X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

Worst NFL Free Agency Signings: Overvalued Busts (2025)

Sam Darnold - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL DFS Picks

John breaks down the worst NFL free agency signings and the most overvalued free agent busts so far ahead of the 2025 NFL season. Who are the biggest fallers.

At this point, the majority of highly sought-after free agents have already been signed. There are still quite a few, like wide receivers Amari Cooper and Elijah Moore, that could be impact players at some point next season, but they remain unattached to any team at this point.

For those who have found new homes, the grass isn't always greener on the other side. One of the quickest ways to kill a player's career is to ship them off to a much worse situation, and we've seen that happen plenty of times in the past. They then get held back from that point forward by said bad team.

It's a story as old as time. I guess it's not as bad as a player spending their whole career on a bad offense or defense and never realizing their full potential. Let's break down the worst NFL free agency signings ahead of the 2025 season.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy football rankings for 2025:

 

Sam Darnold, QB - Seattle Seahawks

The team didn't have a lot of options, to be fair, but trading away quarterback Geno Smith was a mistake. He was the reason the offense was even functional in 2024, as his elusiveness and awareness allowed him to dodge the constant pressure in his face due to the team's terrible offensive line and still make plays.

Seahawks general manager John Schneider signed a quarterback who was horrible when under consistent pressure last season. Detroit Lions defensive coordinator (at the time) Aaron Glenn figured out that if you just constantly sent exotic blitzes at Darnold, he would see ghosts yet again and completely crumble. And it worked to perfection.

I'm not sure how he thinks this will work out. He had plenty of chances to bolster the offensive line in free agency, but that's just not happening, obviously. Having three or four turnstiles in the trenches isn't a good plan for success for Darnold, whose career was basically dead in the water before he was lucky enough to start for the Minnesota Vikings.

He owes his success there to wide receivers Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison, the offensive line (which was a great pass-protecting unit last season), and head coach Kevin O'Connell, who is one of the league's best offensive minds.

I believe Seahawks offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak is a great coach and will maximize his players. I don't think Darnold will have anything like the season he had last year, especially with such a diminished WR group. No, the next guy on our list and WR Marquez Valdes-Scantling aren't proper replacements for DK Metcalf.

 

Cooper Kupp, WR - Seattle Seahawks

Considering the weak contract he got, it won't be much of a surprise if Kupp isn't very productive in 2025. He will be 32 years old before the season starts, and he got a huge downgrade at quarterback, going from Matthew Stafford with the Los Angeles Rams to the aforementioned Darnold.

Kupp, who is primarily a short to intermediate route specialist and slot receiver, will play with WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba, who was primarily a short to intermediate route specialist and slot receiver last season. The fit doesn't make a ton of sense.

Neither WR has the speed to burn, and Valdes-Scantling consistently taking the top off of defenses seems more like wishful thinking than a reasonable reality.

Kupp is also an injury waiting to happen. He has experienced three straight injury-riddled years of declining play, and at his age, that probably isn't going in the other direction. He may have a fine year in 2025 if last season's play was heavily hampered by the high-ankle sprain he suffered early in the season, but his long and brutal injury history is only piling up.

This is a strict downgrade in situation for him, unless Kubiak becomes some massive genius. Which, in my mind, is possible.

 

DeMarcus Lawrence, DE - Seattle Seahawks

Yes, that's right, we're in the midst of another disaster class from Schneider. I'm not sure if Seattle's ownership still thinks that he's capable of putting together a squad like the 2013 group that won the Super Bowl, but he got promoted after last season, so perhaps they do believe he can do so.

He's been coasting off those few great teams for a long time now, and since 2017, has consistently mismanaged the roster, leading the team to massively underachieve again and again.

Seattle's history of first- and second-round picks is especially egregious. Germain Ifedi, Jarran Reed, Malik McDowell, Rashaad Penny, LJ. Collier, Jordyn Brooks, and D'Wayne Eskridge, to name just a few. He's made some solid picks here and there, but they're interspersed with a minefield of busts, and Seattle's lack of success is a direct result of this.

It would be cool if he could make up for his garbage drafting by making good signings in free agency, but he doesn't do that either, and instead handed a three-year contract worth up to $42 million to a defensive end who will be 33 years old before the start of the 2025 season.

He also played in... that's right, just four contests last season due to injury. Maybe Schneider thinks that will give him fresher legs.

What's the most prominent position group of need for the Seahawks right now? Offensive line! It has been for years (Schneider's ENTIRE time with the team, coincidentally), and there were quite a few free agents that would have been worth signing and would have significantly helped the team here, but Schneider continues to make stupid excuses about how it's a bad idea to spend money on protecting the quarterback, the most important position group in the NFL.

No team with the lowest-paid offensive line in the NFL has ever won the Super Bowl. The Seahawks have no shot in 2025, obviously.

 

Mecole Hardman, WR - Green Bay Packers

The Green Bay Packers are a bit behind schedule here -- they're still apparently stuck in the idea that they can have success and reach a Super Bowl with no real WR1 on their team, just like the Kansas City Chiefs did in the 2023 season. The thing is that the Chiefs had quarterback Patrick Mahomes-- wait, he's not been very good recently. Wait, that's right! They still had tight end Travis Kelce playing at an elite level.

Turns out if you don't have a dominant pass-catcher on your team, whether it's a receiver or a tight end, you're pretty much screwed.

Don't worry! Packers head coach Matt LaFleur said he wanted to "vomit" at the idea of having a WR1 and thinks his team has "a bunch" of WR1s. Cool story, but nobody bought it, and it became an issue in the playoffs. No surprise there.

What happens when you field a bunch of mediocre pass-catchers against a good pass defense, especially in the playoffs? You do virtually nothing and end up scoring only 10 points. So what do the Packers do? They signed former Kansas City Chiefs wideout Mecole Hardman.

Yeah, that will totally fix it. They'll now sport Jayden Reed, who can't beat man coverage; Romeo Doubs, who isn't very good yet and will complain when he doesn't get enough targets; Christian Watson, coming off an ACL tear; and Hardman, who's clearly not what he was drafted to be and will be yet another rotational piece on the offense, probably mainly while Watson recovers from his injury.

This is an obvious bust of a signing. The team doesn't have many options in the draft, either. I don't imagine Hardman will last long here because he's not very good.



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!

More Fantasy Football Analysis

POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Mark Scheifele

To Be A Game-Time Call Wednesday
Jason Robertson

Could Return For Game 1 Against Jets
Calvin Pickard

Remains Starter For Game 1 Against Vegas
Frederik Andersen

Ready For Second-Round Opener
Pavel Dorofeyev

Out On Tuesday
Teoscar Hernández

Teoscar Hernandez Has Grade 1 Adductor Strain
Jason Day

Withdraws From The Truist Championship
Colorado Rockies

Tigers, Rockies Postponed On Tuesday
Teoscar Hernández

Teoscar Hernandez Headed To Injured List
Spencer Shrader

The Favorite To Win Colts Kicking Job
DJ Giddens

To Be Colts Pass-Catching Back?
Christian Watson

Christian Watson "In A Really Good Spot" In His ACL Rehab
B.J. Hill

Seen In Walking Boot At Tuesday's Workouts
Jalin Hyatt

Not Likely To Be Cut
Eric Gray

Unlikely To Make 53-Man Roster
J.J. Spaun

Looking To Regain Form With His Irons At Truist Championship
Harris English

Ready For Truist Championship
Si Woo Kim

On A Positive Trend Ahead Of Truist Championship
Sam Burns

Looks To Continue Hot Putting In Philadelphia
Braden Fiske

In "Really Good Spot" In His Recovery
Robert Rochell

Chiefs Release Robert Rochell
Keegan Bradley

Looking Like His January Self
Tommy Mellott

Expected To Play Multiple Positions
Akshay Bhatia

Trying To Regain Form
Diontae Johnson

Deal Doesn't Have Any Guaranteed Money
Jaxson Dart

Has Plenty Of Developing To Do
PGA

Sungjae Im An Interesting Option At Truist Championship
Ludvig Aberg

Hoping To Find Confidence With His Putter In Philly
Sepp Straka

Finishes Tied For 13th At RBC Heritage
Adam Scott

Finishes Tied For 49th At RBC Heritage
Keith Mitchell

Receives Final Sponsor Exemption For Truist Championship
Hideki Matsuyama

Finishes Tied For 21st At Masters
Viktor Hovland

Finishes Tied For 13th At RBC Heritage
Ben Griffin

Finishes Tied For 40th At Valero Texas Open
Jason Day

Finishes Tied For 49th At RBC Heritage
Wyndham Clark

Finishes Tied For 27th At RBC Heritage
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Close To 30-Point Triple-Double In Game 1 Loss
Nikola Jokić

Nikola Jokic Opens Conference Semifinals With Monster Effort
OG Anunoby

Leads Knicks Comeback Monday Night
Jalen Brunson

Bags 29 Points With Five Triples
Jaylen Brown

Nets 23 Points In Game 1 Loss
Jayson Tatum

Fills Stat Sheet On Poor Shooting Night
Sam Hauser

Injures Right Ankle Monday
William Eklund

Undergoes Wrist Surgery
Carter Verhaeghe

Delivers Two Assists In Losing Effort
Brad Marchand

Records Second Consecutive Multi-Point Game
Matthew Knies

Pots Game-Winner Monday Night
Max Pacioretty

Records Two Assists In Game 1 Victory
William Nylander

Shines In Game 1 With Three Points
Anthony Stolarz

Taken To Hospital Monday
Baltimore Ravens

Ravens Add 17 Undrafted Rookie Free Agents
Kansas City Chiefs

Chiefs Sign 16 Undrafted Rookie Free Agents
Freddie Freeman

Hits 350th Career Home Run Monday
Tulu Griffin

Packers Release Tulu Griffin
Cole Ragans

Fans 11 In Dominant Start Monday
Josiah Deguara

Cardinals Sign Josiah Deguara
Jimmie Ward

Out Of Walking Boot And Running
Kristaps Porzingis

Questionable To Return To Game 1
Cleveland Cavaliers

Kenny Atkinson Named NBA Coach Of The Year
Teoscar Hernández

Teoscar Hernandez Injures Hamstring On Monday
MLB

Nationals-Guardians Postponed On Monday
Gary Payton II

Still Battling Illness, Questionable For Tuesday
De'Andre Hunter

Questionable To Play Tuesday
Ronald Acuña Jr.

Ronald Acuna Jr. Will Begin Rehab Assignment In May
Evan Mobley

Iffy For Tuesday's Action
Darius Garland

In Danger Of Missing Another Game
Jesper Bratt

To Undergo Shoulder Surgery
Luke Hughes

Recovering From Shoulder Surgery
Eric Robinson

Returns To Practice Monday
Sergei Bobrovsky

Looks To Continue Domination Against Maple Leafs
Justin Tucker

Released By Baltimore
Anthony Stolarz

Faces Former Team In Round 2
Mitchell Marner

Good To Go Monday
Jackson Merrill

Now Set To Return On Tuesday
Tyrion Davis-Price

Waived By Eagles
Yordan Alvarez

Placed On Injured List
Jalen Milroe

Working On Lower-Half Mechanics To Improve Accuracy
Shota Imanaga

Goes On 15-Day Injured List
Britain Covey

Signs With Rams
Deiveson Figueiredo

Loses Back-To-Back Fights
Cory Sandhagen

Gets Back In The Win Column
Reinier de Ridder

Extends His Win Streak To Four
Matthew Stafford

To Earn $44 Million In 2025
Bo Nickal

Suffers His First Loss At UFC Des Moines
Santiago Ponzinibbio

Suffers TKO Loss At UFC Des Moines
Royce Lewis

Reinstated From 10-Day Injured List
Daniel Rodriguez

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Daniel Marcos

Undefeated No More
Montel Jackson

Extends His Win Streak
Serhiy Sidey

Gets Decision Win At UFC Des Moines
Jeremy Stephens

Unsuccessful In His UFC Return
Mason Jones

Wins Decision At UFC Des Moines
Willy Adames

Goes Yard Twice In Win
Joey Logano

Steals The Victory At Texas On Sunday
Nolan McLean

Promoted To Triple-A
Kyle Larson

Strong Performance Ends With A Top-Five Finish At Texas
Ricky Stenhouse Jr

. Quietly Obtains A New Career-Best Finish At Texas
Josh Berry

Spins His Way To A Poor Result At Texas
Trey Sweeney

Has A Career Day At The Plate
Austin Riley

Blasts Two Home Runs On Sunday
Pavel Buchnevich

Collects An Assist In Game 7 Loss
Jordan Kyrou

Nets Early Goal In Game 7
Cole Perfetti

Pots Two Goals In Game 7 Win
Ross Chastain

Picks Up Second-Place Finish
Carson Hocevar

Bad Pit Strategy And Late-Race Crash Spoil Carson Hocevar's Top-10 Run
Erik Jones

Improbably Finishes Fifth Despite Speeding Penalty
Michael McDowell

Despite Crashing Out At Texas, Michael McDowell Surprisingly Fights For The Win
John Hunter Nemechek

Brilliant Pit Strategy Lifts John Hunter Nemechek To Eighth Place
Ty Jerome

Scores 21 Points Off The Bench On Sunday
Jarrett Allen

Scores 12 Points In Game 1
Pascal Siakam

Drops 17 Points In Win Over Cleveland
Kerry Carpenter

Tallies Four Hits, Drives In Five
Myles Turner

Has A Productive Showing In Game 1
Masyn Winn

Exits With Ankle Sprain
Andrew Nembhard

Leads Indiana In Scoring In Game 1
Tyrese Haliburton

Guides Indiana To A Win On Sunday
Evan Mobley

Nabs A Double-Double In Game 1
Donovan Mitchell

Can't Lead Cleveland To A Win On Sunday
Ryan Blaney

Frustrated After Fumbling Away Potential Win At Texas
Brad Keselowski

Woeful Season Continues With Wreck At Texas
Maikel Garcia

Homers Twice In Victory
Jackson Holliday

Blasts Two Homers
Randy Arozarena

Exits Early On Sunday
Kyle Larson

Has One Of The Best Cars In The Field At Texas
William Byron

Will Be Tough To Beat At Texas
Chase Elliott

A Slam-Dunk DFS Pick At Texas
Austin Cindric

Could Austin Cindric Legitimately Contend At Texas This Weekend?
Ryan Blaney

Is Worth Rostering For Texas DFS Lineups On Sunday
Joey Logano

Struggling To Find Speed At Texas
Tyler Reddick

Should Be Highly Considered For DFS At Texas This Week
Daniel Suarez

Has Been One Of The Best At Texas In Next Gen Car
Denny Hamlin

Might Have Another Quality Texas Start This Week
AJ Allmendinger

Has Shown Speed At Texas This Weekend
Deiveson Figueiredo

Returns To Action
Cory Sandhagen

Set For UFC Des Moines Main Event
Bo Nickal

Set For Co-Main Event
Reinier de Ridder

An Underdog At UFC Des Moines
Daniel Rodriguez

Looks To Win Second Consecutive Fight
Santiago Ponzinibbio

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Daniel Marcos

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Montel Jackson

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Cameron Smotherman

Set For His Second UFC Bout
Serhiy Sidey

A Favorite At UFC Des Moines
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF