NFL Playoffs Wild Card Matchup Analysis: Cleveland Browns vs. Houston Texans

January 11, 2024

Tony analyzes the matchup of the Cleveland Browns vs. Houston Texans on NFL Wild Card Weekend (2023). Who's the favorite, and which team has the edge on both sides of the ball?

The Cleveland Browns are set to face the Houston Texans at NRG Stadium for Super Wild Card Weekend in a clash between the AFC's fourth and fifth seeds. Both teams enter the game with high spirits, confident in their chances.

C.J. Stroud had a historic rookie season at quarterback, orchestrating a remarkable turnaround for the franchise and securing the AFC South title. Throughout the season, the Browns boasted the league's best defense. The late-season resurgence of Joe Flacco, filling in for the injured Deshaun Watson, has added an extra layer of danger to the team.

Let's delve into the offenses and defenses of these two teams as they approach their playoff showdown. Who holds the edge, and what does each team need to do to secure a victory?

Vegas Lines

Cleveland Browns -2.5 at Houston Texans

O/U 44.5

Browns Offense vs. Texans Defense

Cleveland currently ranks 28th in offensive DVOA this year. However, the passing game has gained significant momentum since Joe Flacco's arrival. The Browns have faced consistent injuries across every offensive position, leading to a struggle for consistency in the run game throughout the season.

Notably, Amari Cooper and David Njoku have stepped up for the Browns, with Cooper recording an impressive 265 yards in their recent meeting a few weeks ago. Despite being fourth in pass block win rate, the Browns sit at 26th in run block win rate, emphasizing the need for some success in the ground game.

On the defensive side, the Texans have excelled against the run, ranking second in run-stuff win rate and DVOA. However, they gave up 227 rushing yards in Week 18. Their pass defense tells a different story, ranking 23rd in that category and struggling against a simpler version of this offense earlier in the season. Will Anderson Jr.'s presence contributes to the Texans ranking third in pass rush win rate, posing a challenge for the Browns. Nevertheless, the Browns have showcased strong pass protection throughout the year.

Cleveland may face difficulties establishing a consistent run game, but their ability to move the ball hinges on the offensive line containing the Texans pass rush. The Texans secondary struggled against the Browns in their previous matchup, and with more time playing alongside Flacco, there's no reason to expect a different outcome. Turnovers in this game are likely to play a crucial role in determining the winner.

Texans Offense vs. Browns Defense

C.J. Stroud has elevated the passing attack to a formidable level, yet the Texans have struggled to rely on their run game, ranking 14th in passing DVOA but a challenging 30th in rushing. This is largely attributed to their 25th position in run block win rate. While Devin Singletary has been the recent workhorse, the rushing attack faced difficulties in their earlier matchup.

Notably, Stroud ranks near the top among quarterbacks with at least 50 percent of snaps this year in longest time to throw. Against the Browns, who tend to receive quick schemes from opponents, the Texans will need to decide between trusting pass protection or incorporating more quick game strategies.

The Browns defense has demonstrated dominance throughout the season, securing the first rank in DVOA over the initial 17 weeks. Myles Garrett, Za'Darius Smith, and Ogbo Okoronkwo's elite pass rush has consistently altered the line of scrimmage, placing the Browns second in pass rush win rate and first in run stuff win rate. Employing man coverage due to the abundance of talent in corners Denzel Ward, Martin Emerson, and Greg Newsome, the Browns benefit from the likely return of safeties Juan Thornhill and Grant Delpit, a significant boost after missing their previous matchup.

Given the Browns' prowess in applying pressure and limiting yards after the catch, the Texans face challenges in finding effective ways to attack. Houston's offensive line must perform well to provide Stroud with the opportunity to dissect the defense or they will struggle to move the ball.

More Fantasy Football Analysis