ago

Still Not Swinging
Dallas Cowboys7 hours ago

Cowboys Pick Up Micah Parsons' Fifth-Year Option
Ezekiel Elliott7 hours ago

Cowboys Meeting With Ezekiel Elliott
Cincinnati Bengals7 hours ago

Trey Hendrickson Requests A Trade From Bengals
Carlos Correa8 hours ago

Could Return Soon
Nic Claxton8 hours ago

Nicolas Claxton The "No. 1 Priority" For Nets In Offseason
Grayson Allen8 hours ago

Not Ruled Out For Game 3
Nikola Jovic8 hours ago

Available For Game 2
Ryan Lomberg9 hours ago

Could Be Back For Game 3
Cam Talbot9 hours ago

Starts Game 2 For Kings
Logan Thompson9 hours ago

Heads Out For Another Win Wednesday
Jake Oettinger10 hours ago

Tries To Bounce Back Wednesday
Jani Hakanpaa10 hours ago

Remains Out On Wednesday
Tyler Myers10 hours ago

Battling The Flu
Michael Penix Jr.11 hours ago

Could Be Among Top-Four Quarterbacks Selected
Jared Goff11 hours ago

No New Deal “Imminent” For Jared Goff
J.J. McCarthy12 hours ago

Broncos Interested In J.J. McCarthy
Detroit Lions13 hours ago

Penei Sewell Becomes Highest-Paid Offensive Lineman
Justin Fields13 hours ago

Steelers Not Expected To Pick Up Justin Fields' Fifth-Year Option
Rashod Bateman13 hours ago

Ravens Sign Rashod Bateman To Contract Extension
Ja'Marr Chase13 hours ago

Bengals Exercise Ja'Marr Chase's Fifth-Year Option
Amon-Ra St. Brown13 hours ago

Lions Agree To Four-Year Extension With Amon-Ra St. Brown
Nicolas Hague13 hours ago

Out For Vegas On Wednesday
James van Riemsdyk13 hours ago

To Make Series Debut Wednesday
Sam Bennett14 hours ago

To Miss Significant Time
William Nylander14 hours ago

Looking Unlikely For Game 3
Brett Pesce14 hours ago

Likely Out For Remainder Of First Round
Thatcher Demko14 hours ago

Listed As Week-To-Week
Ilya Sorokin14 hours ago

To Start Game 3
Cale Makar17 hours ago

Registers Two Assists In Game 2
Tom Wilson17 hours ago

Notches Two Points In Tuesday's Loss
Alexis Lafrenière17 hours ago

Alexis Lafreniere Collects Two Assists In Game 2 Victory
Filip Forsberg17 hours ago

Leads The Charge As Nashville Ties Series
Victor Hedman17 hours ago

Posts Two Assists In Game 2
Carter Verhaeghe17 hours ago

Hits Overtime Winner In Game 2
Sam Bennett17 hours ago

Sustains An Upper-Body Injury In Game 2
James Harden18 hours ago

Settles For 22 Points In Game 2
Luka Doncic18 hours ago

Leads All Scorers With 32 Points In Game 2
Damian Lillard18 hours ago

Scores 34 Points In Losing Effort
Tyrese Haliburton18 hours ago

Collects A Double-Double In Game 2 Win
Pascal Siakam18 hours ago

In Fantastic Form Once Again Versus Milwaukee
Devin Booker18 hours ago

Leads Suns With 20 Points In Game 2
Anthony Edwards18 hours ago

Struggles In Game 2
Daniel Gafford1 day ago

Returns To Game 2
Karl-Anthony Towns1 day ago

Has A Rough Night On Tuesday
Jaden McDaniels1 day ago

Erupts In Game 2
Andrew Peeke1 day ago

Considered Week-To-Week
Brandon Aiyuk1 day ago

Trade Remains "Very Much In Play"
Denver Broncos1 day ago

Broncos Pick Up Fifth-Year Option On Patrick Surtain II
New England Patriots2 days ago

Patriots Haven't Received "Serious" Offers For No. 3 Pick
Kadarius Toney2 days ago

Still In Chiefs' Plans
Jake Browning2 days ago

Bengals Re-Sign Jake Browning
Brandon Aiyuk2 days ago

49ers Have Received Calls Regarding Brandon Aiyuk
Dak Prescott2 days ago

Not Trying To Be Highest-Paid Player
Zach Wilson3 days ago

Broncos Acquiring Zach Wilson From Jets
Matt Ryan3 days ago

Officially Retires From NFL
Cincinnati Bengals3 days ago

Sam Hubbard Recovering From Ankle Surgery
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Survives At Talladega For First Win Of 2024
Brad Keselowski3 days ago

Finishes Second At Talladega After Last-Lap Wreck
Anthony Alfredo3 days ago

Gets Best Finish For Beard Motorsports Since 2022
Todd Gilliland3 days ago

One Of The Strongest At Talladega
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Finishes 36th At Talladega Superspeedway
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Fails To Deliver Value In DFS At Talladega
NASCAR3 days ago

Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Finishes Fourth At Talladega
Noah Gragson3 days ago

Surprisingly The Most Consistent Driver At Talladega
Shane Van Gisbergen3 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen Acquits Himself Nicely In Drafting Debut
Michael McDowell3 days ago

Ends Talladega Wrecked From The Lead
Alex Bowman3 days ago

Quietly Captures Top-Five Finish At Talladega
Daniel Hemric3 days ago

Surges To Ninth-Place Result At Talladega
Harrison Burton3 days ago

Squeezes Into Top 10 At Talladega
NASCAR4 days ago

Bubba Wallace Will Start 14th For the GEICO 500
Tyler Reddick4 days ago

Avoid Rostering Tyler Reddick At Talladega?
John Hunter Nemechek4 days ago

Should DFS Players Roster John Hunter Nemechek At Talladega?
Joey Logano4 days ago

Expect Joey Logano To Compete For The Win At Talladega
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Is Denny Hamlin Recommended For Talladega?
Justin Haley4 days ago

Is A Top DFS Value At Talladega
William Byron4 days ago

Is One Of The Top Favorites To Win Talladega
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Is Best Suited As A Tournament Play At Talladega
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
Adonai Mitchell - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft: Top 100 Prospect Rankings (Final Update)

With the NFL Draft just a day away, it’s time to submit my final rankings for this class. Below, you will find the top-100 prospects on my board for 2024. There will be some changes from last month, as well as some surprises. Feel free to criticize my choices and views on the platform formerly... Read More


Rome Odunze - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Final 2024 First-Round NFL Mock Draft - Predictions for all 32 Teams

It's Christmas Eve. The NFL Draft is my favorite day of the year, and the picks made tomorrow night will have an enormous impact on the future of the NFL. With the Chicago Bears expected to select Caleb Williams at No. 1, the real draft begins at No. 2, where the Washington Commanders' pick remains... Read More


Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

2024 NFL Draft - Brandon Murchison's First-Round NFL Mock Draft

In the realm of fantasy football, anticipation and strategy reach a fever pitch as the NFL Draft approaches. Every selection, every pick holds the potential to reshape not only the fortunes of real-life franchises but also the fantasy landscape for millions of enthusiasts. As the curtain rises on this year's first-round NFL Mock Draft, fantasy managers... Read More


2024 NFL Mock Draft Round 1 - Final Predictions from All 32 Teams

Alright, folks, NFL Draft week is finally here: that magical time when every fan can dare to dream again! If you've been reading some of these mocks during the season, you know what a ride it's been and I sincerely appreciate any of you who've been following along. With the first big wave of NFL... Read More


Rome Odunze - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Coach Knows Ball: Rome Odunze NFL Draft Film Breakdown of Washington WR

Welcome to Coach Knows Ball, an NFL Draft series analyzing the top prospects in the 2024 class. I'm a college football coach with nine years of NCAA experience and have been scouting NFL Draft prospects for over 15 years. This series will give a deep dive into the film of some of the top players... Read More


Jordan Travis - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

2024 NFL Draft Injury News - Updates For Jonathon Brooks, Jordan Travis, Cooper DeJean, Kool-Aid McKinstry

The 2024 NFL Draft is here! It's an exciting time for NFL fans and prospects alike, but unfortunately, there are a handful of players who are battling injury concerns before their professional careers even begin. Some injuries will affect a player's draft stock, so it's worth glancing over the latest injury news regarding rising rookies.... Read More


Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

2024 NFL Mock Draft - Best Case First Three Round Scenario for All 32 Teams

NFL Mock Drafts can be conducted in various ways. The most common practice is attempting to predict what will happen, which is futile, especially in March. That is because so many team opinions are going to change. Teams haven't even started doing pre-draft visits yet, which will undoubtedly shed more light on which prospects teams... Read More


Rome Odunze - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Blockbuster Trade Ideas for the 2024 NFL Draft

The 2024 NFL Draft is right around the corner, and the rumor mill is heating up. While the NFL Draft is full of chaos and excitement without trade action, everyone loves to see a blockbuster deal made. A few expected blockbuster deals are getting thrown around on social media, headlined by the Minnesota Vikings trading... Read More


Brian Thomas Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Mock Draft: Rounds 1, 2, 3 Predictions (Post Stefon Diggs Trade)

The better part of free agency is done. While we continue to watch the depth pieces trickle through on smaller deals, the lion’s share of noteworthy moves are behind us. That is usually a sign that another mock draft is needed. In this mock, I will dive three rounds deep. I will factor in A... Read More


Marvin Harrison Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, WR, NFL Draft Sleepers

2024 NFL Draft - Pro Player Comparisons for the Top 12 Fantasy Football Rookies

Rookie fever is nearing its peak, and in just a few days, we'll know with full certainty where these prospects will be playing their games on Sundays. In turn, fantasy football gamers will be poring over player tapes, stats, and metrics like "Oops, I forgot to study, and my final is tomorrow" for upcoming rookie... Read More


Brock Bowers - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers, NCAA College Football, Prospects

2024 NFL Draft - Overvalued Prospects Who Could Slip on Draft Night

A few weeks ago, I was watching the 2007 NFL Draft. It was on the NFL's Pluto TV channel and I didn't have anything else to do, so I figured I'd turn it on. I was struck by two things. First, it's wild how far technology has come since 2007. They kept advertising that you... Read More


Bo Nix - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

2024 NFL Mock Draft - Round 2 and 3 Final Predictions

Can you feel it? We're just over one day away from the 2024 NFL Draft, folks! Summer's breeze is almost here as well, but not before we dive deep into draft season. With the initial wave of free agency settling down, the roster blueprints for our 32 teams are coming into sharp focus. Hunting for... Read More


Tyler Boyd - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Is Tyler Boyd a Free Agent? Top Landing Spots for Boyd This Offseason

For eight seasons, Cincinnati was Tyler Boyd’s home. He amassed 6,000 receiving yards on 513 receptions and scored 31 touchdowns during his time with the Bengals. Boyd was a trusted option for quarterback Joe Burrow and was great as the team’s primary slot receiver. Unfortunately, the club opted not to re-sign him this offseason. After... Read More