X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Preseason Champ or Chump: Shortstop

There are those who will try to convince you SS is amazingly deep this year. Don't buy it. In reality, it is just littered with guys that have ridiculously inflated ADPs based on unsustainable performances in small sample sizes. My best advice on the position is to wait to fill it, kind of like catcher. Ketel Marte, Jean Segura, Wilmer Flores and Alcides Escobar should all approximate the value of the guys below, and all of them have ADPs over 200.

Part of that prediction is liking those guys above, but it is mostly about how much I hate the guys listed below. Regression is foreshadowed by many signs, and I'm pretty sure every single one of them applies to at least one of them. Obviously no champs today, so lets look at some chumps.

Editor's note: Be sure to also check out our 2016 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. Our rankings assistant tool combines all our staff's ranks in one place. You can easily filter and export all sorts of rankings and tiers - mixed leagues, points leagues, AL/NL only, top prospects, dynasty ranks, keeper values, and more.

 

Champ or Chump: Shortstop

Corey Seager (SS, LAD, ADP: 64)

Hello .337/.425/.561 triple slash line, with four homers and two steals in 113 MLB PAs. Hello, unsustainable .387 BABIP. Goodbye, .337/.425/.561 triple slash line with four homers and two steals in 113 MLB PAs.

Kidding aside, if there was ever a poster child for BABIP regression, this is it. Seager's .387 overall BABIP is not inflated by a potentially sustainable LD%, as it stood at just 20.3% last season. He is also not anyone's definition of a speed burner, as evidenced by 10 SBs in 2013 representing his professional best. Yet he somehow managed a .310 BABIP on grounders (average is only .236) and enjoyed an .813 mark on line drives. No way either number repeats.

That would be bad enough for Seager's batting average, but evidence suggests that more strikeouts are coming as well. Seager's excellent 16.8% K% last season was not supported by either a strong SwStr% (11.2%) or elite Contact% (78%). As a result, a K% slightly above the MLB average of 20.4% should be expected going forward. Seager's excellent 12.4% BB% was actually supported by a 29.9% O-Swing%, but his minor league history (6.9% BB% at Triple-A) suggests that this was more luck than skill.

His MLB pace in 2015 suggests the possibility of a 20 HR campaign in 2016. His minor league history could even be seen to support this, as he hit 18 minor league homers last year, 21 in 2014 and 18 in 2013. However, if you dig a little deeper you discover that most of the homers prior to last year came in the low minors, which generally do a poor job of forecasting future performance. Of his 18 minor league dingers last season, 13 came for Oklahoma City in the Pacific Coast League, a league notorious for inflating offensive statistics. His minor league history is therefore inconclusive.

Using his MLB numbers, his 26.6% FB% is nowhere near enough to sustain plus power output. His 19% HR/FB also seems high for a 21 year old middle infielder. At such a tender age, a breakout is certainly possible. However, even some of the greats had to wait a little longer to figure everything out.

With a professional best of just 10 SBs (against four CS), you know Seager should not be expected to be an asset on the basepaths. Blind faith in his age is literally the only reason to believe a huge season is coming, and I do not have enough faith in that to pick him in the sixth round of a standard 12-team draft.

Verdict: Chump

 

Francisco Lindor (SS, CLE, ADP: 73.4)

In many ways Lindor performed better than AL Rookie of the Year Carlos Correa in his 438 PA sample last season, but he failed to win the hardware because nearly everyone expects significant regression. His ADP indicates that most fantasy owners are not expecting enough, however.

Lindor's .313/.353/.482 line was buoyed by a .348 overall BABIP, a number that seems normal only because we looked at Seager first. Once again, Lindor's LD% of 20.6% had nothing to do with the elevated figure. Once again, his .337 BABIP on ground balls doesn't seem sustainable for a player that is not a speed burner.

Wait - isn't he supposed to be a speed guy? While his 12 SB (and two CS) look good in his limited MLB sample, the minor league history tells a different story. He went just 9 for 16 before his callup at Triple-A last year, 3 for 10 in a 180 PA trial at that level in 2014, 25 for 34 at Double-A before that, and an absolutely dreadful 2 for 7 at Rookie ball to start last year. If Lindor performs this poorly in 2016, the Indians will have no choice but to give him a red light.

Lindor's 12 dingers last year seem promising, but once again his minor league history suggests that he just can't deliver consistent power. He connected for only 14 big flies across three levels in 2014, and managed only two in 464 PAs back in 2013. Even in Rookie ball, he hit just six in 567 PAs. If you lack pop in Rookie ball, you're not the 20 HR threat some fantasy owners think Lindor can be.

Using MLB metrics, Lindor's 28.7% FB% does not support a power profile. His 13% HR/FB could be sustainable, but it was almost certainly lower in the minor leagues. Ten homers could very well represent Lindor's 2016 ceiling, with a floor of Ben Revere.

While Lindor's two slot in the order puts him in a favorable position for counting stats, he is not established enough to be able to keep it regardless of performance. He was generally no better than a .280 hitter in the upper minors, has almost no power and can't steal a base. Defensive specialists usually hit ninth in AL orders and provide no fantasy value, and this is the most likely outcome for Lindor in 2016.

Verdict: Chump

 

Addison Russell (2B/SS, CHC, ADP: 138.4)

From one defensive specialist to another, Russell's final line of .242/.307/.389 with 13 HR and four swipes does not look nearly as impressive as the first two players on this list. As a result, his ADP is much later - but still not late enough.

The first problem is a 28.5% K%, a number that is entirely too high to ever post a reasonable batting average. This number is completely supported by a very high 13.7% SwStr% (average is 9.9%) and subpar 71.4% Contact%. His minor league history is better than this (in limited samples), but the adjustment to the majors is the hardest one. Clearly, Russell has some work to do.

Perhaps more troubling is the .324 overall BABIP Russell posted in 2015, indicating that he may have been lucky to hit .242. The biggest outlier in his batted ball profile is a .286 BABIP on ground balls. Russell is not especially fast, but more importantly is extremely prone to pulling his grounders. Last season, he pulled 60.2% of his grounders while sending just 12.8% to the opposite field. This makes him shift bait, and shift bait does not hit .286 on ground balls. Just ask Mark Teixeira. His .193 BABIP on flies also seems unsustainable against the league average of .129.

Fantasy owners could live with the warts if Russell offered strong numbers in the power categories, but he can't be relied on for that either. While his 40.7% FB% indicates that he was trying to hit for power, his 9.8% HR/FB was significantly shy of a power hitter's production. He hit 15 homers over 330 PAs across four levels in 2014, giving him some power upside but also suggesting that 20 would be his high water mark. That might not be enough to overcome his average.

Russell usually hit ninth last year, and Chicago's improvements in the offseason do not figure to give him a better slot in 2016. Not only will the limited PAs hurt his counting stats, he's also dependent on the pitcher's spot doing something to generate R and RBI chances. A 20 HR campaign may fail to break 70 RBI.

Oddly, lefties limited this right-handed bat to just a .156/.233/.294 triple slash line in 2015. Outside of a 21 SB explosion in 2013, speed has never been part of Russell's game. I'm not sure why Russell is being drafted at all, to be honest. He has a lot to prove before he's fantasy relevant.

Verdict: Chump

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Kyle Larson1 hour ago

the Heavy Favorite to Win at Kansas
Denny Hamlin1 hour ago

Looking for Another Win at Kansas
Ross Chastain1 hour ago

Qualifies on the Front Row at Kansas
Martin Truex Jr1 hour ago

a Quiet Contender at Kansas
Ryan Blaney2 hours ago

Has Major Place Differential Upside at Kansas
NASCAR2 hours ago

Bubba Wallace Qualifies 23rd at Kansas But Should Be Better Than That
Alex Bowman2 hours ago

Has Top-10 Potential at Kansas
Carson Hocevar2 hours ago

a Good Value DFS Play at Kansas
Ricky Stenhouse Jr2 hours ago

Has Sleeper Potential at Kansas
Austin Dillon2 hours ago

Always a Sleeper at Kansas
Todd Gilliland2 hours ago

an Interesting DFS Play at Kansas
Josh Berry4 hours ago

Around Middle Of The Pack For Sunday
Joey Logano4 hours ago

Tapered Off Speed Wise At Kansas
NASCAR4 hours ago

Derek Knaus Anchors Rear Of The Field At Kansas
Austin Hill4 hours ago

Not Carrying Much Speed At Kansas
Jimmie Johnson4 hours ago

Tops Legacy Cars In Qualifying
Zane Smith8 hours ago

Fast at Kansas but Unproven in the Cup Series
John Hunter Nemechek8 hours ago

Outqualified by Teammates for Second Straight Week
Justin Haley8 hours ago

Has Improved Rick Ware Racing but They Won't Contend at Kansas
Austin Cindric8 hours ago

Qualifies 7th at Kansas but Consistently Loses Positions in Races
Harrison Burton8 hours ago

Non-Drafting Intermediates Are Harrison Burton's Weakness
Yennier Cano11 hours ago

Notches First Save Of The Season
Steven Kwan11 hours ago

Will Undergo An MRI On Injured Hamstring Sunday
Jarrett Allen11 hours ago

On The Injury Report Again For Sunday
Jamal Murray12 hours ago

Goes Cold In Game 1
Logan O'Hoppe12 hours ago

Removed From Saturday's Game With Hand Contusion
Nikola Jokic12 hours ago

Struggles Shooting On Saturday
Wyatt Langford12 hours ago

Exits Early With Hamstring Tightness
Anthony Edwards12 hours ago

Dominant In Game 1
Alec Bohm12 hours ago

Removed From Saturday's Game With Hip Tightness
Maxi Kleber16 hours ago

Out Indefinitely
Lonzo Ball16 hours ago

Exercises Option For 2024-25
Trea Turner17 hours ago

Out Six Weeks With Hamstring Strain
Alek Manoah19 hours ago

To Start Sunday For Blue Jays
Seiya Suzuki20 hours ago

Could Be Activated In The Coming Week
Cody Bellinger20 hours ago

Could Be Activated Soon
Trea Turner20 hours ago

Placed On 10-Day Injured List
Kevin Kiermaier20 hours ago

Activated From Injured List
Dylan Carlson21 hours ago

With The Cardinals On Saturday
Bryan Ramos21 hours ago

White Sox Call Up Bryan Ramos
Cody Bellinger22 hours ago

Seiya Suzuki, Cody Bellinger Working Out On Saturday
Gerrit Cole22 hours ago

Throws Successful Bullpen Session
Jose Altuve1 day ago

Records 300th Career Stolen Base
Jacob Young1 day ago

Leaves With Back Spasms Friday
Brett Baty1 day ago

Erupts With Two Long Balls
Cal Quantrill1 day ago

Silences Pirates For First Win
Drew Rasmussen1 day ago

Jeffrey Springs, Drew Rasmussen Set For Extended Spring Games
George Kirby1 day ago

Dealing With Knee Issue
Evan Mobley1 day ago

Fizzles Offensively In Game 6
Darius Garland1 day ago

Plays Well On Friday Night
Donovan Mitchell1 day ago

Explodes Offensively In Game 6
NYI2 days ago

Lou Lamoriello, Patrick Roy To Return Next Season
Mason Marchment2 days ago

A No-Go For Friday
Terance Mann2 days ago

Active At Shootaround
Arturs Silovs2 days ago

Expected To Go Again Friday
Adin Hill2 days ago

Back In Goal Friday
Los Angeles Lakers2 days ago

Darvin Ham Dismissed As Lakers Head Coach
Auston Matthews2 days ago

Uncertain For Game 7
Aaron Rodgers2 days ago

No Restrictions For Aaron Rodgers During Offseason Workouts
Mac Jones2 days ago

Jaguars Don't Pick Up Mac Jones' Fifth-Year Option
Jayden Daniels2 days ago

Has A Chance To Start Immediately
Chase Claypool2 days ago

Bills Sign Chase Claypool
Steve Erceg2 days ago

Has A Chance To Become A Champion
Alexandre Pantoja2 days ago

Looks To Defend Flyweight Title
Jarrett Allen2 days ago

Spotted At Shootaround On Friday
Gary Harris2 days ago

Remains Game-Time Decision
Josh Hart2 days ago

Shines Again In Game 6 Victory
Michel Pereira2 days ago

Ihor Potieria Faces Michel Pereira On UFC 301
Joel Embiid2 days ago

Fouls Out With Big Stat Line In Losing Effort
Odell Beckham Jr.2 days ago

Signing One-Year Deal With Dolphins
Michel Pereira2 days ago

Looks To Extend Win Streak To Eight
Paul Craig2 days ago

Looking To Rebound At UFC 301
Jalen Brunson2 days ago

Leads Knicks To Series Win Over 76ers
DJ Chark Jr.2 days ago

Signs With Chargers
Kadarius Toney2 days ago

Chiefs Decline Kadarius Toney's Fifth-Year Option
Khris Middleton3 days ago

Can't Lift Milwaukee To A Win
Damian Lillard3 days ago

Plays Well In Return
Jarrett Allen3 days ago

Officially Questionable For Friday
Tim Hardaway3 days ago

Jr. Still Out For Game 6
Terance Mann3 days ago

On The Injury Report For Game 6
Steven Stamkos3 days ago

Begins Contract Talks With Lightning
Brett Pesce3 days ago

A Potential Option For Round 2
Sam Bennett3 days ago

Should Be Good For Round 2
Adam Fox3 days ago

Doesn't Skate Again On Thursday
Luke Schenn3 days ago

Hopeful For Game 6
Auston Matthews3 days ago

Out For Game 6
Justin Fields3 days ago

Steelers Decline Fifth-Year Option On Justin Fields
Najee Harris3 days ago

Fifth-Year Option On Najee Harris Declined By Steelers
JuJu Smith-Schuster3 days ago

Could Be On His Way Out
Khalil Herbert3 days ago

A Trade Candidate?
T.J. Hockenson3 days ago

Ahead Of Schedule In His Rehab
Nick Chubb3 days ago

"Progressing Nicely"
Caio Borralho3 days ago

Gets Ranked Opponent At UFC 301
Vitor Petrino3 days ago

Puts Undefeated Record On The Line At UFC 301
Anthony Smith3 days ago

A Massive Underdog At UFC 301
Jonathan Martinez3 days ago

Faces A Legend At UFC 301
Jose Aldo3 days ago

Returns At UFC 301
New York Giants3 days ago

Giants Could Sign A Veteran Running Back
Dallas Cowboys3 days ago

Trevon Diggs Expected To Be Ready For Training Camp
Daniel Jones4 days ago

Has Been Cutting, Plans To Be Ready For Camp
Malik Nabers4 days ago

To Be No. 1 Receiver Immediately
Trey Lance4 days ago

Cowboys To Decline Trey Lance's Fifth-Year Option
Tyler Boyd4 days ago

To Meet With Chargers, Titans
Jonathon Brooks4 days ago

On Track For Training Camp
Zach Wilson4 days ago

Broncos Not Picking Up Zach Wilson's Fifth-Year Option
Taylor Pendrith4 days ago

A Volatile Option For CJ Cup
Seamus Power4 days ago

Rounding Into Form Ahead of CJ Cup
Davis Thompson4 days ago

A Player To Watch At CJ Cup
Aaron Rai4 days ago

Lacks Upside At TPC Craig Ranch
Min Woo Lee4 days ago

A Dangerous Pick For CJ Cup
Tom Hoge4 days ago

Seeking Second Tour Victory At CJ Cup
Filip Forsberg4 days ago

Collects Two Apples In Game 5 Win
Juuse Saros4 days ago

Comes Through For Predators In Game 5
Nathan MacKinnon4 days ago

Posts Two More Points In Series-Clinching Win
Mikko Rantanen4 days ago

Helps Finish Off Jets With Three Points
Joseph Woll4 days ago

Excellent In Series-Saving Win
Matthew Knies4 days ago

Bangs In Overtime Winner In Game 5
Evgeny Kuznetsov4 days ago

Posts Goal And Assist In Game 5
Seth Jarvis4 days ago

Puts Up Three Points In Series-Winning Game
Mark Hubbard4 days ago

Will Return To Mediocrity At TPC Craig Ranch
Doug Ghim4 days ago

Putting History In Texas Makes Him A Hard Sell
Nate Lashley4 days ago

Looking To Rebound At Byron Nelson
Kevin Yu5 days ago

A Flier Pick With Likeable Upside At Byron Nelson
Andrew Novak5 days ago

Playing Well Heading To TPC Craig Ranch
Patrick Rodgers5 days ago

Withdraws From CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Luke List5 days ago

In Solid Form Heading To TPC Craig Ranch
Tom Kim5 days ago

A Safe Option With A Questionable Ceiling At Byron Nelson
Taylor Montgomery5 days ago

Searching For Form At TPC Craig Ranch
Jason Day5 days ago

To Defend Title At TPC Craig Ranch
Adam Scott5 days ago

Returns To Action At TPC Craig Ranch
PGA5 days ago

Sungjae Im As Good Of A Pick As Any At TPC Craig Ranch
PGA5 days ago

Alex Noren Looks To Take Another Step At TPC Craig Ranch
Mackenzie Hughes5 days ago

Brings Hot Putter To TPC Craig Ranch
Cole Perfetti5 days ago

To Make NHL Postseason Debut Tuesday
Si Woo Kim5 days ago

Trendy Si Woo Kim Heads To Byron Nelson
Connor Hellebuyck5 days ago

Looking To Get Right Tuesday
Matheus Nicolau6 days ago

Knocked Out At UFC Vegas 91
Alex Perez6 days ago

Scores Second-Round Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 91
MMA6 days ago

Ariane Lipski Loses A Decision At UFC Vegas 91
Karine Silva6 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Jonathan Pearce6 days ago

Suffers Decision Loss
David Onama6 days ago

Wins Second Fight In A Row
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
Blake Corum - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, RB, NFL Draft Sleepers

Fantasy Football Rookie Spotlight: Blake Corum

Leading up to the 2024 NFL Draft, the widespread belief was that Jim Harbaugh would draft and reunite with his former Michigan running back Blake Corum. Instead, Harbaugh opted for a different Wolverine, linebacker Junior Colson, in the third round. Corum will at least play in the same stadium as his former mentor. The Rams... Read More


Bo Nix - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Fantasy Football Rookie Spotlight: Bo Nix

The first 12 picks of the 2024 NFL Draft were heavy on the quarterbacks as six players heard their names called. Of those 12, former Oregon Ducks quarterback Bo Nix was the final selected when the Broncos took him at pick 12. Will Bo Nix start for the Broncos in 2024? What is the fantasy... Read More


Odell Beckham Jr. Signs With Miami Dolphins: 2024 Fantasy Football Impact

Early during the day on Friday, Odell Beckham Jr. signed a one-year contract with the Miami Dolphins. Sources say the deal is worth $3 million with incentives that can push Beckham's financial gains to $8.25 million for the 2024 NFL season. The former 12th overall pick in the 2014 NFL Draft has been a bit... Read More


Rome Odunze - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Dynasty Rookie Draft Mock 2024 (Superflex)

Traditionally, quarterbacks go at the top of Superflex dynasty drafts. That is true in startups and rookie-only drafts. However, that rule has faltered over the past two years. The 2022 NFL Draft included zero high-end quarterback prospects, leading to a running back (Breece Hall) landing at 1.01. The next year was different. We had a... Read More


The Fastest Players In The NFL: Who Finished At The Top Last Season?

The 2024 NFL offseason continues to pass by. With several big free agents signing with new teams, exciting rookies being drafted, and training camp just a couple of months away, we're already looking ahead to 2024 Fantasy Football. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into some of the NFL's fastest players using NextGen Stats. Which game-breakers were... Read More


UFL RANKINGS, FANTASY FOOTBALL,

Free UFL Betting Picks - Best Bets, Odds, Predictions for Week 6

What a week of picking outcomes. I went 4-0 on point spreads and 0-4 on over/unders. One thing that we clearly saw in Week 5: the top four teams in the league put a real beat-down on the four worst teams in the league, and the distinction between those two groups in the 2024 UFL... Read More


Frank Gore Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, RB, NFL Draft Sleepers

Fantasy Football Undrafted Running Back Rookie Sleepers

Last month's NFL Draft saw a number of really good players left on the board after the seven rounds were over. Some of those players are likely going to make it onto NFL rosters in 2024 as undrafted free agents. Some notable recent running backs who went undrafted include three players who saw extensive playing... Read More


Ezekiel Elliott - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Fantasy Football Running Back Sleepers, Undervalued for 2024

The calendar has flipped, and that means we are one step closer to fantasy football drafts. It has surely been a wild offseason that featured many star players changing teams, including at the running back position. Players like Saquon Barkley, Josh Jacobs, Aaron Jones, and Tony Pollard all changed teams this offseason. As a result, we could see some ADP changes at the top of... Read More


Michael Penix Jr. - CFB DFS Picks, Daily College Fantasy Football, NFL Draft Rookies

When Should I Pick Michael Penix Jr. In Rookie Drafts? Dynasty Fantasy Football Outlook

The Atlanta Falcons stunned the football world when they selected Michael Penix Jr. with the eighth overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. It was a head-scratching selection considering Atlanta just inked quarterback Kirk Cousins to a four-year, $180 million contract in free agency. Dynasty managers now have to figure out when to select Penix... Read More


UFL RANKINGS, FANTASY FOOTBALL,

UFL Fantasy Football Rankings for Week 6: QB, RB, WR, TE Rankings and Analysis (2024)

Week 5 of UFL action was dominated by the top teams, as all four favorites covered their respective spreads. Birmingham, St. Louis, and Michigan all won in convincing blowouts while delivering some impressive fantasy performances along the way. It might be a lot of the same in Week 6. Birmingham (5-0) takes on Memphis (1-4)... Read More


Quarterback Winners and Losers for 2024 Fantasy Football

With the 2024 NFL Draft officially in the books, we're looking ahead to which Quarterbacks exit the draft as the biggest winners and losers for 2024 Fantasy Football. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into some of the notable changes at the Quarterback position following the 2024 NFL Draft. Which QBs are the biggest winners and losers... Read More


UFL DFS PICKS, FANTASY FOOTBALL, DRAFTKINGS, FANDUEL

UFL DFS Lineup Picks: DraftKings Daily Fantasy Fantasy Advice for Week 6

Welcome to Week 6 of the inaugural UFL season, RotoBallers! We have a fun football weekend on tap, and there are many different routes we can take to construct lineups for DraftKings contests. Adrian Martinez and the Birmingham Stallions will take their 5-0 record on the road against the Memphis Showboats, where they're massive 11.5-point... Read More


Fantasy Football Rookie Sleepers You Must Have In 2024

The 2024 NFL Draft is officially in the books and the RotoBaller staff is already looking ahead to the 2024 season to help our readers get the jump on their competition. RotoBaller analyst LaQuan Jones discusses some of the most intriguing rookie sleepers of the 2024 draft class. Which players should you target in Dynasty... Read More