X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Fantasy Value In a 50-Game Season: Starting Pitchers

Having now passed the ides of June, there is still no start date for the 2020 season and no guarantee that we'll even ever get one. MLB and the MLBPA continue to pass proposals back and forth, with each side taking their turn at rejection. This puts baseball in a situation where Commissioner Rob Manfred is likely to unilaterally imposed a season length of his own determination, a power given to him in the original March agreement between baseball and the player's union.

All signs seem to point to around a 50-game season being the number that Manfred is most likely to land on, as that's the number of games that owners have said they can financially manage, given the player's insistence on getting the fully prorated salaries they had already agreed to. A 50-game season will have none of the subtlety, with no time to iron out the randomness inherent to the game. With only less than a third of a season, statistics (and their fantasy value) will run to extremes that just aren't usually seen. Lots of suspect pitchers can run elite ratios for 10 starts and stumble their way into a relative pile of wins. For example, after the first 50 games of 2019, Zach Davies was the 10th-most valuable starter in fantasy and Zach Eflin was #22. Marcus Walden was the #3 reliever and John Gant was #5.

Let's look back at the first 50 games in 2019 and see if there will be any strategies for the small-sample carnival that appears likely in 2020. We'll begin with the starting pitchers.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

Methodology For a 50-Game Season

We obviously don't have any precedent for a pandemic-shortened 50-game season. Even in a strike-shortened 1994 season, teams still played around 115 games and plenty of pitchers still had a sample size of innings that allowed more confidence in their numbers. It was a different game and all but 40 pitchers still managed over 150 IP and 37 finished with double-digit wins. And let us never forget that in just 115 games, Greg Maddux had a 1.56 ERA in 202 innings. Praise be to Maddux.

To get a more exact picture of how extreme samples in just 50 games could get, I determined the player values for a standard 12-team 5x5 Roto league using only the first 50 games played in 2019. I used the first 50 games, as opposed to the last 50 because even though the season wouldn't be starting until mid-July, players will still be at the beginning of their season in terms of hitters having seen major league pitching and vice-versa. Using the last 50 games I think would be judging players on the time after they'd been able to make adjustments that they won't have time to make in 2020.

With these "full-season" stats, I then used a standard z-score treatment for assigning dollar-values to each player. Note that this was an attempt to determine the best 108 pitchers and 154 position players in a standard league, not serve as a hindsight draft guide. So while more players than these would've been on rosters, these are the players who finished above replacement-level.

Z-scores (or zed-scores, as my Canadian friends call them) are a popular statistical tool used to assign fantasy value by judging how far away from average a player's particular stat is. The actual number of strikeouts a pitcher has doesn't matter; what matters is how that number compares to that of his peers. In other words, having 300 strikeouts isn't that great if everyone else averages 295 strikeouts.

After calculating and totaling the z-scores for each category (putting the rate categories on a scale that properly accounts for the number of innings pitched/plate appearances) I made positional adjustments and translated the totals to dollar-values. The dollar values were determined using a typical budget of $260 per team, with a 67-33 hitter/pitcher split.

 

50 Game Leaderboard

Included with stats and fantasy values from the first 50 games, are each player's overall and positional rankings, as well as 2019 ADP the difference between ADP and final rankings. Of the 108 best pitchers in our hypothetical season, 58 were starters. Here are their rankings after 50 games, as well as their final starting pitcher ranking in 2019 according to the Fangraphs auction calculator:

ADP 50 G Rank 2019 Rank Name $ VAL IP W SO ERA WHIP
20.9 1 1 Justin Verlander 32.1 72 8 89 2.24 0.73
180.2 2 6 Hyun-Jin Ryu 27.8 59 6 59 1.52 0.74
469.6 3 16 Mike Soroka 20.7 45 5 41 1.01 0.87
65.6 4 4 Zack Greinke 20.7 72 6 67 2.89 0.87
318.0 5 19 Chris Paddack 20.3 51 4 56 1.93 0.76
115.4 6 17 Luis Castillo 19.9 64 5 78 2.38 1.04
162.6 7 21 Tyler Glasnow 19.7 48 6 55 1.86 0.91
430.6 8 24 Domingo Germán 19.7 55 9 57 2.60 0.98
367.1 9 31 Mike Minor 17.7 71 5 72 2.55 1.13
669.4 10 62 Zach Davies 16.3 53 5 36 1.54 1.18
117.7 11 8 Charlie Morton 16.2 60 5 77 2.54 1.16
459.6 12 22 Jake Odorizzi 16.0 53 6 52 2.38 1.06
59.3 13 7 Stephen Strasburg 15.8 72 4 87 3.25 0.99
317.2 14 73 Matthew Boyd 15.2 67 4 80 3.11 1.01
566.2 15 15 Lucas Giolito 14.4 52 6 59 2.77 1.06
70.0 16 33 José Berríos 13.8 70 7 64 3.20 1.15
600.8 17 48 Max Fried 13.8 56 7 51 2.88 1.12
438.1 18 70 Caleb Smith 13.0 56 3 72 3.05 0.96
137.0 19 9 Shane Bieber 13.0 64 3 79 3.11 1.05
29.9 20 67 Blake Snell 12.8 56 3 78 3.07 1.01
652.5 21 23 Frankie Montas 12.6 54 5 52 2.67 1.13
308.8 22 102 Zach Eflin 12.4 62 5 47 2.76 1.15
80.3 23 80 German Marquez 12.2 72 5 72 3.38 1.11
702.7 24 61 Jordan Lyles 12.1 51 5 53 2.81 1.09
49.4 25 18 Patrick Corbin 12.0 64 4 76 3.25 1.10
132.4 26 92 Masahiro Tanaka 11.1 64 3 58 2.94 1.12
666.9 27 182 Martin Perez 11.0 58 7 56 2.95 1.33
293.9 28 45 Luke Weaver 10.3 57 3 62 3.14 1.06
5.4 29 10 Max Scherzer 10.1 71 2 96 3.41 1.18
745.0 30 30 John Means 9.7 44 5 34 2.68 1.10
582.6 31 Matt Shoemaker 9.5 29 3 24 1.57 0.87
24.1 32 2 Gerrit Cole 9.0 66 4 100 4.11 1.08
308.4 33 27 Brandon Woodruff 8.9 56 6 65 3.51 1.22
56.4 34 11 Clayton Kershaw 8.4 46 4 44 3.33 0.98
127.6 35 25 Kyle Hendricks 8.0 62 4 54 3.34 1.18
730.6 36 43 Chris Bassitt 7.6 36 2 44 2.48 1.07
717.3 37 157 Spencer Turnbull 7.3 54 2 54 2.68 1.30
181.4 38 192 Yusei Kikuchi 7.3 60 3 49 3.43 1.08
192.0 39 127 José Quintana 7.3 57 4 54 3.30 1.22
203.8 40 28 Kenta Maeda 7.1 51 5 52 3.51 1.19
11.0 41 3 Jacob deGrom 7.0 58 3 75 3.72 1.14
332.7 42 44 Marcus Stroman 7.0 64 2 55 2.81 1.34
205.6 43 138 Jon Lester 6.9 47 3 47 2.68 1.32
151.1 44 91 Cole Hamels 6.9 59 4 60 3.38 1.26
31.2 45 76 Trevor Bauer 6.6 71 4 80 3.95 1.17
55.0 46 34 James Paxton 6.0 38 3 52 3.11 1.19
123.4 47 65 Robbie Ray 5.9 53 3 67 3.25 1.35
38.6 48 12 Walker Buehler 5.5 49 4 46 3.83 1.05
98.3 49 81 David Price 5.2 41 2 46 3.29 1.07
451.1 50 68 Wade Miley 5.0 56 4 37 3.51 1.17
324.2 51 177 Trevor Williams 5.0 54 2 42 3.33 1.13
437.1 52 26 Jeff Samardzija 4.7 52 2 41 3.27 1.17
279.0 53 69 Julio Teheran 4.4 61 3 62 3.67 1.26
654.8 54 122 Jerad Eickhoff 4.4 39 2 38 3.23 1.13
660.4 55 149 Tyler Mahle 3.6 51 1 54 3.51 1.17
266.7 56 66 Marco Gonzales 3.5 62 5 45 3.65 1.35
91.7 57 38 Madison Bumgarner 3.3 68 3 70 4.10 1.19
211.4 58 148 Jake Arrieta 1.9 62 4 51 3.77 1.37

Did you know that Yusei Kikuchi had earned more after 50 games than Jacob deGrom? The eventual NL Cy Young winner dwarfed Kikuchi in strikeouts (75 K to 49 K) and they both had three wins but Kikuchi narrowly edged deGrom in both the ratio categories. Is this just a funny anamoly or can we we learn anything?

Before we get there, let's also look at the important players who failed to qualify. Here are the remainder of the pitchers who were within the top-300 of ADP but weren't in the top-108 of earnings after 50 games. In addition to their 2019 ADP and 50-game stats, are the eventual starting pitcher ranks for the entirety of the season according to the Fangraphs auction calculator:

2019 ADP 2019 Rank Name IP W SO ERA WHIP
13.9 40 Chris Sale 56 1 83 4.31 1.08
25.0 46 Aaron Nola 58 5 66 4.53 1.54
29.1 132 Corey Kluber 36 2 38 5.80 1.65
36.9 106 Carlos Carrasco 52 4 66 4.30 1.22
38.9 71 Noah Syndergaard 69 3 72 4.93 1.25
59.5 5 Jack Flaherty 54 4 58 4.19 1.25
61.0 13 Mike Clevinger 12 1 22 0.00 0.50
65.1 85 Jameson Taillon 37 2 30 4.10 1.13
87.1 54 Zack Wheeler 63 3 70 4.74 1.37
97.9 83 Miles Mikolas 62 4 46 4.76 1.17
121.6 89 Mike Foltynewicz 27 0 17 6.91 1.35
133.8 152 Chris Archer 41 1 40 5.75 1.55
143.2 115 J.A. Happ 58 4 50 5.16 1.30
143.5 35 Yu Darvish 55 2 67 5.40 1.62
151.5 156 Nick Pivetta 18 2 16 8.35 2.13
152.8 37 Eduardo Rodriguez 55 4 61 5.43 1.46
166.5 168 Rick Porcello 57 3 47 4.45 1.31
176.3 194 Kyle Freeland 52 2 46 6.02 1.43
177.4 214 Nathan Eovaldi 21 0 16 6.00 1.52
184.2 39 Rich Hill 27 1 31 2.67 1.07
194.9 59 Joey Lucchesi 48 3 46 4.28 1.26
199.1 63 Jon Gray 60 4 66 4.62 1.34
208.3 53 Ross Stripling 38 2 37 3.05 1.10
209.8 74 Joe Musgrove 59 3 45 4.27 1.15
212.6 84 Dallas Keuchel Inj
213.7 105 Andrew Heaney Inj
233.1 161 Kevin Gausman 48 2 50 4.31 1.25
238.7 94 Collin McHugh 45 3 48 6.04 1.23
239.9 78 Tyler Skaggs 41 4 40 5.01 1.40
247.6 90 Steven Matz 45 3 45 3.63 1.37
260.6 170 Zack Godley 41 1 35 7.90 1.78
266.5 184 Jhoulys Chacin 50 3 36 4.65 1.31
267.3 29 Julio Urias 28 2 32 3.18 1.09
272.0 14 Sonny Gray 50 1 57 3.78 1.22
276.2 137 Kyle Gibson 50 4 51 4.47 1.25
280.9 166 Michael Wacha 47 3 43 5.59 1.69
286.3 124 Alex Wood Inj
289.5 57 Anibal Sanchez 42 0 41 5.10 1.68
297.1 186 Reynaldo Lopez 60 3 57 6.03 1.56

Parsing through the above lists isn't about trying to gain insight about the stats themselves, or the players that could be helped or hurt by a hot or cold start in a shortened 2020. This is about seeing if there are any strategies that can be identified in the patterns of where value flowed to. Excepting saves, let's go category by category.

 

Wins

Ahh, the category that is both the most fickle and the least indicative of skill. One pitcher had nine wins through 50 games, one had eight wins, and three had seven wins. Of the 40 pitchers drafted inside the top-500 who finished below-replacement, only Aaron Nola (5) had more than four wins. Domingo German had a terrific ERA but his nine wins were a big part of him finishing as SP 6.

I think wins in a short-sample world will be even more disproportionally weighted. When we get to relievers, we'll talk about how I think this call for a more aggressive bullpen strategy but for now, there are some takeaways for evaluating starters in a shortened season.

Bump Up

  • Strong offense - A lot of wins are going to come from backend starters on good teams. Or above-average teams facing a relatively easy schedule. Martin Perez wasn't a superstar in 2019 but he was backed by the league's best offense and he picked up wins against Toronto, Seattle, and Cleveland, with two against Baltimore.
  • Strong Bullpens - Ask Zack Greinke if there was a difference in going from Arizona to Houston. And good relievers will protect leads for average pitching just as they will for the aces.
  • Going Deep - The longer you're in the game, the better chance you have to pick up the win. And the more efficient you are with your batters, the longer you'll potentially stay in the game. Simply put, we want the horses. Here are the top-25 pitchers in 2019 in terms of average innings per start (min. 10 starts). Also included is the average number of batters faced per innings and the accompanying rank:
Name GS W IP IP/GS rank TBF/IP rank
Justin Verlander 34 21 223 6.56 1 3.80 2
Mike Minor 32 14 208 6.51 2 4.14 42
Gerrit Cole 33 20 212 6.43 3 3.85 3
Shane Bieber 33 15 212 6.43 4 4.01 14
Max Scherzer 27 11 172 6.38 5 4.02 16
Jacob deGrom 32 11 204 6.38 6 3.94 7
Stephen Strasburg 33 18 209 6.33 7 4.02 17
Clayton Kershaw 28 16 177 6.33 8 3.96 11
Zack Greinke 33 18 209 6.32 9 3.88 4
Lance Lynn 33 16 208 6.31 10 4.20 56
Zack Wheeler 31 11 195 6.30 11 4.24 77
Hyun-Jin Ryu 29 14 183 6.30 12 3.96 9
Trevor Bauer 34 11 213 6.26 13 4.28 90
Jose Berrios 32 14 200 6.26 14 4.20 58
German Marquez 28 12 174 6.21 15 4.14 43
Noah Syndergaard 32 10 198 6.18 16 4.17 49
Sandy Alcantara 32 6 197 6.17 17 4.25 78
Mike Leake 32 12 197 6.16 18 4.24 76
Patrick Corbin 33 14 202 6.12 19 4.13 40
Ryan Yarbrough 14 3 86 6.12 20 3.97 12
Madison Bumgarner 34 9 208 6.11 21 4.06 25
Lucas Giolito 29 14 177 6.09 22 3.99 13
Walker Buehler 30 14 182 6.08 23 4.04 22
Mike Soroka 29 13 175 6.02 24 4.01 15
Mike Clevinger 21 13 126 6.00 25 3.96 10

Bump Down

  • Bad Offense - We must of course drop the inverses of the attractive situations from above. It's always hard to pick up wins when you're backed by a poor offense but every win will be that much more important in a shortened season and good pitchers on bad teams are getting dinged more in my book.

Here are the 20 pitchers taken inside the top-200 in 2019 who didn't finish above-replacement level after 50 games, along with how their team offenses were ranked in April/May:

19 ADP Name Tm W IP OPS Rank wOBA Rank
13.9 Chris Sale BOS 1 56 9 8
25.0 Aaron Nola PHI 5 58 17 19
29.1 Corey Kluber CLE 2 36 26 26
36.9 Carlos Carrasco CLE 4 52 26 26
38.9 Noah Syndergaard NYM 3 69 19 18
59.5 Jack Flaherty STL 4 54 16 16
61.0 Mike Clevinger CLE 1 12 26 26
65.1 Jameson Taillon PIT 2 37 24 23
87.1 Zack Wheeler NYM 3 63 19 18
97.9 Miles Mikolas STL 4 62 16 16
121.6 Mike Foltynewicz ATL 0 27 14 14
133.8 Chris Archer PIT 1 41 24 23
143.2 J.A. Happ NYY 4 58 7 6
143.5 Yu Darvish CHC 2 55 4 4
152.8 Eduardo Rodriguez BOS 4 55 9 8
166.5 Rick Porcello BOS 3 57 9 8
176.3 Kyle Freeland COL 2 52 6 7
184.2 Rich Hill LAD 1 27 3 3
194.9 Joey Lucchesi SDP 3 48 23 24
199.1 Jon Gray COL 4 60 6 7
  • Bad Bullpens and Defenses - Whether streaming, drafting, or trading, I'm not messing around with average pitchers backed by subpar pitchers coming in behind them. Please tell me more about all of the wins that the Angels bullpen will hang on to for the starters...I'll wait. And whoever thought to pair an atrocious Mets defense with a rotation full of pitch-to-contact pitchers, could you please stand up? Now please imagine all of New York simultaneously booing you.

 

Strikeouts

Elite strikeout rates are like warm and fuzzy security blankets in fantasy. Not only are they incredibly reliable from year to year but they are often the saving grace when pitchers go through rough patches in the other fantasy categories. When the ratios are running high and the wins have been dry, at least you'll always have the K's.

In a shortened season, however, there won't be as many games for differences in strikeout rates to prove to a be a separating factor in the final tally. Being as consistent as it generally is, elite k-rates are a grinding force compared to lesser rates. With every game that passes, the bigger the gap in strikeouts becomes. But with only 50 games, there just isn't enough time for the gaps to become canyons.

Take a look at the top-25 earnings from strikeouts in our mini-2019, along with their starting pitcher rank and ERA earnings rank. What seemed to contribute more to the overall value?

Name SO Rank SP Rank ERA Rank
Gerrit Cole 1 31 71
Max Scherzer 2 28 35
Justin Verlander 3 1 3
Stephen Strasburg 4 12 27
Chris Sale 5 60 81
Matthew Boyd 6 14 21
Trevor Bauer 7 39 68
Shane Bieber 8 18 26
Luis Castillo 9 4 5
Blake Snell 10 23 30
Charlie Morton 11 10 9
Patrick Corbin 12 24 33
Jacob deGrom 13 43 60
Noah Syndergaard 14 86 114
Mike Minor 15 9 6
Caleb Smith 16 22 29
German Marquez 17 19 34
Zack Wheeler 18 85 105
Madison Bumgarner 19 55 70
Zack Greinke 20 3 11
Robbie Ray 21 46 39
Yu Darvish 22 113 125
Carlos Carrasco 23 59 80
Aaron Nola 24 81 90
Jon Gray 25 78 97

Of the 25-highest strikeout earners, only five finished as top-10 pitchers and they all had ERA earnings that were as good or better than from strikeouts. On the other hand, seven finished outside of the top-50. Strikeouts by themselves will not save you and we won't be able to go by Bed, Bath, and Beyond either. There just won't be enough time.

 

Mitigating the Risks

Don't think I'm saying to avoid high strikeout pitchers. That would be silly. I'm only saying to be aware that they won't have the difference-making fantasy effect of year's past. Besides being aware, can anything else be done?

  • One Trick Ponies - I'm downgrading pitchers whose carrying trait is their whiffery if they could be dicey everywhere else. In a full season, I'm fine risking an ERA near four with Dinelson Lamet because of the power of his 30%+ K-rate. Not so much in one-third of a season.
  • Purge the Walkers - Pitchers with questionable walk-rates are also going to take a hit in my book. If your K-BB% is held aloft by a lot more K thank lack of BB, I'll be treading lightly. Rooo-bbie Ray!... Do not come on down!
  • No Homers Allowed - Once again, the more valuable strikeouts are, the more warts high-K guys can get away with having. And having a homer problem when strikeouts are cheaper and each earned run will count against you more than ever, is a big wart to have. It's hard to make me say something bad about Matthew Boyd but what if the homer issue from last year (1.89 HR/9 overall, 2.30 HR/8 in the second half) comes back in 2020? Looking at different bad stretches in his game log last season is downright terrifying. Two games with four home runs, three games with three home runs, and over two different three-game stretches, Boyd allowed a combined 8 HR. When Boyd's slinging up dingers, he does not mess around and that's the kind of volatility that I'm not keen to roster in a shortened season.

 

The Ratios

If you thought wins were important, wait until you get a hold of the ratios. Nothing in baseball is easy but lots of pitchers are capable of going on a 10-start stretch of elite ratios. And these men will be the kings of pitching in 2020 while making paupers of the rest.

Going back to z-scores for a minute, ratio stats are a hair trickier because the value isn't just about the actual number, it's about how long of a period that stat was achieved over. A 2.95 ERA over 200 IP is going to be worth more than a 1.50 ERA over 100 IP, etc.  I won't bore you with the math but calculating z-scores for ratios takes this factor into account and puts all stats on a level playing field, regardless of innings pitched.

By looking at the separate categorical z-scores, we can then determine how much of a player's value came from each category. Here again are the top starting pitchers from the first 50 games, with their ERA and WHIP, as well as their total z-score, their combined z-scores from the two categories, and what percent of that total was earned from ratios.

50 G Rank Name IP ERA WHIP zTOT zRatios Comb%
1 Justin Verlander 72 2.24 0.73 16.7 12.0 71.7%
2 Hyun-Jin Ryu 59 1.52 0.74 14.6 12.4 85.3%
3 Zack Greinke 72 2.89 0.87 10.6 8.1 76.1%
4 Luis Castillo 64 2.38 1.04 10.8 8.2 76.5%
5 Mike Soroka 45 1.01 0.87 10.8 10.1 93.5%
6 Domingo German 55 2.60 0.98 10.2 6.5 63.8%
7 Chris Paddack 51 1.93 0.76 10.1 9.2 91.3%
8 Tyler Glasnow 48 1.86 0.91 10.1 8.2 80.8%
9 Mike Minor 71 2.55 1.13 10.0 7.8 77.7%
10 Charlie Morton 60 2.54 1.16 8.9 6.4 72.2%
11 Zach Davies 53 1.54 1.18 9.3 8.8 95.1%
12 Stephen Strasburg 72 3.25 0.99 8.1 5.7 70.1%
13 Jake Odorizzi 53 2.38 1.06 8.4 6.6 78.6%
14 Matthew Boyd 67 3.11 1.01 7.8 5.7 73.3%
15 Jose Berrios 70 3.20 1.15 7.6 4.7 61.4%
16 Lucas Giolito 52 2.77 1.06 7.3 5.2 70.7%
17 Max Fried 56 2.88 1.12 7.3 5.0 68.3%
18 Shane Bieber 64 3.11 1.05 6.6 5.1 77.7%
19 German Marquez 72 3.38 1.11 6.5 4.3 65.7%
20 Zach Eflin 62 2.76 1.15 6.8 5.8 85.4%
21 Frankie Montas 54 2.67 1.13 6.6 5.4 81.3%
22 Caleb Smith 56 3.05 0.96 6.2 5.1 81.9%
23 Blake Snell 56 3.07 1.01 6.2 4.8 77.1%
24 Patrick Corbin 64 3.25 1.10 6.1 4.3 69.5%
25 Martin Perez 58 2.95 1.33 6.3 3.8 59.6%
26 Jordan Lyles 51 2.81 1.09 6.1 4.8 78.9%
27 Masahiro Tanaka 64 2.94 1.12 5.9 5.5 92.8%
28 Max Scherzer 71 3.41 1.18 5.4 3.7 67.6%
29 Luke Weaver 57 3.14 1.06 5.0 4.4 87.5%
30 Brandon Woodruff 56 3.51 1.22 4.6 2.1 46.5%
31 Gerrit Cole 66 4.11 1.08 4.0 0.9 23.4%
32 John Means 44 2.68 1.10 4.7 4.3 92.5%
33 Kyle Hendricks 62 3.34 1.18 4.1 3.4 81.1%
34 Marcus Stroman 64 2.81 1.34 4.4 4.7 106.3%
35 Matt Shoemaker 29 1.57 0.87 4.0 5.2 131.5%
36 Jose Quintana 57 3.30 1.22 3.8 3.0 79.2%
37 Spencer Turnbull 54 2.68 1.30 4.1 4.4 107.9%
38 Clayton Kershaw 46 3.33 0.98 3.5 3.2 91.7%
39 Trevor Bauer 71 3.95 1.17 3.3 1.2 36.6%
40 Cole Hamels 59 3.38 1.26 3.6 2.6 70.3%
41 Yusei Kikuchi 60 3.43 1.08 3.4 3.4 100.5%
42 Kenta Maeda 51 3.51 1.19 3.3 2.1 62.5%
43 Jacob deGrom 58 3.72 1.14 3.2 1.9 59.8%
44 Jon Lester 47 2.68 1.32 3.6 3.8 103.2%
45 Chris Bassitt 36 2.48 1.07 3.2 4.0 125.5%
46 Robbie Ray 53 3.25 1.35 3.1 2.3 72.1%
47 James Paxton 38 3.11 1.19 2.4 2.3 94.6%
48 Wade Miley 56 3.51 1.17 2.3 2.4 102.4%
49 Julio Teheran 61 3.67 1.26 2.2 1.6 71.9%
50 Walker Buehler 49 3.83 1.05 1.9 1.5 79.9%
51 Trevor Williams 54 3.33 1.13 2.2 3.1 142.2%
52 Marco Gonzales 62 3.65 1.35 2.1 1.2 56.9%
53 Jeff Samardzija 52 3.27 1.17 2.1 3.0 147.0%
54 David Price 41 3.29 1.07 1.8 2.5 140.3%
55 Madison Bumgarner 68 4.10 1.19 1.4 0.4 25.6%
56 Jerad Eickhoff 39 3.23 1.13 9.6 2.3 24.1%
57 Tyler Mahle 51 3.51 1.17 1.3 2.2 168.8%
58 Jake Arrieta 62 3.77 1.37 1.2 0.6 46.6%

You don't have to have high scores in both categories but you better nail one of them. Zach Davies wasn't the #11 starter because of his five wins (2.0 z) and 36 K (0.3 z), or even his 1.18 WHIP (o.6 z). It was because of a 1.54 ERA over 53 IP that was good for an 8.1 z that was the 4th-highest, just behind Justin Verlander's 8.2 z.

Ratios (especially ERA) are going to be the dominant fantasy force for pitchers. Why was Jacob deGrom only the #43 starting pitcher? Just three wins didn't help but it was still above the 1.7 wins that the rest of the pool averaged. His 1.18 WHIP was below the average 1.28 WHIP and deGrom's 75 K was the 13th-highest. However, while his 3.72 ERA was below the average 4.2o ERA, his 1.6 z-score was the 60th-highest among starters. And that's how you turn a top-10 draft pick into an SP4. It's not just deGrom's mediocre ERA, it's also how good everyone else's was.

 

Playing Ratio Whack-A-Mole

You're still going to draft Jacob deGrom and you're still not going to draft Zach Davies. Pointing out the above is about understanding the risks that starters will carry in a shortened season. However, can we really do anything but draft good pitchers and hope for the gods of luck to smile upon them? Sure we can!

  • Diversify Your Bonds - I'm going to want "safe" starters with less ceiling but more floor; and I'm going to want more of them. In terms of who returns the most total value, the trio of Scherzer (16 ADP), Strasburg (29 ADP), and Paddack (50 ADP) would be the favorite over Ryu (146 ADP), Hendricks (153 ADP), and Maeda (162 ADP). However, given their respective draft prices, I'd far prefer the latter group.
  • Protect Your Neck - In defense of my ratios, the bar will be lower for sitting a good pitcher with a tough matchup. You usually want to trust the process with pitchers; always start your studs and you're usually going to start your top three or four guys in a majority of their matchups. But I'll have my safety vest on this year and will be willing to send anyone to the pine. And if baseball is played in normal stadiums, I promise my pitchers will pitch zero innings at Coors. Zero. The upside won't be worth it given that just one bad start can blow an entire season of value.
  • Nothing to FAAB With - No time for waiting, no time for caution. I'm not saying to bust your bankroll early and often, but rather be more willing to gamble on (and pay for) pitchers who may be set up for any sort of hot streak. And also be ready to drop them like hot lava. Look at the below example of our poster boy, Zach Davies, if we were to jump his 2019 season forward in time to our COVID reality of 2020:

Davies started improbably, giving up just three earned runs in his first four starts. Given that starts three and four were against the Dodgers, you probably wouldn't have wanted to open the wallet then. But after he got through them with a 1.19 ERA and staring at an upcoming schedule of St. Louis, Colorado (at home) and the Mets, I'd be looking to spend big, if necessary.

I wouldn't be counting on him keeping it up all (shortened) season, I'd just be looking to squeeze whatever juice was left. Catching even a three or four-game stretch in the middle of a hot streak could be enough to earn back a large FAAB expenditure in this shortened season.

 

Wrap It Up

The statistical extremes that will come along with a shortened season will make projecting performance (and fantasy value) even more difficult than usual. We can't predict the future but that doesn't mean we need to throw our hands up and declare it all a game of chance. It just means that we have to stack every advantage we can, no matter how small.

We've covered the starters but I think relievers will have just as much potential to return excess value and could fill in any holes left by being more careful with some of the players covered above. Next time out we'll dig into the bullpen and see if there are any golden nuggets to be mined. Until then, may Maddux shine down upon all of us and bring tidings soon of a 2020 season.

More 2020 Fantasy Baseball Advice

POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Porter Hodge42 mins ago

Could See Save Opportunities
Luis García51 mins ago

Dodgers Sign Luis Garcia To Minor-League Deal
Drew Thorpe58 mins ago

Could Throw Off The Mound Next Week
Keaontay Ingram59 mins ago

Chiefs Re-Sign Keaontay Ingram
Amir Coffey1 hour ago

Ruled Out For Thursday
Joey Gallo1 hour ago

White Sox Agree To Terms With Joey Gallo
Brandon Ingram1 hour ago

Expected To Miss At Least One More Month
Germán Márquez1 hour ago

German Marquez, Antonio Senzatela, Lucas Gilbreath All Healthy
Chet Holmgren1 hour ago

Back In Action Thursday
Johan Oviedo1 hour ago

Throws Bullpen On Thursday
Anthony Edwards1 hour ago

Ready To Play Thursday
Nikola Jović2 hours ago

Nikola Jovic Available Thursday
Henry Davis2 hours ago

Takes Batting Practice On Thursday
Duncan Robinson2 hours ago

Good To Go Against Mavericks
Gary Payton II2 hours ago

Out Against Rockets
Mike Conley2 hours ago

Not Ready To Return Thursday
Rudy Gobert2 hours ago

Out On Thursday
Dante Exum2 hours ago

Cleared To Play Thursday
Bam Adebayo2 hours ago

Unavailable For Thursday Against Dallas
Klay Thompson2 hours ago

Will Not Play On Thursday
Connor Matthews2 hours ago

Opens Up UFC Vegas 102 Main Card
Kyrie Irving2 hours ago

Ruled Out Against Heat
Jose Delgado2 hours ago

Makes Debut At UFC Vegas 102
Dylan Budka2 hours ago

Searching For First UFC Win On Saturday
Edmen Shahbazyan2 hours ago

A Massive Favorite At UFC Vegas 102
Walker Kessler2 hours ago

Sidelined On Thursday
Youssef Zalal2 hours ago

Gets Ranked Opponent At UFC Vegas 102
Calvin Kattar3 hours ago

Looks To Snap Losing Streak At UFC Vegas 102
Jabari Smith Jr.3 hours ago

On Track To Return After The All-Star Break
Drew Eubanks3 hours ago

Remains Out Against Jazz
Amir Coffey3 hours ago

Questionable Thursday
Markelle Fultz3 hours ago

Will Play On Thursday Night
Jacksonville Jaguars3 hours ago

Jaguars Interview Brandon Brown For GM Position
Kenyon Martin Jr.3 hours ago

Out Against Clippers
Jordan Eberle3 hours ago

Starts Conditioning Stint In AHL
New Orleans Saints4 hours ago

Saints Request To Interview Daronte Jones For Defensive-Coordinator Job
Matthew Tkachuk4 hours ago

Enters 4 Nations Face-Off In Red-Hot Form
Clyde Edwards-Helaire4 hours ago

Saints Re-Sign Clyde Edwards-Helaire
Ben Simmons4 hours ago

Set For His Clippers Debut
Steven Adams4 hours ago

Not Listed On The Injury Report
Las Vegas Raiders4 hours ago

Maxx Crosby Progressing In Recovery From Ankle Surgery
Shea Theodore4 hours ago

Out Week-To-Week
Tank Dell4 hours ago

"On The Right Track" In His Recovery
DK Metcalf4 hours ago

Klint Kubiak Says He Has A Plan For DK Metcalf
Juuse Saros4 hours ago

Named Finland Starter For Thursday
New Orleans Saints4 hours ago

Kellen Moore Plans To Call Offensive Plays For Saints
Connor Hellebuyck4 hours ago

To Face Finland Thursday
Mikko Rantanen4 hours ago

Expected To Play On Thursday
Alvin Kamara4 hours ago

Kellen Moore High On Alvin Kamara
Julian Aguiar5 hours ago

Reds Place Julian Aguiar On 60-Day Injured List
Graham Ashcraft5 hours ago

Throws To Live Hitters
Dedniel Núñez5 hours ago

Dedniel Nunez Healthy At Spring Training
Jordan Montgomery5 hours ago

Dealing With Finger Strain
River Ryan5 hours ago

Lands On 60-Day Injured List
Clayton Kershaw5 hours ago

Expects To Open Season On 60-Day Injured List
Andre Pallante5 hours ago

Wins Arbitration Case Against Cardinals
Nolan Arenado6 hours ago

Likely To Stay With Cardinals
Jonathan Loáisiga6 hours ago

Jonathan Loaisiga Targeting End Of May
Marcus Stroman6 hours ago

Hasn't Reported To Camp
Cody Bradford7 hours ago

Rangers Could Use Cody Bradford In Relief Role
Jon Gray7 hours ago

Throws First Bullpen Session On Thursday
Robbie Ray7 hours ago

Throws Bullpen On Thursday
Jordan Montgomery7 hours ago

Drops 20-25 Pounds
NFL10 hours ago

Travis Hunter To Enter Combine As A Cornerback
Trevor Lawrence10 hours ago

"No Chance" Jaguars Will Trade Trevor Lawrence
Aaron Rodgers10 hours ago

Jets Officially Inform Aaron Rodgers They Are Moving On
James Cook11 hours ago

Seeking New Contract For $15 Million Annually
Chase Briscoe12 hours ago

Earns Toyota's First Daytona 500 Pole
Justin Allgaier12 hours ago

Attempts To Make JR Motorsports's NASCAR Cup Series Debut
Jimmie Johnson12 hours ago

Outqualifies Teammates To Advance To Daytona 500
NASCAR12 hours ago

B.J. McLeod Likely Needs Attrition To Make Daytona 500
Chandler Smith12 hours ago

Competition In First Duel Race Likely Too Stout For Chandler Smith To Make Daytona 500
Jordan Binnington14 hours ago

Earns Victory Over Team Sweden
Nathan MacKinnon14 hours ago

Scores Power-Play Goal In Victory
TOR14 hours ago

Mitch Marner Nets Overtime Winner For Team Canada
Lucas Raymond14 hours ago

Tallies Two Helpers In Overtime Loss
Sidney Crosby14 hours ago

Leads Canada To Victory
Shea Theodore15 hours ago

Out Of 4 Nations Tournament With Injury
JaQuae Jackson23 hours ago

Patriots Re-Sign JaQuae Jackson
Anthony Firkser23 hours ago

Chiefs Re-Sign Anthony Firkser To Futures Deal
C.J. Ham23 hours ago

Undergoes Ankle Surgery
Taysom Hill23 hours ago

Saints To Move On From Taysom Hill?
Dak Prescott24 hours ago

Looking To Amp Up His Rehab
Jacksonville Jaguars1 day ago

Terrance Gray Interviews For Jaguars GM Job
Tennessee Titans1 day ago

Julius Wood's Suspension Temporarily Lifted
San Francisco 49ers1 day ago

De'Vondre Campbell's Suspension Lifted
Jakob Pelletier1 day ago

Ready For Action After 4 Nations Face-Off
Dante Fabbro1 day ago

Expected To Return After 4 Nations Face-Off
Mika Zibanejad1 day ago

To Center Top Line For Sweden
Joel Eriksson Ek1 day ago

Available Wednesday
Filip Gustavsson1 day ago

Faces Canada Wednesday Night
Jordan Binnington1 day ago

To Start For Canada In 4 Nations Face-Off Opener
Sidney Crosby1 day ago

Good To Go Wednesday
Gary Woodland1 day ago

In Great Form Heading Into Genesis Invitational
Cameron Young1 day ago

Is An Interesting Play At Torrey Pines
Akshay Bhatia1 day ago

A Strong Value Play At Genesis Invitational
Sahith Theegala1 day ago

Is Riding The Struggle Bus To Torrey Pines
Justin Rose1 day ago

Looks For Redemption At Torrey Pines
Wyndham Clark1 day ago

Searching For Consistency At Torrey Pines
Sam Stevens1 day ago

Aims To Repeat Success At Torrey Pines
Harris English1 day ago

Looking To Repeat At Torrey Pines
Boone Jenner2 days ago

Expected To Return After International Break
Gustav Forsling2 days ago

Moves Past Illness, Expected To Play On Wednesday
Maverick McNealy2 days ago

A Volatile Play At Genesis Invitational
Min Woo Lee2 days ago

In Great Form Ahead Of Genesis Invitational
Viktor Hovland2 days ago

A Solid Value Play At Torrey Pines
Rasmus Hojgaard2 days ago

A Strong Play At Genesis Invitational
Scottie Scheffler2 days ago

Aims For A Strong Rebound At Torrey Pines
Collin Morikawa2 days ago

An Excellent Play At Genesis Invitational
Shane Lowry2 days ago

Back In Action At Torrey Pines
PGA2 days ago

Sungjae Im Is A Highly Volatile Play With Persuasive Upside
Russell Henley2 days ago

Torrey Pines May Be A Place To Avoid Russell Henley
Nick Taylor2 days ago

Might Not Thrive At Torrey Pines
Adam Scott2 days ago

Is A Fun Long Shot At Genesis Invitational
Andrew Novak2 days ago

Tries To Repeat Torrey Pines Success
Robert MacIntyre2 days ago

Could Be Intriguing At Genesis Invitational
MMA3 days ago

Weili Zhang Wins Decision In Co-Main Event Of UFC 312
Tatiana Suarez3 days ago

Takes Decision Loss
Justin Tafa3 days ago

Gets TKO'd At UFC 312
Tallison Teixeira3 days ago

Gets TKO Win At UFC 312
Francisco Prado3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC 312
Jake Matthews4 days ago

Gets Decision Win At UFC 312
Rodolfo Bellato4 days ago

Battles Back To Get A Draw At UFC 312
Jimmy Crute4 days ago

Fights To A Draw In Return At UFC 312
Sean Strickland4 days ago

Suffers Lopsided Decision Loss At UFC 312
Dricus Du Plessis4 days ago

Retains Middleweight Belt At UFC 312
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
Chig Okonkwo - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Cheap Dynasty Buys - Fantasy Football Trade Targets for Deeper Leagues

While the NFL season just ended, dynasty football players know it’s never too early to start planning for 2025. There are always ways to gain an edge over your league mates. Many dynasty leagues have deep benches, which can make finding players on waivers challenging. This means gamers must place a greater emphasis on trading […]


Jonnu Smith - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Five Tight Ends To Sell In Dynasty Fantasy Football Leagues

I know, I know. Your dynasty fantasy football teams are like your children. You want to hold on to the players who you've had on your roster for years. But if you want to actually win going forward, you have to sell some of those players away when the time is right. This offseason, the […]


Calvin Ridley - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL DFS Picks, Draft Sleepers

Tale of Two Seasons - Fantasy Football Wide Receiver Edition Part IV

If you’ve been following this series, you know the drill and what to expect by now. If you haven’t, we’re identifying receivers who had two significantly different splits during the course of the 2024 season. If you’d like to get caught up and read some of the other previously published editions, you can do so […]


Ashton Jeanty - NFL Draft, Fantasy Football Rookie Rankings, Draft Sleepers

2025 Fantasy Football Rookie Rankings (Pre-NFL Draft) - Ashton Jeanty, Tetairoa McMillan, Shedeur Sanders, Kaleb Johnson, Luther Burden, more

The 2025 NFL Draft will be here before you know it, and we're already thinking ahead to 2025 fantasy football drafts and rookie/dynasty drafts. Our NFL team has released its early 2025 fantasy football rookie rankings for the top 70 NFL rookies, before the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine. These 2025 rookie rankings are released before […]


Tee Higgins - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

2025 NFL Free Agency Primer: Important Dates of 2025 NFL Free Agency

Super Bowl LIX is over and the Philadelphia Eagles are the world champions for the second time in their existence as they stopped the Kansas City three-peat talk cold. After the ups and downs of another crazy season, it is time to glance ahead to the 2025 offseason and all the transactions and chaos that […]


Xavier Worthy - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Dynasty Fantasy Football Risers and Fallers - February 2025 Market Report

With the Super Bowl in the rearview mirror, it is time to look ahead to the NFL Combine and the NFL Draft. In the next couple of months, we should see plenty of movers and shakers in the fantasy football landscape, particularly dynasty leagues. This month, we have seen the market shift with the inclusion […]


Tre Harris - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks, NFL Draft

Early 2025 NFL Draft Rankings - Top Player At Each Position

The 2025 NFL Draft really isn't that far away. For fans of historically terrible teams, the draft is the best time of the year, as it instills hope that things might change. And for Dynasty fantasy managers or those extremely dialed-in who play only redraft, it's an interesting time as well. Knowing which players go […]


Xavier Worthy - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Tale of Two Seasons - Fantasy Football Wide Receiver Edition Part III

If you’ve played fantasy football for any time, you’re accustomed to seeing a player’s splits—a comparison between his stats during one period of the season vs another. This is different than a two or three-game sample. We're looking at two samples, typically consisting of six to eight games per split. Sometimes, splits can be just […]


Rome Odunze - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injuries

2025 Second-Year Breakouts: Sophomores Who Could Shine In Year Two

A 2024 season full of rookie breakouts spoiled the fantasy community. Brian Thomas Jr. (WR4), Malik Nabers (WR6), Ladd McConkey (WR12), Brock Bowers (TE1), Jayden Daniels (QB5), and Bucky Irving (RB13) excelled in their first professional seasons. That made it even more of a bummer when other big-name rookies and first-round picks didn't burst onto […]


Dylan Sampson - Fantasy Football Rankings, Dynasty, Rookie Prospects

Dynasty Fantasy Football Strategy - How To Rebuild Your Roster

It's never easy going from worst to first in Dynasty fantasy football. But it's possible. Just because something isn't easy doesn't mean it's not possible, and certain strategies can help you achieve what might seem impossible at first -- going from the worst team in your league to making a championship run. There are a […]


Jaxson Dart - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

NFL Rookie Dynasty Mock Draft: 2025 Fantasy Football 12-Team, Superflex/Two-QB

The 2025 NFL Draft is still less than 100 days away. More importantly, the NFL Combine is around the corner. While much will change between now and the NFL Draft at the end of April. However, it’s time for my second dynasty rookie mock draft of the year. This rookie mock draft is a two-round, […]


Jerry Jeudy - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Tale of Two Seasons - Fantasy Football Wide Receiver Edition (Part II)

It's not uncommon for a player to have a hot streak or a cold spell during a long season. It's the nature of the beast. What is, however, less common is when a player seemingly flips a switch and becomes a different player entirely. Sometimes, a player has two different seasons in a single year. […]


Kyren Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL DFS Picks

Dynasty League Sells - Overrated Fantasy Football Players To Trade Away

Being tied to bad teams, having anomalously high production that isn't sustainable long-term, and dealing with serious injuries are at least a few reasons why players can become overrated in Dynasty fantasy football leagues. When evaluating your players, it's important to take a wide-angle lens to understand what's going on. Hanging on to an overrated […]