Updated Catcher Rankings - H2H Points Leagues

10 months ago by Ben Rolfe

As we enter the final stretch for drafting it is time to take a look at the latest iteration of points leagues rankings from our amazing hard working rankings staff. Few things in fantasy baseball are more miserable for many than discussing catchers, with perhaps just injuries and suspensions taking the crown. However, getting the right catcher can be important as there can be wild swings in the points to plate appearance ratios among the position. Fortunately, in most points leagues you only need to go 12 deep because this is a position where it gets extremely messy once you get past the top-10.

Points leagues are always tough to assess because there are so many different variations that can be used. Many leagues use fairly similar settings, with slight variations when it comes to stolen bases or walks. However, some leagues really like to put a twist on certain elements. Therefore, it is crucial to know your league and then to use these rankings as a base to adjust off to optimize them for your draft.

Keep an eye out for all other positions to follow and without any more delay, let's take a look at the 2019 catcher points league rankings for March.

Editor's Note: Get our 2020 MLB Premium Pass for 50% off, with exclusive access to our draft kit, premium rankings, player projections and outlooks, our top sleepers, dynasty and prospect rankings, 20 preseason and in-season lineup tools, and over 200 days of expert DFS research and tools. Sign Up Now!

Catcher Tiered Ranks - H2H Points Leagues (March)

In case you missed it, our very own "Big Pick Nick" Mariano was recently named the #1 overall most accurate industry expert ranker for the 2018 season. You can see his secret sauce below! Additionally, industry legend Scott Engel recently joined the RotoBaller team and provides his insights as well. Scott is an FSWA Hall Of Famer and award winner.

Ranking	Tier	Player Name	Position	Nick	JB	Bill
1	1	J.T. Realmuto	C/1B	93	88	114
2	1	Gary Sanchez	C	99	112	122
3	2	Wilson Ramos	C	139	163	176
4	2	Yadier Molina	C	182	175	170
5	2	Buster Posey	C/1B	232	162	152
6	2	Yasmani Grandal	C	204	182	185
7	3	Willson Contreras	C	205	180	200
8	3	Danny Jansen	C	263	248	326
9	4	Welington Castillo	C	274	293	#N/A
10	4	Tucker Barnhart	C/1B	308	307	#N/A
11	4	Francisco Cervelli	C	307	312	324
12	4	Yan Gomes	C	366	285	#N/A
13	4	Mike Zunino	C	360	300	#N/A
14	5	Jorge Alfaro	C	362	305	335
15	5	Francisco Mejia	C	419	279	330
16	5	Willians Astudillo	C	485	272	337
17	5	Robinson Chirinos	C	440	319	#N/A
18	5	Isiah Kiner-Falefa	C/2B/3B	475	342	323
19	5	Austin Hedges	C	452	325	#N/A
20	5	Kurt Suzuki	C	402	377	#N/A
21	5	Austin Barnes	C	490	373	352
22	5	Omar Narvaez	C	468	372	#N/A
23	5	John Hicks	C/1B	466	382	#N/A
24	6	Jonathan Lucroy	C	517	385	#N/A
25	6	Tyler Flowers	C	554	357	#N/A
26	6	Brian McCann	C	#N/A	458	#N/A
27	6	Russell Martin	C	#N/A	461	#N/A
28	6	Grayson Greiner	C	#N/A	469	#N/A
29	6	Elias Diaz	C	556	390	#N/A
30	6	Chris Iannetta	C	568	387	#N/A
31	6	Blake Swihart	C/OF	#N/A	498	#N/A
32	6	Carson Kelly	C	593	424	#N/A
33	6	Jason Castro	C	#N/A	528	#N/A
34	6	Mitch Garver	C	624	432	#N/A
35	6	Manny Pina	C	#N/A	529	#N/A
36	6	Christian Vazquez	C	604	457	#N/A
37	6	Chance Sisco	C	615	472	#N/A
38	6	Max Stassi	C	#N/A	545	#N/A
39	7	Austin Romine	C	#N/A	548	#N/A
40	7	Martin Maldonado	C	571	530	#N/A
41	7	Kevin Plawecki	C	#N/A	554	#N/A
42	7	Tom Murphy	C	#N/A	555	#N/A
43	7	James McCann	C	#N/A	558	#N/A
44	7	Matt Wieters	C	#N/A	565	#N/A
45	7	Travis D'Arnaud	C	#N/A	575	#N/A
46	7	Nick Hundley	C	#N/A	580	#N/A
47	7	Victor Caratini	C/1B	#N/A	585	#N/A
48	7	Austin Wynns	C	#N/A	588	#N/A
49	7	Cam Gallagher	C	588	#N/A	#N/A
50	7	Taylor Ward	C	598	#N/A	#N/A

Catcher Rankings Analysis - H2H Points Leagues (March)

Tier One

Realmuto is maybe the safest catcher this season, and Sanchez may be the one with the most upside. Realmuto's value is spread evenly across all of the elements that make up scoring points in this format. He does not excel at any one thing but he is also not dreadful at anything. Sanchez's power makes him the big upside play here. However, some of that power is negated but having the highest strikeout percentage at the position (24%). Whether they are a tier to unto themselves is a question mark for me.

Tier Two

This tier should arguably be one big tier with the group above. Ramos has the batting average and power upside, but just needs to stay on the field. Molina is much like Realmuto in that he just does everything well without excelling at any one thing. By the same vein he also does not have anything that lets him down either.

Posey might be the surprise candidate to jump back to the top of the rankings. His BB:K ratio is good enough that it negates the negative effect of his waning power. Grandal is the lowest of the bunch as he will likely rival Sanchez for strikeouts, but does not have the same huge power upside that Sanchez has. If anyone of these six should be in a separate tier then it may be Grandal.

Tier Three

Contreras is certainly interesting but his lack of true power upside combined with a strikeout rate which ranks among the worst at the position limits his upside. Jansen is an unknown commodity, but he plays in a good hitters park and comes into the majors having posted a 12.5% walk rate and just a 13.5% strikeout rate in Triple-A last season.

Tier Four

Barnhart, Cervelli and Castillo are all fairly similar in their value. All have some injury risk but all should give fairly good returns on a per PA basis. The odd one out for me is Gomes. The Nationals catcher doesn't strikeout out as much as the others in this tier. but he also does not really walk and he lacks power or doubles upside.

Tier Five and below

The stand out names once we reach this point are Suzuki, Narvaez, Lucroy and Chirinos. Suzuki has value thanks to his low strikeout rate, while Narvaez and Lucroy should have decent BB:K ratios. Chirinos is the power contributor of this group, and he plays in the best lineup. However, his strikeout floor keeps him down in tier five and away from the safer guys in the tier above.