👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE SPRING
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


2016 Fantasy Baseball Tiered Rankings: Second Base (February)

Welcome back to another installment of RotoBaller’s February fantasy baseball rankings. The panel again consists of Brad Johnson, Max Petrie, Kyle Bishop, Nick Mariano, Harris Yudin (me), Jeff Kahntroff and Bill Dubiel.

Today we will take a look at the surprisingly deep pool of second basemen. In addition to our consensus staff rankings at second base, and draft tiers, yours truly has also provided my rankings analysis.

Editor's note: Be sure to also check out our 2016 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard, which is already loaded up with lots of great articles. Aside from staff rankings across all positions, we also dig into MLB prospect rankings, and dynasty/keeper rankings as well.

 

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings Analysis: Second Base

Tier one stayed the same from our January rankings. Jose Altuve, then Dee Gordon. Altuve is a lock for at least 10 home runs, 35 stolen bases and a .310 batting average, with the potential for even more. Gordon has swiped 122 bases over the last two years, and has really improved as a hitter-- I mean, he won the batting title last year.

Most of tier two remained the same. Robinson Cano, Jason Kipnis and Brian Dozier stayed in third, fourth and fifth, respectively, but I bumped Anthony Rendon down to tier three. Cano finished fifth in fantasy points among second baseman in 2015, despite hitting just .238/.277/.344 with four home runs through the end of June.

Continuting with the third tier, Rendon is followed by players in very different situations. Rougned Odor and Kolten Wong are young second baseman with a ton of potential, and Ian Kinsler and Dustin Pedroia are reliable veterans slowly starting on the back end of their respective careers. I brought both Kinsler and Pedroia a bit closer to the top of the list this time, as I felt I may have subjected them to unnecessary agism last month. I fully expect Kinsler's power and speed to continue to diminish, and his batting average could very well come back down towards his career average of .276.

Ben Zobrist, originally in tier three, slides down to tier four, despite the fact that I have him ranked higher than two players in tier three-- his composite ranking is closer to those in tier four. Joe Panik remains in this tier, even though Jeff and I have him ranked 19th and 20th, respectively. Panik is a solid hitter and a strong defender, but his counting stats (eight home runs, three stolen bases in 382 at-bats) are far too low for me to put him above guys like Starlin Castro and Logan Forsythe. Panik never surpassed seven home runs in the minor leagues, so it's hard to imagine him hitting double digits this year in the majors.

Daniel Murphy has passed Neil Walker since our last rankings came out. Brad, Max, Nick and I all dropped Walker in our rankings, and Nick bumped Murphy up to No. 14, just enough for him to edge his replacement in New York.

Tier five is headlined by Howie Kendrick, who understandably shot up from No. 19 to No. 16 after re-signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Second base is such a deep position this year, that any of the players in this group would be worth grabbing in the mid-to-late rounds as a 2B2 or MI. DJ LeMahieu, Devon Travis, Jonathan Schoop, Addison Russell, Forsythe and Castro are all young players with a solid combination of tools. I am higher than most on Castro, who will be playing his natural position of second base for the Yankees. He hit .339/.358/.583 with five home runs in 115 at-bats as a second baseman last year, as opposed to .243/.278/.320 with six home runs in 419 at-bats at shortstop.

Even tier six has some intriguing options. Brett Lawrie is immersed in the middle of a much improved White Sox lineup, Trea Turner is an elite prospect with incredible speed, and Javier Baez and Jedd Gyorko should see decent at-bats despite not having starting roles. Cory Spangenberg is an interesting name to consider in late rounds.

I really like Lawrie from this tier, though. Honestly, how different will Lawrie's numbers be from Panik's?

As mentioned earlier, Panik, who is ranked as our 12th second baseman, never hit more than seven home runs in the minors, and even though he hit eight in 382 AB last year, he will probably top out around 10. Steamer has him projected for seven dingers, to go along with 61 runs, 48 RBI and a .278 batting average. His .312 average last year indicates that he could do better, but he is more likely to end up in the range of his .295 career minor league average.

Lawrie, 24th on our list, is still only 26 years old and has improved his power totals with each passing year, up to 16 HR and 60 RBI in 2015. Those numbers could even increase in a better offense and a more power-friendly park in 2016. His decreasing averages are a bit concerning, but he has been able to hit in the past (.273/.324/.405 in 2012), so if he can bring that slash line back up near his 2012 totals, his unique power for a middle infielder will make him very valuable. Lawrie went 6 for 13 with a home run at U.S. Cellular Field in 2015, and batted .272 overall away from Oakland.

Panik is probably still the better fantasy player, but there's not that big of a difference. If Lawrie can be had several rounds later, it would be worth it to wait.

Finally, tier seven is comprised of players who can basically be ignored in all mixed leagues. Only Scooter Gennett and Johnny Giavotella are projected starters, but neither is capable of putting together appealing stat lines. Wilmer Flores could become relevant if and when David Wright gets injured, but for now, he can be left alone.

Overall, there is some star power at the top of this list, but there is a ton of parity between tiers two and six. It may be in the best interest of fantasy owners to sit back and snag a second baseman late.

 

Second Base Tiered Fantasy Baseball Rankings (February)

Ranking Tier Name Brad Max Kyle Nick Harris Jeff Bill
1 1 Jose Altuve 1 1 1 1 1 2 1
2 1 Dee Gordon 2 2 2 2 3 1 2
3 2 Robinson Cano 4 3 4 4 2 3 5
4 2 Jason Kipnis 3 4 6 5 4 6 3
5 2 Brian Dozier 6 6 3 3 5 5 4
6 3 Anthony Rendon 5 7 5 6 6 9 6
7 3 Rougned Odor 9 10 7 8 7 4 7
8 3 Ian Kinsler 7 5 8 7 12 10 8
9 3 Dustin Pedroia 8 8 10 10 13 11 9
10 3 Kolten Wong 12 14 9 9 8 7 11
11 4 Ben Zobrist 10 9 12 12 9 20 12
12 4 Joe Panik 11 11 11 11 20 19 10
13 4 Daniel Murphy 14 13 18 14 11 12 13
14 4 Neil Walker 15 15 13 15 10 14 16
15 4 Josh Harrison 16 12 22 18 18 8 22
16 5 Howie Kendrick 17 16 20 16 22 13 17
17 5 DJ LeMahieu 19 18 19 19 19 15 14
18 5 Devon Travis 23 17 15 13 14 26 15
19 5 Jonathan Schoop 18 20 14 17 23 16 19
20 5 Addison Russell 13 21 21 20 15 17 21
21 5 Logan Forsythe 20 22 16 21 17 23 18
22 5 Brandon Phillips 21 19 17 22 24 18 23
23 5 Starlin Castro 22 23 23 23 16 21 20
24 6 Brett Lawrie 26 26 28 29 21 22 24
25 6 Cesar Hernandez 24 24 25 26 29 - 25
26 6 Trea Turner 30 25 30 28 25 24 31
27 6 Javier Baez 31 28 29 27 26 25 -
28 6 Brock Holt 25 27 27 25 34 27 30
29 6 Cory Spangenberg 32 31 24 34 27 - -
30 6 Jedd Gyorko - 29 32 32 31 - 27
31 6 Chase Utley - 32 26 30 39 28 28
32 6 Enrique Hernandez - 33 31 24 35 30 -
33 6 Jace Peterson 28 30 33 33 28 33 32
34 6 Chris Owings - 34 34 31 30 29 -
35 7 Ryan Goins 27 35 35 36 38 - 30
36 7 Kelly Johnson 29 39 - 35 - - -
37 7 Scooter Gennett 33 36 - 37 33 - -
38 7 Wilmer Flores - 38 - 38 32 32 -
39 7 Jose Ramirez - 37 - 40 36 31 -
40 7 Jose Peraza - 40 - - 37 - -
41 7 Dilson Herrera - 41 - 39 - - -
42 7 Johnny Giavotella - 42 - - 40 - -
43 7 Darnell Sweeney - 43 - - - -

 
 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 




REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Cade Otton

Remains a Quality Dynasty Depth Piece
CFB

Walker Lyons Could be Go-To Target for Bear Bachmeier
Austin Reaves

Scores 31 Points in Game 2 Defeat
T.J. Hockenson

Bounce-Back Chances Stifled by Improved Pass-Catching Depth
CFB

Ty Benefield a Potential Game-Changer for LSU Defense
Chet Holmgren

Anchors Thunder Past Lakers in Game 2
CFB

Hayden Lowe Set for Significant Role Following Miami's NFL Departures
Jordan Addison

Facing Competition for No. 2 Role?
Tobias Harris

Stays Hot in Game 2 Victory
Cade Cunningham

Pushes Pistons to 2-0 Series Lead
CFB

Taylor Wein in Position for Big Season on Oklahoma's Defensive Line
Taylor Heinicke

Retiring After 11 Seasons
Jarrett Allen

Provides Bright Spot in Cavs' Game 2 Loss to Pistons
Jauan Jennings

Signs With Vikings on One-Year Deal
CFB

Rasheem Biles an Instant Impact Player for Texas
James Harden

Struggles in Game 2 Loss
Donovan Mitchell

Finishes Game 2 Loss with 31 Points
Gradey Dick

Open to Trade Away From Toronto
Michael Porter Jr.

Wants to Stay in Brooklyn
Charlotte Hornets

Hornets Extend Charles Lee After 25-Win Improvement
Jarred Vanderbilt

Ruled Out for Game 2 Against Thunder
Luke Kennard

Cleared to Play Thursday
Ayo Dosunmu

Considered Questionable for Game 3 Against Spurs
Anthony Edwards

Remains Questionable on Injury Report Ahead of Game 3
Mitchell Robinson

Probable for Friday's Action
Kevin Huerter

Remains Out Thursday
Sam Merrill

Unavailable Thursday
OG Anunoby

Tagged as Questionable for Friday
Joel Embiid

Listed as Questionable for Game 3 Against Knicks
Dan Vladar

Looks to Return to Winning Ways Thursday
Connor Dewar

Penguins Re-Sign Connor Dewar for Two Years
Mikko Rantanen

Played Through Torn MCL Late in the Season
Rasmus Dahlin

Ready to Go Friday
Kyle Pitts Sr.

Signs Franchise Tender on Thursday
Alexander Nikishin

Set to Return Thursday
Joe Burrow

Attending Voluntary Workouts, Ready for Monster Season?
Christian Dvorak

Available Thursday
Owen Tippett

Remains Out Thursday
Roman Anthony

Heading for the Injured List
CFB

Sam Leavitt Expected to Be Full-Go for Fall Camp
T.J. Hockenson

Can T.J. Hockenson Bounce Back with Improved Quarterback Play in Minnesota?
Jordan Love

Is Jordan Love's Dynasty Upside Fading Entering 2026?
Dalton Schultz

Facing Increased Playing Time Competition in Houston Entering 2026
Kimani Vidal

Dynasty Value in Question Due to Uncertain Playing Time Outlook
Juwan Johnson

Facing Reduced Role in New Orleans Following NFL Draft?
Chuba Hubbard

a Prime Bounce-Back Candidate Following Offseason Moves
Indianapolis Colts

Kenny Moore Granted his Release by Colts
Minnesota Vikings

Chad Alexander a Candidate for Vikings GM Job
Tarik Skubal

Could Return in 4-6 Weeks After Successful Elbow Surgery
Minnesota Vikings

Vikings Request to Interview RJ Gillen for GM Job
Drake Maye

Shoulder Doing "Great"
Gunnar Helm

a Clear Breakout Candidate Despite Crowded Offense?
Travis Hunter

Dynasty Managers Regret Drafting Travis Hunter?
Khalil Shakir

Offseason Addition a Threat to Khalil Shakir's Consistency?
Christian Watson

Can Christian Watson Overcome Injury History?
Cole Ragans

Royals Hopeful That Cole Ragans Makes his Next Start
Paul George

Does a Little Bit of Everything in Game 2 Loss
Tyrese Maxey

Tallies Team-High 26 Points in Wednesday's Loss
Mark Stone

Nets Late Power-Play Goal in Losing Effort
Leo Carlsson

Pots Game-Winner Wednesday Night
Juraj Slafkovsky

Ends Point Drought in Game 1 Loss
Bowen Byram

Ties Franchise Record With Fourth Postseason Goal
Zach Benson

Posts Second Consecutive Multi-Point Game
Rasmus Dahlin

"Seems Fine" After Early Exit on Wednesday
Emilio Pagán

Emilio Pagan has Grade 2 Hamstring Strain, Expected to Miss 4-8 Weeks
Joe Ryan

Listed as Scheduled Starter for Saturday Against Cleveland
Tyler Glasnow

Not Expected to Land on the Injured List
Framber Valdez

Suspension Reduced to Five Games
Nils Hoglander

Will Miss World Championship Due to Injury
Christian Dvorak

Likely to Play in Game 3 Against Hurricanes
Owen Tippett

a Game-Time Decision Thursday
Noah Cates

to Miss Rest of Round 2
Arber Xhekaj

Rejoins Canadiens Lineup Wednesday
Brendan Gallagher

Scratched on Wednesday
Logan Stanley

Returns to Action Wednesday
Framber Valdez

Suspended Six Games
Tyler Glasnow

Exits Early on Wednesday With Back Pain
CFB

Brauntae Johnson the Next Star in Notre Dame's Secondary?
CFB

Ethan Barbour a Name to Know in Georgia's Tight End Room
CFB

Payton Pierce Next Up at Linebacker for Ohio State
CFB

Javin Gordon to Play Significant Role for Tennessee?
CFB

Tanook Hines Stepping into WR1 Role for USC
CFB

Rueben Owens II has "Star Potential" in Fourth Campaign
Brandon Woodruff

has Fluid Drained From his Right Shoulder
Brandon Woodruff

to Resume Throwing on Saturday, Return Imminent?
Carlos Correa

to Have Season-Ending Ankle Surgery
Jacob Misiorowski

Listed as Friday's Probable Starter
Logan Webb

Dealing With Knee Discomfort
Carlos Correa

Expected to Miss Significant Time With Ankle Injury
Collin Morikawa

Withdraws From Truist Championship
Xander Schauffele

Carries Elite Form Into Quail Hollow
Hideki Matsuyama

Looks to Bounce Back at Truist Championship
Matt Fitzpatrick

Secures Third Win of 2026 Season
Patrick Cantlay

Continues Playing Well Heading to Truist Championship
Ludvig Aberg

Returns to Action For Truist Championship
Justin Thomas

Searching for Consistency at Quail Hollow
Jordan Spieth

Looks to Break Through at Quail Hollow
Adam Scott

Brings Strong Form to Quail Hollow
Robert MacIntyre

a Steady Option at Truist Championship
Jason Day

Looks to Overcome Approach Struggles at Quail Hollow
Akshay Bhatia

Looks for Complete Game at Truist Championship
Mats Zuccarello

Extends Point Streak to Five Games
Emilio Pagán

Emilio Pagan Headed for Injured List With Hamstring Injury
Emilio Pagán

Emilio Pagan Carted Off With Apparent Hamstring Injury on Tuesday
Justin Rose

to Continue Mid-Season Club Change at Truist Championship
Si Woo Kim

is Back to Peak Form Ahead of Truist Championship
Sam Burns

to Bounce Back at Truist Championship
Cameron Young

Looks to Carry Dominance to Quail Hollow
Rory McIlroy

Returns to Familiar Stomping Grounds This Week at Quail Hollow
Chris Gotterup

Looking to Bounce Back at Quail Hollow
MLB

Cardinals-Brewers Game Postponed on Tuesday
Roman Anthony

Day-to-Day With Wrist Sprain
Jacob Misiorowski

"All Things Look Good" for Jacob Misiorowski to Start on Wednesday
Tommy Fleetwood

Looking For Better Iron Play at Quail Hollow
MLB

Rockies-Mets Game Postponed Due to Inclement Weather
CFB

Mario Craver Enters No. 1 Wide Receiver Role for Marcel Reed
CFB

LaNorris Sellers a Strong Rebound Candidate in 2026
CFB

Cam Coleman Poised for Monster Year at Texas?
CFB

Will Hammond Pushing to Be Ready for Week 1
Alex Fitzpatrick

Looking to Keep Up Ball-Striking Output at Quail Hollow
CFB

Notre Dame Leads College Football in Returning Snaps
CFB

Two Ole Miss Football Players Arrested, Charged with DUI
Ben Griffin

Looks Solid on the Surface Heading to Charlotte
Chase Elliott

Earns his Second Texas Motor Speedway Victory
Denny Hamlin

Misses Out on Winning at Texas
Alex Bowman

Finishes Third for the Second Week in a Row at Texas
Tyler Reddick

Earns Seventh Top-Five Finish of the Season at Texas
Chris Buescher

Scores his First Career Texas Finish in the Top Five
CFB

Bryce Underwood in Better Situation Entering Sophomore Season
CFB

Nico Iamaleava Emerging as Leader, Playmaker for UCLA
Jack Della Maddalena

Gets Dominated At UFC Perth
Carlos Prates

Shines At UFC Perth
Beneil Dariush

Suffers A First-Round TKO Loss
Quillan Salkilld

Remains Unbeaten In The UFC
Tim Elliott

Drops Decision At UFC Perth
Steve Erceg

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Ollie Schmid

Suffers First-Round TKO Loss
Marwan Rahiki

Remains Unbeaten
Christopher Bell

Is Christopher Bell Worth Rostering for Texas Lineups?
William Byron

Might have the Speed to Compete for the Win at Texas
Joey Logano

Provides Solid Upside for Texas DFS Lineups
Chase Briscoe

Could Chase Briscoe be A Sneaky Pick for Texas Lineups?
Ty Gibbs

Should DFS Managers Roster Ty Gibbs at Texas?
Daniel Suarez

Is Daniel Suarez Worth Rostering After Career-Best Starting Position at Texas?
Kyle Busch

Is a DFS Risk Starting in the Top 10 at Texas
Tyler Reddick

One of the Favorites to Win at Texas
Chase Elliott

Could Contend for Another Win at Texas
Carson Hocevar

on Pole at Texas
NASCAR

Bubba Wallace Wrecks in Practice at Texas
Chris Buescher

Looking to Continue Strong Run at Texas
Austin Dillon

Blows Engine in Practice at Texas
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF