Andrew Painter - Fantasy Baseball Prospects Waiver Wire Stashes (Week 10)

June 3, 2025

Andrew Painter is a fantasy baseball waiver wire stash for Week 10 (2025). Target Andrew Painter as a top prospect free-agent waiver wire pickup for fantasy baseball.

BALLER MOVE: Add in 12+ team leagues

CALL-UP ETA: June

ANALYSIS: Philadelphia Phillies right-handed pitching prospect Andrew Painter should be viewed as a high-priority stash entering Week 10. Painter is nearing the completion of his buildup. He underwent Tommy John surgery in July 2023 and was slowly increasing his workload this season. He did not pitch in spring training and opened the campaign with Low-A before getting the call to Triple-A.

However, this past week, Painter made his fourth start with Triple-A and could be fastly approaching his MLB debut. Earlier in the season with Low-A, Painter held a 3.97 ERA with a 0.97 WHIP across 11 1/3 innings of work.

In his most recent outing at Triple-A Lehigh Valley, Painter logged five innings of two-run ball with five punchouts and one walk. This was the second time in his four Triple-A starts in which Painter logged five innings of work. Across 17 total innings at the top level of the minor leagues, the former 13th overall pick has held a 2.65 ERA with a 1.24 WHIP.

Hard to believe the Phillies won’t have the best rotation in baseball once Andrew Painter arrives in Philadelphia!

His stuff is world-class! pic.twitter.com/pKeLPJcfBA

— Pitch Profiler (@pitchprofiler) May 29, 2025

He has struck out 20 batters and allowed seven walks.

During the 2022 season, before his Tommy John surgery, Painter tossed 103 2/3 innings across time at Low-A, High-A, and Double-A. During this season, Painter established himself as one of the top pitching prospects in the sport as he struck out 155 batters and held an incredible 1.56 ERA with a 0.89 WHIP.

Given his elite strikeout upside, he is worth stashing in all 12+ team leagues. When the 22-year-old gets the call, he will likely have a spot in the starting rotation for the remainder of the campaign.

- Written by Andy Smith

Top Prospect Rankings and 2025 Call-Up ETAs

You can also check out RotoBaller's fantasy baseball prospect rankings for 2025. Eric Cross updates the below rankings weekly for the top impact prospects for 2025, and when they may be called up:

Top Prospect Dynasty Rankings

Looking for longer term fantasy baseball prospect rankings? You can also check out RotoBaller's top dynasty prospect rankings from Eric Cross:

Popular Player Comparison Searches - Who To Pickup?

Below are some popular searches and comparisons from our fantasy baseball Who To Pickup tool for Andrew Painter and others. You can also use the free Who Should I Pickup tool to run your own waiver wire comparisons, up to four players at once:

Bubba Chandler or Zebby Matthews
Will Warren or Zebby Matthews
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Chase Meidroth or Matt Shaw
Ben Rice or Jonathan Aranda
Brandon Lowe or Matt Shaw
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Jacob Misiorowski or Zebby Matthews
Jackson Jobe or Bubba Chandler
Matt Shaw or Marcelo Mayer
Zebby Matthews or Jacob Misiorowski
Bubba Chandler or Zebby Matthews
Nick Kurtz or Ben Rice
Colin Rea or Zebby Matthews
Zebby Matthews or Cade Horton
Hayden Birdsong or Bubba Chandler
Hayden Birdsong or Zebby Matthews
Logan Henderson or Zebby Matthews
Jack Leiter or Bubba Chandler
Jasson Dominguez or Jordan Lawlar
Masyn Winn or Jordan Beck
Sandy Alcantara or Roman Anthony
Chandler Simpson or Jonathan Aranda
Grant Holmes or Jack Leiter
Jac Caglianone or Zebby Matthews
Jacob Misiorowski or Bubba Chandler
Kyle Manzardo or Jonathan Aranda
Logan Henderson or Jacob Misiorowski
Michael Busch or Wilmer Flores
Shane Smith or Cade Horton
Zebby Matthews or Jack Leiter
Bubba Chandler or Nick Kurtz
Dillon Dingler or Nick Kurtz
Gunnar Hoglund or Zebby Matthews
Josh Lowe or Jordan Lawlar
Kyle Manzardo or Wilmer Flores
Nick Kurtz or Bubba Chandler
Ryan Weathers or Bubba Chandler
Spencer Torkelson or Wilmer Flores
Andrew Abbott or Cade Horton
Ben Rice or Nick Kurtz
Bubba Chandler or Chandler Simpson
Chandler Simpson or Jordan Beck
Clayton Kershaw or Bubba Chandler
David Festa or Zebby Matthews
Gavin Lux or Marcelo Mayer
Gunnar Hoglund or Bubba Chandler
Gunnar Hoglund or Cade Horton
Jack Leiter or Zebby Matthews
Jack Leiter or Zebby Matthews
Kyle Manzardo or Ben Rice
Kyle Manzardo or Nick Kurtz
Lourdes Gurrieljr or Jordan Beck
Marcelo Mayer or Ben Rice
Nick Kurtz or Roman Anthony
Nick Kurtz or Wilmer Flores
Reese Olson or Bubba Chandler
Spencer Steer or Chandler Simpson
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Chandler Simpson
Austin Hays or Ben Rice
Bubba Chandler or Jacob Misiorowski
Bubba Chandler or Roman Anthony
Camilo Doval or Jordan Beck
Chandler Simpson or Jordan Lawlar
Colin Rea or Zebby Matthews
Colt Keith or Jonathan Aranda
Daulton Varsho or Marcelo Mayer
Grant Holmes or Bubba Chandler
Grant Holmes or Jack Leiter
Hyeseong Kim or Jordan Lawlar
Jac Caglianone or Chandler Simpson
Jack Leiter or Bubba Chandler
Jack Leiter or Jacob Misiorowski
Jonathan Aranda or Jordan Beck
Josh Lowe or Matt Shaw
Marcelo Mayer or Matt Shaw
Masyn Winn or Jordan Lawlar
Max Meyer or Jack Leiter
TJ Friedl or Roman Anthony
Tony Gonsolin or Bubba Chandler
Trey Sweeney or Marcelo Mayer
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Will Benson or Chandler Simpson
Wilmer Flores or Ben Rice
Wilmer Flores or Ben Rice
Wilmer Flores or Nick Kurtz
Agustin Ramirez or Marcelo Mayer
Andy Pages or Roman Anthony
Austin Hays or Marcelo Mayer
Ben Rice or Chandler Simpson
Ben Rice or Jonathan Aranda
Ben Rice or Marcelo Mayer
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Bubba Chandler or Cade Horton
Bubba Chandler or Jack Leiter
Bubba Chandler or Jack Leiter
Bubba Chandler or Jacob Misiorowski
Bubba Chandler or Zebby Matthews
Camilo Doval or Bubba Chandler
Chandler Simpson or Ben Rice
Chandler Simpson or Bubba Chandler
Chase Meidroth or Chandler Simpson
Chase Meidroth or Robert Hasselliii
Drake Baldwin or Moises Ballesteros
Gavin Sheets or Jonathan Aranda
Gavin Sheets or Marcelo Mayer
Grant Holmes or Cade Horton
Gunnar Hoglund or Jack Leiter
Hayden Birdsong or Cade Horton
Hayden Birdsong or Cade Horton
Hyeseong Kim or Jordan Beck
Ivan Herrera or Matt Shaw
Ivan Herrera or Zebby Matthews
Jac Caglianone or Matt Shaw
Jac Caglianone or Roman Anthony
Jacob Misiorowski or Cade Horton
Jake Cronenworth or Chandler Simpson
Jake Cronenworth or Jonathan Aranda
Jake Meyers or Zebby Matthews
Joe Boyle or Bubba Chandler
Jonathan Aranda or Ben Rice
Jonathan Aranda or Bubba Chandler
Jonathan Aranda or Wilmer Flores
Justin Martinez or Wilmer Flores
Kyle Stowers or Jonathan Aranda
Logan Henderson or Cade Horton
Logan Henderson or Zebby Matthews
Logan Henderson or Zebby Matthews
Marcelo Mayer or Ben Rice
Marcelo Mayer or Nick Kurtz
Marcelo Mayer or Wilmer Flores
Marcelo Mayer or Wilmer Flores
Marcelo Mayer or Wilmer Flores
Masyn Winn or Chandler Simpson
Masyn Winn or Jordan Beck
Matt Shaw or Jordan Beck
Matthew Liberatore or Cade Horton
Max Meyer or Jack Leiter
Mitchell Parker or Bubba Chandler
Nick Kurtz or Bubba Chandler
Noah Cameron or Bubba Chandler
Porter Hodge or Jordan Lawlar
Roman Anthony or Bubba Chandler
Roman Anthony or Nick Kurtz
Roman Anthony or Zebby Matthews
Ronny Henriquez or Chandler Simpson
Ryan Ohearn or Jonathan Aranda
Ryan Weathers or Bubba Chandler
Ryan Weathers or Cade Horton
Ryan Weathers or Nick Kurtz
Spencer Torkelson or Wilmer Flores
Trent Grisham or Nick Kurtz
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Will Benson or Marcelo Mayer
Will Warren or Zebby Matthews
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Zebby Matthews or Cade Horton
Zebby Matthews or Jacob Misiorowski
Zebby Matthews or Jacob Misiorowski
Zebby Matthews or Jonathan Aranda
Zebby Matthews or Jonathan Aranda
Zebby Matthews or Matt Shaw
Zebby Matthews or Nick Kurtz
Matthew Liberatore or Jack Leiter

More Fantasy Baseball Advice