2018 First Base - Early Points League Rankings and Tiers

If you play in a head-to-head points league, or season long format, you already know how difficult it can be to find fantasy analysis tailored to the format. Not only are the traditional rotisserie and head-to-head arrangements more popular, but the very nature of points leagues makes them difficult to cover in a general sense because they carry significantly more variance in terms of settings.

Niche audience or no, there are still plenty of folks out there who love the format, and y’all deserve help from the experts just as much as those who stick to roto or H2H. That’s why we’re excited to unveil the first round of RotoBaller’s 2018 fantasy baseball points league rankings for first base and the month of January.

This round comes to you courtesy of Bill Dubiel, Nick Mariano, Chris Zolli and Kyle Richardson. For those of you scoring at home, that means I provided no input, but I’m happy to backseat drive through their first base rankings below.

Editor's Note: Be sure to also check out more of our staff's initial 2018 fantasy baseball rankings and analysis columns for other formats including mixed leagues, dynasty leagues, 2018 prospects and more.

2018 Fantasy Baseball Points League Rankings: First Base (January)

Ranking	Tier	Player Name	Pos	Nick	Bill	Chris	Kyle R.
1	1	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	3	4	3	7
2	2	Joey Votto	1B	20	9	10	13
3	2	Anthony Rizzo	1B/2B	28	19	16	19
4	3	Freddie Freeman	1B/3B	19	27	20	21
5	3	Cody Bellinger	1B/OF	24	34	26	30
6	3	Jose Abreu	1B	32	38	37	33
7	4	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	45	35	41	36
8	4	Rhys Hoskins	1B/OF	85	33	35	58
9	4	Wil Myers	1B	84	62	50	61
10	4	Buster Posey	C/1B	77	71	48	62
11	4	Miguel Cabrera	1B	36	64	100	66
12	4	Eric Hosmer	1B	123	63	67	87
13	5	Justin Smoak	1B	74	84	83	101
14	5	Ryan Zimmerman	1B	61	92	106	89
15	5	Matt Carpenter	1B/2B/3B	119	102	104	97
16	5	Matt Olson	OF/1B	140	107	96	115
17	5	Justin Bour	1B	149	117	129	127
18	5	Josh Bell	1B	175	134	127	128
19	5	Carlos Santana	1B	171	127	131	137
20	5	Ian Desmond	OF/1B	184	125	122	139
21	6	Greg Bird	1B	112	170	172	140
22	6	Jay Bruce	OF/1B	221	151	156	158
23	6	Chris Davis	1B	101	227	223	172
24	6	Joey Gallo	3B/1B/OF	249	165	152	181
25	6	Eric Thames	1B/OF	185	198	196	180
26	6	Hanley Ramirez	1B	104	254	251	196
27	6	Marwin Gonzalez	1B/2B/3B/SS/OF	273	182	170	213
28	6	Ryon Healy	3B/1B	226	217	212	226
29	7	Trey Mancini	1B/OF	295	199	191	232
30	7	Kendrys Morales	1B	195	258	260	244
31	7	Albert Pujols	1B	227	249	267	256
32	7	Logan Morrison	1B		252	248	264
33	7	Mark Reynolds	1B	302	239	238	270
34	7	Brandon Belt	1B/OF	159	317	314	262
35	7	C.J. Cron	1B	246	284	271	258
36	7	Yonder Alonso	1B	270	280	269	275
37	7	Lucas Duda	1B	#N/A	310	312	308
38	7	Victor Martinez	1B	203	346	350	364
39	7	Jedd Gyorko	1B/3B	#N/A	322	322	324
40	7	Mike Napoli	1B	305	#N/A	363	335
41	7	Jose Martinez	OF/1B	309	344	369	345
42	7	Adrian Gonzalez	1B	325	#N/A	368	350
43	8	A.J. Reed	1B	#N/A	351	382	367
44	8	Dan Vogelbach	1B	#N/A	366	395	382
45	8	David Freese	1B/3B	#N/A	376	411	397
46	8	Kennys Vargas	1B	#N/A	379	414	394
47	8	Matt Holliday	1B/OF	385	#N/A	424	411
48	8	Matt Adams	1B	395	392	437	416
49	8	Jefry Marte	1B/OF	#N/A	388	428	417
50	8	Joe Mauer	1B	#N/A	389	429	418
51	8	Adam Lind	1B	#N/A	399	444	431
52	8	Danny Valencia	1B/3B/OF	#N/A	401	447	436

Tiers 1 and 2

Paul Goldschmidt stands alone in the top tier. He checks all the boxes for a points league stud – high average, lots of extra base hits, plenty of walks with a palatable strikeout rate, and great run production. But there’s a strong argument that Joey Votto deserves a spot right alongside him:

2015-17	R	1B	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	K	SB
Goldschmidt	326	314	105	8	93	325	322	448	71
Votto	302	331	101	5	94	277	385	338	24

Votto’s incredible plate discipline gives him a huge value boost in points leagues, and he more or less matches Goldschmidt in home runs and total bases. The Reds’ general ineptitude hurts Votto’s run production, but the only stat where Goldschmidt really blows him out of the water is stolen bases, which aren’t as valuable in points as they would be in roto or H2H.

I’d also argue that Freddie Freeman belongs in the second tier with Anthony Rizzo. Their production over the last two seasons has been almost identical in the counting stats despite Freeman missing a big chunk of 2017. Rizzo gets the edge due to a significantly lower strikeout rate, but that’s an area in which Freeman made strides last season.

Tier 3

Freeman is joined in this tier by Cody Bellinger and Jose Abreu. For all the talk that Bellinger was exposed in the World Series after fading in the second half, it’s worth noting that he lopped over five percentage points from his strikeout rate after the break. Whether he can maintain that improvement will go a long way toward determining if this valuation is appropriate. As for Abreu, last season was an emphatic repudiation of anyone who looked askance at his falling ISO rates. He’s never failed to hit at least .290 or drive in at least 100 runs, and has averaged 31 homers and 36 doubles per year in his four MLB seasons.

Tier 4

I’ve said this before and I’m sure I’ll say it again, but Nick Mariano is outside his mind. Look at that disrespectful ranking of Rhys Hoskins! Small sample be damned, Hoskins displayed fantastic plate discipline (17.5 BB%, 21.5 K%) and is projected for close to 40 home runs. He’ll also be hitting the middle of a Phillies lineup that A) showed pronounced improvement in the second half last season and B) now includes OBP machine Carlos Santana. Bill and Chris both have him as a back-end third-rounder, which smells about right. That’s where Nick has Miguel Cabrera, which is a good bit more optimistic than his early ADP (95). I think Nick’s valuation is closer than the crowd’s – Miggy struggled through an injury-plagued 2017 and will turn 35 in April, but for the preceding decade-plus there was no better combo of durability and elite production. At the current price, I’ll gladly bet on a rebound.

Tier 5

Carlos Santana (176 ADP) jumps out as a great value in this group. He’s one of the most consistent hitters around, he’s failed to play in 150 games just once in his MLB career, and his plate approach makes him even more appealing in this format. Santana strikes me as a more appealing, if less exciting, option than Matt Olson, whom all three of my colleagues ranked significantly higher. I don’t dislike Olson, but between the high strikeout rate and the inevitable regression in the power department (ain’t nobody running a 41.4 HR/FB% over a full season), it’s tough to see a lot of profit potential at the price you’ll need to pay for his services.

Tier 6

Understandably, at this point we’re talking about players with significant warts or question marks. In a points league, I’m staying far away from the likes of Chris Davis, Eric Thames, and Joey Gallo, particularly the former. Too many whiffs. How much does Hanley Ramirez have left in the tank? Can Marwin Gonzalez sustain his breakout performance from a year ago? Will Greg Bird manage to stay healthy this season? How the hell is Jay Bruce still only 30 years old?

Tiers 7 and 8

Most of the dudes in the bottom two tiers have more name recognition than actual fantasy value at this point, but let’s quickly highlight a few interesting players. Jose Martinez is currently penciled in as the starter for the Cardinals after putting up a .309/.379/.518 line in a half-season’s worth of plate appearances as a 28-year-old rookie. Yonder Alonso had a career year at age 30, and while he did fade as the year went on, his second-half production still exceeded the mediocre standard he’d set in years prior. Finally, Trey Mancini feels like the best bet in this group to outperform his lackluster ranking after acquitting himself well in his first season.