Andrew Painter - Fantasy Baseball Prospects Waiver Wire Pickups, Stashes (Week 13)

Andrew Painter is a fantasy baseball waiver wire pickup for Week 13 (2025). Target Andrew Painter as a top prospect waiver wire stash for fantasy baseball.

BALLER MOVE: Add in 12+ team leagues

CALL-UP ETA: July

ANALYSIS: It has been a long road back for Painter. MLB Pipeline's No. 5 overall prospect hasn't pitched in many games over the past few years, so it's not a complete surprise to see him struggle a bit on the mound. He allowed four runs across four innings on June 4 and six runs across five frames on June 10. 

Those two rough outings gave Painter a 5.19 ERA across his first 10 starts. The 22-year-old bounced back on June 15, though, throwing five shutout innings with six strikeouts against Triple-A Worcester. That type of performance is why the Phillies were so high on the pitcher coming out of high school. 

Then on June 21, Painter continued to find his footing, tossing five innings of two-run ball wth five punchouts.

There's no doubt that Painter will make his MLB debut at some point this season. However, fantasy managers shouldn't expect that to come until after the All-Star break. The Phillies plan to allow their top prospect to get more reps at Triple-A before calling him up sometime in the second half of the season. 

When asked in late May about when we could expect Painter in the big leagues, Phillies manager Rob Thomson said he doesn't think the right-hander will be promoted before the All-Star break. That means fantasy managers could potentially see him in the majors sometime toward the end of July. 

Hard to believe the Phillies won’t have the best rotation in baseball once Andrew Painter arrives in Philadelphia!

His stuff is world-class! pic.twitter.com/pKeLPJcfBA

— Pitch Profiler (@pitchprofiler) May 29, 2025

As a result, he should be stashed in almost all 12-plus team leagues in Week 12 of the fantasy baseball season. Painter is currently the second-best pitching prospect in baseball and has the tools to be a solid fantasy option right away. With his MLB debut possibly a month away, now would be the perfect time to add him. 

- Written by Joey Pollizze

Top Prospect Rankings and 2025 Call-Up ETAs

You can also check out RotoBaller's fantasy baseball prospect rankings for 2025. Eric Cross updates the below rankings weekly for the top impact prospects for 2025, and when they may be called up:

Top Prospect Dynasty Rankings

Looking for longer term fantasy baseball prospect rankings? You can also check out RotoBaller's top dynasty prospect rankings from Eric Cross:

Popular Player Comparison Searches - Who To Pickup?

Below are some popular searches and comparisons from our fantasy baseball Who To Pickup tool for Andrew Painter and others. You can also use the free Who Should I Pickup tool to run your own waiver wire comparisons, up to four players at once:

Roman Anthony or Jac Caglianone
Chase Burns or Jacob Misiorowski
Jurickson Profar or Roman Anthony
Bubba Chandler or Chase Burns
Dillon Dingler or Nick Kurtz
Nick Kurtz or Cam Smith
Miguel Vargas or Otto Kemp
Nick Kurtz or Jac Caglianone
Bubba Chandler or Joe Boyle
Chase Burns or Eury Perez
Cam Smith or Jonathan India
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Colton Cowser
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jo Adell or Christian Encarnacionstrand
Spencer Torkelson or Tyler Soderstrom
Willy Adames or Volpe Temp
Addison Barger or Nate Lowe
Gavin Sheets or Colton Cowser
Jac Caglianone or Cam Smith
Jac Caglianone or Roman Anthony
Jacob Misiorowski or Bubba Chandler
Shelby Miller or Colton Cowser
Addison Barger or Miguel Vargas
Alejandro Kirk or Agustin Ramirez
Brady House or Addison Barger
Chase Burns or Misiorowski Temp
Colton Cowser or Gavin Sheets
Daniel Palencia or Will Vest
Joe Boyle or Chase Burns
Miguel Vargas or Jonathan India
Miguel Vargas or Nick Kurtz
Addison Barger or Jac Caglianone
Andrew Painter or Bubba Chandler
Andrew Painter or Hayden Birdsong
Ben Rice or Christian Encarnacionstrand
Brooks Lee or Carlos Correa
Chandler Simpson or Miguel Vargas
Chandler Simpson or Wenceel Perez
David Bednar or Shelby Miller
Denzel Clarke or Michael Busch
Ernie Clement or Cam Smith
Gavin Sheets or Christian Encarnacionstrand
Ivan Herrera or Drake Baldwin
Jake Burger or Addison Barger
Jeff McNeil or Matt Shaw
Jesus Sanchez or Jake Mangum
Landen Roupp or Jose Berrios
Lane Thomas or Christian Yelich
Nick Kurtz or Michael Busch
Noah Cameron or Cade Horton
Orion Kerkering or Shelby Miller
Shelby Miller or Daniel Palencia
Tommy Kahnle or Dylan Lee
Addison Barger or Jake Mangum
Addison Barger or Michael Busch
Agustin Ramirez or Alejandro Kirk
Andy Pages or Andy Pages
Brady House or Jac Caglianone
Bryce Elder or Joe Boyle
Bubba Chandler or Emmet Sheehan
Bubba Chandler or Jacob Misiorowski
Bubba Chandler or Mclaun Temp
Cade Horton or Hayden Birdsong
Cam Smith or Jesus Sanchez
Cam Smith or Josh Smith
Cam Smith or Luis Rengifo
Cam Smith or Royce Lewis
Camilo Doval or Daniel Palencia
Chase Burns or Max Scherzer
Clayton Kershaw or Trevor Story
Coby Mayo or Chase Meidroth
Daniel Palencia or David Bednar
Daniel Palencia or Shelby Miller
David Bednar or Shelby Miller
David Festa or Andrew Painter
Ernie Clement or Jo Adell
Eury Perez or Chase Burns
Eury Perez or Jacob Misiorowski
Eury Perez or Lance Mccullersjr
Eury Perez or Will Warren
Gavin Sheets or Nolan Schanuel
Gavin Williams or Shane Baz
Giancarlo Stanton or Trevor Larnach
Grant Holmes or Gavin Williams
Hayden Birdsong or Jacob Misiorowski
Jac Caglianone or Addison Barger
Jac Caglianone or Addison Barger
Jac Caglianone or Addison Barger
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jason Adam or Jose Quintana
Javier Baez or Josh Smith
Jonathan Aranda or Jackson Holliday
Jonathan Aranda or Nick Kurtz
Jose Alvarado or Jordan Hicks
Josh Lowe or Addison Barger
Josh Lowe or Colton Cowser
Josh Lowe or Luis Robert
Josh Lowe or Nick Kurtz
Jp Crawford or Nick Kurtz
Jung Hoolee or Yandy Diaz
Jurickson Profar or Masyn Winn
Logan Henderson or Jacob Misiorowski
Matt Shaw or Ernie Clement
Matt Shaw or Jose Caballero
Matt Shaw or Marcelo Mayer
Matt Shaw or Miguel Vargas
Matt Shaw or Ronny Mauricio
Matthew Liberatore or Jack Leiter
Max Muncy or Connor Norby
Michael Harrisii or Roman Anthony
Mick Abel or Bubba Chandler
Mick Abel or Shane Smith
Mick Abel or Will Warren
Miguel Vargas or Addison Barger
Miguel Vargas or Nick Kurtz
Nick Kurtz or Abraham Toro
Nick Kurtz or Jp Crawford
Nick Kurtz or Samuel Basallo
Noah Cameron or Ben Brown
Noah Cameron or Ben Brown
Noah Cameron or Mick Abel
Quinn Mathews or Bubba Chandler
Sal Frelick or Royce Lewis
Shelby Miller or Colton Cowser
Shelby Miller or Daniel Palencia
Trevor Story or Evan Carter
Victor Scottii or Cam Smith
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Will Vest or Tommy Kahnle
Wilmer Flores or Michael Busch
Zebby Matthews or Jacob Misiorowski
Abner Uribe or Jason Adam
Abraham Toro or Nick Kurtz
Abraham Toro or Tyler Freeman
Abraham Toro or Tyler Freeman
Addison Barger or Ben Rice
Addison Barger or Brady House
Addison Barger or Brady House
Addison Barger or Christian Encarnacion
Addison Barger or Evan Carter
Addison Barger or Jo Adell
Addison Barger or Marcelo Mayer
Addison Barger or Max Muncy
Addison Barger or Miguel Vargas
Addison Barger or Ryan McMahon
Addison Barger or Sal Frelick
Addison Barger or Shelby Miller
Agustin Ramirez or Miguel Vargas
Agustin Ramirez or TJ Friedl
Alec Burleson or Cam Smith
Alec Burleson or Evan Carter
Alec Burleson or Gavin Sheets
Alec Burleson or Jurickson Profar
Austin Hays or Christian Encarnacion
Ben Brown or Hayden Birdsong
Ben Rice or Addison Barger
Ben Rice or Spencer Torkelson
Bowden Francis or Seth Halvorsen
Brady House or Jacob Misiorowski
Brandon Nimmo or Harris Ii
Brandon Nimmo or Michael Harris
Brandon Walter or Cam Smith
Brandon Walter or Hunter Dobbins
Brandon Walter or Kikuchi Temp
Brandon Walter or Luis Castillo
Brandon Walter or Ronny Mauricio
Brayan Bello or Jacob Misiorowski
Brayan Bello or Shane Smith
Brooks Lee or Willi Castro
Bryce Elder or Joe Boyle
Bubba Chandler or Andrew Painter
Bubba Chandler or Andrew Painter
Bubba Chandler or Emmet Sheehan
Bubba Chandler or Eury Perez
Bubba Chandler or Jacob Misiorowski
Bubba Chandler or Joe Boyle
Bubba Chandler or Logan Henderson
Bubba Chandler or Mick Abel
Bubba Chandler or Mitch Keller
Cade Horton or Jacob Lopez
Cade Horton or Joe Boyle
Calvin Faucher or Randy Rodriguez
Calvin Faucher or Tommy Kahnle
Cam Smith or Addison Barger
Cam Smith or Aranda Temp
Cam Smith or Jonathan Aranda
Cam Smith or Jordan Westburg
Cam Smith or Maikel Garcia
Cam Smith or Marcelo Mayer
Cam Smith or Westburg Temp
Camilo Doval or Daniel Palencia
Camilo Doval or Will Vest
Casey Schmitt or Mckinstry Temp
Ceddanne Rafaela or Correa Temp
Ceddanne Rafaela or Ernie Clement
Chad Patrick or Dustin May
Chandler Simpson or Jordan Beck
Chandler Simpson or Jordan Lawlar
Chase Burns or Bubba Chandler
Chase Burns or Bubba Chandler
Chase Burns or Eury Perez
Chase Burns or Joe Boyle
Chase Burns or Luis Severino
Chase Meidroth or Matt Shaw
Chase Meidroth or Tyler Fitzgerald
Christian Encarnacion or Strand Christian
Christian Encarnacion or Strand Jac
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Ben Rice
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Evan Carter
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Jo Adell
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Jo Adell
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Miguel Vargas
Colin Rea or Eury Perez
Colt Keith or Willi Castro
Colton Cowser or Cam Smith
Colton Cowser or Jesus Sanchez
Colton Cowser or Josh Lowe
Colton Cowser or Springer Temp
Daniel Palencia or Justin Martinez
Daniel Palencia or Luke Weaver
David Bednar or Greg Weissert
David Bednar or Jac Caglianone
Denzel Clarke or Cole Young
Dillon Dingler or Joey Bart
Drake Baldwin or Tyler Stephenson
Dylan Lee or Greg Weissert
Dylan Lee or Iglesias Temp
Ernie Clement or Casey Schmitt
Ernie Clement or Trevor Story
Eury Perez or Bubba Chandler
Eury Perez or Daniel Palencia
Eury Perez or Josh Lowe
Eury Perez or Will Warren
Eury Perez or Will Warren
Evan Carter or Adolis Garcia
Evan Carter or Bubba Chandler
Evan Carter or Cam Smith
Evan Carter or Giancarlo Stanton
Evan Carter or Nick Kurtz
Garrett Whitlock or Orion Kerkering
Gavin Sheets or Tyler Soderstrom
Gavin Sheets or Wilmer Flores
Geraldo Perdomo or Bichette Temp
Giancarlo Stanton or Addison Barger
Giancarlo Stanton or Jac Caglianone
Grant Holmes or Will Warren
Greg Weissert or Daniel Palencia
Greg Weissert or Tommy Kahnle
Hayden Birdsong or Cade Horton
Hayden Birdsong or Cade Horton
Hyeseong Kim or Jordan Beck
Jac Caglianone or Alec Burleson
Jac Caglianone or Chandler Simpson
Jac Caglianone or Jake Mangum
Jac Caglianone or Josh Lowe
Jac Caglianone or Kyle Manzardo
Jac Caglianone or Matt Shaw
Jac Caglianone or Michael Busch
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jac Caglianone or Nick Kurtz
Jac Caglianone or Will Warren
Jackson Jobe or Brayan Bello
Jacob Lopez or Brandon Walter
Jacob Misiorowski or Brady House
Jacob Misiorowski or Brady House
Jacob Misiorowski or Matt Shaw
Jacob Misiorowski or Shelby Miller
Jacob Misiorowski or Shelby Miller
Jacob Misiorowski or Will Warren
Jacob Misiorowski or Will Warren
Jake Burger or Cam Smith
Jake Cronenworth or Yandy Diaz
Jake Irvin or Cade Horton
Jake Mangum or Tyler Fitzgerald
Jake Meyers or Jesus Sanchez
Janson Junk or Charlie Morton
Jason Adam or Jose Soriano
Jason Adam or Orion Kerkering
Javier Baez or Gabriel Arias
Jeff Mcneil or Jo Adell
Jeff Mcneil or Masyn Winn
Jeff Mcneil or Nick Kurtz
Jesus Sanchez or Jake Mangum
Jo Adell or Addison Barger
Jo Adell or Ernie Clement
Jo Adell or Hoskins Temp
Jo Adell or Jake Burger
Jo Adell or R Temp
Jo Adell or Rhys Temp
Jo Adell or Willi Castro
Joe Boyle or Bubba Chandler
Joe Boyle or David Festa
Joe Boyle or Grant Holmes
Jonathan Aranda or Colt Keith
Jonathan Aranda or Jordan Lawlar
Jonathan Aranda or Kyle Manzardo
Jonathan Aranda or Ryan Ohearn
Jonathan Aranda or Spencer Torkelson
Jonathan India or Matt Shaw
Jonathan India or Miguel Vargas
Jordan Beck or Javier Baez
Jordan Beck or Matt Wallner
Jordan Beck or Trevor Larnach
Jose Caballero or Nick Kurtz
Jose Soriano or Lucas Giolito
Josh Lowe or Austin Hayes
Josh Lowe or Gavin Sheets
Josh Lowe or Marcelo Mayer
Josh Lowe or Matt Wallner
Jurickson Profar or Jake Mangum
Jurickson Profar or Jake Mangum
Jurickson Profar or Jo Adell
Jurickson Profar or Marcelo Mayer
Kyle Manzardo or Nick Kurtz
Kyle Stowers or Javier Baez
Kyle Stowers or Jonathan Aranda
Kyle Teel or Drake Baldwin
Kyle Teel or Drake Baldwin
Kyle Teel or Marcelo Mayer
Kyle Teel or Samuel Basallo
Lance Mccullersjr or Royce Lewis
Landen Roupp or Jose Berrios&Scrlybrkr=5C2B0Bb0
Lucas Giolito or Charlie Morton
Lucas Giolito or Ranger Suarez
Lucas Giolito or Shane Smith
Lucas Giolito or Zach Littell
Luis Severino or Max Scherzer
Marcelo Mayer or Addison Barger
Marcelo Mayer or Brady House
Marcelo Mayer or Chase Meidroth
Marcelo Mayer or Jurickson Profar
Marcelo Mayer or Will Benson
Masyn Winn or David Bednar
Masyn Winn or Jp Crawford
Masyn Winn or Nick Kurtz
Matt Brash or Daniel Palencia
Matt Shaw or Addison Barger
Matt Shaw or Jo Adell
Matt Shaw or Jordan Beck
Matt Wallner or Jordan Beck
Matthew Liberatore or Hayden Birdsong
Max Muncy or Addison Barger
Max Muncy or Ernie Clement
Max Muncy or Javier Baez
Max Muncy or Lamahieu Temp
Max Muncy or Miguel Vargas
Michael Busch or Alec Burleson
Michael Busch or Nick Kurtz
Michael Busch or Nick Kurtz
Michael Busch or Nolan Schanuel
Michael Harrisii or Trent Grisham
Mick Abel or Noah Cameron
Mick Abel or Noah Cameron
Mick Abel or Noah Cameron
Mick Abel or Shane Smith
Mick Abel or Will Warren
Mickey Moniak or Carpenter Temp
Miguel Vargas or Brooks Lee
Miguel Vargas or Gavin Sheets
Miguel Vargas or Jesus Sanchez
Miguel Vargas or Jordan Beck
Miguel Vargas or Otto Kemp
Miguel Vargas or Sal Frelick
Nick Kurtz or Ben Rice
Nick Kurtz or Cam Smith
Nick Kurtz or Christian Encarnacionstrand
Nick Kurtz or Eury Perez
Nick Kurtz or Evan Carter
Nick Kurtz or Kyle Manzardo
Nick Kurtz or Luis Robert
Nick Kurtz or Mick Abel
Nick Kurtz or Spencer Torkelson
Nick Kurtz or Wilmer Flores
Noah Cameron or Bubba Chandler
Noah Cameron or David Festa
Noah Cameron or David Festa
Noah Cameron or Shane Smith
Orion Kerkering or Trevor Story
Otto Kemp or Brooks Lee
Pavin Smith or Zac Veen
Rhys Hoskins or Nolan Schanuel
Robert Garcia or Calvin Faucher
Roman Anthony or Andy Pages
Ronny Mauricio or Luis Arrez
Royce Lewis or Sal Frelick
Ryan Mcmahon or Brady House
Ryan Ohearn or Camilo Doval
Ryan Ritter or Otto Kemp
Ryan Weathers or Kumar Rocker
Sal Frelick or Josh Lowe
Sal Frelick or Jung Holee
Samuel Basallo or Nick Kurtz
Seiya Suzuki or Mickey Moniak
Shane Smith or Hayden Birdsong
Shane Smith or Sawyer Gipsonlong
Shelby Miller or Addison Barger
Tommy Kahnle or Calvin Faucher
Tommy Kahnle or Luke Weaver
Trevor Larnach or Christian Encarnacionstrand
Trevor Larnach or Jake Mangum
Trevor Story or Geraldo Perdomo
Ty France or Abraham Temp
Tyler Freeman or Casey Schmitt
Tyler Freeman or Colton Cowser
Victor Scottii or Byron Buxton
Victor Scottii or Jasson Dominguez
Victor Scottii or Jordan Walker
Victor Scottii or Josh Lowe
Will Vest or Tommy Kahnle
Will Warren or Eury Perez
Will Warren or Lucas Giolito
Will Warren or Michael Wacha
Willi Castro or Addison Barger
Willi Castro or Brooks Lee
Willi Castro or Jackson Holliday
Willi Castro or Nolan Temp
Wilmer Flores or Gavin Sheets
Wilyer Abreu or Jurickson Profar
Zach McKinstry or Jake Meyer
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Kyle Teel or Drake Baldwin
Shelby Miller or Ryan Pressley
Trevor Story or Evan Carter

More Fantasy Baseball Advice