2024 Fantasy Football: Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft For Non-Superflex Leagues

It's NFL Draft season, which means dynasty managers are already chomping to get started. Many of you are likely already searching to add another league. Others are probably pushing your commissioner to set dates for your rookie draft, perhaps wanting to pick before the real draft even happens.

This is also the ideal time for dynasty managers to start planning for the future. You must ask yourself what your team is and what this draft class is. Where is the depth, what are the tiers, and where will these rookies go? Asking these questions will help you better understand the value of trades, what veterans to move for which picks, and how far you have to go for your guy.

With this in mind, we at RotoBaller decided to get an early start and conduct a staff dynasty rookie draft. We held a non-Superflex draft on Sleeper this week, running five rounds deep. Below is the draft broken down by round, with my notes on each round. Please note that if I criticize a pick, it doesn’t mean it can’t be a good move or a good player. It’s just not ideal value.

Editor's Note: Our incredible team of writers won two writing awards and received 12 award nominations by the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. A big congrats to our very own Byron Lindeque (Golf) and Jordan McAbee (NASCAR) for both winning Writer Of The Year awards! Be sure to follow RotoBaller's analysis and advice all year long, and win more. Win More With RotoBaller!

Fantasy Football Draft Board

Below, you will find my round-by-round breakdown of the mock draft. Please note that the following rookies, Kendall Milton, Luke McCaffrey, and Daijun Edwards, were not available on Sleeper during the draft. A placeholder was used for these three draft selections. Milton replaces Devin Leary, McCaffrey replaces Bryson Nesbit, and Edwards replaces Moose Muhammad.

Round 1

Pick	Team	Player	College	Pos.
1	Brandon Murchison	Marvin Harrison Jr.	Ohio St.	WR
2	Chris Gregory	Malik Nabers	LSU	WR
3	Jorden Hill	Rome Odunze	Washington	WR
4	Kevin Campbell	Brock Bowers	Georgia	TE
5	Brad Camara	BrIan Thomas Jr.	LSU	WR
6	Phil Clark	Caleb Williams	USC	QB
7	LaQuan Jones	Roman Wilson	Michigan	WR
8	Richard King	Xavier Worthy	Texas	WR
9	Jackson Sparks	Jayden Daniels	LSU	QB
10	Nick Rodriguez	Troy Franklin	Oregon	WR
11	Joey Pollizze	Jonathon Brooks	Texas	RB
12	Matt Donnelly	Keon Coleman	FSU	WR

Chalk Up Top: Very few non-Superflex drafts should deviate from how our first four picks go here. Marvin Harrison Jr. is in a tier of his own as an elite weapon. He should be the undisputed first pick in all rookie drafts that are not Superflex. His grade is on par with what I gave Ja'Marr Chase and Larry Fitzgerald as prospects. The odds of him not becoming a superstar are low.

The three players taken after Harrison should also be considered in a tier of their own. Malik Nabers, Rome Odunze, and Brock Bowers must be the next three players off the board after Harrison. The order may vary depending on whether you're in TE Premium, PPR, or half-PPR, but those three are comfortably ahead of the rest in non-Superflex drafts.

Draft Begins at Pick No. 5: Brad Camara’s choice of Brian Thomas Jr. at No. 5 was the right one in my book, but some will disagree. That is why this is the first pick with some volatility to it.

Some will prefer Troy Franklin as the fifth pick. Others will want Keon Coleman in that spot. Depending on how some teams are built, some will even prefer the top quarterback or running back in this spot. Thomas is my preferred fifth option, though. He is tremendously long, tracks the deep ball well, and I currently project him to catch passes from Trevor Lawrence.

One Possible Reach in the First: Perhaps the only “reach” in this mock first round was Roman Wilson going at pick 1.07. The speedy Michigan product was tremendous at the Senior Bowl, showing elite quickness out of his breaks and superior route running. However, I have a third-round grade on Wilson in the NFL Draft and value him as the 19^th-best asset in non-Superflex dynasty rookie drafts.

Receivers whom I prefer over Wilson include Keon Coleman, Troy Franklin, Adonai Mitchell, Xavier Worthy, and Ladd McConkey. Wilson lacks the size and TD upside of Coleman, Franklin, and Mitchell. Meanwhile, McConkey and Worthy can do what Wilson does and more.

With all of that said, if you have conviction about a player, then you have to commit. Roman Wilson has talent and LaQuan clearly believes in it. If that’s his guy, then kudos to him for having the guts to take him where he did. I’d hazard LaQuan would have tried to trade back and get Wilson later in a regular draft, though.

 

Round 2

Pick	Team	Player	College	Pos.
13	Brandon Murchison	Malachi Corley	W. Kentucky	WR
14	Chris Gregory	Ladd McConkey	Georgia	WR
15	Jorden Hill	Adonai Mitchell	Texas	WR
16	Kevin Campbell	Drake Maye	N. Carolina	QB
17	Brad Camara	Braelon Allen	Wisconsin	RB
18	Phil Clark	Ja'Lynn Polk	Washington	WR
19	LaQuan Jones	Devontez Walker	N. Carolina	WR
20	Richard King	Ja'Tavion Sanders	Texas	TE
21	Jackson Sparks	Trey Benson	FSU	RB
22	Nick Rodriguez	Bucky Irving	Oregon	RB
23	Joey Pollizze	Blake Corum	Michigan	RB
24	Matt Donnelly	Audric Estime	Notre Dame	RB

Receivers With Lofty Comparisons: The first two picks of Round 2 are receivers who have earned lofty comparisons. Malachi Corley is a thick receiver who consistently produces big plays after contact, earning comparisons to Deebo Samuel. Meanwhile, Ladd McConkey is the best and most sudden route runner in this class and can play all over. I saw some Cooper Kupp in his film.

Running Backwards: The running backs in this draft are underwhelming. In fact, it isn’t unthinkable that the first running back will come off the board in the third round of this NFL Draft.

Just consider that Jonathon Brooks, the most rounded and popular back in this class, is coming off a torn ACL. Blake Corum, the most famous back, is on the older side and lacks elite speed and power. Meanwhile, Trey Benson is a complete back who isn’t elite at anything, and Jaylen Wright never averaged more than 13 touches per game. Beyond them, this class is mostly specialty backs.

Bucky Irving, who displays good hands and burst on tape, is the best of the timeshare backs in this class. He looks lighter than his listed college weight of 195 pounds. However, he can reacclimate and gain positive yards when his lanes close or a bigger body runs into him. He is a quality choice in PPR leagues, where he should become an RB3 with RB2 upside.

 

Round 3

Pick	Team	Player	College	Pos.
25	Brandon Murchison	MarShawn Lloyd	USC	RB
26	Chris Gregory	Ricky Pearsall	Florida	WR
27	Jorden Hill	J.J. McCarthy	Michigan	QB
28	Kevin Campbell	Bo Nix	Oregon	QB
29	Brad Camara	Michael Penix Jr.	Washington	QB
30	Phil Clark	Xavier Legette	S. Carolina	WR
31	LaQuan Jones	Jaheim Bell	FSU	TE
32	Richard King	Will Shipley	Clemson	RB
33	Jackson Sparks	Jalen McMillan	Washington	WR
34	Nick Rodriguez	Jacob Cowing	Arizona	WR
35	Joey Pollizze	Cade Stover	Ohio St.	TE
36	Matt Donnelly	Jaylen Wright	Tennessee	RB

A Good Reminder About Early Drafts:  The best value pick in Round 3 of this mock was the last one: Jaylen Wright. He is an explosive back with breakaway speed and could be the best back in this class. Wright’s value bears watching as draft day comes closer.

You may ask, “If Wright is so good, why did he fall to 3.12?” Well, one reason may be that Wright wasn’t initially in Sleeper’s player pool. In fact, Sleeper didn’t add Wright until the end of this third round. This early in the draft process, applications like PFF’s mock draft simulator and Sleeper’s draft list are often incomplete. That is why drafting this early can be a poor move.

Best Value Picks of Round 3: As stated above, Jaylen Wright was the best value in this round by a good margin. Beyond him, two others bear mentioning.

Xavier Legette is a massive receiver whose stock is falling after he struggled at the Senior Bowl. Going into that event, some thought Legette could sneak into the first round. He has contested catch ability, can contort to make off-target catches, and has adequate straight-line speed. Unfortunately, Legette can also be lumbering, and his hands are inconsistent. Pick 3.06 is a good spot for him.

Jalen McMillan is also worth mentioning. Another big-bodied receiver, McMillan fell to Washington's third passing option this year due to injuries. However, on film, he has consistent hands, a good feel for zone coverage, and he gets open in the red zone. He could be a better version of Jauan Jennings, a large slot receiver who blocks and moves the chains.

 

Round 4

Pick	Team	Player	College	Pos.
37	Brandon Murchison	Ray Davis	Kentucky	RB
38	Chris Gregory	Rasheen Ali	Marshall	RB
39	Jorden Hill	Johnny Wilson	FSU	WR
40	Kevin Campbell	Frank Gore Jr.	S. Miss.	RB
41	Brad Camara	Brenden Rice	USC	WR
42	Phil Clark	Cody Schrader	Missouri	RB
43	LaQuan Jones	Jermaine Burton	Alabama	WR
44	Richard King	Ainias Smith	Texas A&M	WR
45	Jackson Sparks	Javon Baker	UCF	WR
46	Nick Rodriguez	Dylan Laube	New Hampshire	RB
47	Joey Pollizze	Jamari Thrash	Louisville	WR
48	Matt Donnelly	Malik Washington	Virginia	WR

Some Worthwhile Dart Throws: The fourth round is where dynasty managers have to dig deeper into their bag of tricks. This is the range you should start targeting players with an elite trait or a versatile profile that could earn them a role in their offense right away. Think along the lines of guys like Elijah Mitchell and Puka Nacua, who were perfect fits for the schemes and needs of the teams that drafted them.

Players who could fit that mold in this mock include Jamari Thrash and Dylan Laube. Thrash was really effective at the Senior Bowl, getting open against well-known corners and making several difficult catches on the sideline. He could be effective as the second or third option for the Bengals. Laube could also become an interesting stash in PPR leagues if he landed with a team like the Chargers.

 

Round 5

Pick	Team	Player	College	Pos.
49	Brandon Murchison	Isaiah Davis	S. Dakota State	RB
50	Chris Gregory	Kendall Milton	Georgia	RB
51	Jorden Hill	Jase McClellan	Alabama	RB
52	Kevin Campbell	Spencer Rattler	S. Carolina	QB
53	Brad Camara	Theo Johnson	Penn State	TE
54	Phil Clark	Ben Sinnott	Kansas State	TE
55	LaQuan Jones	Dominic Lovett	Georgia	WR
56	Richard King	Jordan Travis	FSU	QB
57	Jackson Sparks	Michael Pratt	Tulane	QB
58	Nick Rodriguez	Dillon Johnson	Washington	RB
59	Joey Pollizze	Luke McCaffrey	Rice	WR
60	Matt Donnelly	Daijun Edwards	Georgia	RB

Georgia on My Mind: When I sat down to review Georgia’s film in December, I was looking for the obvious names. Players like Brock Bowers, Kamari Lassiter, Ladd McConkey, and Amarius Mims were all guys I'd noted early in the season and was excited to dive deeper into the holiday break. So color me surprised when two other unsung Bulldogs really grabbed my eye.

One of those Bulldogs was Kendall Milton. The bruising back isn’t in PFF’s draft simulator, Sleeper’s player list, or Mel Kiper’s running back rankings. However, Milton is a punishing runner with good speed and an elite trait. That elite trait? Contact balance. Milton rarely goes down on first contact, nor on second or third. That skill is worth stashing in your TAXI.

The other Georgia player who stood out on film was Marcus Rosemy-Jacksaint. The kid has a weird name and little buzz around it, but he gets open on film. He has good size and the length to extend and bring in high throws, plus he came up big for Georgia several times this year. He is a vastly underrated prospect who I would have drafted over Michael Pratt, Dominic Lovett, and Ben Sinnott.

Other Players Worth Mentioning: Luke McCaffrey has name recognition. That should elevate him in many dynasty drafts, getting him in the mid-fourth range by May. He is a tough and versatile player, too. He can cover multiple offensive positions and play special teams, which should earn him a role as a rookie. Just don’t draft him expecting his brother or his dad.

Also worth mentioning is another Georgia running back, Daijun Edwards. This is the more popular and mainstream Bulldog back. While my preference is Milton, Edwards was the one who handled receiving work for Georgia. He is a shifty player who can do a little bit of everything. Edwards is a fine value at the end of this mock.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!

Win More With RotoBaller

Be sure to also check out all of our other daily fantasy football articles and analysis to help you set those winning lineups, including this new RotoBaller YouTube video:

More Fantasy Football Analysis