👉 TAP TO SAVE 30% WITH CODE NEW
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Top-Rated Accuracy
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

2016 Fantasy Baseball Tiered Rankings: Outfield, Part 1 (March)

This is the fourth and final update to our outfield staff rankings. Once again, I was joined by colleagues Kyle Bishop, Bill Dubiel, Brad Johnson, Nick Mariano, Max Petrie, and Harris Yudin.

In case you missed them, you can see our updated March tiered rankings and analysis breaking down our thoughts for catcher, first base, second base, shortstop and third base. Let's cut the foreplay and dive right in.

Editor's note: Make sure to also bookmark our Fantasy Baseball Rankings Assistant. The draft prep tool consolidates all our staff ranks in one easy place, shows ADP industry comparisons, and identifies the rankings risers/fallers. Sort our rankings by positional tiers, AL/NL only, dynasty, points leagues, top prospects and more.

 

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings Analysis: Outfield (Tiers 1-4)

Tier 1

While the first tier has baseball's two best hitters, it's not too interesting to discuss. You know who Trout and Harper are. I placed Trout ahead of Harper simply because he has been more consistent; as crazy as it sounds, Harper has more upside in my opinion. Just for eye candy, here are their 5x5 lines from last year: .299/41/90/101/11 (Trout) and .330/42/118/99/6 (Harper). In any event, you cannot go wrong with either barring injury. If you like to gamble, Harper is a fine choice ahead of Trout.

Tier 2

In the second tier, one addition should be Chris Davis who played 30 games in RF last year. Due to many not knowing he is OF eligible, you can likely get good value. Leaving out his 2014 - during which he did not have a Therapeutic Use Exemption from MLB for an Adderall-like drug and was also battling an oblique injury - he posted lines of .286/53/103/138/4 in 2013 and .262/47/100/117/2 in 2015. While his 2014 is a red flag, the upside is enormous and I value him around the same as Jose Bautista. The other under-ranked player in the second tier is AJ Pollock. His 162 game averages the past two years are .311/19/107/70/36, and he bested those numbers last year. His elbow is a concern, so make sure he is healthy as Opening Day approaches, but those numbers are spectacular.

Two players ranked a little too highly by my peers in the second tier are McCutchen and Springer. McCutchen's steals have declined from 27 to 18 to 11 the past three years. He has not hit more than 25 homers or cracked 100 runs or RBIs (in a lineup that is largely similar). While it's possible that he could have dropped off a bit last year due to an early injury he played through, it's also possible he is just enduring a bit of a decline. .300/23/95/95/10 is a slash line you could approach or possibly beat with Pollock, Betts, or even approach with Cain or Marte who will go much later. For Springer, I have trouble envisioning a player who hits for a high average with great power; if he cuts down on his high K-rate as he did last year, it seems he would lose some power as he did last year. And while he ran more than his rookie year, he still didn't nearly approach his minors numbers in terms of steals. Add in that he is coming off injury, and he is being rated a little too highly for my tastes.

Tier 3

In the third tier, two players I like slightly more than my peers are Carlos Gomez and Lorenzo Cain. Carlos Gomez had a down year last year battling an injury. At 30, he is unlikely to have a career year. Nevertheless, he has a 162-game average over the last three years of .276/24/94/80/36. The most encouraging sign from last year is that Houston let him run; he stole 10 bases in 41 games for them. In a good lineup, he is being undervalued. Lorenzo Cain has had an issue staying healthy, but he has shown speed (28 SBs each of the last two years despite averaging 137 games), the ability to hit for average (.301 and .307), and surprising power last year (16 homers in 140 games). While he is an injury risk, his batting average and steals provide a nice floor if healthy.

Tier 4

In the fourth tier, I am targeting Michael Brantley even though he is coming off injury. Brantley has a 162 game average the past two years of .319/20/90/101/22. Those numbers are an optimistic line for even Andrew McCutchen. With him continuing to beat his recovery timeline, an April return is looking likely and he's too good not to gamble on. Corey Dickerson, on the other hand, was not dinged enough by my peers after his trade out of Colorado. He has a career 1.085 OPS at Coors and a .695 OPS outside of Coors and is coming off an injury-riddled season. Matt Holliday is also ranked too highly. He's 36, coming off an atrocious and injury-plagued year, and he even showed a tick of decline in 2014. At his age, the upside does not appear to be there to offset the risk that the decline is real.

Lastly, while not fitting in one specific tier, Schwarber and Soler (and possibly even Fowler) take a hit from Fowler joining the Cubs. The Cubs now have at least four starting caliber outfielders - Schwarber, Soler, Heyward, and Fowler. Javier Baez has been playing some outfield as well. While Schwarber can play catcher too, barring a trade or injury, it is hard to find a clear path to everyday playing time for Schwarber and Soler at the very least. It is a situation to monitor as the season approaches.

Check back tomorrow for my late round targets.

 

Outfield Tiered Fantasy Baseball Rankings (March)

Rank Tier Name Brad Max Kyle Nick Harris Jeff Bill
1 1 Mike Trout 1 1 1 1 2 1 2
2 1 Bryce Harper 2 2 2 2 1 2 1
3 2 Giancarlo Stanton 4 3 3 3 3 3 4
4 2 Andrew McCutchen 3 5 4 4 4 6 3
5 2 Jose Bautista 8 6 6 5 5 7 5
6 2 George Springer 6 7 5 6 6 9 7
7 2 Mookie Betts 5 4 9 7 7 5 10
8 2 A.J. Pollock 7 9 8 8 11 4 6
9 2 Starling Marte 10 8 7 12 10 8 8
10 3 J.D. Martinez 9 12 10 9 8 12 11
11 2 Ryan Braun 13 10 11 11 13 10 9
12 3 Justin Upton 12 11 12 10 14 13 13
13 3 Charlie Blackmon 11 14 13 13 19 15 14
14 3 Lorenzo Cain 17 18 15 16 12 11 12
15 3 Nelson Cruz 18 15 16 15 9 16 16
16 3 Carlos Gonzalez 19 16 19 18 18 18 18
17 3 Adam Jones 15 20 21 14 23 19 15
18 3 Jason Heyward 14 17 17 20 16 22 21
19 3 Carlos Gomez 21 13 23 19 22 14 19
20 3 Kyle Schwarber 22 19 14 21 15 25 17
21 3 Yoenis Cespedes 20 21 20 17 17 20 20
22 4 Yasiel Puig 16 23 18 23 25 21 24
23 4 Hunter Pence 34 22 22 22 32 23 23
24 4 Jacoby Ellsbury 26 32 41 30 20 24 25
25 4 Curtis Granderson 29 33 28 27 28 30 26
26 4 Alex Gordon 23 31 29 35 26 35 29
27 4 Kole Calhoun 28 24 30 34 31 33 28
28 4 David Peralta 35 25 24 25 38 29 32
29 4 Christian Yelich 27 36 35 28 21 32 36
30 4 Brett Gardner 39 26 27 32 33 31 31
31 4 Corey Dickerson 25 28 32 26 37 54 22
32 4 Adam Eaton 37 37 26 24 34 28 39
33 4 Michael Brantley 56 27 37 40 27 17 27
34 4 Joc Pederson 41 41 25 37 24 34 35
35 4 Matt Holliday 43 30 31 29 43 45 30
36 4 Gregory Polanco 32 29 42 42 44 26 36
37 4 Shin-Soo Choo 42 35 38 31 30 39 40
38 4 Billy Hamilton 33 40 55 51 29 27 34
39 5 Michael Conforto 40 34 40 47 36 37 42
40 5 Josh Reddick 31 43 36 39 53 38 38
41 5 Hanley Ramirez 24 48 44 33 45 44 46
42 5 Stephen Piscotty 48 39 39 36 39 52 44
43 5 Randal Grichuk 49 44 34 38 54 43 45
44 5 Matt Kemp 36 45 45 41 52 49 41
45 5 Jorge Soler 63 38 46 49 40 46 33
46 5 Dexter Fowler 44 42 43 44 47 53 43
47 6 Ben Zobrist 30 52 33 56 55 64 50
48 6 Delino Deshields 50 49 49 46 41 60 53
49 6 Ben Revere 57 51 58 53 42 42 48
50 6 Billy Burns 38 54 48 59 50 55 55
51 6 Kevin Pillar 58 55 53 48 49 47 51
52 6 Steven Souza 52 56 47 45 46 56 61
53 6 Gerardo Parra 45 50 59 52 56 48 60
54 6 Evan Gattis 51 47 57 43 57 72 49
55 6 Ender Inciarte 68 46 56 54 61 51 47
56 6 Wil Myers 74 60 66 57 35 40 58
57 6 Marcell Ozuna 47 57 51 60 65 58 57
58 6 Jayson Werth 60 59 50 70 67 41 52
59 6 Khris Davis 46 62 54 55 58 62 62
60 6 Melky Cabrera 53 53 60 65 69 63 54
61 7 Mark Trumbo 54 78 73 58 59 36 74
62 7 Aaron Altherr 65 69 87 69 88 65
63 7 Colby Rasmus 62 75 67 63 51 61 72
64 7 Jay Bruce 67 70 69 50 64 66 69
65 7 Carlos Beltran 70 67 64 62 70 59 66
66 7 Odubel Herrera 64 63 61 61 86 67 56
67 7 Byron Buxton 72 76 70 73 48 50 70
68 7 Brad Miller 59 66 52 71 71 71 76
69 7 Cameron Maybin 79 64 63 64 72 70 59
70 7 Eddie Rosario 69 61 68 78 68 68 67
71 7 Aaron Hicks 66 68 72 66 78 69 63
72 7 Rusney Castillo 75 58 65 72 89 57 68
73 8 Danny Valencia 61 65 71 68 80 81 73
74 8 Denard Span 73 73 88 76 60 65 71
75 8 Domingo Santana 71 71 62 74 66 76 87
76 8 Brandon Moss 76 77 77 67 74 74 64
77 8 Nori Aoki 77 72 82 80 62 75 88
78 8 Kevin Kiermaier 78 84 80 82 73 73 80
79 8 Hyun-soo Kim 55 92 75 77 - 85 92
80 8 Marlon Byrd 80 79 76 85 84 80 75
81 9 Yasmany Tomas 97 74 83 75 81 78 82
82 9 Brock Holt 79 83 78 86 94 91 79
83 9 Derek Dietrich 80 96 74 87 - 88 81
84 8 Chris Colabello 93 82 86 79 75 90 86
85 9 Eduardo Escobar - 88 79 89 - 84 89
86 9 Austin Jackson 72 95 95 83 76 87 95
87 9 Jackie Bradley Jr. 96 97 85 88 77 77 90
88 9 Nick Markakis 87 91 94 91 79 93
89 9 Franklin Gutierrez 95 100 91 81 - 79 91
90 9 Leonys Martin 94 93 96 94 63 93 94
91 9 Mark Cahna 98 89 84 109 83 86 78
92 9 Andre Ethier 85 87 89 90 99 83 96
93 9 Dalton Pompey 86 80 81 102 87 97 98
94 9 Jarrod Dyson 106 81 93 84 85 94 -
95 9 Alex Rios 88 90 102 98 96 - 84
96 9 Avisail Garcia - 85 100 103 82 - 97
97 9 Rajai Davis 100 - 97 92 - 89 -
98 9 Desmond Jennings 99 86 103 100 90 92 -
99 9 Josh Hamilton 91 94 - 99 91 100
100 9 Anthony Gose - 102 98 105 93 96 77
101 9 Preston Tucker 107 99 90 97 - 83
102 9 Oswaldo Arcia - 105 - 107 100 82 85
103 9 Chris Coghlan 84 103 99 93 - 101
104 9 Michael Taylor 89 102 92 108 95 98 99
105 9 Adam Duvall 90 104 106 101 92 99 -
106 9 Coco Crisp 92 106 107 106 98 95 -
107 9 Rymer Liriano 105 101 101 104 - 100 -
108 9 Will Venable - 108 109 95 97 -
109 9 Nomar Mazara 103 - 108 96 - - -
110 9 Angel Pagan 102 99 105 110 - - -
111 9 Abraham Almonte 104 - - - - - -
112 9 Seth Smith 101 107 104 111 - - -

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Top-Rated Accuracy
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Ronnie Rivers

Rams Re-Sign Ronnie Rivers to One-Year Deal
Las Vegas Raiders

Raiders to Host Fernando Mendoza for a Top-30 Visit in Two Weeks
Tua Tagovailoa

Open to Being a QB Mentor in Atlanta
Zay Flowers

Ravens Want to Extend Zay Flowers Soon
Jeremy Peña

Jeremy Pena on the Astros Opening Day Roster
Blake Snell

Dodgers Place Blake Snell on 15-Day Injured List
John Carlson

Sets Up Three Goals Tuesday Night
Joel Hofer

Picks Up Sixth Shutout of the Season
John Tavares

Records Three Assists in Tuesday's Win
NJ

Arseni Gritsyuk Scheduled for Imaging Wednesday
Jordan Mason

Could Benefit from Quarterback Change
Tony DeAngelo

Suffers Lower-Body Injury Tuesday
Aaron Rodgers

Mike McCarthy Would Welcome an Aaron Rodgers Reunion
Emmitt Finnie

Enters Concussion Protocol
Ryan Fox

a High-Upside Value in Houston
Barrett Hayton

Sustains Upper-Body Injury Tuesday
Dak Prescott

Remains Egregiously Undervalued
Marco Penge

a Boom-or-Bust Option in Houston
Cedric Coward

Returns From Three-Game Absence
CeeDee Lamb

Cowboys' Offensive Cohesion Could Lead to Another Big Year from CeeDee Lamb
Jaylen Wells

Won't Play Against Spurs
NFL

Jeremiyah Love Does Not Participate at Notre Dame Pro Day
Ty Jerome

Unavailable Wednesday
Brice Sensabaugh

Resting on Wednesday
Kyle Filipowski

Dealing With Illness, Unlikely to Play Wednesday
Jakob Poeltl

Could Miss Another Game Wednesday
Immanuel Quickley

Questionable Wednesday
Puka Nacua

Accused of Biting a Woman, Making Antisemitic Remarks
Aaron Rai

Looks to Bounce Back in Houston
Luther Burden III

Ascending Into Major Role on Offense?
Jason Day

a Volatile Option at the Texas Children's Houston Open
Joe Mixon

Remains a Free Agent as April Approaches
Kirby Yates

Angels Place Kirby Yates on 15-Day Injured List
Elijah Moore

Eagles Sign Elijah Moore to a One-Year Deal
Harris English

Eyes a Bounce-Back at the Texas Children's Houston Open
Ben Griffin

Looks for Turnaround at the Texas Children's Houston Open
Kirk Cousins

an Option as Backup Quarterback in Green Bay?
Zach Wilson

Saints Sign Zach Wilson to a One-Year Deal
Rickie Fowler

Brings Strong Form Into Texas Children's Houston Open
Brandon Clarke

to Miss Rest of Season
Ja Morant

Done for the Season
Brady Tkachuk

Collects Two More Points on Tuesday
Royce O'Neale

Available Tuesday Night
Grayson Allen

Cleared for Action Tuesday
Martin Necas

Scores Twice Against Penguins
Brandon Ingram

Questionable for Wednesday's Game
Ryan Dunn

Won't Play Against Nuggets
Paul George

Officially Available Wednesday
Nick Lodolo

Will Open 2026 on the Injured List Due to Finger Ailment
Pete Crow-Armstrong

Agrees to Six-Year, $115 Million Extension With the Cubs
John Collins

is Returning on Wednesday
Jordan Miller

is Questionable for Wednesday's Game
Bennedict Mathurin

is Returning on Wednesday
Kawhi Leonard

is Uncertain for Wednesday's Game
Kyle Kuzma

Carries Questionable Tag for Wednesday
Bobby Portis

is Tagged as Questionable for Wednesday
Kevin Porter Jr.

to Miss Fourth Straight Game
Igor Chernyshov

Returns to Sharks Lineup
Dylan Larkin

Good to Go Tuesday
Ross Colton

Logan O'Connor, Ross Colton Available Tuesday
Morgan Rielly

Back in Action Tuesday
Joel Eriksson Ek

Kirill Kaprizov, Joel Eriksson Ek Returning Tuesday
Thomas Chabot

to Be "Out a While"
Evgeni Malkin

Out Against Avalanche Tuesday
Joe Flacco

Reaches Agreement to Return to Bengals
Marvin Mims Jr.

Now a Trade Candidate in Denver?
Francisco Lindor

Likely to be Ready for Opening Day
Ryan Gerard

Can Continue Rolling at Texas Children's Houston Open
Pierceson Coody

Bounces Back at Valspar Championship
Rasmus Hojgaard

Trying to Get Back on Track at Texas Children's Houston Open
Michael Thorbjornsen

Playing Well Heading to Texas Children's Houston Open
Harry Hall

Looking for Consistency at Texas Children's Houston Open
Brooks Koepka

Continues Building Momentum
Odell Beckham Jr.

Plans to Play in 2026
RJ Harvey

Ready for a Year 2 Jump?
Baker Mayfield

Buccaneers Expected to Discuss Extension With Baker Mayfield This Offseason
Brian Robinson Jr.

Falcons to Sign Brian Robinson Jr.
Roki Sasaki

to Stick in Rotation Despite Spring Struggles
Kevin McGonigle

Makes Tigers Opening Day Roster
Scottie Scheffler

Withdraws From Texas Children's Houston Open
James Reimer

Picks Up Victory Against Rangers
Ryan Pepiot

Placed on Injured List to Open the Season
J.J. Wetherholt

JJ Wetherholt Likely to Hit Leadoff on Opening Day
Connelly Early

to Make First Start on Sunday
Luke Clanton

Might Have a Problem in Houston
Sam Stevens

Happy to See Houston This Week
Keith Mitchell

Tries to Rebound After The Players Championship
Will Zalatoris

Returning This Week at Houston
Wyndham Clark

Trending in the Wrong Direction Heading to Houston
Shane Lowry

Seeking Better Luck in Houston This Weekend
Kurt Kitayama

Poised to Bounce Back at the Houston Open
Pete Crow-Armstrong

Cubs, Pete Crow-Armstrong Finalizing Long-Term Extension
Shane Pinto

Opens Scoring Versus Rangers
Blake Snell

Targeting a May Return
Hunter Greene

Reds Place Hunter Greene on 60-Day Injured List
J.J. Wetherholt

JJ Wetherholt Makes Cardinals Opening Day Roster
Nick Pivetta

to Start on Opening Day for Padres
Brandon Woodruff

Makes Brewers Opening Day Rotation
Zack Wheeler

to Start Rehab Assignment on Saturday
Carson Benge

Makes Mets Opening Day Roster
Seiya Suzuki

to Start the Season on the Injured List
Lerone Murphy

Suffers His First Loss
Dennis Santana

Won't be Pirates' Primary Closer
Movsar Evloev

Edges Out Lerone Murphy
CFB

Notre Dame Ranks No. 1 in Returning Production for 2026
Michael Aswell

Jr. Drops Decision At UFC London
Michael Aswell

Luke Riley Outclasses Michael Aswell Jr.
Sam Patterson

Suffers Unanimous-Decision Loss
Michael Page

Wins Lackluster Decision
Austen Lane

Suffers First-Round TKO Loss
Iwo Baraniewski

Delivers 28-Second TKO
Lawson Crouse

Picks Up Three Points in Overtime Win
Filip Forsberg

Takes Predators Past Blackhawks
Alex Ovechkin

Scores 1,000th Career Goal
Tyler Reddick

Overcomes Adversity for Fourth Victory of the Season At Darlington
Brad Keselowski

Falls Short of Darlington Victory Despite Domination
Ryan Blaney

Recovers From Pit-Road Struggles to Score Career-Best Darlington Finish
Carson Hocevar

Rallies to Finish Fourth at Darlington
Kyle Larson

Decent Performance Ends with Technical Issues At Darlington
Tyler Reddick

the Clear Favorite at Darlington
Kyle Larson

a High-Risk, High-Reward Driver at Darlington
Ryan Blaney

Is Getting Better at Darlington
NASCAR

Bubba Wallace Not Slowing Down at Darlington
Chris Buescher

Should be a Top-10 Contender at Darlington
Austin Cindric

a Sleeper at Darlington
Erik Jones

Quickest in Practice at Darlington
Denny Hamlin

Qualifies Ninth for this Week's Cup Race at Darlington
Chase Briscoe

Is One of the Top DFS Options of the Week for Darlington
William Byron

Is William Byron A Playable DFS Option for Darlington Lineups?
Christopher Bell

Could Christopher Bell be Considered A Decent DFS Option for Darlington?
Chase Elliott

Is Chase Elliott Worth Rostering At Darlington This Week For DFS?
Joey Logano

May Not Have the Speed to Warrant A Darlington DFS Lineup Spot
Ross Chastain

Should DFS Players Trust Ross Chastain at Darlington?
Kyle Busch

Could Kyle Busch Be A Worthy DFS Option for Darlington?
Brad Keselowski

May be A Contriarian DFS Tournament Option At Darlington
Lerone Murphy

Set For UFC London Main Event
Movsar Evloev

Looks To Remain Unbeaten
Michael Aswell

Jr. An Underdog At UFC London
Luke Riley

Set For UFC London Co-Main Event
Sam Patterson

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Michael Page

Set For Welterweight Bout
Austen Lane

In Dire Need Of Victory
Iwo Baraniewski

A Favorite At UFC London
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF