X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

ADP Debate - Mallex Smith vs. Victor Robles

When given the choice between a mostly-unproven talent who could contribute something in five categories on one hand, and a newly-successful player likely to be limited in HR and RBI, who would you pick?

This is essentially the choice presented by Mallex Smith and Victor Robles this draft season. Both are being drafted within the same round of each other, based on preseason ADP. That doesn't mean they will necessarily provide the same return on investment, however.

Today, we'll break down the key differences between these outfielders to determine which player should be selected first on draft day. When you're done, take a look at some other ADP Debates for outfielders, such as Adam Eaton vs Kyle Schwarber or Andrew Benintendi vs Marcell Ozuna.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:

 

Mallex Smith - Natural Born Thief

(ADP: 99)

Mallex Smith has always been a base-stealer. He nabbed 32 bags on 45 tries in his first 153 games with the 2016 Braves and 2017 Rays. However, that came with just a .256/.323/.360 slash line, limiting his playing time and hence his fantasy production.

In 2018, however, Smith produced a jump in his play that rivaled his jumps off of pitchers: he gave the Rays a .296/.367/.406 line in 141 games. All that time on base paid off with a career-high 40 steals on 52 attempts. Only Whit Merrifield and Trea Turner had more SB, and now Smith is a borderline top-100 asset entering his 2019 debut campaign for the Mariners.

Projection systems aren't usually convinced by a single season, however, it's too early to assume Smith's true talent matches the 117 wRC+ he put up in 2018. Steamer, for example, foresees only a .263 average as part of a 98 wRC+ in 2019. That is even lower than his .270 average in 2017, however.

That said, the speed is real, and another 40 steals are a real possibility. Smith draws enough walks, an 8.6% career clip, that he can still be a viable leadoff hitter even with a .270 average, and last year probably did earn him the ability to work through at least one slump without hitting the bench too hard.

However, despite the projections, Smith could prove himself to be an above-average hitter now, similar to what Eddie Rosario and Aaron Hicks did for themselves last year, and there is no doubt that Smith can justify his 99 ADP this year. But is he a better choice than Victor Robles?

 

Victor Robles - New Sheriff in Town

(ADP: 102)

Victor Robles' elbow injury last April not only denied him the opportunity that Juan Soto so thoroughly exploited, but it also denied us analysts of some of our beloved sample size. Robles only got 291 plate appearances last year across all levels. Despite that, the 66 of those that came at the highest level went quite well: .288/.348/.525 with three HR, three SB (on five tries), and 10 RBI. Don't go prorating that over a full season or you'll start to get 30-30 vision, and that won't happen. Robles' 2019 upside is closer to 20-20, although that would still represent a surprising amount of power. Steamer likes 12 home runs and 27 steals with a 102 wRC+.

There's a reason scouts love Victor Robles, and this is his third preseason as a top-10 prospect at MLB.com and Baseball Prospectus. MLB.com states that Robles "has the makings of plus hitter from the right side of the plate, with a compact but explosive swing and a present feel for using the whole field. His power played consistently in 2017 thanks to a more leveraged swing and better pitch selection." Given a 60 hit tool, 55 power tool, and 75 run tool by MLB.com, Robles has backed up the scouts with a career .300/.392/.457 minor league line.

Unfortunately, with just 93 total plate appearances for Washington over two years, Robles is still ultimately an unknown at the Major League level. However, given his prospect pedigree and success in the minors, he is very likely to be competent. Can you absolutely rely on him for more than competence? No. But does he have a chance to give you more? Absolutely.

 

Conclusion

Context always matters, so if you've entirely ignored steals or already drafted some riskier assets, you might want Smith over Robles. However, Robles has a ceiling that many drafters are finding irresistible near pick 100, and it's a ceiling that just isn't there for Smith due to his power shortcomings.

Importantly, however, even if each player only hits to their projections, Robles can still give you 10 points of BA and 10 extra HR in exchange for 15 fewer SB. Depending on lineup positioning, you could very well do better in R+RBI with Robles also, especially if he lives up to that .392 minor league OBP.

There seems to be a consensus that Robles is one of the safer prospects in some time and his upside on top of that is worth a shot over Smith in most draft situations (barring an unanticipated return of Bryce Harper returning to Washington without a corresponding trade of Adam Eaton). Things can always change but for now, unless you are solely searching for speed, Robles seems to be the one to target when approaching the triple-digit selection mark of your draft.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Colorado Rockies28 mins ago

Rockies Agree To One-Year Extension With Manager Bud Black
Drake Maye1 hour ago

To Make First Career Start In Week 6
Rashee Rice1 hour ago

Has Surgery, Officially Out For The Season
Jordan Binnington1 hour ago

Takes On Kraken Tuesday
Philipp Grubauer1 hour ago

Starts For Kraken On Tuesday
Nicolas Aube-Kubel1 hour ago

Ruled Out For 3-6 Weeks
Jake Guentzel2 hours ago

Expected To Play In Season Opener
Tomás Nosek2 hours ago

Tomas Nosek Remains Week-To-Week
Sergei Bobrovsky2 hours ago

Faces Bruins In Season Opener
Joonas Korpisalo2 hours ago

To Start Season Opener
Aaron Jones3 hours ago

Appears To Have Avoided Long-Term Injury
Russell Wilson4 hours ago

"Door Is Ajar" For Russell Wilson To Be Active In Week 6
Derek Carr4 hours ago

Going For MRI On Tuesday
Rashee Rice6 hours ago

Season Expected To Be Over for Rashee Rice
New York Jets7 hours ago

Jets Fire Head Coach Robert Saleh
Macklin Celebrini7 hours ago

Expected To Play In Season Opener
Artturi Lehkonen7 hours ago

To Be Re-Evaluated At The End Of October
Jakub Vrana7 hours ago

Signs One-Year Contract With Capitals
Matthew Poitras7 hours ago

Ruled Out For Tuesday
Brandon Saad8 hours ago

Will Miss Season Opener
Artemi Panarin8 hours ago

Ready To Go For Season Opener
Max Pacioretty8 hours ago

Signs One-Year Deal With Maple Leafs
Nick Smith Jr.8 hours ago

Dealing With Groin Injury
P.J. Washington8 hours ago

Battling Hip Tightness
Kevin Huerter8 hours ago

Remains Limited To Non-Contact Activities
Rico Hoey8 hours ago

Could Find Black Desert ChampionshIp Challenging
Emoni Bates9 hours ago

Undergoes Knee Surgery
Doug Ghim9 hours ago

Has Been OK But Not Great
Wendell Carter Jr.9 hours ago

Signs Three-Year, $59 Million Extension
Chris Kirk9 hours ago

Getting Some Holes In At Black Desert
Ja Morant9 hours ago

Suffers Minor Ankle Injury In Preseason Win
Harris English9 hours ago

Still Trying To Improve Ranking In Utah
Chan Kim9 hours ago

Needs A Few More Birdies In Utah
Kareem Hunt12 hours ago

Dominates In Week 5 Win
JuJu Smith-Schuster12 hours ago

Juju Smith-Schuster Leads Receivers In Week 5
Patrick Mahomes13 hours ago

Throws For 331 Yards In Win
Maikel Garcia17 hours ago

Collects Four Hits, Steal In ALDS Game 2 Win
Derek Carr17 hours ago

Injures Left Side, Will Have MRI Tuesday
Kerry Carpenter17 hours ago

Hits Decisive ALDS Game 2 Homer
Adam Svensson18 hours ago

Looks To Rediscover Putter Magic At Black Desert Championship
Michael Thorbjornsen18 hours ago

Looks To Keep Momentum Going In Utah
Freddie Freeman19 hours ago

Status For Game 3 Of NLDS Is Unclear
Patrick Fishburn19 hours ago

Looking To Bounce Back At Black Desert Championship
Keith Mitchell20 hours ago

Looks To Shake Off Poor Sunday In Jackson At Black Desert Championship
Kodai Senga21 hours ago

To Start Potential Game 5 For Mets?
Las Vegas Raiders22 hours ago

Raiders Not Naming A Starting Quarterback On Monday
Rashee Rice22 hours ago

Receives Good News, Return Still Uncertain
Tua Tagovailoa22 hours ago

To Meet With Specialist This Week
Tyler Herro22 hours ago

Dealing With A Groin Strain
Travis Etienne Jr.22 hours ago

Still Dealing With Shoulder Injury
Jaime Jaquez Jr.22 hours ago

Battling A Groin Injury
Matthew Stafford23 hours ago

Has A Sore Back
Andrew Wiggins23 hours ago

Practices On Monday
Cooper Kupp23 hours ago

Not "Guaranteed" To Return In Week 7
Joel Embiid23 hours ago

Out For Monday's Exhibition
Romeo Doubs23 hours ago

Plans To Be Back At Wednesday's Practice
Paul George23 hours ago

Won't Face New Zealand
Evan Engram23 hours ago

Likely To Return In Week 6
Khalil Shakir1 day ago

Considered Day-To-Day This Week
Joe Mixon1 day ago

Still Being Evaluated, Uncertain For Week 6
Terance Mann1 day ago

Set To Start On Tuesday
Trendon Watford1 day ago

Out For At Least Two Weeks
Day'Ron Sharpe1 day ago

Out For At Least Six Weeks
Wendell Carter Jr.1 day ago

Suffers Sprained Ankle On Monday
Kawhi Leonard1 day ago

Clippers Taking Knee Recovery "Day By Day"
Ryan Lindgren1 day ago

Placed On Injured Reserve
Yegor Sharangovich1 day ago

Placed On Injured Reserve
Boone Jenner1 day ago

To Open Season On Injured Reserve, Could Miss Significant Time
Alex Nedeljkovic1 day ago

Hits Injured Reserve
Bryan Rust1 day ago

Opens Season On Injured Reserve
Wyatt Johnston1 day ago

Expected To Play On Thursday
Walker Kessler1 day ago

Jazz Asking For Two First-Round Picks For Walker Kessler
Gary Trent Jr.1 day ago

Leaves Sunday With Elbow Injury
RJ Barrett1 day ago

Suffers A Shoulder Injury On Sunday
P.J. Tucker1 day ago

Away From The Clippers, Future In Doubt
Brandon Ingram1 day ago

Won't Suit Up For First Preseason Game
Alex Pereira1 day ago

Remains Undefeated At Light Heavyweight
Khalil Rountree Jr.1 day ago

Gets TKO'd In UFC 307 Main Event
Ketlen Vieira1 day ago

Drops Decision At UFC 307
Roman Dolidze1 day ago

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Kevin Holland1 day ago

Suffers Rib Injury In TKO Loss
Tyler Reddick1 day ago

Struggles At Talladega But Leaves Above The Playoff Cut Line
Brad Keselowski1 day ago

Falls Short Of Victory By Inches At Talladega
Denny Hamlin1 day ago

Despite Setbacks, Denny Hamlin Leaves Talladega With A Solid Top-10 Finish
Alex Bowman1 day ago

Survives Talladega With A Solid Points Cushion Against The Cutoff Line
Christopher Bell1 day ago

Pushes Through For A Talladega Top-10 Finish
Mikey Eyssimont1 day ago

Lightning Hope To Have Mikey Eyssimont Available For Season Opener
NASCAR2 days ago

Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Wins At Talladega To Salvage Lackluster Season
Joey Logano2 days ago

Triggers Big One At Talladega, Falls Below Cut Line
Chase Elliott2 days ago

Maintains Playoff Position Despite Talladega Crash
Austin Cindric2 days ago

Fights For The Win At Talladega Before Late-Race Crash
Chase Briscoe2 days ago

Runs Decently But Crash Likely Eliminates Him From Round Of 8
Fernando Tatis Jr.2 days ago

Stays Red Hot, Collects Three Extra-Base Hits
Nick Castellanos2 days ago

Walks Off Mets In Game 2
Mark Vientos2 days ago

Hits Pair Of Homers In Game 2
Freddie Freeman2 days ago

Leaves Game Early After Feeling Renewed Pain In Ankle
Xander Bogaerts2 days ago

Leaves Game Early After Homering
Shohei Ohtani2 days ago

Hits Three-Run Shot In Game 1 Of NLDS
Alec Bohm2 days ago

Riding Pine In Game 2
José Aldo2 days ago

Jose Aldo Loses Split Decision At UFC 307
Mario Bautista2 days ago

Edges Out Decision Win At UFC 307
Kayla Harrison2 days ago

Picks Up Decision Win At UFC 307
Raquel Pennington2 days ago

Loses Title At UFC 307
Julianna Peña2 days ago

Julianna Pena Becomes New Champ At UFC 307
Zack Wheeler2 days ago

Dominant In Game 1
Martin Truex Jr2 days ago

.'s Final Full-Time Talladega Race May End With A Favorable Result
Ricky Stenhouse Jr2 days ago

. Can Excel As A Top DFS Value Play With Upside For Talladega
Tyler Reddick2 days ago

Looks To Sweep Talladega For The 2024 Cup Season
John Hunter Nemechek2 days ago

Is One Of The More Favorable DFS Value Options For Talladega
NASCAR2 days ago

B.J. McLeod Will Ride Around The Back, But Be A Solid Punt Play For Talladega
Kyle Larson2 days ago

Do Not Expect A Strong Result From Kyle Larson At Talladega
Brad Keselowski2 days ago

Is A Top DFS Recommendation For Talladega Lineups
Carson Hocevar2 days ago

Expect Carson Hocevar To Be A Pleasant DFS Surprise At Talladega
Denny Hamlin2 days ago

Is Denny Hamlin Worth Rostering For Talladega Lineups?
NASCAR3 days ago

J.J. Yeley Too Slow to Be a Solid Underdog Play
Daniel Suarez3 days ago

Unlikely to Repeat Atlanta Triumph at Talladega
Clayton Kershaw3 days ago

Will Not Pitch Again In 2024
Freddie Freeman3 days ago

Remains Uncertain For Game 1 Of NLDS
Clayton Kershaw3 days ago

Not On NLDS Roster
Brent Rooker4 days ago

Undergoes Right-Forearm Surgery
Anthony Rizzo4 days ago

Won't Be On ALDS Roster
Tarik Skubal4 days ago

Set To Start Game 2 Of ALDS
Tyler Glasnow4 days ago

Still Unsure About Recovery Plan, Not Throwing Yet
Freddie Freeman4 days ago

Says He Will Play In Game 1 Of NLDS
Alex Pereira4 days ago

Set For Third Light-Heavyweight Title Defense
Khalil Rountree Jr.4 days ago

Looks To Become UFC Middleweight Champion
Ketlen Vieira4 days ago

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Roman Dolidze4 days ago

An Underdog At UFC 307
Kevin Holland4 days ago

Set For Middleweight Matchup
Kayla Harrison5 days ago

A Massive Favorite At UFC 307
Mario Bautista5 days ago

Faces A Legend At UFC 307
José Aldo5 days ago

Jose Aldo An Underdog At UFC 307
Julianna Peña5 days ago

Julianna Pena Tries To Reclaim Bantamweight Title At UFC 307
Raquel Pennington5 days ago

Looks To Defend Title For First Time At UFC 307
Eric Cole6 days ago

Hopes To Rediscover Form At Sanderson Farms Championship
Mackenzie Hughes6 days ago

Looks To Rebound From Tough Presidents Cup
Henrik Norlander6 days ago

A Course Horse At Country Club Of Jackson
Ryan Fox6 days ago

Debuts At Sanderson Farms Championship
Charley Hoffman6 days ago

Consistently Playing Well
PGA6 days ago

Matthew McCarty Debuts At Sanderson Farms Championship
Ben Griffin6 days ago

Returns To Action At Sanderson Farms Championship
Beau Hossler6 days ago

Looks To Bounce Back At Jackson Country Club
Keith Mitchell6 days ago

Continues Playing Well

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP