Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Pickups & Streamers
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Brett Baty: Champ or Chump for Fantasy Baseball?

Brett Baty - Fantasy Baseball Rankings, MLB Prospects, Draft Sleepers, Wavier Wire Pickups

The Braves (and fantasy managers) are enjoying the production of Vaughn Grissom following injuries to Ozzie Albies and Orlando Arcia, so the Mets decided to try the same trick by promoting top prospect Brett Baty in the wake of injuries to Eduardo Escobar and Luis Guillorme. Like Grissom, Baty has relatively little experience in the high minors but has hit everywhere he's been assigned.

Unlike Grissom, Baty hit a homer on the first pitch he saw at the MLB level but has otherwise struggled with a .136/.208/.273 triple slash line and several questionable plays in the field. Baty has the better prospect pedigree between the two, but the 38% of fantasy managers who currently roster him in Yahoo! leagues want to know if that will translate to production down the stretch.

The 22-year-old has elite raw power that could play well in fantasy, but the smart money suggests that he won't be able to access it in games immediately. The third baseman still has a solid future in Flushing, but he looks more like a post-hype sleeper in 2023 or 2024 than an immediate add.

Editor's Note: Our incredible team of writers received five total writing awards and 13 award nominations by the Fantasy Sports Writers Association, tops in the industry! Congrats to all the award winners and nominees including Best MLB Series, NFL Series, NBA Writer, PGA Writer and Player Notes writer of the year. Be sure to follow their analysis, rankings and advice all year long, and win big with RotoBaller! Read More!


Brett Baty's Huge Potential Not Yet Ready

Baty's raw power is immediately apparent whenever you read a scouting report on him. FanGraphs assigns him 70-grade raw power both now and in the future, adding 60-grade game power in the future. Unfortunately, his scouting report notes that a swing change will be necessary to access that power in games and his 40-grade current hit tool (50 in the future) represents a potential batting average risk. Overall, they rank Baty as the 26th best prospect in the game.

MLB Pipeline likes him more, giving Baty 60-grade hit and power tools and ranking him 19th overall. However, his scouting report includes the following passage, "[Baty is] capable of putting on a powerful show in batting practice, but it hasn't translated into eye-popping slugging numbers. A 50-plus percent ground-ball rate has kept him from making the most of that strength, but there's hope that more upper-level experience could iron out those issues."

That passage was startling to this author because MLB Pipeline is typically extremely optimistic about top prospects. It seems to be advocating for the same type of swing change the FanGraphs scouting report mentioned, indirectly saying that he needs more time against advanced pitching to mature. The future potential is great, but an immediate impact seems unlikely.


Brett Baty's Batting on the Farm

Baty has posted strong batting lines throughout his MiLB career, but the huge HR totals that you would expect from a guy with 70-grade raw pop have been noticeably absent. He began 2021 at High-A (Brooklyn), hitting a robust .309/.397/.514 but with just seven homers over 209 PAs. The raw pop was there with a 28% HR/FB, but his 19.5 FB% was way too low to maximize it. The low fly ball rate contributed to a .402 BABIP, but no one consistently runs BABIPs that high in the majors.

Baty also struck out at a 25.4% clip with a 12.9 SwStr%, suggesting some swing and miss in his game that isn't immediately apparent by looking at his season numbers. He knows how to work a walk if his 11.5 BB% is any indication, but a high strikeout rate and low FB% will be difficult to overcome. The Mets liked what they saw though and promoted him to Double-A (Binghamton) mid-season.

The result was a muted version of the same production as Baty hit .272/.364/.424 with five homers in 176 PAs. His raw power looked great with a 20% HR/FB, he didn't consistently access it with a 24.3 FB%, he posted an elevated .350 BABIP, and he struck out (25.6%) and walked (12.5%) a lot. His SwStr% fell to 10.3 and he improved his FB% slightly, but he didn't solve any of his issues.

That earned him a second trip to Binghamton to begin the 2022 campaign and again, little changed. His surface stats were better with a .312/.406/.544 line and 19 HR over 394 PAs, but a lot of that can be attributed to his .390 BABIP and 26% HR/FB. Baty's flyball rate was still low (though improving) at 30.8% and his 13 SwStr% was higher than anything he posted in 2021. He kept his 11.7 BB% and 24.9 K% effectively constant.

To be fair, both of Baty's home parks were pitcher-friendly. Per Baseball America, Brooklyn was in the 23rd percentile for runs, 13th for HR, and 8th for BABIP in 2019. Binghamton had a 95 HR factor and 101 BABIP factor from 2017-2019. Still, Baty is supposed to have the kind of pop where the environment doesn't matter.

Baty received 26 PAs at Triple-A (Syracuse) before making his major league debut, so the statistics above are all we have to work with. He doesn't hit enough flies to generate the prodigious HR totals fantasy managers expect when they read his scouting report, he doesn't have great contact skills, and his high BABIPs don't involve sustainable skills like speed or line drives.

Baty swiped a handful of bases on the farm, but his success rates are nowhere near high enough to grant him a green light in the Show. He went 4-for-7 for Brooklyn and at Binghamton if you combine both years, so speed isn't part of his game. His glove is also a work in progress, with the Mets giving him outfield reps at Double-A just in case.


The Final Verdict on Brett Baty

Baty has consistently cracked the Mets lineup since his debut, but he has without exception hit 8th: a role that offers no fantasy value. His 18.8 FB% at the MLB level suggests that his biggest bugaboo still exists in full force as well. The 12th overall pick in the 2019 Amateur Draft has a bright future, but 2022 isn't the year to roster him. He's a Chump in redraft leagues.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!

More Fantasy Baseball Player Profiles


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Pickups & Streamers
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts


Trey Murphy15 mins ago

III Scores Season-High 30 Points In Sunday's Win
Desmond Bane22 mins ago

Leads The Way For Grizzlies Sunday
Joel Embiid31 mins ago

Eases His Way To Another Double-Double
Myles Turner39 mins ago

Very Productive In 24 Minutes Sunday
Paolo Banchero47 mins ago

Notches A Double-Double Against Charlotte
LaMelo Ball52 mins ago

Scores Season-High 33 Points Sunday
Zach Wilson10 hours ago

Jets Have No Plans To Trade Zach Wilson
Seth Curry10 hours ago

Will Be Sidelined On Monday Versus Clippers
Kyle Kuzma10 hours ago

Ruled Out On Monday With Sprained Ankle
Cleveland Browns10 hours ago

Myles Garrett Dislocates Toe At Pro Bowl Games
Bradley Beal10 hours ago

Uncertain To Play On Monday Versus Cleveland
Isaiah Stewart10 hours ago

Questionable Against Boston On Monday
Drew Eubanks11 hours ago

Likely To Suit Up On Monday
Gary Payton11 hours ago

II Probable To Play On Monday
Kyle Anderson11 hours ago

Exits Sunday's Game With Back Spasms
Kyle Anderson14 hours ago

Playing On Sunday
Rudy Gobert14 hours ago

Starting Against Denver
RJ Barrett14 hours ago

Ruled Out Right Before Tip Off
Jordan McLaughlin14 hours ago

Will Play On Sunday
Brandon Ingram14 hours ago

Out With Toe Soreness
Jonas Valanciunas14 hours ago

Out Sunday, Avoids Serious Injury
Joel Embiid15 hours ago

Starting Against Knicks
Jaren Jackson15 hours ago

Jr. Playing Sunday
Jordan Romano19 hours ago

Won't Pitch In World Baseball Classic
Nick Plummer19 hours ago

Reds Sign Nick Plummer
Chad Kuhl19 hours ago

Nationals Add Chad Kuhl On Minor-League Deal
Jake Faria19 hours ago

Red Sox Sign Jake Faria To Minor-League Deal
Bobby Witt Jr.19 hours ago

Royals Exploring Extensions For Bobby Witt Jr., Others
Logan Webb19 hours ago

Giants Discussing Extension With Logan Webb
Miguel Rojas19 hours ago

Dodgers, Miguel Rojas Agree On Two-Year Deal
Max Fried20 hours ago

Loses Arbitration Case
Joey Logano22 hours ago

Facing Different Reality At Los Angeles
Ross Chastain22 hours ago

And The Clash On Sunday
Ty Gibbs22 hours ago

Has To Race Into Coliseum Main Event
Kyle Larson23 hours ago

Bit Of A Wildcard At Los Angeles
Alex Bowman23 hours ago

Qualified Ninth At Los Angeles
NASCAR23 hours ago

A.J. Allmendinger Has Exciting Saturday At Coliseum
Denny Hamlin23 hours ago

Starts Second In Heat Three At Coliseum
Austin Dillon23 hours ago

Continues Chevy Theme In Los Angeles
Aric Almirola23 hours ago

Rises To Fifth In Qualifying Saturday
William Byron23 hours ago

Qualifies Fourth For Sunday At Los Angeles
Christopher Bell23 hours ago

Surprises Some At Coliseum Saturday
Kyle Busch23 hours ago

Loves Los Angeles Again On Saturday
Justin Haley23 hours ago

Heats Up Coliseum Track Saturday
Josh Jacobs1 day ago

Won't Settle In Extension Talks
Aleksander Barkov2 days ago

Riding A Career-High Point Streak
Steven Stamkos2 days ago

On An 11-Game Point Streak
Sebastian Aho2 days ago

Enjoying Career-Best Goal Streak
Connor McDavid2 days ago

On Track For A 150-Point Campaign
Jake DeBrusk2 days ago

Ready To Return After The Break
Bowen Byram2 days ago

Expected To Be Back After The Break
Matthew Tkachuk2 days ago

Voted MVP At The All-Star Game
Fernando Tatis Jr.2 days ago

Open To Any Position
Luke Williams2 days ago

Dodgers Re-Sign Luke Williams To Minor-League Deal
Nolan Blackwood2 days ago

Twins Sign Nolan Blackwood
Jake McGee2 days ago

Announces His Retirement
Juan Minaya2 days ago

Pirates Sign Juan Minaya To Minor-League Deal
Yusniel Diaz2 days ago

Dodgers Sign Yusniel Diaz To Minor-League Deal
Franklin German2 days ago

White Sox Acquire Franklin German From Red Sox
Aaron Sanchez2 days ago

Twins Re-Sign Aaron Sanchez
Mecole Hardman3 days ago

Doubtful For Super Bowl
JuJu Smith-Schuster3 days ago

Kadarius Toney Questionable
Miguel Sanó3 days ago

Miguel Sano Hosting Workout Next Week
DL Hall3 days ago

Orioles Want DL Hall To Start
Anthony Misiewicz3 days ago

DFA'd By Royals
Eguy Rosario3 days ago

Out Until Summer With Broken Ankle
Jesús Luzardo3 days ago

Jesus Luzardo Wins Arbitration Case Over Marlins
Derek Carr3 days ago

Won't Extend Contract Trigger Date
Derek Carr3 days ago

Expected To Draw Plenty Of Interest
Aaron Rodgers3 days ago

: "I'm Not Going To San Fran"
Joe Mixon3 days ago

Charges Against Joe Mixon Will Be Dropped
Joe Mixon4 days ago

Has Warrant For Arrest
Mecole Hardman4 days ago

Unlikely To Play In Super Bowl
Mark Stone4 days ago

Out Indefinitely Following Back Surgery
Mitchell Marner4 days ago

Reaches 60 Points With Wednesday's Goal
Charlie Coyle4 days ago

Hands Out Two Assists
Alex Tuch4 days ago

Scores Only Sabres Goal In Wednesday's Defeat
Jesperi Kotkaniemi4 days ago

Picks Up Two Assists Against Buffalo
Tage Thompson4 days ago

Exits With Injury
Antti Raanta4 days ago

Shuts Down Sabres Wednesday
Stefan Noesen4 days ago

Picks Up Two Points In Victory
Pavel Zacha4 days ago

Scores Twice In Bruins Win
David Krejci4 days ago

Pockets Assist Wednesday
Jimmy Garoppolo5 days ago

Will Not Return To 49ers Next Season
Gustav Nyquist5 days ago

Set To Miss Rest Of The Season
Linus Ullmark5 days ago

Tries To End A Losing Run Wednesday
Ilya Samsonov5 days ago

Chases Another Home Win
Mattias Samuelsson5 days ago

Available Again Wednesday
Tua Tagovailoa5 days ago

Clears The Concussion Protocol
Dak Prescott5 days ago

Cowboys Open To Extension For Dak Prescott
Daniel Jones5 days ago

Giants Want To Re-Sign Daniel Jones
Justin Fields5 days ago

Bears Sticking With Justin Fields; Set To Trade First Pick?
MMA5 days ago

Sergey Spivak Can Earn A Big Victory Saturday
Derrick Lewis5 days ago

Looking For First Win Since 2021
Devin Clark5 days ago

Hoping To Turn Things Around
MMA5 days ago

Jung Da Un Set For Big Co-Main-Event Spotlight
Will Gordon5 days ago

In The Field At Pebble Beach
Thomas Detry5 days ago

Set For Pebble Beach Debut
Blagoy Ivanov5 days ago

Hoping For Big Start To 2023
MMA5 days ago

Marcin Tybura Set To Improve No. 10 Ranking If Victorious
Jordan Spieth5 days ago

Always An Option At Pebble Beach
Kyle Nelson5 days ago

Hoping To Prevent Three-Fight Losing Streak
MMA5 days ago

Choi Doo-ho Returns To Action After Layoff
Viktor Hovland5 days ago

Set To Play At Pebble Beach
Maverick McNealy5 days ago

A Nice Option At Pebble Beach
Tom Brady5 days ago

Announces Retirement From The NFL
Lamar Jackson6 days ago

Likely To Be Franchise Tagged
Houston Texans6 days ago

Texans Hire DeMeco Ryans As Head Coach
Denver Broncos6 days ago

Broncos Acquire Sean Payton As Next Head Coach
Ben Griffin6 days ago

Set To Make AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am Debut
Beau Hossler6 days ago

Looks To Repeat Success At Pebble Beach
Kurt Kitayama6 days ago

Searching For Form
Russell Knox6 days ago

Looks To Stay Consistent At Pebble Beach
PGA6 days ago

Matt Fitzpatrick An Elite Fantasy Option At Pebble Beach
Adam Fugitt6 days ago

Set For A Very Tough Test
Yusaku Kinoshita6 days ago

Japanese Finisher Yusaku Kinoshita Set For UFC Debut
Taylor Pendrith6 days ago

Seeking Better Fortune At Pebble Beach
Justin Lower6 days ago

Sets Up Well For Pebble Beach
Davis Riley6 days ago

Not On Many Radars For Pebble Beach
Matthew NeSmith6 days ago

Trying To Turn Back Clock At Pebble Beach
Justin Rose6 days ago

Needs To Avoid Mistakes At Pebble Beach