Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Pickups & Streamers
Rookies & Call-Ups
News and Alerts

Jose Ramirez Rankings Debate: Comparing RotoBaller's Rankers

It's the fantasy baseball draft season. To us baseball nerds, few things are more exciting than arguing about player rankings. Today, we'll discuss and compare Jose Ramirez's RotoBaller staff rankings. He was ranked No. 40 overall by Jeff Kahntroff, and No. 106 by Brad Johnson.

Throughout this series, we'll be using our February Staff Rankings to debate where to draft certain players. In cases where our writers had discrepancies, we've asked them to explain their rankings. These debates will provide us with some well-rounded analysis, and help identify undervalued/overvalued draft picks.

Editor's note: Check out our previous rankings debates on Trea Turner, J.D Martinez, Nelson Cruz, Jose Abreu, and Bryce Harper.


2017 Draft Rankings Debate: Jose Ramirez

Jeff Kahntroff's Rankings Analysis

His Overall Ranking: 40

In 152 games last year, Jose Ramirez posted a .312/11/84/76/22 line with 46 doubles at 23 years old. He played at least five games at SS, 3B, 2B, and OF, which are the league settings we are using for our rankings. While his frame does not suggest massive power, and his spray chart reveals a lot of doubles of the type we would not expect to turn into homers necessarily (sharp ground balls, line drives), due to his age, he is likely to hit the ball in the air slightly more and hit for more power. We could easily see a .300/15/90/85/20 line, putting him way closer to my ranking (40) than Brad’s (106). If you think I’m being too optimistic, let’s compare Ramirez’s Steamer projections to six players who Brad rated much higher:

Name (Brad’s Rank) Positional Eligibility (5 or more games) 2017 Steamer AVG HR + SB RUNS + RBIs
Xander Bogaerts (18) SS .296/17/82/78/9 0.296 26 160
Francisco Lindor (27) SS .290/15/81/76/16 0.291 31 157
Christian Yelich (40) OF .294/16/80/72/12 0.294 28 152
Kyle Seager (43) 3B .268/24/75/82/4 0.268 28 157
Matt Carpenter (44) 1B/2B/3B .268/18/86/70/4 0.268 22 156
Jason Kipnis (47) 2B .267/14/82/67/13 0.267 27 149
AVG (36.5) One position 0.281 27 155
Jose Ramirez (106) 2B/SS/3B/OF .287/11/69/65/20 0.287 31 134
% Difference 300% 2% 15% -16%

Ramirez beats the average player by 2% in average, 15% in homers plus steals, and loses by 16% in run production. At worst, Steamer views him as equal to the average player. Moreover, Ramirez leads all these players in projected steals, which are more valuable than homers; in 2016, there were more than twice as many homers than steals.

This is before addressing Ramirez’s positional eligibility. In daily leagues, we have often faced the issue of having to bench a player who is playing but have an open spot at another position due to positional restrictions. Moreover, we’ve been forced to settle for a lesser player on the waiver wire due to positional needs. Having a player like Ramirez who can play multiple positions allows you to get value elsewhere, with much less positional restrictivity, and allows you to maximize your games played. It may even allow you to carry an extra pitcher, say a dominant setup man off the waiver wire, to get your rate stats down. All these factors show that Brad has Ramirez ranked way too low.


Brad Johnson's Rankings Analysis

His Overall Ranking:106

During the December round of rankings, I had Ramirez placed much much higher. In fact, I ranked him...(*checks desktop, checks online backups, sees December top 500 rankings were overwritten by February, shrugs). Well, I don't remember. Point being, I really like Ramirez as a versatile, quality draft target for all the reasons Jeff cites.

When I built those December rankings, they were completely innocent of ADP data. Instead, they were purely a combination of statistical analysis, projections, and gut instinct. By now I've done a dozen industry mocks. It's time to incorporate ADP. One player I got very wrong was Ben Zobrist. I over-ranked him by nearly 60 picks. I wasn't much better with Ramirez. He's consistently chosen between picks 100 and 110.

If you're in need of some utility, there's nothing wrong with bumping him up a round or two. In a 12 team draft, that means taking him in the seven or eighth round instead of the ninth. He has enough talent to support that valuation. Jeff is suggesting you take him in the middle of the fourth round. Not only is that a slight reach on his talent, it's also leaving value on the table. Because there is a very large chance you can select him several rounds later.

I'll note one thing about ADP - your draft platform matters. I haven't checked where Yahoo! or ESPN ranked Ramirez. If they're saying he's the 40th pick, then he'll be somewhere around the 40th pick. In behavioral economics, they call that "anchoring."


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Pickups & Streamers
Rookies & Call-Ups
News and Alerts


Andrei Svechnikov15 mins ago

Doesn't Play Tuesday Due To Illness
Zach Hyman20 mins ago

Misses Tuesday's Game With Illness
Mark Giordano26 mins ago

To Miss Extended Time After Blocking Shot Off Hand
Jonathan Taylor27 mins ago

Undergoing Thumb Surgery Wednesday
Dougie Hamilton34 mins ago

Leaves Game Early Tuesday, Undergoing Evaluation
Kenneth Walker III35 mins ago

Unlikely To Play In Week 13?
Jacob Markstrom42 mins ago

Back At Practice Wednesday
Aaron Rodgers1 hour ago

Jets Open Practice Window For Aaron Rodgers
New England Patriots2 hours ago

Patriots Not Ready To Name Starting Quarterback
Baker Mayfield2 hours ago

Expected To Be Full-Go On Sunday
Filip Forsberg3 hours ago

Maintains Momentum With Game-Winner
Seth Jarvis3 hours ago

Continues Hot Spell With Ninth Goal
Connor McDavid3 hours ago

Notches Three Points In Tuesday's Win
Jake Oettinger3 hours ago

Posts First Shutout Of Season
Brock Boeser3 hours ago

Hits Two Goals In Tuesday's Win
Michael Carcone3 hours ago

Nets Two Goals Against Tampa Bay
Jamal Murray3 hours ago

Considered Questionable Wednesday
Kelly Olynyk4 hours ago

Questionable Wednesday
Jordan Clarkson4 hours ago

Questionable For Wednesday's Action
DeSean Jackson4 hours ago

Calling It A Career
Trey Murphy4 hours ago

III Listed As Doubtful Wednesday
Jonathan Isaac4 hours ago

Questionable For Wednesday
Cam Reddish4 hours ago

Likely Returning For Lakers On Wednesday
Anthony Davis4 hours ago

Probable On Wednesday
Mathew Barzal13 hours ago

Has Three-Point Night In Loss
Dylan Cease13 hours ago

Dodgers "Among Most Aggressive" Teams For Dylan Cease
Jack Hughes13 hours ago

Contributes With Three Points In Victory
Shohei Ohtani13 hours ago

Yoshinobu Yamamoto "Above All Other Options" For Giants
Akira Schmid14 hours ago

Picks Up Victory In Relief Appearance
Miami Dolphins14 hours ago

Dolphins Signing Jason Pierre-Paul
Juan Soto14 hours ago

"Almost Certain To Be Traded"
Cody Bellinger14 hours ago

Earns NL Comeback Player Of The Year Award
Liam Hendriks14 hours ago

Earns AL Comeback Player Of The Year Award
Anthony Beauvillier14 hours ago

Blackhawks Acquire Anthony Beauvillier
LeBron James16 hours ago

Uncertain For Wednesday
Draymond Green16 hours ago

Returning On Tuesday
CJ McCollum16 hours ago

Tagged As Questionable For Wednesday
Zach LaVine16 hours ago

Won't Return On Tuesday
Nikola Jokic17 hours ago

Listed As Questionable For Wednesday
Lauri Markkanen17 hours ago

To Miss Next Two Games
Keon Ellis17 hours ago

Available On Tuesday
Pat Connaughton17 hours ago

Won't Return Tuesday
Jackson Chourio19 hours ago

Brewers Discussing Deal With Top Prospect Jackson Chourio
Wendell Carter19 hours ago

Jr. Seen At Practice, Still Out Wednesday
Kevin Durant19 hours ago

Practices, Grayson Allen Absent Tuesday
Zach LaVine19 hours ago

Alex Caruso Both Active Against Celtics
Jrue Holiday20 hours ago

Derrick White Both Good To Go Tuesday
Fred VanVleet20 hours ago

Ready To Roll Against Mavericks
LaMelo Ball20 hours ago

Likely Facing Extended Absence
Aaron Rodgers20 hours ago

Not Ready To Play Yet
Kenneth Walker III20 hours ago

Trending Toward Missing Another Game
Jake Walman20 hours ago

To Return On Wednesday
Radko Gudas20 hours ago

Out Of Commission On Tuesday
Thomas Chabot20 hours ago

Expected Back On Friday
Matt Martin21 hours ago

Available Again On Tuesday
Curtis Lazar21 hours ago

Returns To Action Tuesday
Brandon Tanev21 hours ago

Out On Tuesday
Jonathan Taylor22 hours ago

To Have Surgery, Hoping To Return In 2-3 Weeks
Justin Jefferson24 hours ago

Vikings To Activate Justin Jefferson From Injured Reserve On Tuesday
Jonathan Taylor24 hours ago

Could Go On Injured Reserve
Tyler Glasnow1 day ago

Cubs In Trade Talks For Tyler Glasnow
Shane Bieber1 day ago

Cubs, Reds Looking At Shane Bieber
Kenny Pickett1 day ago

Experiencing "Ankle Discomfort"
Jonathan Taylor1 day ago

Status In Doubt Going Forward
Joshua Dobbs2 days ago

Vikings Considered Benching Joshua Dobbs Late On Monday Night
T.J. Hockenson2 days ago

Lifts Fantasy Output With Late Score
Joshua Dobbs2 days ago

Comes Back Down To Earth On MNF
Jason Heyward2 days ago

Reportedly Re-Signs With Dodgers Monday
Kenneth Walker III2 days ago

Listed As DNP Monday
Joe Burrow2 days ago

Undergoes Successful Surgery Monday
Tee Higgins2 days ago

Bengals Hope Tee Higgins Can Return In Week 13
Quentin Johnston2 days ago

Should Practice This Week
Lucas Giolito2 days ago

Dodgers Interested In Lucas Giolito This Offseason
Steven Matz2 days ago

Available Via Trade
Tyler Glasnow2 days ago

Reds Showing Interest In Tyler Glasnow
Alex Bregman2 days ago

Could Be Moved This Offseason
Dylan Cease2 days ago

Braves In Talks For Dylan Cease
Jason Heyward2 days ago

Close To Re-Signing With Dodgers
Sonny Gray2 days ago

Cardinals Finalizing Three-Year Deal
Kenta Maeda3 days ago

Agrees To Two-Year Deal With Tigers
Johan Oviedo4 days ago

To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
Anthony Rizzo5 days ago

Doing "Great"
Shohei Ohtani5 days ago

At Least Seven Teams Linked To Shohei Ohtani
Jordan Montgomery5 days ago

Still On Rangers Radar