Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

3 Starting Pitcher Busts for 2024 Fantasy Baseball Drafts - AL Edition

Dylan Cease - Fantasy Baseball Rankings, MLB Injury News, DFS and Betting Picks

Sleepers and breakout candidates are popular topics as fantasy baseball managers prepare for their drafts. Hitting big on a player in the middle-to-late rounds can go a long way toward winning a title.

Another key to winning a league might be avoiding players who could potentially bust. Missing on a player who is drafted inside the top 125 can have a significant impact on a roster.

With that in mind, let’s highlight three American League pitchers who could be busts for the 2024 campaign.

Be sure to check all of our preseason fantasy baseball rankings for Roto, Points, H2H, dynasty, best ball, prospects and more:


Dylan Cease, Chicago White Sox

Cease was one of the best pitchers in baseball in 2022. He finished with a 2.20 ERA, 1.11 WHIP, and a 30.4 percent strikeout rate across 32 starts. He gave up just 0.8 HR/9, which was the lowest mark of his career. Part of that was because he allowed only a 31.2 percent hard-hit rate.

If there was any reason to pause, it’s that Cease’s production in 2022 didn’t match his previous stats, and by a wide margin. Before the campaign, he had never allowed a hard-hit rate below 37.5 percent, had never had a WHIP below 1.25, and had never finished with an ERA below 3.91. While his FIP wasn’t bad at 3.10, it was significantly higher than his 2.20 ERA.

Last season, Cease took a significant step backward. His hard-hit rate jumped up to 41.6 percent, while his WHIP finished at 1.42. That left him with a 4.58 ERA, although his FIP wasn’t quite as bad at 3.72.

With the White Sox diving into a rebuild, there were rumors that they might be willing to move Cease during the offseason. However, with them seeking a hefty return, he has yet to change teams. While he will likely begin the season on the White Sox, he could ultimately be moved by the trade deadline.

Cease currently has an ADP of 101 on Yahoo. The projection systems are forecasting that he finishes closer to his 2023 stats than his 2022 ones. ATC has him projected to finish with a 4.03 ERA, 4.04 FIP, and a 1.30 WHIP. THE BAT has him projected to compile a 4.24 ERA, 4.18 FIP, and a 1.31 WHIP. Despite him being a good source for strikeouts, his deficiencies elsewhere could deal a blow to fantasy managers who select him so high.


Justin Verlander, Houston Astros

Verlander left the Astros before last season to join the Mets. It was the first time that he pitched in the National League during his illustrious career, but he had championship aspirations again with the Mets loading up on top talent. However, injuries and underperformance by some of their key players turned the Mets into sellers by the time the trade deadline arrived.

The Mets were quick to move on from Verlander, shipping him back to the Astros. He would conclude the season with 27 total starts, registering a 3.22 ERA, 3.85 FIP, and a 1.13 WHIP.

As good as those numbers were, there are plenty of areas to be concerned with for Verlander. His strikeout rate fell to 21.5 percent, which was his lowest mark since the 2015 season. His whiff rate was only 22.5 percent, while his hard-hit rate allowed ballooned to 41.3 percent.

Verlander will enter the season at 41 years old, so expecting him to produce like he did in his prime is not reasonable. The question is, does what he have left in the tank warrant his Yahoo ADP of 114? The Astros do have quality depth in terms of starting pitchers, so they don’t need to push Verlander to log 200 innings. They also have championship aspirations again, so it will be important for them to have Verlander healthy by the time the playoffs roll around.

Most projection systems have Verlander taking a significant step back this season. ATC has him projected for a 3.92 ERA, 1.19 WHIP, and a 22.6 percent strikeout rate. Steamer has him projected to finish with a 4.22 ERA, 1.22 WHIP, and a 22.4 percent strikeout rate. That lack of strikeouts would severely limit his upside in fantasy.


Chris Bassitt, Toronto Blue Jays

The Blue Jays added Bassitt prior to last season to help bolster their starting rotation. He finished 2023 with a 3.60 ERA, marking his sixth straight season with an ERA of 3.81 or lower. He also logged 200 innings, marking his third straight campaign with at least 27 starts.

There were still some stats to be concerned about with Bassitt last season. His 4.28 FIP wasn’t as impressive as his final ERA. In terms of avoiding contact, he only had a 21.9 percent whiff rate and a 22.5 percent strikeout rate. His 8.3 percent barrel rate allowed was also the second-highest mark of his career.

Bassitt has spent most of his career with the Athletics, who have a pitcher-friendly home park. That’s part of why it wasn’t surprising to see him give up more home runs with the Blue Jays. His 1.3 HR/9 allowed broke a streak of three straight seasons in which he allowed fewer than one home run per nine innings.

Bassitt has an ADP of 117 on Yahoo. However, ATC, Steamer, and THE BAT all have him projected to finish with an ERA of at least 4.00 and a strikeout rate below 22.0 percent. They all also have him finishing with a WHIP of 1.22 or higher. None of those stats are particularly helpful to fantasy managers.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!

More Fantasy Baseball Advice


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts


Vince Dunn8 mins ago

Exits Monday's Game With Undisclosed Injury
Dylan Larkin14 mins ago

Ruled Out For Two Weeks
Josh Okogie30 mins ago

Unavailable On Tuesday
Nassir Little42 mins ago

Will Continue To Sit On Tuesday
Maxi Kleber47 mins ago

Questionable For Tuesday's Game
Derrick Jones58 mins ago

Jr. On The Injury Report With Shoulder Issue
Aaron Nesmith1 hour ago

Listed As Questionable Versus Dallas
Quentin Grimes1 hour ago

Doubtful For Tuesday's Game
Nick Richards1 hour ago

Could Sit Out Another Game On Tuesday
Markelle Fultz9 hours ago

Questionable Versus Hornets Tuesday
PGA10 hours ago

Stephen Jaeger Misses First Cut In 2024
Anthony Davis10 hours ago

Available Monday
LeBron James10 hours ago

Cleared For Monday Against Oklahoma City
Shane Lowry11 hours ago

Falls Short At Cognizant Classic
Seth Curry11 hours ago

Slated To Miss Tuesday's Game Against Orlando
Si Woo Kim11 hours ago

Off To Hot Start
Russell Henley11 hours ago

Playing Well Heading To Bay Bill
Cody Martin11 hours ago

Won't Play Tuesday Versus Orlando
Luka Doncic12 hours ago

Questionable Again For Tuesday
Hideki Matsuyama12 hours ago

Returns To Action
Jusuf Nurkic12 hours ago

Back On The Injury Report
Kentavious Caldwell-Pope12 hours ago

Set To Return On Tuesday
Alex Caruso12 hours ago

Will Play On Monday
De'Aaron Fox12 hours ago

Available Versus Bulls
Isaac Okoro12 hours ago

Iffy For Tuesday
Caris LeVert13 hours ago

Questionable For Meeting With Boston
J.J. McCarthy13 hours ago

A Top-10 Pick?
Max Strus13 hours ago

Missing First Game Of The Season Tuesday
Victor Wembanyama13 hours ago

Questionable For Tuesday
Kenny Pickett13 hours ago

Could Get Another Shot As Starting QB
Carolina Panthers13 hours ago

Panthers Expected To Trade Or Release Donte Jackson
Miami Dolphins13 hours ago

Dolphins Won't Franchise Tag Christian Wilkins
Dak Prescott13 hours ago

"Confident" In A New Deal
Cedric Mullins14 hours ago

' Injury Isn't Serious
Sonny Gray15 hours ago

Heading For MRI Exam
Joe Burrow16 hours ago

Expects To Be Fully Cleared In May
Russell Wilson17 hours ago

Broncos Inform Russell Wilson Of Release
Kansas City Chiefs17 hours ago

Chiefs Officially Place Franchise Tag On L'Jarius Sneed
Ricky Tiedemann18 hours ago

Faces Hitters Sunday
Sonny Gray18 hours ago

Exits With Hamstring Tightness Monday
Cedric Mullins18 hours ago

Exits With Hamstring Discomfort
Philadelphia Eagles19 hours ago

Jason Kelce Officially Retires
Kirk Cousins19 hours ago

Commanders An Option For Kirk Cousins?
Kendrick Bourne19 hours ago

Patriots Make Offer To Kendrick Bourne
Mike Evans19 hours ago

Buccaneers Sign Mike Evans To Two-Year Extension
Jose Quintana20 hours ago

Looks Like Opening Day Starter
Matt McLain20 hours ago

Could Make Spring Debut This Week
Jairzinho Rozenstruik20 hours ago

Returns To Win Column
Shamil Gaziev20 hours ago

Takes TKO Loss Saturday
Bekzat Almakhan20 hours ago

Suffers Unanimous-Decision Loss In UFC Debut
Matt Schnell21 hours ago

Suffers Knockout Loss At UFC Vegas 87
Tommy Edman21 hours ago

Growing Concern About Tommy Edman
David Bednar21 hours ago

Hopes To Be Back Soon
Steve Erceg21 hours ago

Scores Second-Round Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 87
Gunnar Henderson21 hours ago

Will Make Spring Debut Monday
Kirill Kaprizov22 hours ago

Scores Third Hat Trick Of Season
Ross Chastain22 hours ago

Earns Fourth Top-Five Finish In Last Five Trips To Vegas
Filip Hronek22 hours ago

Reaches 40-Assist Mark In Sunday's Win
Vladislav Namestnikov23 hours ago

Collects Two Points In Top-Six Role
Martin Truex Jr23 hours ago

. Collects His Seventh Consecutive Las Vegas Top 10 Finish
Tyler Reddick23 hours ago

Falls Short Of Vegas Victory Despite Great Run
Kevin Gausman23 hours ago

Dealing With Shoulder Fatigue
William Byron23 hours ago

Despite Car Overheating, William Byron Finishes In Top 10
Phillip Danault23 hours ago

Fires In His Second Hat Trick
Zack Wheeler23 hours ago

Signs Big Extension
Dylan Guenther23 hours ago

Notches Career-High Three Points Sunday
Leon Draisaitl23 hours ago

Picks Up Three Assists In Sunday's Win
Kyle Larson1 day ago

Dominates Again at Las Vegas
NASCAR1 day ago

Pit Problems Ruin Bubba Wallace's Day at Las Vegas
Carson Hocevar1 day ago

Fights Through Adversity for 15th at Las Vegas
Corey Lajoie1 day ago

Makes Statement at Las Vegas Despite Poor Finish
Noah Gragson1 day ago

Shines at Las Vegas, Posts Career-Best Finish
Ty Gibbs1 day ago

Circles Back For Fifth In Vegas
Ryan Blaney1 day ago

Settles For Third In Las Vegas
Joey Logano1 day ago

Uninspiring Run Proves Ford Speed Deficit
Denny Hamlin1 day ago

Recovers from Subpar Qualifying Run at Las Vegas
Kent Johnson2 days ago

Ruled Out For Rest Of Season
Evgeny Kuznetsov2 days ago

Assigned To AHL After Clearing Waivers
Derek Ryan2 days ago

Won't Play On Sunday
Cole Perfetti2 days ago

Back In Winnipeg Lineup Versus Buffalo
Brenden Dillon2 days ago

Returns To Jets Lineup Sunday
Marcus Johansson2 days ago

Questionable For Sunday
Tampa Bay Buccaneers2 days ago

Antoine Winfield Jr. Expected To Receive Franchise Tag
Dak Prescott2 days ago

Not A Lock To Receive Extension From Cowboys?
Baker Mayfield2 days ago

Patriots Could Be In Play For Baker Mayfield
Kirk Cousins2 days ago

Not Willing To Give Vikings A Discount?
Nick Lodolo2 days ago

To See Specialist On Monday
Alex Verdugo2 days ago

Scratched With Leg Contusion
Justin Verlander2 days ago

Throws Bullpen Session
Gunnar Henderson2 days ago

Expected To Play In Spring Game Monday
Josh Jung2 days ago

Doing "Baseball Activities"
Ronald Acuña Jr.2 days ago

Braves GM “Highly Confident” Ronald Acuna Jr. Will Be Ready
Kyle Larson2 days ago

the Heavy Favorite to Win at Las Vegas
William Byron2 days ago

Super Fast Once Again at Las Vegas
Kyle Busch2 days ago

Has High DFS Upside and Great Track Record at Las Vegas
Martin Truex Jr2 days ago

. A Good DFS Pivot Pick at Las Vegas
Joey Logano2 days ago

Wins Pole at Las Vegas But Has Speed Concerns
Ross Chastain2 days ago

Starts Mid-Pack at Las Vegas But Can Contend
Ryan Blaney2 days ago

Starts 15th, Has Top-10 Potential at Las Vegas
Brad Keselowski2 days ago

Lacks Speed But Has Great Las Vegas Record
Matt McLain2 days ago

Set To Have Live At-Bats
Max Scherzer2 days ago

Could Return In June
Umar Nurmagomedov3 days ago

Overcomes Adversity At UFC Vegas 87
Muhammad Mokaev3 days ago

Gets Decision Win At UFC Vegas 87
Alex Perez3 days ago

Falls Short In Return
Tyson Pedro3 days ago

Retires After UFC Vegas 87 Loss
Vitor Petrino3 days ago

Remains Undefeated
Eury Pérez3 days ago

Eury Perez Suffers Broken Nail Saturday
Justin Fields3 days ago

Raiders In Play For Justin Fields
Kirk Cousins3 days ago

Falcons Interested In Kirk Cousins
San Francisco 49ers3 days ago

Nick Sorensen To Become New 49ers Defensive Coordinator
Dallas Cowboys3 days ago

Tyron Smith Unlikely To Return To Cowboys
Jayden Daniels3 days ago

Malik Nabers Won't Measure At Combine
Travis Konecny3 days ago

To Remain Out On Saturday
Lukas Dostal3 days ago

Sets New Ducks Record With 52 Saves
Dylan Strome3 days ago

Collects Three Points In Friday's Win
Matias Maccelli3 days ago

Extends Scoring Streak With Three-Point Outing
Brady Tkachuk3 days ago

Makes Early Exit Friday
Mason McTavish3 days ago

Sustains Lower-Body Injury Friday
Mats Zuccarello4 days ago

Fined $2K For Unsportsmanlike Conduct
Shamil Gaziev4 days ago

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Jairzinho Rozenstruik4 days ago

In Dire Need Of Victory
Bekzat Almakhan4 days ago

Set For UFC Debut
Matt Schnell4 days ago

Looks To Get Back In Win Column
Steve Erceg4 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 87
Umar Nurmagomedov5 days ago

Takes On Newcomer At UFC Vegas 87
Muhammad Mokaev5 days ago

Puts Undefeated Record On The Line At UFC Vegas 87
Alex Perez5 days ago

Finally Ends Layoff At UFC Vegas 87
Tyson Pedro5 days ago

Set For 11th UFC Appearance
Vitor Petrino5 days ago

A Big Favorite At UFC Vegas 87
Doug Ghim6 days ago

Is On An Impressive Run To Start The Florida Swing
Maverick McNealy6 days ago

Is An Intriguing Play At PGA National
Lucas Glover6 days ago

Far From A Must-Play At PGA National
Erik Van Rooyen6 days ago

Can Erik Van Rooyen Keep His Consistency Going In Florida?
Adam Svensson6 days ago

Needs To Find Some Putting Form In Florida
Beau Hossler6 days ago

Looking To Keep The Good Times Rolling In Florida
Denny McCarthy6 days ago

Looking To Heat Up At PGA National
Taylor Montgomery6 days ago

Putting Together Solid Results
Christiaan Bezuidenhout6 days ago

Arrives To Florida In Stellar Form
Luke List6 days ago

On A Mission To Reverse Past Heartbreak
Matthieu Pavon6 days ago

Looking To Widen His Season-Long Lead
Shane Lowry6 days ago

Leaning On Some Positive Florida Vibes
Ryo Hisatsune6 days ago

Heads To Palm Beach Gardens For Debut
Brendon Todd6 days ago

Takes Hot Putter To PGA National
Ben Griffin6 days ago

Loves The Bermuda Grass
Chris Kirk6 days ago

Looks To Defend Title At Cognizant Classic