Hot MLB Prospects to Watch for Fantasy Baseball - Week 5

April 24, 2024

Andersen looks at the top prospects who are coming off an impressive week in the minor leagues heading into Week 5 of the 2024 season. These MLB prospects may become strong fantasy baseball waiver wire stashes or pickups.

Welcome back, RotoBallers! We're heading into Week 5 of the fantasy baseball season. The minor league baseball season is off to a hot start, providing us with plenty of big plays and impressive prospect performances.

It's imperative to monitor the top fantasy baseball prospects who have turned heads thus far. The players listed here are not only coming off dominant weeks but have also impressed over the entire season. Don't be surprised when these exact names are painting corners, mashing homers, and swiping bags at the big-league level soon.

Savvy fantasy managers looking for an edge in their leagues should certainly keep an eye on these players over the long haul as they may prove to be excellent adds in no time.

• Fantasy baseball draft kit
• Fantasy baseball rankings
• Team Sync platform and Draft Assistant
• Fantasy baseball mock draft simulator
• Fantasy baseball draft cheat sheets
• Fantasy baseball closer depth charts
• Fantasy baseball prospects

Matthew Lugo - LF, Boston Red Sox

Level: Double-A
2024 stats: Nine G, .357/.471/.857, Three HR, 12 RBI, Five R, Zero SB, 17.6% BB%, 23.5% K%, .412 BABIP, .564 wOBA, 252 wRC+

Lugo endured a subpar 2023 campaign at the Double-A level, showing a tendency to commit errors on the left side of the infield, as well as a below-average hit tool. The organization has experimented with his positional versatility and seems to have found a better home for him in left field, where he made a Gold Glove-caliber catch last week. Meanwhile, his bat has played very well so far this year as he has demonstrated an ability to put the ball in play, work walks, and even deliver a hint of power.

Over five games last week, Lugo went 8-for-21 with two home runs, 11 RBI, five walks, and five strikeouts. He currently owns a seven-game hitting streak and could be pushing for his first-ever promotion to Triple-A sooner rather than later.

Matthew Lugo doubles (4) and Portland scores another run. Suddenly down just 9-6 in the ninth.

The Boston Red Sox prospect has 13 RBI this season. pic.twitter.com/UdOUlxwLps

— Hunter Noll (@Hunter_Noll) April 24, 2024

Aaron Brown - SP, Houston Astros

Level: Double-A
2024 stats: Three G, One GS, 1-0, 13.2 IP, 3.95 ERA, 1.95 xFIP, 15.15 K/9, 3.29 BB/9, 1.32 HR/9, 55.2% GB%, .333 BABIP

Brown is a former ninth-round pick who joined the Astros organization following the 2021 draft. He spent all of last season at Double-A and has consistently shuttled between a bullpen and rotation role. He boasts high strikeout rates and has managed to keep his walk rate down for the most part.

Brown made his first start of 2024 last Thursday. He tossed five scoreless innings, allowing one hit and zero walks. Best of all, he managed to record 10 strikeouts along the way, good for a rate of two per inning. Brown's high strikeout rate could make him an appealing multi-inning bullpen arm for Houston next season.

Aaron Brown dominated for the Hooks tonight striking out 10 over 5 scoreless innings! #Astros pic.twitter.com/PP1KUBcJkn

— Astros Future (@AstrosFuture) April 19, 2024

Nathan Church - OF, St. Louis Cardinals

Level: Double-A
2024 stats: 14 G, .355/.408/.516, Three HR, 15 RBI, 13 R, Four SB, 9.9% BB%, 5.6% K%, .333 BABIP, .421 wOBA, 152 wRC+

The Cardinals have to like what they've seen from Church, their 11th-round pick in the 2022 draft. The UC Irvine product has terrific bat-to-ball skills and should continue to showcase both contact and power throughout all levels of the minor leagues. He's also swiped some bags. However, he does have some limitations defensively and could be bound to left field long-term.

Nevertheless, Church continued to make a name for himself last week, going 9-for-25 with two homers, eight RBI, six walks, and a stolen base. As he has done for his entire career, Church showed terrific plate discipline, adding just two strikeouts to his ledger over last week's six-game span.

HOME RUN NATHAN CHURCH!! Church keeps up his hot hitting to start the season at AA, hitting his 3rd homer on the season.
Church matches his HR total from all of last season. pic.twitter.com/Olm9O9Cck6

— Kyle Reis, 58% Neanderthal (@kyler416) April 21, 2024

Winston Santos - SP, Texas Rangers

Level: High-A
2024 stats: Three G, Three GS, 2-1, 15.2 IP, 0.57 ERA, 1.13 FIP, 13.79 K/9, 2.30 BB/9, 0.00 HR/9, 36.7% GB%, .281 BABIP

Santos is a 22-year-old who signed with the Rangers out of the Dominican Republic in 2019. He gets good velocity behind his mid-90s fastball and has also shown the ability to harness his changeup for strikes and induce weak contact. However, he needs to focus on significant development for his slider. The offering is not an established pitch, and he would benefit drastically from rounding out his repertoire with a reliable third offering that generates movement.

Last week, Santos made his third start of the season and showcased pure excellence. He tossed five shutout innings, allowing one hit and a pair of walks along the way. However, what stood out most were his 12 strikeouts, a clear reflection of his ability to get control of his top offerings and miss bats. If he can continue to pitch at a high level, he'll be knocking on the door of the majors early next year.

What a sequence by Winston Santos!

The 22-year-old @Rangers prospect struck out the side (with a walk in between) in three consecutive innings for the @HickoryCrawdads: pic.twitter.com/k3Bzt9jcP8

— Minor League Baseball (@MiLB) April 20, 2024

Gregory Barrios - SS, Milwaukee Brewers

Level: High-A
2024 stats: 13 G, .404/.453/.574, Zero HR, 12 RBI, Eight R, Two SB, 5.7% BB%, 17.0% K%, .487 BABIP, .470 wOBA, 185 wRC+

The Brewers signed Barrios out of Venezuela in early 2021. He has proven himself as a reliable hitter and defender, possessing the qualities needed to ascend through the minors. He's not a power hitter -- he has just one home run over 198 pro games -- but shows a decent understanding of the strike zone, puts the ball in play, runs the bases well, and demonstrates the glovework needed to carve out a significant career at shortstop.

Last week, Barrios logged multiple hits in all five of his games. He ultimately went 13-for-18 during his big week, adding six extra-base hits, seven RBI, two walks, one strikeout, and one stolen base. The 20-year-old will need to spend a little more time at High-A before he's ready for a promotion, but Barrios is certainly a name to monitor.

🏆 Gregory Barrios named Midwest League Player of the Week after strong performances on both sides of the ball

Last week Barrios posted a .762 OBP / 1.056 SLG / 1.818 OPS with 6 2Bs (‼️), 2 BBs to just 1 K, a stolen base, with some stellar defense at shortstop#ThisIsMyCrew pic.twitter.com/gFOMPywmDs

— Brewers Player Development (@BrewersPD) April 22, 2024

More Fantasy Baseball Prospects and Rookies