👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE CHAMP
X
or
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X
or

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 1 TNF? DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, Jalen Tolbert Outlooks

DeVonta Smith - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Who should I start for Week 1? Fantasy football outlooks for DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, Jalen Tolbert. Our expert fantasy football start 'em, sit 'em picks.

The 2025 NFL season kicks off with a bang on Thursday night as the Philadelphia Eagles square off against the Dallas Cowboys in a prime-time divisional showdown. Beyond the playoff implications that come with every NFC East matchup, fantasy managers will have their eyes locked on the wide receiver talent taking the field. With high-powered passing attacks on both sides, this game has the potential to deliver fireworks and plenty of tough lineup decisions.

Three players in particular stand out heading into Week 1: DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, and Jalen Tolbert. Smith enters the season looking to build off another strong campaign as Philadelphia’s dynamic No. 2 option, while Pickens makes his highly anticipated debut in Dallas after leaving Pittsburgh’s struggling offense behind. Tolbert, meanwhile, comes off a breakout 2024 season but now faces increased competition for targets with Pickens added to the mix. All three receivers will play critical roles for their teams, but their fantasy outlooks for this opener couldn’t be more different.

With the Eagles boasting one of the league’s stingiest secondaries and the Cowboys reshuffling their passing game around Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and Pickens, fantasy managers face some tough choices. Can Smith repeat last year’s success against Dallas? Will Pickens hit the ground running in his Cowboys debut? Can Tolbert carve out enough volume to stay fantasy-relevant in a crowded offense? Let’s break down each wideout’s Week 1 outlook.

Should I Start DeVonta Smith for Fantasy Football Week 1?

The Philadelphia Eagles open their 2025 campaign in prime time, facing the rival Dallas Cowboys on Thursday night. Wideout Smith will be a key player to watch after torching Dallas in both meetings last season. Across those contests, Smith totaled eight receptions for 134 yards and two touchdowns, consistently finding ways to exploit mismatches in coverage.

This year’s matchup tilts even more in Smith’s favor with the Cowboys adjusting to life without their top pass-rusher. That absence should give Jalen Hurts more time in the pocket, allowing Philadelphia to push the ball downfield. Expect Trevon Diggs to spend most of his snaps shadowing A.J. Brown, leaving newcomer Kaiir Elam as Smith’s likely assignment. Elam arrives from Buffalo with length and athleticism, but he remains untested against a route runner as polished as Smith.

If Dallas rolls extra coverage toward Smith, it could open things up elsewhere, but the Eagles will still scheme their third-year star plenty of opportunities. Fantasy managers should treat Smith as a strong flex option with legitimate WR2 upside in this divisional clash.

 

Should I Start George Pickens for Fantasy Football Week 1?

Pickens enters 2025 with a fresh opportunity, joining the Dallas Cowboys after three uneven seasons in Pittsburgh. Despite flashes of brilliance, he was often held back by a stagnant Steelers passing attack that ranked just 27th in the league last year. Even so, Pickens managed 59 receptions for 900 yards, showcasing his big-play ability in tough circumstances.

In Dallas, the outlook is much brighter. The Cowboys finished with the league’s 11th-ranked passing offense in 2024 despite Dak Prescott missing nine games. With Prescott back healthy and CeeDee Lamb commanding attention on the other side, Pickens should benefit from softer coverage and more consistent quarterback play.

Week 1 presents a difficult test against an Eagles defense that allowed a league-best 174.2 passing yards per game in 2024. However, Philadelphia’s pass rush was far from dominant, ranking middle of the pack with just 41 sacks and a 17.9% pressure rate. That could give Prescott enough time to find his new weapon.

Fantasy managers should view Pickens as a safe flex or low-end WR2 play in Week 1, with long-term upside as a breakout candidate in this high-volume offense.

Should I Start Jalen Tolbert for Fantasy Football Week 1?

Tolbert enters 2025 coming off a breakout season in Dallas, where he posted 49 receptions for 610 yards and a team-leading seven touchdowns. While he carved out a consistent role last year, the Cowboys’ offseason addition of Pickens clouds his path to targets in what suddenly looks like a crowded passing attack.

Tolbert will continue to start alongside Lamb and Pickens, but his weekly fantasy value hinges on volume. With tight end Jake Ferguson heavily involved near the goal line, Tolbert’s red-zone opportunities may be further limited. That leaves him in a precarious spot as the potential odd man out in Prescott’s pecking order.

The matchup doesn’t do him any favors, either. The Eagles pass defense was among the NFL’s toughest in 2024, holding opponents to a league-best 174.2 passing yards per game. Unless Dallas schemes specifically to get Tolbert involved, his ceiling in Week 1 feels capped.

Fantasy managers should keep Tolbert rostered in deeper leagues, but touchdown dependency makes him a risky play against Philadelphia. Safer alternatives like Wan'Dale Robinson, Marquise Brown, or Cedric Tillman offer more upside for opening week lineups.

Who Should I Start Tool

Not sure who to start? Check out the Who Should I Start tool:

Who Should I Start for 10?

Compare up to four players and we'll tell you who to start...

 
Player 1
 
Player 2
 
Player 3
 
Player 4
Who To Start?
Reset

Choose From The Top Ranked Players
Overall
QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DST
Rookies
1.
 
 
2.
 
 
3.
 
 
4.
 
 
5.
 
 
6.
 
 
7.
 
 
8.
 
 
9.
 
 
10.
 
 
11.
 
 
12.
 
 
13.
 
 
14.
 
 
15.
 
 
16.
 
 
17.
 
 
18.
 
 
19.
 
 
20.
 
 
21.
 
 
22.
 
 
23.
 
 
24.
 
 
25.
 
 
26.
 
 
27.
 
 
28.
 
 
29.
 
 
30.
 
 

 

Who Should I Start? Who Should I Sit? Some common Week 1 fantasy football lineup decisions are regarding players like DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, and Jalen Tolbert outlooks. But not to worry, we are here to help make these decisions and build winning lineups in Week 1. Set your optimal fantasy football lineups for Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season. Our free Who Should I Start? tool will help make your fantasy football lineup decisions. Compare up to four NFL players, and we tell you who to start ... all free! Get your winning lineups set, and make the right decisions.

Week 1 Player Decisions. Today's focus is on specific players -- DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, and Jalen Tolbert. These are some of the most common searches for fantasy football lineups in Week 1.

Using The Tool. This is a simple tool but very powerful. The first step is to enter the player names that you want to compare. In the first box, search for the first player's name. In the second box, search for the second player's name. Compare up to four NFL players at once, and then click the Who To Start? button to see who the recommended starts are based on weekly fantasy football matchups.

Improvements For Who Should I Start? You may have noticed that our Who Should I Start? tool has gotten an overhaul. We've added lots of great features for you to give you as much information as possible to win your fantasy football matchups each week. You'll see NFL player tiles with headshots and bye weeks, enhanced search results with data to compare, and a slick new interface. We hope you enjoy!

How It Works. Each week, our RotoBaller staff puts together their weekly fantasy football rankings and projections based on their research. That information is the core data that is powering the decision-making in this tool. When you search for player names, you will only see those players who are ranked. If someone is out for the week, they will not appear in the search results.

Scoring Formats. Fantasy football managers play in various types of leagues, and this tool allows you to choose whether it's PPR scoring, half-PPR scoring, or standard (non-PPR) scoring. The second thing you want to do is to select the scoring format. There are three small radio buttons (small circles), so click on the scoring format you prefer. The results may vary based on the scoring format you select.

Popular Week 1 Searches. Curious to see some tough lineup decisions for Week 1 (2025)? Below you will find a list of some popular Who Should I Start? searches that RotoBaller readers are looking at this week. Click any of the links to see the result and recommendation.

 

Popular Week 1 Searches - Start/Sit Player Comparisons

Below are some popular Week 1 searches and comparisons from our 'Who To Start' tool for DeVonta Smith, George Pickens, and Jalen Tolbert compared to others:

George Pickens
vs
Rashee Rice
George Pickens
vs
Garrett Wilson
George Pickens
vs
Brock Bowers
George Pickens
vs
DJ Moore
George Pickens
vs
Nico Collins
George Pickens
vs
Jameson Williams
George Pickens
vs
George Kittle
George Pickens
vs
Ollie Gordon II
George Pickens
vs
Tetairoa McMillan
George Pickens
vs
Chase Brown
George Pickens
vs
Parker Washington
George Pickens
vs
Ashton Jeanty
George Pickens
vs
Drake London
George Pickens
vs
Jalen Coker
George Pickens
vs
Christian Watson
George Pickens
vs
Tony Pollard
George Pickens
vs
Matthew Golden
George Pickens
vs
Breece Hall
George Pickens
vs
Chris Olave
George Pickens
vs
Tyler Warren
George Pickens
vs
Emmett Johnson
George Pickens
vs
Trey McBride
George Pickens
vs
Malik Nabers
George Pickens
vs
Stefon Diggs
George Pickens
vs
Jonathan Taylor
George Pickens
vs
Isaiah Likely
George Pickens
vs
Zay Flowers
George Pickens
vs
Travis Kelce
George Pickens
vs
Derrick Henry
George Pickens
vs
Sam Laporta
George Pickens
vs
Bhayshul Tuten
George Pickens
vs
Blake Corum
George Pickens
vs
Kyren Williams
George Pickens
vs
Woody Marks
George Pickens
vs
Justin Jefferson
George Pickens
vs
Dalton Kincaid
George Pickens
vs
Tee Higgins
George Pickens
vs
Zach Charbonnet
George Pickens
vs
Chuba Hubbard
George Pickens
vs
Jadarian Price
George Pickens
vs
Javonte Williams
George Pickens
vs
Cam Skattebo
George Pickens
vs
Amon-Ra St. Brown
George Pickens
vs
DK Metcalf
George Pickens
vs
Jaylen Warren
George Pickens
vs
Rachaad White
George Pickens
vs
Ja'Marr Chase
George Pickens
vs
Quinshon Judkins
George Pickens
vs
James Cook III
George Pickens
vs
Deebo Samuel Sr.
George Pickens
vs
CeeDee Lamb
George Pickens
vs
KC Concepcion
George Pickens
vs
Bijan Robinson
George Pickens
vs
Harold Fannin Jr.
George Pickens
vs
Jaxon Smith-Njigba
George Pickens
vs
Hunter Henry
George Pickens
vs
Christian McCaffrey
George Pickens
vs
Denzel Boston
George Pickens
vs
Jahmyr Gibbs
George Pickens
vs
Travis Etienne Jr.
George Pickens
vs
Tucker Kraft
George Pickens
vs
Jakobi Meyers
George Pickens
vs
Braelon Allen
George Pickens
vs
Aaron Jones Sr.
George Pickens
vs
Wan'dale Robinson
George Pickens
vs
Jordan Mason
George Pickens
vs
Tyler Higbee
George Pickens
vs
Germie Bernard
George Pickens
vs
Chig Okonkwo
George Pickens
vs
Rico Dowdle
George Pickens
vs
Adonai Mitchell
George Pickens
vs
A.J. Brown
George Pickens
vs
Demario Douglas
George Pickens
vs
Antonio Williams
George Pickens
vs
Jordyn Tyson
George Pickens
vs
Ryan Flournoy
George Pickens
vs
Tank Dell
George Pickens
vs
Khalil Shakir
George Pickens
vs
Keenan Allen
George Pickens
vs
Omar Cooper Jr.
George Pickens
vs
Caleb Douglas
George Pickens
vs
Josh Downs
George Pickens
vs
Tre Tucker
George Pickens
vs
Jordan Watkins
George Pickens
vs
Malik Washington
George Pickens
vs
Konata Mumpfield
George Pickens
vs
Mack Hollins
George Pickens
vs
Keon Coleman
George Pickens
vs
Laquon Treadwell
George Pickens
vs
Quentin Johnston
George Pickens
vs
Demarcus Robinson
George Pickens
vs
Devaughn Vele
George Pickens
vs
Reggie Virgil
George Pickens
vs
Tutu Atwell
George Pickens
vs
Xavier Hutchinson
George Pickens
vs
Savion Williams
George Pickens
vs
Xavier Worthy
George Pickens
vs
Malachi Fields
George Pickens
vs
Kayshon Boutte
George Pickens
vs
Elic Ayomanor
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Luke McCaffrey
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Israel Abanikanda
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Dareke Young
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Theo Wease Jr.
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jordan James
Jalen Tolbert
vs
J. Michael Sturdivant
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Rasheen Ali
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Ronnie Rivers
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tyler Conklin
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Mark Redman
Jalen Tolbert
vs
LaJohntay Wester
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tay Martin
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Isaiah Davis
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Charlie Jones
Jalen Tolbert
vs
DeeJay Dallas
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Ian Thomas
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Derius Davis
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Andrew Armstrong
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jalen Reagor
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Dylan Laube
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Julius Chestnut
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tahj Brooks
Jalen Tolbert
vs
David Moore
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Elijah Sarratt
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Xavier Restrepo
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Xavier Smith
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Malachi Corley
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Mitch Tinsley
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Nikko Remigio
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Brandon Johnson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Josh Allen
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Brycen Tremayne
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Brock Purdy
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Ameer Abdullah
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Joe Burrow
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jaleel McLaughlin
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Drake Maye
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Camden Brown
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Dak Prescott
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Greg Dortch
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tyler Shough
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Dare Ogunbowale
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Trevor Lawrence
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Cody White
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jared Goff
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Teagan Quitoriano
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Patrick Mahomes II
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Will Kacmarek
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jayden Daniels
Jalen Tolbert
vs
DJ Giddens
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jordan Love
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Colbie Young
Jalen Tolbert
vs
C.J. Stroud
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jake Briningstool
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Bryce Young
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Charlie Woerner
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Kirk Cousins
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Isaiah Bond
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Aaron Rodgers
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jeremy Ruckert
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Geno Smith
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jacob Cowing
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Deshaun Watson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jackson Hawes
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Matthew Stafford
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Ben Sinnott
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jacoby Brissett
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Oscar Delp
Jalen Tolbert
vs
J.J. McCarthy
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jaxon Smith-Njigba
Jalen Tolbert
vs
CeeDee Lamb
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Ja'Marr Chase
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Amon-Ra St. Brown
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tee Higgins
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Justin Jefferson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Zay Flowers
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Malik Nabers
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Chris Olave
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Matthew Golden
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Christian Watson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Drake London
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Parker Washington
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Tetairoa McMillan
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Nico Collins
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Rashee Rice
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Garrett Wilson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
DJ Moore
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jameson Williams
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jalen Coker
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Stefon Diggs
Jalen Tolbert
vs
DK Metcalf
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Deebo Samuel Sr.
Jalen Tolbert
vs
KC Concepcion
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Denzel Boston
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Jakobi Meyers
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Wan'dale Robinson
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Germie Bernard
Jalen Tolbert
vs
Adonai Mitchell
Jalen Tolbert
vs
A.J. Brown

More Fantasy Football Analysis



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP