Andrew Painter - Fantasy Baseball Prospects Waiver Wire Stashes (Week 11)

Andrew Painter is a fantasy baseball waiver wire stash for Week 11 (2025). Target Andrew Painter as a top prospect free-agent waiver wire pickup for fantasy baseball.

BALLER MOVE: Add in 12-team leagues

CALL-UP ETA: June

ANALYSIS: Philadelphia Phillies right-handed pitching prospect Andrew Painter should continue to be viewed as a top stash option. After recovering from Tommy John and missing the entirety of the 2023 and 2024 seasons, Painter has returned to the bump this season and is fast approaching his MLB debut.

Painter was able to pitch in the Arizona Fall League but was held out of action during spring training to preserve his workload.

The Phillies opted for their top prospect to open the campaign with Low-A Clearwater. Across 11 1/3 innings of work, the right-hander struck out 12 batters and allowed just one walk.

He was then given the green light to make the jump to Triple-A, where he currently resides. In his most recent outing on June 4, Painter struggled as he allowed six hits and four runs across four frames. However, prior to this minor skid, Painter held a 2.65 ERA with a 1.24 WHIP through his first 17 frames at the level.

During this stretch, he tallied 20 punchouts and allowed just one long ball.

While manager Rob Thompson noted that it is "unlikely" Painter reaches the majors until after the All-Star break, he remains a strong stash option in all 12-team leagues. In 2022, Painter struck out an incredible 155 batters in just 103 2/3 innings of work.

When he gets the call, he will carry just as much upside as fellow top pitching prospect Bubba Chandler.

Andrew Painter collects 2 K's in the first inning on nasty curveballs pic.twitter.com/g8DTmKe3Uc

— Phillie Phacts (@PhilliePhacts) June 4, 2025

- Written by Andy Smith

Top Prospect Rankings and 2025 Call-Up ETAs

You can also check out RotoBaller's fantasy baseball prospect rankings for 2025. Eric Cross updates the below rankings weekly for the top impact prospects for 2025, and when they may be called up:

Top Prospect Dynasty Rankings

Looking for longer term fantasy baseball prospect rankings? You can also check out RotoBaller's top dynasty prospect rankings from Eric Cross:

Popular Player Comparison Searches - Who To Pickup?

Below are some popular searches and comparisons from our fantasy baseball Who To Pickup tool for Andrew Painter and others. You can also use the free Who Should I Pickup tool to run your own waiver wire comparisons, up to four players at once:

Jacob Misiorowski or Zebby Matthews
Bubba Chandler or Mclaun Temp
Colton Cowser or Grisham Temp
Zebby Matthews or Bubba Chandler
Bubba Chandler or Jacob Misiorowski
Joe Boyle or Bubba Chandler
Kristian Campbell or Marcus Semien
Kyle Stowers or Jonathan Aranda
Matt Shaw or Jordan Beck
Roman Anthony or Andy Pages
Ryan Ohearn or Jonathan Aranda
Sandy Alcantara or Roman Anthony
Trey Sweeney or Marcelo Mayer
Ben Rice or Jake Burger
Bubba Chandler or Roman Anthony
Colin Rea or Grant Holmes
David Bednar or Shelby Miller
Gavin Sheets or Tyler Soderstrom
Brandon Nimmo or Michael Harris
Bubba Chandler or Mick Abel
Cade Horton or Joe Boyle
Christian Encarnacionstrand or Ben Rice
Cole Young or Denzel Clarke
Colin Rea or Zebby Matthews
Dalton Rushing or Samuel Basallo
Daniel Palencia or Luke Weaver
Daulton Varsho or Trent Grisham
Dillon Dingler or Nick Kurtz
Drake Baldwin or Gavin Sheets
Gavin Sheets or Brett Baty
Gavin Williams or Shane Baz
Geraldo Perdomo or Bichette Temp
Geraldo Perdomo or Jacob Wilson
Grant Holmes or Jack Leiter
Grant Holmes or Lance Mccullersjr
Grant Holmes or Shane Smith
Hayden Birdsong or Cade Horton
Sal Frelick or Jj Bleday
Spencer Horwitz or Jake Burger
Spencer Torkelson or Jac Caglianone
Tj Friedl or Sal Frelick
Tony Gonsolin or Will Warren
Trent Grisham or Daulton Varsho
Victor Scottii or Jordan Beck
Wilmer Flores or Michael Busch
Zac Veen or Jj Bleday
Zebby Matthews or Jacob Misiorowski
Abner Uribe or Jason Adam
Ben Rice or Brett Baty
Ben Rice or Carlos Santana
Ben Rice or Gabriel Moreno
Ben Rice or Spencer Torkelson
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Brady House or Andrew Painter
Brandon Lowe or Matt Shaw
Jason Adam or Chris Martin
Jonathan Aranda or Jose Caballero
Jonathan Aranda or Kyle Manzardo
Jonathan Aranda or Mick Abel
Jonathan Aranda or Rhys Hoskins
Jonathan Aranda or Ryan Ohearn
Jonathan Aranda or Spencer Torkelson
Jordan Beck or Addison Barger
Jordan Beck or Sal Frelick
Jordan Walker or Matt Wallner
Josh Lowe or Jac Caglianone
Josh Lowe or Matt Wallner
Kyle Manzardo or Gavin Sheets
Kyle Stowers or Jonathan Aranda
Kyle Teel or Dalton Rushing
Lance Mccullersjr or Grant Holmes
Lars Nootbaar or Trent Grisham
Lourdes Gurrieljr or Hyeseong Kim
Lucas Giolito or Shane Smith
Maikel Garcia or Cam Smith
Marcelo Mayer or Nick Kurtz
Marcelo Mayer or Will Benson
Masyn Winn or Chase Meidroth
Matt Shaw or Jordan Beck
Matthew Liberatore or Max Meyer
Max Muncy or Connor Norby
Mick Abel or Bubba Chandler
Miguel Vargas or Brett Baty
Moises Ballesteros or Ivan Herrera
Noah Cameron or Ryan Weathers
Addison Barger or Jac Caglianone&Scrlybrkr=75E55Bf9
Addison Barger or Kyle Stowers
Andrew Abbott or Cade Horton
Andrew Abbott or Matthew Liberatore
Andrew Heaney or Dean Kremer
Andrew Painter or Luis Robertjr
Andy Pages or Kyle Stowers
Andy Pages or Kyle Stowers
Andy Pages or Kyle Stowers
Andy Pages or Roman Anthony
Andy Pages or Victor Scottii
Austin Hays or Andy Pages
Austin Hays or Ben Rice
Austin Hays or Colton Cowser
Austin Hays or Marcelo Mayer
Austin Hays or Noelvi Marte
Ben Brown or Jack Leiter
Ben Brown or Ryan Weathers
Ben Casparius or Luke Weaver
Ben Rice or Bowden Francis
Ben Rice or Carlos Santana
Ben Rice or Jake Burger
Ben Rice or Josh Lowe
Ben Rice or Kyle Manzardo
Ben Rice or Nick Kurtz
Ben Rice or Nick Kurtz
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Ben Rice or Wilmer Flores
Brett Baty or Lourdes Gurrieljr
Cade Horton or Noah Cameron
Cade Smith or Daniel Palencia
Cam Smith or Colt Keith
Cam Smith or Kyle Manzardo
Camilo Doval or Bubba Chandler
Camilo Doval or Daniel Palencia
Eury Perez or Lance Mccullersjr
Eury Perez or Lance Mccullersjr
Eury Perez or Lance Mccullersjr
Eury Perez or Ryan Weathers
Gavin Sheets or Drake Baldwin
Gavin Sheets or Jake Burger
Gavin Sheets or Kyle Manzardo
Gavin Sheets or Ty France
Gavin Williams or Kumar Rocker
Gavin Williams or Nick Kurtz
Grant Holmes or Tony Gonsolin
Grant Holmes or Will Warren
Jack Leiter or Stephen Kolek
Jack Leiter or Zebby Matthews
Jackson Holliday or Tovar Temp
Jackson Jobe or Spencer Arrighetti
Jacob Melton or Nick Kurtz
Jacob Wilson or Anthony Volpe
Jacob Wilson or Zac Veen
Jake Burger or Andrew Painter
Jake Burger or Ben Rice
Jake Burger or Jac Caglianone
Jake Burger or Max Muncy
Jake Burger or Miguel Vargas
Jake Mangum or Kyle Stowers
Jason Adam or Alex Vesia
Jason Adam or Ben Casparius
Jasson Dominguez or Jordan Lawlar
Jesus Sanchez or Jake Mangum
Jesus Sanchez or Jake Mangum
Jj Bleday or Tyler Fitzgerald
Jonathan Aranda or Ben Rice
Jonathan Aranda or Colt Keith
Lance Mccullersjr or Ranger Suarez
Lance Mccullersjr or Sawyer Gipsonlong
Lance Mccullersjr or Shane Smith
Landen Roupp or Shane Smith
Matt Wallner or Colton Cowser
Matt Wallner or Jake Mangum
Matt Wallner or Jake Meyers
Matt Wallner or Jesus Sanchez
Matthew Liberatore or Ben Brown
Max Meyer or Jack Leiter
Max Muncy or Jake Burger
Max Muncy or Josh Lowe
Nick Kurtz or Jacob Melton
Nick Kurtz or Josh Lowe
Nick Kurtz or Kyle Manzardo
Nick Kurtz or Michael Harrisii
Noah Cameron or Jacob Misiorowski
Stephen Kolek or Cam Smith
Tj Friedl or Roman Anthony
Tj Friedl or Victor Scottii
Tommy Kahnle or Abner Uribe
Tommy Kahnle or Bassitt Temp
Tommy Kahnle or Robert Garcia
Tony Gonsolin or Bubba Chandler
Tony Gonsolin or Robert Garcia
Trent Grisham or Hunter Goodman
Trevor Larnach or Solee Temp
Trevor Story or Geraldo Perdomo
Trevor Story or Spencer Torkelson
Tyler Fitzgerald or Brett Baty
Tyler Fitzgerald or Brooks Lee
Tyler Fitzgerald or Colt Keith
Tyler Fitzgerald or Dean Kremet
Tyler Fitzgerald or Dylan Moore
Tyler Fitzgerald or Edman Temp
Victor Scottii or Byron Buxton
Victor Scottii or Cam Smith

More Fantasy Baseball Advice