Re-Drafting The 2017 NFL Draft: Entire First Round Do-Over

April 16, 2024

After seven seasons, did NFL teams make the correct selections in the 2017 NFL Draft? Alex Ciulla re-drafts the entire first round.

With just over a week until the start of the NFL Draft, the buzz has become palpable. It's a time when football fans look to the future, pining over incoming rookies and crossing their fingers in hopes that their team will select its next cornerstone piece. While first-round picks are prized possessions, let us not forget that not all future stars are decided solely on day one. With that in mind and the power of hindsight, let's look at one of the more intriguing drafts in recent history.

The 2017 NFL Draft class was brimming with game-changing prospects, still impacting the gridiron today. The first round had some swings and misses and a few absolute bomb home runs...but what if we could do it over?

Seven seasons later, we have a ton of on -- and off-field -- data for these veterans as they continue their stellar careers. Many teams could have altered the direction of their franchise with a different selection on draft day. Below, we'll look at what each team might have done differently in this redo of the 2017 NFL Draft's first round. Let's dive in.

Picks 1-10

1. Cleveland Browns - Patrick Mahomes, QB, Texas Tech

Original Pick: Myles Garrett, EDGE, Texas A&M

In the most no-brainer redo of all time, the Browns take Patrick Mahomes first overall -- nine slots higher than his original pick. The baby GOAT has all but cemented himself as a future Hall-of-Famer, torching defenses since his early days in the league. 2023 was no different. Even though Mahomes had a down year by his standards, he still led the Kansas City Chiefs to a Super Bowl victory. That's my kind of St. Patrick's Day.

St. Patrick's Day 🍀
St.Patrick's da
S Patrick d
Patrick
Patrick Mahomes
Patrick Mahomes highlights pic.twitter.com/hHKFMlhk5t

— NFL (@NFL) March 17, 2022

2. Chicago Bears (from 49ers) - T.J. Watt, EDGE, Wisconsin

Original Pick: Mitchell Trubisky, QB, North Carolina

The Bears traded three picks in this draft (#3, #67, #111) and a 2018 third-rounder to move up one slot and select Mitchell Trubisky -- potentially proving to be one of the biggest blunders in NFL Draft history. T.J. Watt's selection would have bolstered an already impressive Bears defense that ranked top 10 in both points and yards allowed.

Watt has haunted quarterbacks' nightmares for years with his unrelenting athleticism and a motor that doesn't quit. This pairing seems like a natural fit for a team that has prided itself on its defensive prowess through the decades.

3. San Francisco 49ers (from Bears) - Myles Garrett, EDGE, Texas A&M

Original Pick: Solomon Thomas, DE, Stanford

After committing grand theft against the Bears, San Francisco drafts arguably the top pass-rusher in this class. Solomon Thomas has been a fine player in his own right, but he doesn't even shake a stick at Watt or Garrett. They're very close for me, and you could make a case to flip their order here. Regardless, either would have been a massive upgrade over Solomon Thomas.

4. Jacksonville Jaguars - Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford

Original Pick: Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU

The Jacksonville Jaguars still get a running back and would be much happier with Christian McCaffrey than their original selection of Leonard Fournette. Run-CMC has proved to be one of the most versatile running backs ever to grace a professional field, showcasing an elite blend of agility and receiving ability. His play is reminiscent of LaDainian Tomlinson and is a constant reminder that the running back position still matters.

Christian McCaffrey was a human highlight reel at Stanford ⚡️pic.twitter.com/Wv36pxcG9X

— 247Sports (@247Sports) March 8, 2023

5. Tennessee Titans (from Rams) - Cooper Kupp, WR, Eastern Washington University

Original Pick: Corey Davis, WR, Western Michigan

The Titans traded away their first overall selection to the Rams in the 2016 NFL Draft -- a pick that turned into Jared Goff -- and received a bevy of draft selections, including LA's 2017 first. Corey Davis never quite lived up to his draft billing, though he has been a serviceable pro wide receiver.

Conversely, Cooper Kupp has turned his day-two selection (66th overall) into an impressive career. Kupp would have been a fantastic selection for Tennessee at the top of round one, but the Titans can only dream. This one seems to sting a bit more, considering the Rams got Kupp anyway.

6. New York Jets - George Kittle, TE, Iowa

Original Pick: Jamal Adams, S, LSU

Jamal Adams was a good pick here for New York. With our current knowledge of Adams' injury history, though, he falls in the first round this time. Adams has been great, but Kittle has been better. It's been some time since the Jets have had a weapon at tight end. Kittle could have provided a stable underneath option in the offense to ease the woes the Jets have experienced at quarterback.

Kittle's versatility as a blocker and pass-catcher, paired with his bully-ball play style, would be a welcome addition to a Jets offense that has been bereft of talent for what seems like forever. The 'bright lights' of New York would also have suited Kittle's larger-than-life personality.

7. Los Angeles Chargers - Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State

Original Pick: Mike Williams, WR, Clemson

Mike Williams has been a strong contributor when healthy. The whole 'when healthy' thing is a huge factor, though. Williams has missed at least one game every season but one since he became a pro. While the Chargers might need a receiver in this slot, it's hard to pass on Marshon Lattimore.

Lattimore only played two seasons at Ohio State before declaring for the NFL, hinting at his ability as a shutdown corner. Infamous for his battles on the field with future Buccaneers Hall-of-Famer Mike Evans, He's been a consistent defensive presence at the cornerback position.

DO NOT TRY MARSHON LATTIMORE.

📺 CBS pic.twitter.com/Ru0CvSHYN6

— New Orleans Saints (@Saints) September 10, 2023

8. Carolina Panthers - Marlon Humphrey, CB, Alabama

Original Pick: Christian McCaffrey, RB, Stanford

The Carolina Panthers paired McCaffrey with then-franchise QB Cam Newton, adding an explosive option to an offense that needed weapons. McCaffrey was a great pick at this spot, but there were other positions of need. Instead of going offensive tackle, I have them shoring up their defensive backfield with Marlon Humphrey.

The Panthers had a pretty solid defense overall in 2017. Led by Luke Kuechley, they ranked seventh in total defense at 317.1 yards per game. 229.1 of those yards came through the air, though, as their defense never had the star power on the back end to complement their ferocious front seven. Marlon Humphrey fits nicely here and moved up a few slots from his draft day.

9. Cincinnati Bengals - Dion Dawkins, OT, Temple

Original Pick: John Ross, WR, Washington

We can add John Ross to the growing list of one-trick burners to be over-drafted and flame out of the league nearly as fast as their 40-yard dash time. Maybe one day, the NFL will stop trying to turn every speedster they get their hands on into Tyreek Hill, but I digress.

Anyone on this list -- and maybe even the whole draft class -- might have been a better selection for the Bengals than Ross. It would be nice to see Dion Dawkins protecting Joe Burrow, but he's done a fine job as a staple on the Bills' offensive line. The three-time Pro Bowl selection just inked a three-year extension with Buffalo earlier this year.

10. Kansas City Chiefs (from Bills) - Deshaun Watson, QB, Clemson

Original Pick: Patrick Mahomes, QB, Texas Tech

The Chiefs take the largest L in this scenario since Mahomes is rightfully off the board at their selection. Deshaun Watson is a nice consolation prize, though. Watson would have gone higher in this redraft if only for his massage addiction. In pro football, though, the quarterback is vital, so he still gets picked early.

It's easy to forget the kind of player Watson was due to his antics off the field. Before his nonsensical decisions and holdout during the 2021 season, Watson was a consensus next 'big thing' at quarterback. He was an exciting prospect that immediately translated to the NFL field.

Picks 11-20

11. New Orleans Saints - Trey Hendrickson, DE, Florida Atlantic

Original Pick: Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State University

The Saints get one of their picks from 2017 back, albeit at a far lesser value. New Orleans had an excellent draft in 2017, as we'll see four of their seven picks taken in this round -- proving how this draft helped elongate the success of this franchise led by an aging Drew Brees.

Hendrickson was an adequate player in his time with New Orleans, but he took his game to new heights after signing as an unrestricted free agent with the Bengals in 2021.

12. Houston Texans (from Browns via Eagles) - Alvin Kamara, RB, Tennessee

Original Pick: Deshaun Watson, QB, Clemson

Oddly enough, Watson could have been a Brown from the get-go. Alas, we know how this story ends. Alvin Kamara marks the second pass-catching back to come off the board. The Texans want a quarterback, but Kamara would have been a slick grab for a Houston backfield that did not fare as well as they envisioned when grabbing Lamar Miller from the Miami Dolphins the year prior.

Kamara has been one of the best backs in the league since 2017. He's second only to CMC in receptions and receiving yards by a running back since then and third in touchdowns (Derrick Henry).

On Sunday @A_kamara6 became the first player in @Saints history with 10,000+ scrimmage yards 🔥

These were the longest plays that helped him get there. pic.twitter.com/3hPFEwcl0S

— NFL (@NFL) January 2, 2024

13. Arizona Cardinals - Ryan Ramczyk, OT, University of Wisconsin

Original Pick: Haason Reddick, LB, Temple

That makes three Saints in a row as the Cardinals flip from defense to offense here at pick #13. Ramczyk has been a stable force at tackle for New Orleans, and he would serve the Cardinals well as a crucial piece protecting Kyler Murray.

Even with Ramczyk's playing career in question, he should not slide by Arizona. The Cardinals have been up-and-down in recent years regarding their offensive line play, and they desperately need to keep Murray healthy.

14. Philadelphia Eagles (from Vikings) - Chris Godwin, WR, Penn State

Original Pick: Derek Barnett, DE, Tennessee

The combination of Nelson Agholor's failed development and Alshon Jeffery's failure to deliver are worthy reasons to draft Chris Godwin. The Eagles lacked consistency on offense outside of Zach Ertz, but they won the Super Bowl -- so does it matter? Derek Barnett has played well in his career. He's aided Philly's defense in keeping up its formidable nature against the rush over the last string of seasons -- he just doesn't measure up to Godwin.

Chris Godwin would have significantly improved the Eagle's receiving corps and potentially given Carson Wentz his best target ever. If not for his ACL injury in recent years, we might still be talking about Godwin as a top-six wideout in the league.

15. Indianapolis Colts - Budda Baker, S, University of Washington

Original Pick: Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State University

Indianapolis stays within the position it drafted but gets a nice upgrade in selecting Budda Baker over Malik Hooker. Hooker has been solid for Indy, but Baker is a more decorated defensive player.

Baker has been selected for six Pro Bowls and thrice as an All-Pro. He's been a captain for the Cardinals for the past four seasons and has been an excellent, game-changing defender. Not many people can outrun D.K. Metcalf, though.

Two years ago, DK Metcalf chased down Budda Baker to save a TD 😤

(via @NFL) pic.twitter.com/CLmXFjZLBv

— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) October 25, 2022

16. Baltimore Ravens - Jonathan Allen, DE, Alabama

Original Pick: Marlon Humphrey, CB, Alabama

Baltimore misses out on its stud cornerback but drafts his former Alabama running mate Jonathan Allen. Allen gets a bump-up one slot in the redo and adds a legitimate threat on the end of an already stout defensive front. The Ravens ranked Top 12 in points against and yards allowed in 2017.

17. Washington Commanders - Tre'davious White, CB, LSU

Original Pick: Jonathan Allen, DE, Alabama

After just missing the first pick that aligned with my rankings, the Commanders stick to upgrading their defense -- just at a different position. Tre'davious White garnered an 89.8 coverage grade per Pro Football Focus his rookie year and has shown true, lockdown corner upside over his years as a pro.

While White has had some flaws in his game over recent seasons, he picked his game back up in 2023. After playing his past seven years in Buffalo, White will spend the '24 season in sunny Los Angeles as one of the newest members of the Rams defense sans Aaron Donald.

18. Tennessee Titans - Haason Reddick, LB, Temple

Original Pick: Adoree' Jackson, CB, USC

Like Washington, Tennessee's second pick this round will be a varied position for them on defense. Adoree' Jackson nearly made the end of this round but will have to settle for an honorable mention. Again, this speaks to the quality of prospects in this class and just how good they've been in NFL uniforms.

19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Mike Williams, WR, Clemson

Original Pick: O.J. Howard, TE, Alabama

O.J. Howard fell to pick #19 in 2017, and everyone nearly lost their minds. Howard was anointed as the next potential superstar at tight end, receiving a prospect grade of 7.00 by the NFL -- a 'Pro Bowl Talent.' It shows that as much as the NFL gets it right. Nobody is perfect.

This time, Tampa Bay actually upgrades its offensive unit. It isn't Chris Godwin, but a Mike Williams and Mike Evans WR duo would have been a red-zone nightmare for opposing defenses.

Most TD at Arrowhead by a visiting player:

MIKE WILLIAMS - 7
LaDainian Tomlinson - 6
Marvin Harrison - 6
Antonio Gates - 6
Eric Decker - 6pic.twitter.com/Jh2p6btVst

— Pinhead Sports® (@_PinheadSports) September 16, 2022

20. Denver Broncos - Garett Bolles, OT, Utah

Original Pick: Garett Bolles, OT, Utah

Denver takes Garett Bolles at a great spot in this draft. I have Matt Milano over Bolles, but Denver did not need any more help at linebacker, and Bolles has been a good fit for the Broncos.

Picks 21-32

21. Detroit Lions - Matt Milano, LB, Boston College

Original Pick: Jarrad Davis, LB, Florida

Detroit still gets a linebacker at pick #21 but a slightly different caliber of player. Jarrad Davis and Matt Milano have been reliable defensive contributors, but Milano offers a bit more as a defender.

To this point in their careers, Milano has out-tackled Davis 645 - 462, has nine more interceptions, and scored the only touchdown between them.

22. Miami Dolphins - Rasul Douglas, CB, Nassau Community College

Original Pick: Charles Harris, DE, Missouri

Charles Harris hasn't been more than a rotational pass-rusher during his time in the league, while Rasul Douglas has been a solid, if not slightly above-average-defender.

The Dolphins still use this pick to help strengthen the defensive side of the ball, and they get a little more bang for their buck in this version.

23. New York Giants - Dalvin Cook, RB, Florida State University

Original Pick: Evan Engram, TE, Ole Miss

Evan Engram broke out his rookie season as a Giant but fell a bit to the wayside as the Giants' offense experienced many changes over the next few seasons. Engram is good, but there is no possible scenario where I see them passing up Dalvin Cook at this spot.

Cook had a stretch of dominance as an elite big-play threat in his time as a Viking. The Giants selecting Cook leads to an interesting thought experiment where they would not feel forced to take Saquon Barkley the following year as they already have their hyper-athletic backfield lead.

Dalvin Cook is one of the best College RBs ever⚡️. Somehow was never a Heisman Finalist 🤔 pic.twitter.com/kfcavMwHKr

— College Football Report (@CFBRep) January 25, 2024

24. Las Vegas Raiders - Jabrill Peppers, S, Michigan

Original Pick: Gareon Conley, CB, Ohio State

When the Raiders were still in Oakland, they chose Gareon Conley at pick #24. I still have them adding to their defensive backfield, this time from Ohio State's arch-nemesis: Michigan.

Conley played just three years in the league, while Peppers is still kicking -- most recently contributing 104 total tackles and two interceptions for the Patriots in 2023.

25. Cleveland Browns (from Texans) - Eddie Jackson, S, Alabama

Original Pick: Jabrill Peppers, S, Michigan

Cleveland is up again, and they're still taking a safety at this pick. While it was almost Peppers, they'll "settle" for Eddie Jackson. Jackson originally wasn't drafted until the fourth round- pick #112.

26. Atlanta Falcons (from Seahawks) - Carl Lawson, DE, Auburn

Original Pick: Takkarist McKinley, DE, UCLA

The redraft has been oddly succinct with the original draft from 2017. Even if the players aren't the same, most teams still attack their position of need. This trend continues here as Carl Lawson replaces Takkarist McKinley. Lawson was drafted in the fourth round in 2017, too, a few picks after Eddie Jackson at #116.

27. Buffalo Bills (from Chiefs) - Jamal Adams, S, LSU

Original Pick: Tre'davious White, CB, LSU

Buffalo doesn't get its stud cornerback but gets an equally dynamic player in Jamal Adams. Adams fell a bit from his original draft pick and landing spot. Mostly, that is due to injuries as Adams has had trouble staying on the field.

He does not possess the coverage ability of White, though when healthy, he plays up in the run game with the best in the league. Adams has always been a terror when assigned to blitz, too -- even when he doesn't get there.

.@Prez with the header cross to set up the game-winning score ⚽️

(by @FanDuel) pic.twitter.com/zoM6YBlGxt

— NFL (@NFL) October 31, 2023

28. Dallas Cowboys - Evan Engram, TE, Ole Miss

Original Pick: Taco Charlton, DE, Michigan

Taco Charlton only played in Dallas for two seasons before spending the next four seasons on four separate teams. He did not play in 2023 or provide much value for the Cowboys in his time there.

Evan Engram would slide in as the defacto replacement for an aging Jason Witten and probably play a critical role for the offense in 2017. Engram had more yards, receptions, and touchdowns than every Dallas player not named Dez Bryant that year.

29. Cleveland Browns (from Packers) - David Njoku, TE, Miami

Original Pick: David Njoku, TE, Miami

This selection is the second pick that perfectly aligns with timing and necessity. Back-to-back tight ends mean Njoku lands in Cleveland as intended.

.@David_Njoku80 really got that DAWG in him 😤🐶 pic.twitter.com/vGgJnRHa0t

— NFL GameDay (@NFLGameDay) December 21, 2023

30. Pittsburgh Steelers - Deatrich Wise, DL, Arkansas

Original Pick: T.J. Watt, EDGE, Wisconsin

There may be no team on this list -- besides Kansas City -- that hates this redo more than the Pittsburgh Steelers. Drafting T.J. Watt at the end of the first round feels criminal.

The Steelers aren't as lucky this time, but they still get a quality, versatile defensive lineman in Deatrich Wise. Wise has spent his whole career as a Patriot thus far, and he's shown adaptability by playing each position on the line. 

31. San Francisco 49ers (from Seahawks via Falcons) - Aaron Jones, RB, University of Texas at El Paso

Original Pick: Reuben Foster, LB, Alabama

Aaron Jones was the latest selection on this list, but he still garners first-round value. He's the fourth running back taken -- something we're unlikely to see in the first round ever again -- and adds another agile, versatile pass-catcher to this list.

Jones does not carry the same shine as the three taken before him. He does provide this 49ers squad with a complement to Carlos Hyde, though. Coincidentally, this was Hyde's last year as a 49er. Aaron Jones in a Kyle Shanahan offense would have been a sight indeed.

Aaron Jones continues to live up to the nickname "Showtyme." 💪

Packers Daily ⤵️ pic.twitter.com/49lrpX8676

— Green Bay Packers (@packers) February 15, 2024

32. New Orleans Saints - Joe Mixon, RB, Oklahoma

Original Pick: Ryan Ramczyk, OT, Wisconsin

The fifth and final running back on this list is the first to bring a bit more 'boom' than 'zoom,' but that doesn't diminish his contributions. Joe Mixon was a second-round pick in 2017 -- #48 overall -- and well worth it. While Mixon may not provide the same burst Kamara does, he is a superb option in this spot.

Mixon has been a gritty runner in his career, consistently grinding out yards after contact behind a rough Cincinnati front. Even this past year, in the wake of Joe Burrow's injury, he was frequently given carries to supplement Jake Browning's lackluster play -- and scored a bunch of touchdowns.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!

LIKE ROTOBALLER?

CLICK HERE, ENTER ROTOBALLER.COM, THEN CHECK THE BOX

More Fantasy Football Analysis