X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Champ or Chump: David Peterson and Jacob Misiorowski Fantasy Baseball Outlooks

Jacob Misiorowski - Fantasy Baseball Rankings, MLB Prospects, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire

Are David Peterson and Jacob Misiorowski fantasy baseball sleepers, busts, or neither? Rick takes a deep dive into their 2025 fantasy baseball value.

All-Stars aren't a fantasy category, but it still feels great when your roster has more than your rivals. Granted, all All-Stars aren't equal for this purpose. If Aaron Judge didn't perform like an All-Star, his fantasy managers would likely be in trouble. Similarly, an All-Star first half doesn't necessarily translate to fantasy production in the second.

David Peterson has decent surface stats to go with his All-Star nod, but a lack of strikeouts and hidden struggles against right-handed batters (RHBs) suggest he should be a sell-high guy. Jacob Misiorowski's All-Star selection was controversial, considering he appeared in only five MLB games, and the Brewers are likely to severely limit his workload moving forward.

Let's take a closer look at what these arms might have to offer in the second half.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and resources:

 

David Peterson (SP, New York Mets)

67% Rostered

The 29-year-old Peterson is 6-4 with a 3.06 ERA in 109 innings pitched (IP) this season. He's inducing grounders at a 55.9 percent clip, and his .292 BABIP, 76 percent strand rate, and 9.1 percent HR/FB are all in the normal range. The Mets didn't need an All-Star with Francisco Lindor, Pete Alonso, and Edwin Diaz already representing the club, but he doesn't seem like the worst pick.

Unfortunately, a closer examination reveals several red flags. His 3.58 xFIP and 4.14 xERA suggest negative ERA regression. While Peterson offered strikeout upside earlier in his career, his current 20.5 percent K% and 8.1 percent BB% are simply not All-Star worthy.

Peterson's arsenal doesn't offer much strikeout upside, either. He has a five-pitch mix: sinker, fastball, slider, change, and curve. Peterson's sinker gets him ahead in the count with a 63.1 percent Zone% and induces grounders with its 67.6 percent GB%, but its 3.1 percent swinging strike percentage (SwStr%) offers zero strikeout potential.

Peterson's fastball is better with a nine percent SwStr%, but its 50 percent Zone% is too low for a primary offering. His slider is his best pitch with an 18.9 percent SwStr%, 45.4 percent Zone%, and 39.3 percent chase rate, but it's only his third pitch by usage rate.

Peterson rounds out his repertoire with a changeup (9.7 percent SwStr%, 43.1 percent Zone%, 30.5 percent chase) and curve (12 percent SwStr%, 47.8 percent Zone%, 39.4 percent chase), but neither offers strikeouts for fantasy. Overall, it's a kitchen sink pitch mix befitting a No. 4 starter.

That might be okay if Peterson excelled at managing contact, but he doesn't. Check out his Statcast metrics:

Peterson's GB% and Barrel% rank well, but opposing hitters generally hit the ball hard. His .240 batting average against (BAA) should be more than 30 points higher, meaning that regression would turn his 1.24 WHIP into a fantasy issue. Strangely, all of Peterson's good fortune comes against RHB.

Righties have a .257 average and .329 slugging percentage against Peterson's sinker, but they deserve .306 and .398, respectively. They tattoo Peterson's fastball with a .318 average and .545 slugging, but deserve even more with a .359 xBA and .622 xSLG. Peterson's change has held RHBs to a .200 average and .273 SLG, but they've deserved marks of .260 and .342.

Peterson's slider is his best pitch against opposite-handed batters, which is strange in itself. Still, its .231 BAA and .333 slugging percentage are better than its .245 xBA and .406 xSLG. Finally, Peterson's curve has a .217 BAA and .283 slugging percentage against RHB but a .281 xBA and .389 xSLG. Literally every pitch has overperformed against RHB this season.

Even that could be sustainable if Peterson could expect help from his fielders, but he cannot. The Mets rank 22nd in Outs Above Average (OAA) at -8. Their infield (one OAA, 14th) ranks better than their outfield (-9 OAA, 24th), which is good for a groundball specialist like Peterson. Still, the infield alone is average at best, not good enough to support Peterson's overperformance.

The Mets are a contending team, and Peterson is generally permitted to pitch deep into games, so there are worse speculative win options on waivers. However, his workload could prove to be a detriment with his relative lack of strikeouts in K/9 and formats with an innings cap (effectively turning strikeouts into K/9). An elevated ERA over a high innings count is problematic, too.

Nobody wants to see Peterson pitch in the All-Star Game tonight, and you shouldn't want to see him on your fantasy roster, either. Sell this Chump now while his value is at its peak and his issues are buried in his peripherals.

 

Jacob Misiorowski (SP/RP, Milwaukee Brewers)

84% Rostered

Misiorowski is only 25 2/3 IP into his MLB career, but he's 4-1 with a 2.81 ERA, 2.60 xERA, and 3.13 xFIP. The 23-year-old has a 33.7 percent K% against an 11.2 percent BB% and has been heavily marketed by MLB, especially his marquee matchups against Paul Skenes and Clayton Kershaw.

Misiorowski's scouting report suggests fantasy upside, but also highlights significant risk as a reliever, rooted in control issues. Here's his FanGraphs scouting report:

Misiorowski's velocity sits elite with an unreal top end, and his curve and cutter are big-league ready as well. Unfortunately, his command is below average and isn't expected to become even MLB-average in the future. His write-up notes that Misiorowski's questionable control could make him a high-leverage reliever rather than a starter.

His MiLB.com scouting report tells a similar story:

His slider is his cutter, so this scouting report is more optimistic on all three of his pitches. However, his write-up notes that Misiorowski is "lanky" and "looks like all elbows and knees," making it difficult for him to repeat his delivery and throw strikes. Reliever risk remains a key concern.

Misiorowski's MiLB history is categorized by immense strikeout potential and persistent walk issues. He reached the high minor leagues with Double-A (Biloxi) last season, pitching to a 3.50 ERA and 3.81 xFIP in 79 2/3 IP. His 30.3 percent K% was excellent, though his 14.4 percent BB% was alarming. Hitters didn't do much when they made contact with a .257 BABIP and 11.1 percent HR/FB.

Misiorowski earned a promotion to Triple-A (Nashville) and a bullpen role to keep his innings down, pitching to a 2.55 ERA but 4.40 xFIP in 17 2/3 IP. His 31.4 percent K% and 14.3 percent BB% were virtual repeats of his Double-A rates, and hitters were even less productive on contact with an .118 BABIP and 9.1 percent HR/FB.

Misiorowski returned to Nashville to begin 2025 in a starting role, posting a 2.13 ERA and 3.71 xFIP in 63 1/3 IP. His 31.6 percent K% was great, while his 12.3 percent BB% was a slight improvement over 2024. Once again, opposing hitters managed little with a .248 BABIP and 8.9 percent HR/FB.

It's a small sample, but Misiorowski's 11.2 percent BB% as a Brewer is better than his mark at Triple-A. First-pitch strike percentage (F-Strike%) is one of the best predictors of BB%, and Misiorowski's 60.2 percent mark in the majors is much better than his 51 percent at Nashville this season. He may be figuring things out.

Misiorowski's repertoire also has the look of a strike thrower. His heater has a 57.9 percent Zone% and 12.6 percent SwStr%, allowing Misiorowski to get ahead and put hitters away. His slider/cutter acts as a second heater with a 63.5 percent Zone% and 10.4 percent SwStr%.

Misiorowski's curve has a 54.7 percent Zone%, and its 41.7 percent chase rate helps it generate an elite 22.6 percent SwStr%. He's also working on a change with a 31.6 percent Zone%, but he throws it less than five percent of the time, and batters chase it at an impressive 46.2 percent clip, generating a 21.1 percent SwStr%.

It seems like Misiorowski has addressed his biggest bugaboo, giving him elite fantasy upside as a huge strikeout arm on a contending team. The only question now is what kind of innings limit the Brewers have him on, and fantasy managers probably won't like the answer.

Misiorowski threw 71 1/3 IP in 2023 and 97 1/3 last season, just shy of a 35 percent increase year-over-year. If we assume the plan for this year is also about a 35 percent increase, that gives him a total of 130 IP. He's already thrown 89, meaning he has about 40 IP to go before Milwaukee shuts him down.

That's eight abbreviated five-inning starts, but he probably won't hit even that number. The Brewers have an 82.9 percent chance of making the playoffs, according to FanGraphs, and Milwaukee will want Misiorowski available in some capacity in October. If they save 15-20 innings for the postseason, we're looking at 20-25 IP for fantasy managers split across two and a half months.

You could argue that the Brewers have to "go for it" to make sure they get a playoff spot, but they probably won't. Between Logan Henderson, Nestor Cortes, Chad Patrick, and Tobias Myers, the team has four MLB-caliber starters who aren't currently in their rotation. Misiorowski could easily have a phantom IL stint without compromising October baseball in Milwaukee.

It's just not enough volume to live up to the hype, even if his ratios are elite for a contending team. Usage alone makes Misiorowski a Chump in 2025, though he should be excellent whenever he's allowed to pitch.



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!



More Fantasy Baseball Analysis




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Emmanuel Clase

Luis L. Ortiz to Remain On Leave for Rest of Season
Kyle Schwarber

has Historic Performance in Rout of Braves
Boston Red Sox

Payton Tolle Expected to Make Debut on Friday
Green Bay Packers

Packers Acquire Micah Parsons, Sign him to Four-Year Extension
Jauan Jennings

Remains Sidelined at Practice
Corey Seager

Undergoing Appendectomy on Thursday
Chris Godwin

to Miss First Month of Season, Possibly More
Quinshon Judkins

Not Considering Return to College
A.J. Brown

Returns to Practice, Expected to Play in Week 1
Jaylen Wright

Undergoes Surgery, Could be Back "Septemberish"
Tyreek Hill

on Track to Play in Week 1
Kyren Williams

to See Reduced Workload?
Jayden Reed

Dealing with Jones Fracture in Left Foot
Lauri Markkanen

Torches Sweden
Neemias Queta

Dominates in EuroBasket Opener
Kawhi Leonard

Clippers Not Allowing Kawhi Leonard to Play Back-to-Backs
Olivier-Maxence Prosper

Mavericks Looking to Trade Olivier-Maxence Prosper
Tyrese Haliburton

Expects to Return in 15 Months
Malik Nabers

Expected to be Full-Go for Week 1
Freddie Freeman

Out Wednesday With Neck Stinger
Alejandro Kirk

Avoids Major Injury, Remains Out on Wednesday
Travis Hunter

Back at Practice, Will be Ready for Week 1
Luis Robert Jr.

Could Miss the Rest of the Season
De'Von Achane

Not Practicing on Wednesday
Trevor Megill

Brewers Place Trevor Megill on Injured List With Flexor Strain
Luis Robert Jr.

Placed on Injured List With Hamstring Strain
Rashee Rice

Accepting Six-Game Suspension to Begin the Year
Kyle Hamilton

Ravens, Kyle Hamilton Finalizing Four-Year Extension
Rashee Rice

NFL Aiming to Place Six-Game Suspension on Rashee Rice
De'Von Achane

Dolphins GM Says De'Von Achane Will be Ready for Week 1
Joe Mixon

Texans GM: "We'll See" if Joe Mixon Plays in 2025
Adam Thielen

Traded to the Vikings
Nick Lodolo

Expected to Return Wednesday Against the Dodgers
Terance Mann

Confident About Having a Big Year in Brooklyn
Zaccharie Risacher

Aims to Improve Ball-Handling Skills
NBA

Pistons And Timberwolves Join Race for Malik Beasley
John Tonje

Signs Two-Way Deal With Jazz
Max Strus

to Miss 3-4 Months After Surgery
Blake Snell

Activated From Paternity List Tuesday
Dallas Cowboys

Cowboys Still Expect Micah Parsons to Play in Week 1
Luis Robert Jr.

Exits Early With Hamstring Soreness
Chris Godwin

Passes Physical, Will be Activated From PUP List
Willson Contreras

Issued Six-Game Suspension
Randy Rodríguez

Randy Rodriguez Placed on Injured List
Brandon Aiyuk

49ers Officially Place Brandon Aiyuk on PUP List
Nathan Eovaldi

Likely Done for the Season
Yordan Alvarez

Activated and Starting on Tuesday
Oneil Cruz

Back From Injured List
New York Mets

Jonah Tong Promoted to Major Leagues
Nikola Jović

Heat Have High Hopes for Nikola Jovic
Golden State Warriors

Cody Martin Drawing Interest From Warriors
Minnesota Timberwolves

Timberwolves Interested in Reunion With Bones Hyland
Kylor Kelley

Joins Lakers
Colin Castleton

Links Up With Magic
Malik Monk

Kings "Not Actively Engaged" in Trade Discussions Involving Malik Monk
P.J. Washington

Mavs Likely to Offer P.J. Washington a Contract Extension
NHL

Jan Rutta Lands in Switzerland
Kirby Dach

Skates on Monday
COL

Tyson Barrie Retires From NHL
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Back in Toronto's Lineup
Zhang Mingyang

Suffers His First UFC Loss
Johnny Walker

Gets Back In The Win Column
Brian Ortega

Loses Back-To-Back Fights
Aljamain Sterling

Proves Too Much For Brian Ortega
Chris Sale

Penciled in to Start on Saturday
Waldo Cortes-Acosta

Suffers Unanimous-Decision Loss
Sergei Pavlovich

Wins Decision At UFC Shanghai
Kevin Borjas

Drops Decision At UFC Shanghai
Sumudaerji

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Kiefer Crosbie

Still Winless In The UFC
Taiyilake Nueraji

Gets His First UFC Win
Ryan Blaney

Earns his Second Daytona Cup Series Win
Tyler Reddick

Locks Into the 2025 Playoffs Despite Underwhelming Daytona Performance
Erik Jones

Misses the 2025 Playoffs Despite Top-Five Run at Daytona
Justin Haley

Best Performance of 2025 Falls Short of Victory at Daytona
Chase Burns

To Throw Bullpen on Tuesday
Kyle Larson

Enters Playoffs As Co-Points Leader
Alex Bowman

Advances to Playoffs Despite Crashing at Daytona
Cole Custer

Finally Shows Signs of Life at Daytona
Daniel Suarez

Lame-Duck Daniel Suarez Delivers Clutch Second-Place Finish
Chase Elliott

Despite Being Winless at Daytona, Chase Elliott is Probably the Best DFS Option
Ryan Blaney

Will Likely Lead a Lot at Daytona
Kyle Larson

a Poor DFS Option at Daytona
Christopher Bell

Consistent Enough to Consider for DFS
Chris Buescher

Now Must Win His Way Into Playoffs
Ryan Preece

Being One of the Slowest-Starting Fords Makes Ryan Preece a Strong DFS Option
Ross Chastain

Leads a Lot on Drafting Tracks
Daniel Suarez

Now in Desperation Mode With his Career on the Line
Chase Briscoe

Tendency to Finish Better Than He Runs May Reap Dividends at Daytona
Carson Hocevar

Hard to Forecast Since He's Rarely Given 100 Percent at Daytona
Michael McDowell

has a Solid Drafting Record
AJ Allmendinger

A.J. Allmendinger Arguably Starting Too Well for Place-Differential Points
Austin Dillon

Will Likely Be Too Conservative for DFS Consideration
Moses Moody

Warriors Not Interested in Trading Moses Moody
Kevin Durant

Rockets Expected to Agree on New Contract
Trey Murphy III

Warriors, Spurs Interested in Trey Murphy III

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP