👉 TAP TO SAVE 30% WITH CODE NEW
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Top-Rated Accuracy
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

2017 Catchers: Top MLB Prospects for Fantasy Baseball

Welcome back, RotoBallers. I've already looked at the top 10 prospects for each MLB team, and now I'll be breaking down impact prospects by position. Today I'm bringing you my top 10 catchers - MLB prospect rankings for the 2017 fantasy baseball season.

Catching prospects can often come in and play a huge role for fantasy baseball owners. In 2015, J.T. Realmuto and James McCann broke out for fantasy owners and their fantasy owners while in 2016, Gary Sanchez and Willson Contreras were incredibly productive for fantasy owners.

This season might be a different story. There aren’t as many catchers out there who look to be explosive prospects. Tom Murphy could be solid in Colorado, but no one else will open up with a guaranteed spot for playing time. Injuries could change anything, but rookie catchers does not figure to have as much of an impact this season as they did last year.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

Top 10 Catcher Prospects for 2017 Fantasy Baseball

1. Tom Murphy (COL, MLB)
Stats: (from AAA) 321 PA, .327/.361/.647, 19 HR, 1 SB, 5.0% BB rate, 24.3% K rate
ETA: Opening Day
Do you want a power-hitter catching at Coors Field? You should and that’s exactly what Murphy brings to the table. Murphy has game-changing power, more than just about any other catcher in baseball and Coors Field could turn him into a 30 home run hitter at the big-league level. He has some serious plate discipline issues which will keep his batting average down in the low-mid-.200s, but the power should be well worth owning. And manager Bud Black has already said Murphy and Wolters will split starting time behind the dish. Look for Murphy to be so explosive that by mid-season, he establishes himself as the full-time starter at catcher.

2. Bruce Maxwell (OAK, MLB)
Stats: (from AAA) 219 PA, .321/.393/.539, 10 HR, 1 SB, 11.0% BB rate, 17.4% K rate
ETA: Mid-May
Maxwell had not strung together the most impressive professional career before 2016, but he was clicking on all cylinders throughout last season. He mashed Triple-A so much that he actually received quite a bit of playing time in the big leagues after his promotion. He hit quite well up there, but will probably still begin 2017 in the minors. With that said, the A’s are mired in a rebuild and he is exactly the kind of guy you want to see receive playing time. He may force Stephen Vogt to the DH spot if he tears up Nashville again at the start of the season.

3. Jorge Alfaro (PHI, MLB)
Stats: (from AA) 435 PA, .285/.325/.458, 15 HR, 3 SB, 5.1% BB rate, 24.1% K rate
ETA: Early August
Alfaro has been considered one of the top catching prospects in baseball for a very long time. He has always shown a ton of raw power with an absolute cannon for an arm, and now everything else seems to be falling into place for him. He is becoming a much better all-around defender and he lowered his strikeout rate from last season. Alfaro is not going to be the next Gary Sanchez, but he is undoubtedly the catcher with the most upside remaining in the minors. If he impresses early at Triple-A, he could force himself past Cameron Rupp and Andrew Knapp on the Phillies’ catcher depth chart really quickly and be an extremely productive catcher for fantasy owners.

4. Mitch Garver (MIN, AAA)
Stats: (from AA) 407 PA, .257/.334/.419, 11 HR, 1 SB, 10.6% BB rate, 21.1% K rate
ETA: Mid-May
Garver is not the most noteworthy catcher out there, but he does not have an overly difficult path to playing time in Minnesota. Jason Castro was recently signed to a deal there, but if Garver can hit like he did in 2016, he may force them to promote him to the big leagues. He started to show off some of his raw power for the first time since Class-A back in 2014 and also proved that he could carry his strong plate discipline numbers into the higher levels of the minors. With the Twins in a rebuilding stage, Garver is the kind of player they will likely want to see perform at the big leagues if he does enough to impress at Triple-A. If he receives a promotion to the big leagues, he could be a sleeper catcher prospect as his name does not show up on a lot of top prospect lists.

5. Carson Kelly (STL, MLB)
Stats: (from AAA) 126 PA, .292/.352/.381, 0 HR, 0 SB, 8.7% BB rate, 13.5% K rate
ETA: Mid-June
Kelly was recently named the top catching prospect by MLB.com and it is easy to see why. He has always been a very solid defender behind the plate, but he finally started to show off the bat in 2016. Though he did not hit a single home run at Triple-A, scouts saw a lot of raw power potential in his swing and they think he could be a 15 homer threat if given the playing time. He will not start off the season with the big-league club and will only play if Yadier Molina is hurt, but Molina is getting up there in age and fantasy owners in redraft leagues need to be at least aware of who the guy is who will take over the starting catching spot if Molina is hurt.

6. Austin Barnes (LAD, MLB)
Stats: (from AAA) 385 PA, .295/.380/.443, 6 HR, 18 SB, 11.2% BB rate, 13.8% K rate
ETA: Opening Day
Barnes is considered the favorite to open the season as the backup catcher to Yasmani Grandal, which already makes him a bit valuable. Though he has not always hit for a ton of power, Barnes has consistently hit for a high average in the minors while also flashing some decent speed. If he ever gets a chance to start on a regular basis in Los Angeles, he could put up numbers resembling J.T. Realmuto.

7. Chance Sisco (BAL, AAA)
Stats: (from AA) 479 PA, .320/.406/.422, 4 HR, 2 SB, 12.3% BB rate, 17.3% K rate
ETA: Early June
Sisco, like Barnes, does not possess the most exciting skillset. He does not possess much of any power and he is not particularly fast, but he combines excellent plate discipline with solid hand-to-eye coordination which should help him maintain a high average in the majors. Matt Wieters is now gone from Baltimore, and while Welington Castillo could keep Sisco in the minors for a while, the Orioles may elect to see what Sisco is capable of in the beginning of the summer. He could be a solid two-catcher or deep redraft league add if it looks like he may receive consistent, starting playing time.

8. Zack Collins (CWS, A+)
Stats: 153 PA, .258/.418/.467, 6 HR, 0 SB, 21.6% BB rate, 25.5% K rate
ETA: Mid-August
No one you did misread that stat line, Collins did walk 21.6 percent of the time. Collins is very patient and one of the most potent bats at the catching position in the minors and could be an elite contributor if he is called up. There is no one necessarily keeping Collins down in the minors, but he will need to shore up his defensive ability if he is going to get called up. If he defends well enough to build confidence in the White Sox front office, he could get a chance to start in the latter half of the season and might have a major impact on fantasy playoff races.

9. Garrett Stubbs (HOU, AA)
Stats: 137 PA, .325/.401/.517, 4 HR, 5 SB, 10.2% BB rate, 8.0% K rate
ETA: Early June
Stubbs is a lot like Maxwell and Garver in that he was not well known before the 2016 season, but a great season between Class-A Advanced and Double-A helped him gain some name recognition among prospect evaluators. He is very undersized for a catcher, but he has been able to hold his own against the higher levels. He will not unseat Brian McCann and Evan Gattis anytime soon, especially since the Astros figure to be in playoff contention, but if any of the two current sluggers get hurt, Stubbs will probably be the first name called up and he could have a real impact on redraft leagues.

10. Francisco Mejia (CLE, A+)
Stats: 184 PA, .333/.380/.488, 4 HR, 1 SB, 7.1% BB rate, 13.0% K rate
ETA: Mid-August
Mejia gained a ton of recognition in 2016 for his 50-game hit streak between Class-A and High-A. During that time, it just seemed to be impossible to get him out. But even after that hit streak came to an end, he still continued to be a consistently great hitter. He not only reached base at a high clip, but he also made real strides in keeping his strikeout rate low. He does not have a ton of power nor is he all that fast, but he could still be a valuable fantasy asset if given playing time. If Yan Gomes gets hurt and Roberto Perez loses some of his 2016 magic, Mejia could start for Cleveland towards the end of the summer.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Top-Rated Accuracy
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Olivier-Maxence Prosper

Ruled Out Vs. Nuggets
Vít Krejčí

Vit Krejci Remains Sidelined Vs. Spurs
Shaedon Sharpe

Downgraded to Out Wednesday
J.K. Dobbins

Broncos Prioritized Re-Signing J.K. Dobbins
Pascal Siakam

Remains Out on Thursday
NFL

Francis Mauigoa to Undergo Additional Imaging on a Back Issue
Darius Garland

Won't Play on Wednesday
Mark Williams

is Resting on Wednesday
Kaleb McGary

Retires After Seven Years in the NFL
Josh Giddey

to Remain Out on Thursday
Jawaan Taylor

Signs with the Falcons
Matas Buzelis

to Miss Third Straight Game
Isaiah Stewart

is Available on Wednesday
Cade Cunningham

is Officially Returning on Wednesday
Victor Wembanyama

Set to Sit Out on Wednesday
Stephon Castle

Ruled Out for Wednesday's Matchup With Portland
Wendell Carter Jr.

Active Against Minnesota
Andrei Kuzmenko

to Be Re-Evaluated in 7-8 Days
Jaden McDaniels

Slated to Suit Up Wednesday
Mason Appleton

Won't Play Thursday
Jalen Williams

Available Against Clippers
Tony DeAngelo

Expected to Return Thursday
John Klingberg

Rejoins Sharks Lineup Wednesday
Alex Lyon

Dealing With Lower-Body Injury
Rudy Gobert

Unavailable on Wednesday
Oliver Ekman-Larsson

Back in Action Wednesday
Alex Ovechkin

Won't Decide Future Until Offseason
Cade Cunningham

Expected to Suit Up Wednesday
Cole Ragans

"Should be Good" for Next Start
Reynaldo López

Reynaldo Lopez Handed Seven-Game Suspension
Jorge Soler

Suspended Seven Games, Will Appeal
NFL

NFL Scouts See Plenty of Upside With Drew Allar
NFL

Ty Simpson to Fall into Second Round in NFL Draft?
Cleveland Browns

Todd Monken "Fired Up" About Quarterback Competition
Cleveland Browns

KC Concepcion Visiting With the Browns
Cole Ragans

Diagnosed With Thumb Contusion
Houston Texans

Texans Pick Up Will Anderson's Fifth-Year Option
C.J. Stroud

Texans Exercise C.J. Stroud's Fifth-Year Option
Cole Ragans

Leaves Early on Wednesday After Being Hit in the Hand
Jacob deGrom

Expects to Make his Next Start
Konnor Griffin

Pirates Sign Konnor Griffin to Nine-Year Extension
Parker Washington

Undervalued Despite League-Winning Finish in 2025
Nico Collins

Is Nico Collins Still a Dynasty WR1?
Rome Odunze

Does Rome Odunze Offer the Highest Ceiling in Chicago?
Justus Annunen

Ends Predators' 120-Game Streak Without a Shutout
Tank Bigsby

Still Holds Value Despite Limited Usage
Trevor Zegras

Leads Flyers to Victory Tuesday
Matthew Golden

A Matthew Golden Breakout Still Faces Obstacles
Kevin Bahl

Sustains Lower-Body Injury Against Stars
Michael Rasmussen

Likely to Miss Rest of Regular Season
Dmitry Kulikov

Done for the Season After Breaking Finger
Jalen Chatfield

Exits Early With Lower-Body Injury
Nazem Kadri

Suffers Upper-Body Injury Tuesday
Ty Jerome

Remains Out Wednesday
Wendell Carter Jr.

Iffy for Wednesday
Isaiah Stewart

Might Be an Option for Pistons Wednesday
Thomas Bryant

Misses Wednesday's Game
Ray Davis

Patience Dwindling for Ray Davis' Dynasty Managers?
Ja'Marr Chase

a Real Threat to Finish as Overall WR1?
Javonte Williams

Returning to Face Minimal Competition?
Tyrrell Hatton

a Steady Option at The Masters
Justin Thomas

a High-Risk, High-Reward Option at The Masters
Terry McLaurin

the Undisputed Focal Point of Washington's Offense
Justin Herbert

a Dynasty Target with New-Look Offense Around Him?
Tee Higgins

an Intriguing Dynasty Trade Target with QB Healthy?
PGA

Sungjae Im a Volatile Option at the Masters
Nicolai Hojgaard

Carrying Momentum Into The Masters
Si Woo Kim

in Strong Form Heading to The Masters
Chris Gotterup

Ready to Make His Masters Debut
Patrick Reed

Brings Momentum to The Masters
Jon Rahm

Looks Poised for His Second Green Jacket
Morgan Geekie

Collects Second Career Hat Trick
Joel Eriksson Ek

has Three Points in Victory
Jacob deGrom

Doesn't Have Structural Damage in his Knee
J.T. Realmuto

Leaves Game on Tuesday Due to Bruised Right Foot
Cody Ponce

to Have Knee Surgery, Expected to Miss Six Months
Alejandro Kirk

Facing Six-Week Absence
Jacob deGrom

to Undergo MRI on Tuesday
Mike Trout

Back in the Lineup on Tuesday
Hunter Brown

Diagnosed with Grade 2 Shoulder Strain
Pavel Mintyukov

Returns From Three-Game Absence
Cutter Gauthier

Remains Sidelined Tuesday
Kirby Dach

Ready to Return Tuesday
Jordan Staal

Good to Go Tuesday
Adam Scott

Form Points to Him Competing at Masters
Jordan Spieth

Finding Consistency Heading to Masters
Hideki Matsuyama

Trending In Right Direction For Masters
Valeri Nichushkin

Nicolas Roy Available Tuesday
Cade Horton

to Undergo Season-Ending Elbow Surgery
Tommy Fleetwood

a Contender if his Putter Cooperates at The Masters
Jacob deGrom

Pitches Through Knee Issue on Monday
Dalton Rushing

Smacks Two Homers in Rout of Blue Jays
Max Scherzer

Dealing With Forearm Tendinitis, Expected to Make his Next Start
Collin Morikawa

Vegas has Lost Confidence in Collin Morikawa Ahead of Masters Tournament
Ludvig Aberg

One of the Top Plays For This Week's Masters Tournament
Rory McIlroy

Set to Defend his Long-Awaited Masters Victory
Bryson DeChambeau

Looks to Finally Claim a Green Jacket
Patrick Cantlay

Needs Plenty to Go Right at Augusta
Harris English

Playing Solid Golf Heading to Masters
Sam Burns

Bouncing Back Nicely After Slow Start to 2026 Season
Corey Conners

Quietly Putting Together A Strong 2026 Season
Russell Henley

Looks to Bounce Back At Masters
Mike Trout

Held Out of Series Opener Against Braves
Alejandro Kirk

to Undergo Thumb Surgery on Tuesday
Juan Soto

Mets Place Juan Soto on 10-Day Injured List
Chris Duncan

Suffers Second-Round Submission Loss
Renato Moicano

Gets Back In The Win Column
Tabatha Ricci

Gets Outgrappled
Virna Jandiroba

Bounces Back
Brendson Ribeiro

Suffers First-Round Submission Loss
Abdul-Rakhman Yakhyaev

Earns First-Round Submission Win
Rafael Estevam

Suffers His First Loss
Ethyn Ewing

Dominates At UFC Vegas 115
Chris Duncan

Set For UFC Vegas 115 Main Event
Renato Moicano

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 115
Tabatha Ricci

Set For UFC Vegas 115 Co-Main Event
Virna Jandiroba

Looks To Bounce Back
Brendson Ribeiro

In Desperate Need Of Win
Abdul-Rakhman Yakhyaev

Looks To Remain Unbeaten
Ethyn Ewing

Set For His Second UFC Bout
Rafael Estevam

Looks To Remain Undefeated
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF