Is Keon Coleman or Khalil Shakir the WR1 for the Bills?

May 7, 2024

Will rookie Keon Coleman take over the No. 1 wide receiver role in Buffalo? Will Khalil Shakir make a leap? Justin Pottinger breaks it down.

The question of who claims the coveted title of WR1 carries substantial weight, especially within the dynamic offense of the Buffalo Bills and superstar quarterback Josh Allen. Amidst the roster shuffle and strategic planning, the debate intensifies between rookie Keon Coleman and Khalil Shakir about who emerges as the premier pass-catching threat for the Bills.

With his imposing size, impressive athleticism, and raw talent, Coleman represents a tantalizing prospect for Buffalo. At the same time, Khalil Shakir brings a combination of polished route running, sure hands, and versatility to the forefront, vying for the spotlight in the Bills' aerial attack.

This article aims to dive into the skill sets, potential roles within the Bills' offensive scheme, and the intricacies of their competition, offering insights into the ultimate determination of who truly embodies the role of WR1 for the Buffalo Bills. Let's check it out.

Who is the Buffalo Bills' WR1?

As the Bills chart their course in pursuit of championship contention, the comparison between Coleman and Shakir ignites fervent discussions among fans and analysts. While Coleman's potential for dominance looms large, Shakir's reliability and adaptability present a compelling case for his ascent to WR1 status. With no more Stefon Diggs or Gabe Davis on the roster, the Bills are searching for their new WR1. 

Last season, Shakir saw 39 receptions for 611 yards and two touchdowns as the WR3 for Josh Allen. A few highlight plays were seen from Shakir, who is ready to take his career leap and will see many targets regardless of who emerges as the WR1. For Coleman, the Bills selected the talented wide receiver in the second round of Florida State. This is a player that I am very excited for, and he could be one of the best rookies in 2024.

Which of these two wide receivers will become the team's No. 1 option? It should be expected that Shakir will begin the season as Allen's first option, but as Coleman develops throughout the year, I'm not surprised that he will emerge as the best wideout on the team.

Keon Coleman is a national treasure

pic.twitter.com/GgxrRoJ2G5

— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) April 30, 2024

Who Should I Draft in Fantasy Football?

Both wide receivers should bring plenty of value to fantasy football this season, but I suggest drafting Keon Coleman between the two options. Coleman could be one of the best rookies this season, and being paired with Josh Allen is a dream come true for him. His current ADP on Sleeper is 126 overall, which is incredible value for a wide receiver who could see over 90 receptions this season. 

Keon Coleman on if his “you can’t cover me” mindset will remain going up against the best DBs in the NFL,

“Of course, cause we’re in the same league. We both had to do the same thing. Make a play and kill one another. So the best man gonna win.” @keoncoleman6 #BillsMafia… https://t.co/TGEUgHnEXP pic.twitter.com/Er6ZpOjpkX

— Robert Griffin III (@RGIII) May 1, 2024

More Fantasy Football Analysis