X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Five Catcher Draft Values and Sleepers For 2017

Rick Lucks analyzes some MLB catchers as 2017 fantasy baseball sleepers. These catchers are draft values and targets to provide value in the later draft rounds.

The 2017 MLB season, like the vast majority of campaigns that have come before it, figures to feature a weak catcher position. Not to worry - today I'm here to help identify some early catcher draft values and potential sleepers for the 2017 fantasy baseball season.

Catchers who can hit at all require you to take a hit elsewhere on your roster, as they are taken where the game's best players leave the board. The scrubs you can take later on are worse than leaving the spot blank. Add in how many leagues demand two of these, and you can only conclude that fantasy baseball is intended for masochists.

Thankfully, there is some upside available later in the draft. Here are five catchers who may not make you cringe every time you check your league's standings.

Editor's note: make sure you also visit our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. It already has lots of great staff rankings articles and draft analysis. You will find tiered rankings for every position, 2017 impact rookie rankings, AL/NL only league ranks, dynasty prospect rankings, keeper league rankings and more. Bookmark the page, and win your drafts.

 

Catcher Draft Values - 2017 Fantasy Baseball

Wilson Ramos - Tampa Bay Rays

Ramos had one of the better 2016 seasons for a catcher, as he hit .307/.354/.496 with 22 bombs in a breakout campaign. He also tore his ACL, preventing him from playing until May 2017 at the earliest. He seems to be recovering nicely from the knee injury by all accounts, and Tampa intends to use him as a DH while he gets healthy enough to go back behind the plate.

The DH thing is huge. Most catchers pale in comparison to other positions because the frequent days off limit their PAs and counting stats, but Ramos may be able to outperform his position mates just by batting more often. Using Ramos and somebody else in April could give you more PAs from your C than everyone who did not draft Buster Posey or Jonathan Lucroy.

Those PAs should be a plus from a batting average perspective. His .327 BABIP last year may seem high, but between Ramos's low FB% (25.3%) and sustainable 2016 LD% (20.4%), he projects as a plus-BABIP guy moving forward. Ramos's eye also improved last year, as a career best 30.2% O-Swing% helped to produce an excellent 15.1% K%. The low FB% and inflated HR/FB (21.4%) make me pessimistic about a power repeat, but a catcher that can help with anything toward the end of the draft is welcome.

 

Stephen Vogt - Oakland Athletics

Vogt's .251/.305/.406 line with 14 HR wasn't sexy, but the bar for catchers is pretty low. He is a little better than his surface stats suggest, too. His BABIP on ground balls was just .153 last year against a career average of .218. The shift was not the issue, as Vogt hit .287 against it. A few more singles are all it would take to bring his average to respectability, as his 15.6% K% is already strong.

He also offers power upside. His HR/FB has never been great (7.4% last year, 8.9% career), but Vogt makes up for it by hitting a ton of fly balls (46.5% FB% last year, 45.1% career). A true breakout could occur if Vogt is acquired by a contender midseason, as 29 of his 45 career bombs have come on the road.

PAs inflate Vogt's fantasy value as well, as Oakland frequently DHs him on off days from catching. The 532 PAs he recorded last year were a ton for a catcher as a result. The team also bats him in attractive batting order slots, leaving Vogt with more counting stats than most catchers can hope to put up.

 

Travis d'Arnaud - New York Mets

TDA was a popular sleeper pick heading into 2016, as his .268/.340/.485 line with 12 dingers in 268 PAs had fantasy owners interested. A shoulder injury bit into his playing time and limited him to a .247/.307/.323 with four homers, however, removing him from the fantasy radar. He is expected to be fully healthy by Spring Training, giving him some post-hype sleeper appeal.

A mechanical flaw in d'Arnaud's batting stance has also been cited as a potential reason for the nosedive in FB% (41.7% to 30.8%) and IFFB% spike (16.3% to 19.4%). The Mets are aware of the problem, and plan to correct it during Spring Training. If these rates return to 2015 levels, 2017 fantasy owners will turn a significant profit on their investment.

Finally, TDA faces little competition for his lineup spot. Kevin Plawecki looked like a disaster in 2016, while Rene Rivera is nothing more than a glove. If nothing else, d'Arnaud will play.

 

Tom Murphy / Tony Wolters - Colorado Rockies

When in doubt, try the Coors player(s) no one has ever heard of. Murphy offers the most fantasy upside in this duo with 19 bombs in 321 Triple-A PAs last year before clubbing five in 49 PAs with the big club. He hit 23 homers across three levels in 2015 as well, so the pop seems genuine. His 25% K% in the upper minors represents significant risk, and the 38.8% strikeout rate he posted in his brief MLB tenure is alarming. Still, he makes an intriguing flyer if called on.

The principle alternative is Tony Wolters, who would get the lion's share of the playing time should a platoon develop thanks to his left-handed bat. He hit .259/.327/.395 with three big flies in 230 PAs last year, and has nothing in his minor league history to suggest offensive upside. Still, you could do a lot worse than a Coors regular in a second C slot.

Dustin Garneau could complicate things as another catcher on the roster, as his .292/.367/.595 with 15 blasts in 211 Triple-A PAs  seems great. He is almost certainly a product of the hitter-friendly PCL, however, as the rest of his minor league history reads like a right-handed version of Wolters. Still, Coors is desirable if he ends up with an opportunity.

 

Francisco Cervelli - Pittsburgh Pirates

When all else fails, you should look to acquire a cheap catcher who will not actively harm you. Cervelli's .264 batting average last year accomplished exactly this despite a down year, and his 1.6% HR/FB has nowhere to go but up. His .329 BABIP may seem inflated for a C, but he can run a little (six steals last year!) and avoids popping the ball up. The combination of a 24.1% FB% and 1.6% IFFB% is difficult to top in the pop up avoidance category.

His average may actually have room to increase, as his 19.8% LD% last year was less than his 20.8% career mark. His batting eye is elite, so be sure to take advantage if your rivals sleep on him in an OBP league. Those in traditional formats will at least benefit from a low K%.

Cervelli has almost no power potential at all, but started last year in the heart of the Pirate order anyway. The club's fondness for their spiritual leader could give him more counting stat opportunities than you might suspect, too.


Check out RotoBaller's entire fantasy baseball waiver wire pickups and sleepers list, updated daily!




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Tyler Reddick

a Strong DFS Contender on Paper, but He'll Likely Run Worse Than Expected
Joey Logano

Team Will Likely Ignore Nashville After He Locked Into the Playoffs
Kyle Busch

Loss of Intermediate Speed This Year Will Likely Foil Him at Nashville
Chris Buescher

Despite Improved Qualifying Speed, Chris Buescher Seems Much Slower in Races
Austin Cindric

Team Penske's Firing of Austin Cindric's Dad May Hurt the No. 2 Team's Morale
Ryan Preece

an Underrated DFS Option Given His Impressive Passing This Year
Noah Gragson

Passing Will Likely Prove to Difficult for Noah Gragson to Have DFS Value
Michael McDowell

Qualified Too Well for DFS Consideration
Erik Jones

Probably Starting too Well for Place Differential Points but Not Well Enough for Other Bonus Points
Corey Heim

Unlikely to Match 23XI Racing Teammates' Speed at Nashville
Cole Custer

Likely Needs Strategy Shakeup to Have DFS Value at Nashville
Ty Dillon

Likely Needs Another Chaotic Nashville Race to Contend
Adolis García

Adolis Garcia Could Continue to Rest
Zack Littell

Throws Complete Game
Junior Caminero

Homers Twice in Win
Tony Bradley

Available Saturday
A.J. Greer

Questionable for Start of Stanley Cup Finals
Roope Hintz

Dealing with Fractured Foot
Sean Walker

Nursing a Shoulder Injury
Daulton Varsho

Exits Early on Saturday
Jalen Chatfield

Recovering From Hip Injury
Seth Jarvis

to Delay Shoulder Surgery
Adam Boqvist

Agrees to One-Year Extension with Islanders
Kyle Palmieri

Signs Two-Year Extension with Islanders
Xavier Edwards

Reinstated from 10-Day Injured List
Yordan Alvarez

has Hand Fracture, Set to Return in Near Future
David Fry

Returns from 60-Day Injured List
Matt Wallner

Activated from Injured List
Justin Fields

has Faith in Himself
Keston Hiura

Michael Toglia Optioned, Keston Hiura Recalled
Shay Whitcomb

Promoted to Major Leagues
Quinshon Judkins

to Work With Starters Sooner Than Later
Dawand Jones

Takes Part in OTAs
Ryan Mountcastle

Orioles Place Ryan Mountcastle on 10-Day Injured List With Hamstring Strain
Freddie Freeman

Aggravates his Ankle
Mookie Betts

has Fractured Toe, to Miss Rest of Series Against Yankees
Cole Young

Mariners to Promote Cole Young to Major Leagues
Willi Castro

Goes Deep Twice
Shohei Ohtani

Crushes Pair of Homers
Cal Raleigh

Smacks Two More Homers on Friday
Marcus Semien

Swipes Bag, Homers Amidst Four-Hit Effort
Framber Valdez

Hurls Complete Game Friday
Francisco Lindor

Two Homers Power Mets Over Rockies
Shedeur Sanders

Last in Line in QB Competition
Joe Flacco

the Favorite for Starting QB Job
Christian Yelich

Blasts Two Homers in Win
Tony Bradley

Questionable For Saturday Night
Karl-Anthony Towns

Not on the Injury Report for Game 6
Joe Mixon

Currently in Walking Boot
C.J. Stroud

Dealing with Minor Injury
Dillon Gabriel

Unlikely to Win Starting Gig
Bryce Huff

49ers Nearing Trade for Bryce Huff
Seattle Seahawks

Anthony Campbell Signs with Seattle
Baltimore Ravens

Ravens Sign Malaki Starks
Audric Estime

in Line for More Touches
Jaxson Dart

Signs Rookie Contract
Erin Blanchfield

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 107
Maycee Barber

Looks To Extend Her Win Streak
Ludovit Klein

Set For UFC Vegas 107 Co-Main Event
Mateusz Gamrot

Returns At UFC Vegas 107
Billy Ray Goff

Looks For His Second UFC Win
Ramiz Brahimaj

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 107
Dustin Jacoby

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Bruno Lopes

Set For His Second UFC Bout
Ketlen Vieira

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Macy Chiasson

Looks For Third Consecutive Win
Duško Todorović

Dusko Todorovic In Dire Need Of Victory
Zachary Reese

Set To Open Up UFC Vegas 107 Main Card
Minnesota Vikings

Vikings Sign Kwesi Adofo-Mensah to Multi-Year Extension
Isaiah Likely

John Harbaugh Wants to See Isaiah Likely Become an All-Pro
Jameson Williams

Lions Expecting Big Season From Jameson Williams
Brandon Aiyuk

49ers Optimistic About Brandon Aiyuk's Recovery
Jakobi Meyers

Other Receivers Being Moved Around a Lot
Christian Wilkins

Malcolm Koonce Returns to Practice, Christian Wilkins Still Out
Geno Smith

Things Going Smoothly With Geno Smith, Chip Kelly
Travis Kelce

Patrick Mahomes Says Travis Kelce is Locked In
Wyatt Johnston

Finishes Thursday's Loss with Two Assists
Jason Robertson

Pots Two Goals in Season-Ending Defeat
Stuart Skinner

Picks Up Fourth Consecutive Win
Mattias Ekholm

Collects an Assist in Postseason Debut
Leon Draisaitl

Delivers Two Assists in Series-Clinching Win
Connor McDavid

Extends Multi-Point Streak in Series-Clincher
Karl-Anthony Towns

Cleared to Play Thursday
Aaron Nesmith

Available Thursday
Shakir Mukhamadullin

Inks One-Year Extension with Sharks
Tyson Foerster

Signs Two-Year Extension with Flyers
NHL

Jonathan Toews Eyeing NHL Comeback
Bo Horvat

Out 4-6 Weeks with Ankle Injury
Jeff Skinner

Back in Oilers Lineup Thursday
Mattias Ekholm

Returns to Action Thursday
Julius Randle

Notches Team-High 24 Points in Blowout Loss
Anthony Edwards

Struggles in Game 5 Loss
Jalen Williams

Remains Busy Wednesday
Chet Holmgren

Strong at Both Ends Wednesday
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Records Another 30-Point Performance
Brandin Podziemski

Recovering From Wrist Surgery
Connor Brown

to Miss Second Consecutive Game
Seth Jarvis

Notches Two Points in Wednesday's Loss
Aaron Nesmith

Back on the Injury Report Ahead of Game 5
Karl-Anthony Towns

Listed as Questionable for Thursday's Game 5
PGA

Byeong Hun An Is a Shaky Play at Muirfield
Christiaan Bezuidenhout

a Decent Play at Muirfield
Brian Harman

May Not Be a Good Option at Muirfield
Matt Fitzpatrick

Has Great History at Memorial
Denny McCarthy

A Solid Choice At Muirfield Village
Tony Finau

Shaping Into Form Heading Into Memorial
Cameron Young

Hard to Trust at the Memorial
PGA

Alex Noren a Sneaky Value Play at the Memorial
Patrick Cantlay

Has Potential Heading Into Muirfield
Sepp Straka

Eyeing Another Elite Signature-Event Performance
Wyndham Clark

Not A Reliable Option Ahead Of Memorial
Aaron Rai

Looking to Bounce Back at the Memorial
Max Homa

Still in Fantasy Golf Purgatory at Memorial Tournament
Viktor Hovland

Rounding into Form Ahead of the Memorial
Stephan Jaeger

is a Scary Play at Muirfield Village
PGA

Sungjae Im a Volatile Option at the Memorial
Jordan Spieth

Looks to Turn the Corner at Muirfield Village
Xander Schauffele

a Strong Contender at Muirfield Village
Robert MacIntyre

Making Muirfield Village Debut
Michael Kim

Slide Continues Heading into Colonial
Josh Hart

Logs a Double-Double Off the Bench Tuesday
Karl-Anthony Towns

Collects Another Double-Double in Tuesday's Loss
Sam Burns

Playing Well as the Memorial Approaches
Jalen Brunson

Leads Knicks with 31 Points in Tuesday's Loss
Pascal Siakam

Drops 30 Points on Knicks in Game 4 Win
Tyrese Haliburton

Records Historic Triple-Double Tuesday
Russell Westbrook

Undergoes Hand Surgery
Brad Keselowski

Finally Gets a Good Finish in 2025
William Byron

Dominant Charlotte Performance Falls Short At the End
Tyler Reddick

Strong Coca-Cola 600 Run Ruined By A Late Pit-Road Penalty
Denny Hamlin

Is Relegated to 16th Place At Charlotte Despite Strong Car
Kyle Larson

Coca-Cola 600 Performance Crashes Down In Disappointment
Nickeil Alexander-Walker

Leads Timberwolves in Scoring Monday
Jaden McDaniels

Busy Against Thunder in Game 4
Christopher Bell

Disappoints by his High Standards But Gains on Points Lead
Chase Elliott

has Another Invisible Race but Still Improves Playoff Position
AJ Allmendinger

A.J. Allmendinger Earns Highest Oval Driver Rating Since 2011 at Charlotte
Chase Briscoe

Recovers from Pit-Road Penalty to Finish Third
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF