X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Real Deal or Impostor: Why Dickey, Revere and Duffy Are Solid Waiver Wire Pickups for 2015

 

Three Players Who Should Carry Over Their 2014 Success

Is that guy on waivers a flash in the pan or the final piece you need to win your league? In this weekly column, we will examine underlying numbers in order to determine whether a given player is the real deal at his current pace - positive or negative - or if he is an imposter due for a significant regression (either way). With that said, 2-3 games worth of data is hardly a sufficient sample to do this (Adrian Gonzales will not hit over 200 HR), so this first article will look at three players that many are convinced will regress from their 2014 numbers.

Spoiler alert: all three should be able to sustain their recent performance, for reasons that can (and should) be applied to other players throughout this season.

 

Danny Duffy, SP, KC

Many are leery of Duffy's sterling 2.53 ERA last season due to his significantly higher Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP) of 3.83. In general, FIP factors out luck - most notably hits on balls in play - to determine a pitcher's true skill level. Duffy's .239 BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) was exceptionally low last year. While Duffy's true skill level may be less than last year's performance, there are reasons to expect that he will be able to outperform it again.

Duffy is an extreme flyball pitcher - 46% of batted balls against him were in the air last year - which gives him a BABIP advantage in that flyballs generally record the lowest BABIPs of any batted ball type. The downside is an increased risk of HR leaving the yard on all of those flies, but Duffy has Kauffman Stadium to keep many of them within the bounds of play. His 6.1% HR/FB rate last season was favorable, but the ballpark should help keep it that way.

Since the flies will stay in play, Duffy will trust his defense to convert those flies into outs - and the unit behind him is worthy of trust. Alex Gordon's LF defense makes him a sabermetric darling, recording an insanely strong 27 DRS (Defensive Runs Saved) in 2014. Centerfielder Lorenzo Cain's 24 DRS was nearly as good. Newcomer Alex Rios may seem like a risk to let Duffy down with a -3 DRS last season, but that actually represents an improvement from Nori Aoki's -8 DRS a year ago. The unit is strongest when Jarrod Dyson fills the last OF slot (14 DRS in limited playing time), and there are whispers that he may do so more often in 2015. The fact that nearly all of Duffy's flies found leather last season is not the result of unsustainable luck but the natural result of these outfielders doing what they do, making it likely to repeat.

Duffy's below average line drive rate rate (18.1% a year ago) will likely normalize to a league average 21% mark this year, but the outfield should help mitigate the damage. Duffy's ERA is due for a slight uptick to the low three range, which is still good enough to be a fantasy asset in the category. If you can stream him in only favorable venues, the value he provides should be even greater than that. BABIP for pitchers can be repeatable if the defense behind him is good enough.

Also applies to: Any KC flyball pitcher, pitchers for PIT and TB (whose frequent shifts give them an edge), and anyone lucky enough to call Andrelton Simmons a teammate.

 

Ben Revere, OF, PHI

Contrary to popular belief, the Phillies are still a major league team. They do not have many MLB caliber players, but Revere is one. His 49 SB last season approached Billy Hamilton's 56 mark, with Revere posting a much better success rate (8 CS to 23). While Revere is a good base thief willing to hit the ball on the ground (64.7% GB rate in 2014) to reach first and swipe second, he is not usually mentioned in the same breath as Hamilton. Yet he arguably outperformed him last year and should do so again this year. Why? The division he plays in.

The NL East also includes the Braves, Nationals, Marlins, and Mets - teams the Phillies will play 19 times each due to the unbalanced schedule in 2015. This is extremely favorable for a base stealer like Revere, as two of those teams employ the worst catchers (minimum 900 innings caught) by CS%: Miami's Jarrod Saltalamacchia and New York's Travis d'Arnaud, each of whom managed to throw out only 19% of would be base thieves in 2014. Salty led the majors in SB allowed, implying that teams were more willing to run on him due to his difficulties in controlling the running game. d'Arnaud should expect similar treatment in 2015. Revere gets 38 games to pad his speed totals against this pair, and there is no reason he should not run wild. Daily leaguers should note that both teams have backups that can shut down an opponent's legs, Jeff Matthis (33% CS) and Anthony Recker (37% CS). Still, the NL East is likely to produce a SB champion this year.

Also applies to: Whoever sees more playing time out of Eric Young Jr. and Cameron Maybin in Atlanta's OF, Denard Span when he comes off of the DL.

 

R.A. Dickey, SP, TOR

Who wouldn't want to root for a knuckleballer? Like Duffy, Dickey's 3.71 ERA last season was not supported by his 4.32 FIP, leading many to predict regression. Toronto's defense is not stellar, but Dickey has another factor in his favor. When Voros McCracken initially proposed that pitchers have no control over what happens after a ball is put into play, everyone tried to disprove his radical theory, including Bill James. They failed to do this, hence why FIP exists, but they did discover that "there was a slight tendency for knuckleballers to control hits per balls in play" (p. 239, Moneyball). Dickey is the exception to the rule of FIP by virtue of the mercurial pitch he throws.

In 2013, Dickey's ERA (4.21) was better than his FIP (4.58). In his Cy Young 2012, the ERA (2.73) again surpassed the FIP (3.27). There is a clear trend here. This trend goes beyond Dickey. Tim Wakefield surpassed 200 innings five times in his career, producing the following ERA and FIP numbers:

SEASON ERA FIP
1996 5.14 5.63
1997 4.25 4.69
1998 4.58 4.88
2003 4.09 4.07
2005 4.15 4.75

The only time FIP is lower than ERA is 2003, and it is only by two hundredths of a run and goes away if expected FIP (xFIP) is used (4.31). Wakefield clearly supports the trend. So does everyone's favorite Hall of Fame knuckleballer, Phil Niekro. In 21 full seasons, Niekro's ERA was higher than his FIP all of four times, with the fourth being his final season ugly by any metric.

Some predict Dickey will regress due to age, but knuckleballers are the only commodity in baseball that could routinely last well into their 40s before steroids provided "help." Consider the example of Hall of Famer Ted Lyons, who posted back-to-back career high strikeout rates in his age 38 and 39 seasons throwing the knuckleball. Unless you think Lyons had modern steroids in 1939 or 1940, Dickey can pitch indefinitely. Dickey is also Tommy John proof, as he has no UCL in his pitching elbow and therefore is biologically incapable of tearing it.

Ultimately, Dickey's value is determined by league format. If IP are inherently valuable, Dickey could be among the best pitchers in the format. All of the innings allow him to compile Ks and Ws even if IP are not worth anything. If an innings cap is in place, Dickey's mediocre rate stats are less appealing, but there is no reason he can't repeat last year, or even 2012 in a pitcher's park. Don't discount Dickey because of FIP or age, as the knuckleball trumps both.

Also applies to: Steven Wright, BOS

Not only can these three players repeat last year despite naysayers, the reasons behind their continued success can be applied to others throughout the campaign.

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Jadon Janke

Signs With Green Bay
Cameron Smith

May Not Be Worth The Risk At Quail Hollow
Jaylen Brown

Jayson Tatum Injury: Fantasy Basketball Impact and Boston Celtics Team Outlook After Torn Achilles
Joaquin Niemann

A Strong Play At Quail Hollow
Stephen Curry

Cleared For Light On-Court Work
Sam Hauser

Returns To Action Wednesday
Patrick Cantlay

2025 PGA Championship Power Rankings: Top 10 Players To Watch
Evan Bouchard

Relishes Series-Clinchers
Ben Joyce

Expected To Miss Rest Of Season After Shoulder Surgery
Jalen Chatfield

Good To Go For Thursday's Game 5
Brandon Saad

Not Expected To Return In Round 2
Ryan Weathers

Activated And Starting On Wednesday
Mark Stone

Doubtful For Game 5 Wednesday
Evan Rodrigues

Won't Play On Wednesday
Oliver Ekman-Larsson

Good To Go Wednesday
PGA

Sungjae Im Could Be Someone To Watch At Quail Hollow
Jordan Spieth

Spencer Aguiar's Top One And Done Picks To Consider - The PGA Championship (Premium Content)
Max Homa

Still Not Trustworthy Ahead Of PGA Championship
Joaquin Niemann

TeeOffSports' PGA DFS Rankings Wizard In-Tournament FanDuel Model Included - The PGA Championship (Premium Content)
Jrue Holiday

NBA DFS Targets for 5/14/25 (Premium Content)
Jalen Royals

Inks Rookie Deal With Chiefs
Dalton Rushing

Dodgers Calling Up Dalton Rushing
Hendon Hooker

"Off To A Good Start" In QB2 Competition
PGA

TeeOffSports' PGA DFS Rankings Wizard In-Tournament Model (Wednesday Update) - The PGA Championship (Premium Content)
Quintin Morris

Jaguars Signing Tight End Quintin Morris
Elgton Jenkins

Skipping Offseason Workouts, Seeking New Deal To Move To Center
Bryce Miller

Mariners Place Bryce Miller On 15-Day Injured List With Elbow Inflammation
Josh Jacobs

Looks "Better" This Offseason
Jason Day

Looking To Continue Success At Quail Hollow
Sam Burns

A Shaky Play At Quail Hollow
Derrick Henry

Ravens Agree On Two-Year Extension
NFL

Vikings To Host Lions On Christmas Day
Daniel Berger

Looking To Capture First Major At Quail Hollow
NFL

Super Bowl Rematch Will Come In Week 2
NFL

Chiefs To Face Cowboys On Thanksgiving Day
Bubba Watson

Spencer Aguiar's Vegas Report - PGA Betting and DFS Picks for The PGA Championship (Premium Content)
Gabe Davis

Giants Host Gabe Davis On A Visit
NFL

Packers-Lions To Face Each Other In Week 1
Brian Harman

Market Movers - PGA Championship Matchups to Consider (Premium)
Jacoby Brissett

Dynasty Fantasy Football Risers and Fallers - May 2025 Market Report and Rankings
Justin Rose

DraftKings Core Four: PGA DFS - 2025 PGA Championship (Premium Content)
Patrick Reed

DraftKings PGA DFS Lineup Picks - The PGA Championship Advice (2025)
Jordan Spieth

Looks To Complete Career Grand Slam At Quail Hollow
Derek Carr

"Extremely Unlikely" To Make A Comeback
Rory McIlroy

All Eyes Are On Rory McIlroy At Quail Hollow
Jon Rahm

Fits Quail Hollow Well On Paper
Keegan Bradley

A Reliable Option At Quail Hollow
Will Zalatoris

Enters PGA Championship With Major Concerns
Justin Thomas

Peaking At The Right Time For PGA Championship
Donovan Mitchell

Scores Game-High 35 Points In Tuesday's Loss
Tyrese Haliburton

Returns To Form In Closeout Game
Jamal Murray

Tallies 28 Points In Game 5 Loss
Nikola Jokić

Nikola Jokic Ends Shooting Slump In Game 5
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Leads Team With 31 Points In Comeback Victory
DeAndre Hopkins

Assembling the Greatest Fantasy Football Teams Ever (2025 Edition)
Stephen Curry

Officially Ruled Out For Game 5
Tetairoa McMillan

Should I Draft Kyle Williams or Jack Bech? 2025 Dynasty Rookie Draft Analysis
Anthony Stolarz

Back On The Ice
Josh Morrissey

Extends Assist Streak
Nikolaj Ehlers

Scores Lone Jets Goal Tuesday
Thomas Harley

Continues Home Point Streak
Jason Robertson

Grabs First Postseason Point
Mikael Granlund

Nets First Playoff Hat Trick
Derek Carr

Tyler Shough, Chris Olave, Rashid Shaheed Fantasy Football Outlooks: Post-Derek Carr Retirement
Stephen Curry

NBA DFS: Top Daily Fantasy Expert Picks for DraftKings, FanDuel (5/14/25)
Dylan Cease

Strikes Out 10 In No-Decision On Tuesday
Daulton Varsho

Homers Twice, Drives In Four On Tuesday
Javier Báez

Javier Baez Hits Two Homers With Walk-Off Tuesday
Josh Jung

Hits Two Homers, Plates Four Tuesday
Roki Sasaki

Dodgers Place Roki Sasaki On Injured List With Shoulder Impingement
NHL

NHL DFS Picks and Heat Map (Premium Content) - May 14, 2025
Clayton Kershaw

Set For Season Debut Saturday
Roki Sasaki

Could Be A Candidate For The IL
Sam Hauser

Expected To Play On Wednesday Night
Evan Rodrigues

Practices On Tuesday
Las Vegas Raiders

Raiders Sign Rookie Darien Porter
Oliver Ekman-Larsson

Misses Practice Due To Illness
Calvin Pickard

Not Expected To Return In Round 2
Mattias Ekholm

Could Be Available For Conference Finals
Keith Cooper Jr.

Inks Rookie Deal With Lions
Connor Hellebuyck

Starts Game 4 Against Stars
Colston Loveland

Overvalued Fantasy Football Rookies: 5 Draft Avoids in 2025
Jake Oettinger

Seeks Another Home Win Tuesday
Baltimore Ravens

Kaimon Rucker Signs With Baltimore
Miro Heiskanen

Set To Return Tuesday
MLB

MLB Reinstates Pete Rose, Shoeless Joe Jackson From Ineligible List
Jayson Tatum

Tears Achilles, Undergoes Successful Surgery
Corey Seager

Officially Goes Back On Injured List
Max Scherzer

Now Dealing With Back Tightness
Ben Lively

Guardians Place Ben Lively On 15-Day Injured List
Oswaldo Cabrera

Placed On 10-Day Injured List With Fractured Ankle
Jason Foley

To Have Season-Ending Shoulder Surgery
Yandy Díaz

Rays Place Yandy Diaz On Restricted List Due To Passport Issue
Yordan Alvarez

Won't Come Off Injured List On Tuesday
MLB

Cardinals-Phillies Postponed On Tuesday
MLB

Twins-Orioles Game Postponed On Tuesday
Draymond Green

NBA DFS Targets for 5/13/25 (Premium Content)
Alex Ovechkin

Ends Goal Drought With Power-Play Marker
Jonathan Kuminga

Leads Warriors in Scoring Monday Night
Anthony Edwards

Scores 30 Points With Six Triples In Game 4 Win
Julius Randle

Continues To Excel Against Warriors
Mikal Bridges

Does It All For Knicks In Game 4 Victory
Jalen Brunson

Leads Knicks With 39 Points Monday Night
Jayson Tatum

To Undergo MRI Tuesday
Aaron Gordon

NBA DFS: Top Daily Fantasy Expert Picks for DraftKings, FanDuel (5/13/25)
Jack Della Maddalena

Becomes The New UFC Welterweight Champion
Belal Muhammad

Outclassed At UFC 315
Manon Fiorot

Drops Decision At UFC 315
Valentina Shevchenko

Defends Title
José Aldo

Jose Aldo Retires After UFC 315 Loss
Aiemann Zahabi

Extends His Win Streak
Alexa Grasso

Loses Back-To-Back Fights
Alexa Grasso

Natalia Silva Outclasses Alexa Grasso
Kyle Prepolec

Submitted In His UFC Return
MMA

Benoit Saint-Denis Gets Back In The Win Column
Ryan Blaney

Holds Strong For A Top-Five Finish At Kansas
William Byron

Struggles At Kansas With An Underwhelming Finish
Chase Briscoe

Scores A New Career-Best Cup Finish At Kansas
Denny Hamlin

Mechanical Issues Ruin Denny Hamlin's Promising Kansas Performance
Alex Bowman

Puts Together A Strong Top-Five Finish At Kansas
Ryan Preece

Earns His First Career Top-10 Finish At Kansas
Christopher Bell

Finishes Second In Otherwise Subpar Day For Toyota
Chris Buescher

Has Decent Run At Kansas, But Teammates Outperform Him
Josh Berry

Despite Qualifying Error And Speeding Penalty, Josh Berry Finishes Sixth
Joey Logano

Despite Joey Logano's Complacency, Penske Cars Fast Enough For Top-10 Finish
Tyler Reddick

Once Again Inexplicably Mediocre At One Of His Better Tracks
Brad Keselowski

Crashes Out At Kansas But Shows First Hint Of Speed
Kyle Larson

Could Embarrass The Field At Kansas
Tyler Reddick

Should Be Fast At Kansas
Denny Hamlin

Has Been Phenomenal At Kansas in Next Gen Car
Ryan Blaney

Expect Ryan Blaney To Obtain Another Quality Kansas Finish
Chris Buescher

May Be One To Watch At Kansas
William Byron

Is Among The Top Favorites To Win At Kansas
NASCAR

Should DFS Players Roster Bubba Wallace At Kansas?
Christopher Bell

Qualifies Third For This Week's Kansas Race
Austin Cindric

May Be A Great And Sneaky DFS Pick For Kansas
Belal Muhammad

Set For His First Title Defense
Jack Della Maddalena

Has A Chance To Become UFC Champion
Manon Fiorot

Looks To Become The New Champion
Valentina Shevchenko

Set For UFC 315 Co-Main Event
Aiemann Zahabi

Looks For His Sixth Win In A Row
José Aldo

Jose Aldo Set For Featherweight Bout
Natalia Silva

Looks To Extend Her Win Streak
Alexa Grasso

Returns At UFC 315
Kyle Prepolec

Set For UFC 315 Main-Card Opener
Benoît Saint Denis

Benoit Saint Denis Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF