👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE SPRING
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

Fantasy Football Dynasty Start-Up Mock Draft: 12-Teams, Superflex (RotoBaller Staff Picks)

Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, QB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

Chris' analysis of the RotoBaller staff's fantasy football dynasty startup mock draft for Superflex leagues ahead of the 2026 fantasy season. Includes notes about changing values post free agency moves.

Spring is the time for sprouting flowers, April showers, and the dawn of hope as ice melts into a dewy morning. However, for true football degenerates, spring is exclusively the time for dynasty startup drafts. For some of us, no matter how many leagues we are already in, we cannot help but enroll in draft after draft to feed our need for football in the offseason.

With that in mind, our staff got together for a full staff dynasty startup draft. The format we chose was Superflex, meaning you start one quarterback and have a flex position that can be filled with a second passer if you choose… and you should choose to do that. This league is otherwise standard, with no TE Premium scoring or other unique tweaks.

Below you will find each team drafted, with the starting lineup and bench laid out, along with the corresponding picks and rounds for each player. Please note that this mock was conducted prior to the beginning of free agency, but the analysis of each team was written after the first wave of free agency in order to give you better context in light of those free agency moves.

Editor's Note: The FFPC Baby Gorilla Tournament is now open, featuring a $100,000 grand prize and a $675,450 total prize pool! This 12-team, Tight End Premium contest uses a 20-round draft format, with the overall winners determined by total points scored during Weeks 15–17. Get $25 to use toward your first entry by signing up through our link. Grab your team now! Sign Up Now!

 

Team #1 (Dakota Legg)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Josh Allen Bills 1.1
RB James Cook III Bills 2.12
RB Breece Hall Jets 4.12
WR Ladd McConkey Chargers 5.1
WR Jaylen Waddle Dolphins 6.12
WR Davante Adams Rams 9.1
TE Trey McBride Cardinals 3.1
Flex Emmett Johnson Rookie 8.12
Flex Kenyon Sadiq Rookie 11.1
SF Tyler Shough Saints 7.1
Bench
QB Ty Simpson Rookie 10.12
WR Brandon Aiyuk 49ers 12.12
RB David Montgomery Texans 13.1
RB Alvin Kamara Saints 14.12
WR Rashid Shaheed Seahawks 15.1
RB Demond Claiborne Rookie 16.12
WR Isaac TeSlaa Lions 17.1
QB Carson Beck Rookie 18.12
WR Tre Tucker Raiders 19.1
WR Eric McAlister Rookie 20.12
Rookies Second Year Strategy
6 1 Win Now

Best Picks: Getting Kenyon Sadiq 121st overall was a bargain for Dakota.

While this is not a TE Premium format, Sadiq displays rare athleticism and receiving skills on film that should translate in the NFL. In other words, the film backs up the testing numbers. There is also a good chance the Oregon product lands with a TE-friendly offense (Kansas City, San Francisco, etc.), which means his fantasy stock could skyrocket quickly.

Tyler Shough at 7.01 is also a good value, considering that the Saints appear committed to the Louisville product and are building a promising offense around him. With Travis Etienne Jr. now a Saint, Shough should have more room to run and complete easy passes. In Superflex formats, Shough’s mobility, blocking, and play-calling all make him an intriguing QB2 option.

Worst Picks: It is worth noting that this mock occurred before Breece Hall was franchise-tagged by the Jets… but taking Hall at 4.12 was still a bit rich before he got the tag. After the tag, it’s even worse.

Hall made my list of Dynasty Sells last month because his advanced metrics aren't as strong as many think, and his situation in New York is concerning. Now he looks to be committed to that bad situation for another year, or longer if the contract extension buzz comes to fruition.

Emmett Johnson at 8.12 was also a bit of a reach, considering he does not have any elite measurables and is widely considered the fourth or fifth best running back in a weak rookie class. This felt like a panic pick after a heavy dose of running backs went right before.

Predicting Team Outcome: It is hard to draft the Bills duo of Josh Allen and James Cook III and not be considered a win-now build. Allen still has some good years left, but his playing style suggests his fantasy value could dip around age 32, rather than the age 36-38 we see with traditional passers. Meanwhile, Cook is an elite rusher, but his usage and age are worrisome.

Throw in the fact that Dakota used premium picks on Trey McBride, Hall, and Davante Adams, and this team has the bones of an early contender. Of course, some of these players will age quickly, and that could force the window to close soon, particularly with the potentially short lifespan of his Bills superstars.

There is a world where Hall, Emmett Johnson, and Sadiq all hit their ceilings early, and this team contends. However, the profile for Johnson and Hall suggests both won’t carry their weight in 2026 and that their peaks will come after Allen, Adams, and Cook’s are done.

 

Team #2 (Phil Clark)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Drake Maye Patriots 1.2
RB De'Von Achane Dolphins 2.11
RB Josh Jacobs Packers 6.11
WR Nico Collins Texans 3.2
WR Denzel Boston Rookie 7.2
WR Terry McLaurin Commanders 8.11
TE Colston Loveland Bears 4.11
Flex D'Andre Swift Bears 9.2
Flex Woody Marks Texans 10.11
SF Cam Ward Titans 5.2
Bench
WR Omar Cooper Jr. Rookie 11.2
WR Jalen Coker Panthers 12.11
RB Tony Pollard Titans 13.2
RB Mike Washington Jr. Rookie 14.11
QB Jacoby Brissett Cardinals 15.2
TE Mason Taylor Jets 16.11
WR Kyle Williams Patriots 17.2
QB Cole Payton Rookie 18.11
RB Najee Harris Chargers 19.2
WR Deion Burks Rookie 20.11
Rookies Second Year Strategy
5 5 Balanced

Best Picks: Phil’s best pick was easily Colston Loveland.

Including the playoffs, Loveland averaged a whopping 12 targets per game, which set him on a pace of 204 targets over a 17-game schedule. While that pace is unsustainable, Caleb Williams has referred to the rookie as a “home run pick,” and the quarterback’s potential reliance on Loveland makes him a bargain at 47th overall.

Getting Drake Maye at 1.02 was also an easy win, given that Maye is the top overall player in many Superflex dynasty rankings. While many may question Maye’s weak 2026 schedule, especially after a disappointing Super Bowl, remember that the North Carolina alum finished second in total fantasy points as a sophomore without a clear WR1 or WR2 on the team.

Rounding out Phil’s best picks, we must mention Omar Cooper Jr. The National Champion is a dynamic weapon who could become a first-round pick on a quality offense like San Francisco’s or New England’s. If the shifty receiver lands in one of those scenarios, expect his ADP to jump two full rounds from where Phil took him (122nd overall).

Worst Picks: Phil didn’t have too many headscratchers in this mock, but Woody Marks was not a favorite.

While many would call Marks a bargain in the 10th round, the USC alum was wildly inefficient as a rusher, and his college film never suggested he could be a lead back. Amongst backs with at least 70 carries, Marks ranked 52nd in yards after contact per attempt and 28th in explosive run rate. That was all bad news, even before Houston traded for David Montgomery.

Another potential reach for Phil was Nico Collins at 3.02.

While Collins still carries attractive upside, he is an aging receiver with questions all around him. However, Collins was not an awful choice in a vacuum… but the run on quarterbacks that happened soon after poisoned the well. Had Phil taken Trevor Lawrence at 3.02 instead, he would not have been forced to reach for Cam Ward as his QB2 early in the fifth round.

Predicting Team Outcome: Phil’s receiver room is a bit of a question mark, given that two of his top wideouts are aging (Collins and Terry McLaurin), while his WR2 is the fourth-rated receiver in this upcoming rookie class.

Phil also has questions at Flex, where Marks and D’Andre Swift both profile as short-term assets who could be phased out of fantasy relevance next season (Swift) or this year (Marks).

However, Phil’s starting running backs are elite. His QB1 and starting TE both offer immense upside with youth, talent, and favorable situations around them. If Ward were to hit his ceiling and Loveland continues to be Chicago’s top weapon for the next five years, this team should contend for the foreseeable future.

 

Team #3 (Chris Gregory)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Jayden Daniels Commanders 1.3
RB Jeremiyah Love Rookie 3.3
RB Bhayshul Tuten Jaguars 8.10
WR Carnell Tate Rookie 5.3
WR Jordyn Tyson Rookie 6.10
WR Rome Odunze Bears 7.3
TE Brock Bowers Raiders 2.10
Flex Tyreek Hill Dolphins 14.10
Flex Oronde Gadsden Chargers 11.3
SF Fernando Mendoza Rookie 4.10
Bench
QB Malik Willis Free Agent 9.3
RB Nicholas Singleton Rookie 10.10
RB Jonathon Brooks Panthers 12.10
WR Zachariah Branch Rookie 13.3
WR Malachi Fields Rookie 15.3
WR Tank Dell Texans 16.10
QB Shedeur Sanders Browns 17.3
WR Ted Hurst Rookie 18.10
QB Garrett Nussmeier Rookie 19.3
WR Jack Bech Raiders 20.10
Rookies Second Year Strategy
9 4 Future Build

Best Picks: Perhaps my best pick was selecting Bhayshul Tuten 94th overall, knowing that his stock was suppressed by Etienne’s presence, but Etienne was likely to leave in free agency. That gamble proved right within a week, as Etienne left and Tuten seemingly has the RB1 job in Jacksonville to himself… barring a surprising move in the NFL Draft.

While Tuten carries significant risk, the Jaguars do not have a first-round pick in the NFL Draft, and this rookie class is weak at RB. So, Tuten and his elite athleticism should have a big runway to take off. Thus, taking him in the eighth round was a gamble that is already paying off.

Another worthwhile risk was Jonathon Brooks going 130th overall.

While the 12th round is a tad early for Brooks, considering his current ADP and injury status, all reports on the former Longhorn’s injury rehab are positive, and he is easily the most athletic and polished back in Carolina when healthy. A 23-year-old back with high-end RB2 potential is worth the 130th pick, even if he never plays another down in the NFL.

Finally, both Garrett Nussmeier and Ted Hurst are solid values at the 18/19 round turn. Nussmeier has a realistic chance of going in the second round of the NFL Draft and has the skills to become the next Geno Smith. Meanwhile, Hurst is a phenomenal athlete who has burned almost everyone he faced, both at the lower level of college football and at the Senior Bowl.

Worst Picks: Brock Bowers was a logical choice at 2.10, especially considering the guy picking behind me (Phil) is a Raiders fan. However, this mock saw a lot of premium tight end talent fall well past their ADP, which meant I ended up regretting taking Bowers instead of going quarterback (Jaxson Dart) with my second pick while waiting on tight end.

In hindsight, waiting to draft Colston Loveland in the fourth round would have been my preferred method, and I strongly regretted not going that route almost immediately. Taking a QB earlier and still getting Loveland in the fourth would have broadened my roster options while still giving me a significant edge at the TE position.

Instead, I neglected my QB2 position and took Bowers… which was a decision that rippled throughout the rest of my draft and forced me to commit to a youth/win-later build early.

Predicting Team Outcome: This team is the definition of a lottery ticket and a future build.

If Jeremiyah Love turns into a Jahmyr Gibbs-style asset while Carnell Tate and Jordyn Tyson reach their physical ceilings, this team could be a contender for a decade or more. However, I admittedly went too heavy with the rookie and youth picks, which means this roster could quickly devolve into a long rebuild if I miss on those top rookies.

 

Team #4 (Dan Fornek)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Justin Herbert Chargers 2.9
RB Omarion Hampton Chargers 3.4
RB TreVeyon Henderson Patriots 5.4
WR Ja'Marr Chase Bengals 1.4
WR DeVonta Smith Eagles 7.4
WR Christian Watson Packers 8.9
TE Isaiah Likely Giants 14.9
Flex RJ Harvey Broncos 6.9
Flex Alec Pierce Colts 9.4
SF Jared Goff Lions 4.9
Bench
RB Tyler Allgeier Cardinals 10.9
WR Matthew Golden Packers 11.4
RB Tyrone Tracy Jr. Giants 12.9
WR Josh Downs Colts 13.4
RB Tyjae Spears Titans 15.4
TE AJ Barner Seahawks 16.9
RB Devin Neal Saints 17.4
TE Max Klare Rookie 18.9
QB Mac Jones 49ers 19.4
TE Elijah Arroyo TE 20.9
Rookies Second Year Strategy
1 5 Win Now

Best Picks: Justin Herbert was arguably Dan’s best pick of the draft.

In six games with Joe Alt on the field, Herbert averaged just shy of 24 points per game in four-point passing touchdown leagues, and he was on pace to be QB1 overall in fantasy. QB1 could be a realistic goal for Herbert in 2026, too, considering he should get two elite tackles back this offseason and his new offensive coordinator is much more creative in the passing game.

Another strong pick for Dan was Isaiah Likely in the 14th round.

At the time of this choice, Likely did not have a new team, but we all expected he would land somewhere where he would be a starter and see real volume. That expectation became reality when the former Raven signed with his old head coach in New York, setting him up for a starter-level snap share and potentially the second-most targets on the Giants’ offense.

Worst Picks: The biggest reach for Dan was RJ Harvey in the sixth round.

Harvey was one of the least efficient rushers in the NFL last year. He finished 64th in PFF’s Rushing Grade, 81st in yards after contact per attempt, and he graded poorly as a blocker. The newly re-signed J.K. Dobbins graded better in each of those categories.

While Harvey could still be Denver’s primary passing downs back, taking him at 69th overall was rich when you consider his inefficiency and the team’s interest in adding running back competition this offseason.

Predicting Team Outcome: Dan had a strong draft, with only one obvious head-scratching pick amongst his starters. Herbert's availability in the second made his decision to select Ja’Marr Chase in the first round look brilliant. He then solidified his balanced roster with a youthful but talented running back room and a steady QB2 (Jared Goff).

The only downside to this build is the fact that some of Dan’s potential depends on changes of scenery or changes in personnel, lifting the stock of Likely, Alec Pierce, DeVonta Smith, and Tyler Allgeier. While that could happen and rocket Dan’s team into elite status, his squad could get stuck in the middle if those players don’t see a serious spike in their production.

 

Team #5 (Tipp Major)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Kyler Murray Vikings 5.5
RB Jonathan Taylor Colts 2.8
RB Christian McCaffrey 49ers 3.5
WR Puka Nacua Rams 1.5
WR Emeka Egbuka Buccaneers 4.8
WR Luther Burden III Bears 6.8
TE Dallas Goedert Eagles 11.5
Flex Jadarian Price Rookie 7.5
Flex KC Concepcion Rookie 8.8
SF Matthew Stafford Rams 9.5
Bench
WR Jayden Higgins Texans 10.8
QB Anthony Richardson Sr. Colts 12.8
RB Kimani Vidal Chargers 13.5
RB Adam Randall Rookie 14.8
WR Troy Franklin Broncos 15.5
WR Jerry Jeudy Browns 16.8
RB Rachaad White Commanders 17.5
TE Juwan Johnson Saints 18.8
RB Tank Bigsby Eagles 19.5
WR Ryan Flournoy Cowboys 20.8
Rookies Second Year Strategy
3 3 Win Now… but Won’t

Best Picks: Emeka Egbuka at 44th overall could prove a bargain now that Mike Evans has left Tampa.

Egbuka’s dip in targets last year coincided with two things. First, Evans and Chris Godwin Jr. both returned from injury during different stages of Egbuka’s decline. Second, the rookie dealt with a nagging injury that reportedly hindered his production after mid-season. However, the Ohio State product is now healthy and faces less competition, making him a safe WR2.

Adam Randall was another fine value pick in the 14th round, as he is a former receiver with the size to be a power back in the NFL. If some team can get Randall to play with more leverage and help him improve his lateral movement, he has the skillset to be an every-down back despite his lack of pedigree.

Worst Picks: Tipp’s quarterback situation could be a problem quickly.

His QB1 is currently Kyler Murray, a player who was signed to “compete” for the starting job after Arizona happily released him without a clear replacement in place. His QB2 is the aging Matthew Stafford, who had a back injury last offseason and was rumored to be considering retirement early this offseason.

To make matters worse, Tipp’s only backup quarterback is Anthony Richardson. Reports indicate that the only team that was interested in giving Richardson a starting shot this year (Minnesota) is no longer interested after adding Murray.

Predicting Team Outcome: Tipp’s roster could age into a problem quickly. As we noted above, his quarterbacks are anything but safe. Worse, Christian McCaffrey showed signs of aging last year and turns 30 this summer. Plus, Jonathan Taylor’s playing style and usage suggest he may be nearing the end of his peak.

When you consider just how close to the end several of Tipp’s starters are, it is increasingly concerning that he relies on Luther Burden III, Jadarian Price, and KC Concepcion as starters. While two of those players have elite upside (Burden and Concepcion), each of them has noteworthy flaws and limitations that make them significant risks with this kind of build.

In other words, Tipp’s team could be elite if everything goes right. However, if the clock strikes on any of the problems we noted (Stafford and CMC’s age, Burden’s immaturity, Concepcion’s drops, injuries, etc.), then this roster is ill-equipped to adapt and still compete.

 

Team #6 (Matt Donnelly)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Baker Mayfield Buccaneers 4.7
RB Bijan Robinson Falcons 1.6
RB Javonte Williams Cowboys 7.6
WR Drake London Falcons 2.7
WR Garrett Wilson Jets 3.6
WR A.J. Brown Eagles 5.6
TE Kyle Pitts Falcons 8.7
Flex Jordan Addison Vikings 9.6
Flex Travis Hunter Jaguars 10.7
SF C.J. Stroud Texans 6.7
Bench
WR Mike Evans Buccaneers 11.6
RB Zach Charbonnet Seahawks 12.7
WR Kayshon Boutte Patriots 13.6
WR Chris Brazzell II Rookie 14.7
WR Tre' Harris Chargers 15.6
RB James Conner Cardinals 16.7
QB Tua Tagovailoa Dolphins 17.6
QB Derek Carr Free Agent 18.7
TE Mark Andrews Ravens 19.6
RB Isiah Pacheco Ravens 20.7
Rookies Second Year Strategy
1 2 Win Now

Best Picks: Bijan Robinson at sixth overall was a fine value, even if running back is typically the position you wait on in dynasty. However, taking Bijan that early in a startup means you must build a roster capable of winning now, and in order to utilize Robinson’s elite window… Luckily, Matt did just that.

You can squabble over the value of taking older or capped players like A.J. Brown, Javonte Williams, and Baker Mayfield all you want, but those players fit Matt’s decision to win now. With those vets, he solidified his running back and wide receiver positions with established veterans who can help him win immediately.

While many of Matt’s picks were perfect for his team (not necessarily others), Travis Hunter was an intriguing pivot with his 10th-round pick. Hunter could have zero fantasy value in non-IDP leagues for the rest of his career… or Brian Thomas Jr. could be traded next offseason and Hunter’s elite ceiling could be realized quickly. That possibility makes him a worthy risk.

Worst Picks: As many accolades as Matt should receive for recognizing the structure of his team early and committing to it, you would like to see him get better quarterbacks in a Superflex dynasty draft. Mayfield is coming off his worst season as a Buccaneer, while C.J. Stroud has put together two disappointing years after his Rookie of the Year performance.

While there is reason for optimism that Mayfield and Stroud will both rebound if they get better blocking and play-calling, trusting an otherwise trim-and-fit roster with those passers limits this team’s upside against streaking or stacked squads.

Matt would have been better served by taking Lawrence in the third over Garrett Wilson, then taking Egbuka in the fourth.

Predicting Team Outcome: Matt should contend immediately and for several years.

The age of this roster somewhat caps his long-term potential, as does the relatively low fantasy ceiling of two quarterbacks who don’t run and have struggled recently. However, every starting position on this roster should contribute and be reliable for at least two more years. If you plug Evans in for Hunter, there are no glaring risks/holes in Matt’s starting lineup.

 

Team #7 (Brad Camara)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Patrick Mahomes Chiefs 2.6
RB Chase Brown Bengals 4.6
RB Travis Etienne Jr. Saints 7.7
WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba Seahawks 1.7
WR Jameson Williams Lions 6.6
WR DK Metcalf Steelers 8.6
TE Tyler Warren Colts 5.7
Flex Michael Pittman Jr. Colts 9.7
Flex Kyle Monangai Bears 10.6
SF Trevor Lawrence Jaguars 3.7
Bench
WR Khalil Shakir Bills 11.7
RB Rhamondre Stevenson Patriots 12.6
RB Kaytron Allen Rookie 13.7
WR Stefon Diggs Free Agent 14.6
TE Eli Stowers Rookie 15.7
RB Dylan Mitchell Browns 16.6
WR Antonio Williams Rookie 17.7
QB Justin Fields Jets 18.6
QB Jalen Milroe Seahawks 19.7
TE Jake Tonges 49ers 20.6
Rookies Second Year Strategy
3 4 Balanced

Best Picks: Patrick Mahomes has been a top-10 pick in Superflex dynasty startups for nearly a decade, but that trend has ended in 2026. In this mock, Mahomes fell to 18th overall, a result consistent with every other startup and mock I’ve done this spring. Whether it is his injury, age, or lack of elite production over the past three years, the needle is pointing down on Mahomes.

However, this dip is the kind that smart dynasty managers buy. While Mahomes has disappointed since his MVP-caliber seasons and is coming off a serious injury, he will be 31 this entire season, and his game is the type that ages well. Also, while his fantasy ceiling is lower, his floor remains that of a low-end QB1 who should age better and more reliably than most.

Along with getting Mahomes at a good discount, Brad made a worthwhile gamble on Eli Stowers in the 15th round. The Vanderbilt tight end is relatively new to the position but displayed elite athleticism at the Combine. That athleticism shows up on his tape, where he regularly finds creases in the zone and burns linebackers with his speed.

Worst Picks: Michael Pittman Jr. going in the ninth round was a bit of a reach when he was a Colt, which he was at the time of this mock, but it’s worse now that he’s in Pittsburgh. The USC alum is a strong possession receiver, but this Steelers offense has no starting QB, an established WR1 across from Pittman, and a scheme that should skew run-heavy again.

Pittman was not Brad’s only miss in the Flex. While Pittman and Kyle Monangai are “safe” but low ceiling Flex starters, Brad doesn’t balance that “safety” out with upside on his bench. Instead, he added more low ceiling backups like Stefon Diggs, Rhamondre Stevenson, Khalil Shakir, and Kaytron Allen. There is little boom or excitement in his Flex or on the bench.

Predicting Team Outcome: Brad took a risk by drafting an elite receiver (Jaxon Smith-Njigba) with his first pick, but that risk paid off when both Mahomes and Trevor Lawrence fell to his next two picks. The presence of Tyler Warren at tight end and a capable running back room solidifies this team as a balanced threat in 2026.

However, Brad’s problems at Flex and the risk of unleashing Jameson Williams as his WR2 mean this team’s title window may not open until he drafts a couple of new starters in the 2027 rookie draft. Luckily, Brad’s core is good enough and young enough to thrive even if he needs to wait a year or two to really compete.

 

Team #8 (Andrew Ball)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Jalen Hurts Eagles 2.5
RB Kyren Williams Rams 6.5
RB Jaylen Warren Steelers 9.8
WR Justin Jefferson Vikings 1.8
WR Rashee Rice Chiefs 4.5
WR Tee Higgins Bengals 5.8
TE Sam LaPorta Lions 8.5
Flex Michael Wilson Cardinals 7.8
Flex Chuba Hubbard Panthers 11.8
SF Jaxson Dart Giants 3.8
Bench
QB Daniel Jones Colts 10.5
WR Parker Washington Jaguars 12.5
RB Kenneth Gainwell Steelers 13.8
WR Jalen McMillan Buccaneers 14.5
RB Le'Veon Moss Rookie 15.8
TE Terrance Ferguson Rams 16.5
RB Jordan Mason Vikings 17.8
TE Gunnar Helm Titans 18.5
QB Taylen Green Rookie 19.8
WR Brenen Thompson Rookie 20.5
Rookies Second Year Strategy
3 3 Win Now

Best Picks: Getting Dart at 32nd overall was a fantastic value for the Superflex format, especially considering his ADP is currently 24th overall. While there is considerable risk with Dart’s injury history and inconsistent passing, he flashed elite fantasy upside as a rookie even without Malik Nabers or a reliable WR1.

Andrew got Dart at a full round discount.

Sam LaPorta was also a fine choice in the eighth round. Although his back injury is a red flag, new Lions Offensive Coordinator Drew Petzing should be a massive boost to LaPorta’s fantasy profile. Petzing engineered the most TE targets in the NFL last year, the third most in 2024, and he tied for the most in 2023. This man loves to target the tight end position.

Worst Picks: Andrew did not have a single glaring mistake in this draft plan, even if some of his choices were not always in line with ADP or perceived value. However, the running back position overall is a weakness for him, even if his draft plan was sound.

Deploying Jaylen Warren and Chuba Hubbard as your RB2 and RB3 is problematic, even if Hubbard unexpectedly returns to the 2024 efficiency he showed for the first and last time in his career. Remember, both Warren and Hubbard play for teams that value running back timeshares, and both have teammates who threaten to steal a significant number of touches.

The best-case scenario for Andrew’s backfield is that both Warren and Hubbard see 60% of their teams’ touches and deliver high-end RB3 production, in line with their career averages. The worst case is that Warren loses significant snaps to Rico Dowdle, while Brooks becomes the lead back he was drafted to be in Carolina by mid-season.

Predicting Team Outcome: Andrew drafted a Superflex team like you are supposed to, hitting on wide receiver early while securing the three capable quarterbacks that are necessary in Superflex. His quarterback room, receiver lineup, and LaPorta give him youth and talent at the three most important positions in fantasy.

With that said, Andrew has likely positioned himself to compete in 2026, but he will not be a true contender until he drafts or trades for at least one more capable RB/Flex.

 

Team #9 (Jamie Calandro)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Lamar Jackson Ravens 1.9
RB Ashton Jeanty Raiders 2.4
RB Saquon Barkley Eagles 5.9
WR Tetairoa McMillan Panthers 3.9
WR Zay Flowers Ravens 6.4
WR Xavier Worthy Chiefs 8.4
TE Tucker Kraft Packers 7.9
Flex Quentin Johnston Chargers 10.4
Flex Rico Dowdle Steelers 11.9
SF Jordan Love Packers 4.4
Bench
QB J.J. McCarthy Vikings 9.9
Rb Jacory Croskey-Merritt Commanders 12.4
WR Pat Bryant Broncos 13.9
WR Romeo Doubs Patriots 14.4
TE Hunter Henry Patriots 15.9
WR Elic Ayomanor Titans 16.4
RB Aaron Jones Vikings 17.9
WR Keon Coleman Bills 18.4
RB Kendre Miller Saints 19.9
QB Quinn Ewers Dolphins 20.4
Rookies Second Year Strategy
0 6 Win Now

Best Picks: Although Saquon Barkley may be on the downside of his career, getting him with the 57th overall pick is still strong value.

The record-setting back was bound to decline after his heavy usage in 2024, but much of his struggles last year were due to poor play design. That should hopefully be solved with a new play caller, making Barkley a good win-now pick here. While he’s unlikely to replicate his 2024 season, Barkley’s burst on film and receiving ability suggest he can still be a low-end RB1.

Jordan Love was also a solid value with the 40th overall pick.

While Green Bay historically likes to lean on the run, which has limited Love’s fantasy upside in the past, Josh Jacobs began to show signs of age last year, and Love took advantage. In four full games with Jacobs out or playing injured, Love was on pace to finish as QB2 overall with 21.7 fantasy points per game.

That rate could become Love’s norm this year, given Jacobs’ injury history and age (28).

Worst Picks: While he is still young and physically gifted, the train seems to already be leaving the station on J.J. McCarthy, making him a reach at 105th overall… even in a Superflex league.

It is worth noting that this mock was conducted before Murray signed with Minnesota. However, the buzz for months has suggested the Vikings were looking to bring in a quarterback to compete with McCarthy after the Michigan alum put together some of the worst tape in recent memory. Murray is arguably the worst-case scenario for McCarthy truthers, though.

Xavier Worthy was also a bit of a reach/risk at 88th overall, given that his startup ADP is in the 12th round and the Chiefs are reportedly looking for receiving help this offseason. While Worthy showed flashes as a rookie and could rebound, reports that Kansas City could draft a receiver in the first round of the NFL Draft, or sign Tyreek Hill, are troubling.

Predicting Team Outcome: The primary concerns on this roster are at WR3 (Worthy) and Flex (Dowdle and Quentin Johnston). However, Jamie’s starters at quarterback, running back, and tight end are all borderline elite. If Zay Flowers and Tetairoa McMillan receive a spike in targets this year, then Jamie has a real shot to contend in 2026.

However, like most teams in this mock, Jamie’s team lacks depth. That could become a problem if Lamar Jackson continues to get hurt, if Barkley really has hit his wall, or if Worthy really does lose his job to a new addition.

 

Team #10 (Jorden Hill)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Caleb Williams Bears 2.3
RB Jahmyr Gibbs Lions 1.10
RB Jonah Coleman Rookie 8.3
WR George Pickens Cowboys 3.10
WR Brian Thomas Jr. Jaguars 5.10
WR Makai Lemon Rookie 6.3
TE Dalton Kincaid Bills 11.10
Flex DJ Moore Bills 12.3
Flex Wan'Dale Robinson Titans 10.3
SF Bo Nix Broncos 4.3
Bench
QB Bryce Young Panthers 7.10
RB Blake Corum Rams 9.10
WR Jayden Reed Packers 13.10
RB Braelon Allen Jets 14.3
TE Theo Johnson Giants 15.10
WR Tory Horton Seahawks 16.3
RB Sean Tucker Buccaneers 17.10
TE T.J. Hockenson Vikings 18.3
QB Will Howard Steelers 19.10
WR Adonai Mitchell Jets 20.3
Rookies Second Year Strategy
2 2 Balanced

Best Picks: While 13th overall is exactly where Caleb Williams’ ADP is for Superflex startups, it is still a strong value when you consider what we have already seen and what he still has left to give.

Williams was seventh amongst quarterbacks in rushing yards and eighth in fantasy ppg last year. Better yet, he did all that with multiple injuries in his receiving corps and raw mechanics that can still be improved upon. That all suggests that 13th overall is Williams’ fantasy floor, but not his ceiling if Ben Johnson can continue to develop the supremely talented Heisman winner.

In addition to Williams, D.J. Moore proved to be a fantastic value in the 12th round of this mock. However, it is worth noting that this mock was conducted before Moore was traded to Buffalo, which explains why he was drafted three full rounds behind his current ADP.

Worst Picks: Jonah Coleman at 87th overall is a significant reach, even for those who believe in the Husky more than almost every NFL Draft analyst.

For context, consider that most NFL Draft analysts (including Yours Truly) consider Coleman a third-round prospect with limited receiving ability in a weak running back class. Nothing about his film suggests he has more upside than Tuten, or is safer than LaPorta or Kyle Pitts Sr., all of whom were drafted after Coleman in this mock

Predicting Team Outcome: Jorden is set at quarterback, with Caleb Williams offering elite potential while Bo Nix and Bryce Young offer relatively safe floors. He also has an elite lead back in Jahmyr Gibbs, along with a talented receiving corps that balances upside (George Pickens, Makai Lemon, and Brian Thomas Jr.) with stability (Moore, Wan’Dale Robinson).

The biggest holes on this roster are at RB2 and TE, where Jordan’s selection of Coleman over Pitts and Swift resulted in two roster holes instead of one. Had Jordan taken Tuten/Swift as his RB2 and drafted George Kittle or Jake Ferguson in the 13th round, he would have improved his upside and added elite depth at the two positions he is weakest.

Kittle should not fall to the 14th round, injured or not.

 

Team #11 (Nicho Roessler)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Brock Purdy 49ers 4.2
RB Bucky Irving Buccaneers 3.11
RB Cam Skattebo Giants 6.2
WR Amon-Ra St. Brown Lions 1.11
WR Malik Nabers Giants 2.2
WR Marvin Harrison Jr. Cardinals 5.11
TE Harold Fannin Jr. Browns 7.11
Flex Derrick Henry Ravens 8.2
Flex Courtland Sutton Broncos 9.11
SF Michael Penix Falcons 10.2
Bench
WR Jauan Jennings Free Agent 11.11
WR Elijah Sarratt Rookie 12.2
TE Jake Ferguson Cowboys 13.11
RB J.K. Dobbins Broncos 14.2
WR Germie Bernard Rookie 15.11
RB Kaleb Johnson Steelers 16.2
RB Ollie Gordon II Dolphins 17.11
WR Ja'Kobi Lane Rookie 18.2
RB Joe Mixon Free Agent 19.11
WR Tez Johnson Buccaneers 20.2
Rookies Second Year Strategy
3 5 Balanced

Best Picks: Harold Fannin Jr. is a strong value at 83rd overall, even if this is not a TE Premium format.

While there are concerns about the Browns turning away from a tight end-centric offense after Kevin Stefanski’s firing, the exit of David Njoku should solidify Fannin’s role as TE1 in Cleveland. Plus, new Head Coach Todd Monken’s offense actually targeted the tight end position on 29% of their throws, which was top ten in the NFL.

Germie Bernard also offers strong value at 179th overall. Bernard is likely a Day 2 pick in this year’s NFL Draft, which is draft capital that usually leads to a spike in fantasy manager interest. Given that some liken Bernard to a poor man’s Deebo Samuel, it is safe to say his stock will only climb from where Nicho drafted him.

Worst Picks: Nicho practically doomed his team to a mediocre start just by waiting at quarterback.

All reports are that Michael Penix Jr.’s injury could linger into the season, if not longer. Worse, all reports are that the team signed Tua Tagovailoa to “compete” with Penix for the starting job, even if the Washington alum is healthy and ready for camp. That is not news you want to hear when Penix is your starting QB2, and you have no other backup at the position.

The choice of Cam Skattebo at 62nd overall was also a risky one, as the team has reportedly shown interest in adding a “significant” running back this offseason. At the time of this mock, reports of New York’s interest in Jeremiyah Love were already prevalent, so that risk makes Skattebo an incredibly risky pick, even if it does carry upside.

Predicting Team Outcome: This team is in trouble at quarterback… which isn’t always a bad thing.

One of the biggest CHEAT CODES in dynasty Superflex is to draft an elite roster everywhere… but leave your quarterback positions empty. If you follow that strategy, you can often field a very good team but still secure the 1.01 pick in your next rookie draft because your team consistently rolls out a zero-burger at QB, keeping your max points and record low.

If you were to utilize this Zero Quarterback strategy, you could hypothetically build an elite roster at every other position and then draft one or two elite quarterback prospects in the “historic” 2027 rookie class.

Unfortunately, Nicho stopped short of the Zero QB theory when he drafted Brock Purdy. That pick, combined with Amon-Ra St. Brown, Nabers, Fannin, and Derrick Henry, should keep Nicho from securing one of the first few picks in rookie drafts. As a result, his QB2 spot could be a problem for several years and keep him from contending before Henry retires.

 

Team #12 (Brandon Murchinson)

Pos. Player Team Pick #
QB Joe Burrow Bengals 2.1
RB Quinshon Judkins Browns 5.12
RB Kenneth Walker III Chiefs 6.1
WR CeeDee Lamb Cowboys 1.12
WR Chris Olave Saints 3.12
WR Ricky Pearsall 49ers 7.12
TE Brenton Strange Jaguars 11.12
Flex Jakobi Meyers Jaguars 9.12
Flex Trey Benson Cardinals 10.1
SF Dak Prescott Cowboys 4.1
Bench
QB Sam Darnold Seahawks 8.1
WR Chris Bell Rookie 12.1
WR Chris Godwin Jr. Buccaneers 13.12
TE George Kittle 49ers 14.1
WR Skyler Bell Rookie 15.12
WR Chimere Dike Titans 16.1
RB Brian Robinson Jr. 49ers 17.12
RB Keaton Mitchell Ravens 18.1
TE David Njoku Free Agent 19.12
RB J'Mari Taylor Rookie 20.1
Rookies Second Year Strategy
3 2 Win Now

Best Picks: Getting Chris Olave with the 36th overall pick is good value, given his current ADP in startups is 30th.

While injuries remain a concern, Olave is still relatively young and is coming off the best season of his career with the best quarterback he’s played with in his career. Remember that Olave finished sixth in targets, eighth in receiving yards, and eighth in receiving touchdowns last year.

With Shough, Olave’s pace was even better. Shough had the former Buckeye on pace for the fifth-most targets, fifth-most receiving yards, and second-most receiving touchdowns in the NFL.

Along with Olave, Brandon got a screaming deal on Kittle in the 14th round. While the former All-Pro is dealing with an Achilles injury that could change the course of his career, Kittle’s importance to the 49ers as a blocker, short-area weapon, and leader means he should have at least two more years of fantasy relevance in a tight end-friendly offense.

Finally, Brandon was wise to secure Chris Bell in the 12th round, even if he did reach a bit above Bell’s current ADP (15th round). Bell has the size, speed, and contested catch skills to grow into a WR1 if he can get healthy and land with the right team. Rumors are that the 49ers are very interested in Bell, which could be his ideal long-term fit.

Worst Picks: Taking Ricky Pearsall at 84th overall was a head-scratching pick when you consider Brandon had a need at tight end and both Pitts and LaPorta were available. Both tight ends carry more positional value, upside, and safety than the unproven Pearsall. Plus, tight end wound up being a significant weakness for Brandon, who is starting Brenton Strange.

When you break down the math of this mock, it is clear why Brandon felt he had to fill his WR room with Pearsall, but receiver is the deepest position in fantasy. Had he taken Pitts or LaPorta over Pearsall, Brandon would have solidified his weakest position while retaining the ability to load up on receivers with later picks.

Predicting Team Outcome: Brandon is set at quarterback for the near future with two veteran passers who could both finish top-10 at their position (Joe Burrow and Dak Prescott). He also drafted two high upside options at running back, with Kenneth Walker III being a particularly strong pick since he subsequently became a Chief.

However, the selections of Pearsall and Trey Benson have aged poorly since free agency. Plus, Strange makes tight end a weakness and means Brandon needs Kittle to return quickly. While Kittle may solve the TE problem, there is no answer on the bench if Pearsall, Benson, or Quinshon Judkins struggle this year.

More Fantasy Football Analysis



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Luis Robert Jr.

Officially Placed on Injured List
Isaac TeSlaa

Still a Dynasty Depth Piece Worth Holding
Pat Bryant

Still a Quality Buy-Low Despite Crowded Broncos Receiver Room
Luis Robert Jr.

Likely to Land on the Injured List
Troy Franklin

Dynasty Expectations Low for Troy Franklin
Trevor Lawrence

Dynasty Value Remains High Despite Quiet Jaguars Offseason
Courtland Sutton

Dynasty Value Unaffected by NFL Draft
Clayton Keller

Sets Up Two Goals Wednesday Night
Pavel Dorofeyev

Nets Special Hat Trick in Game 5 Win
Dan Vladar

Backstops Flyers to Series-Clinching Win
Leon Draisaitl

Oilers to Use Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl on Same Line Thursday
Brady Tkachuk

Remains Committed to Senators
Arttu Hyry

Could Be Available Thursday
James Harden

Contributes in All Areas Wednesday
Dennis Schröder

Dennis Schroder Plays Key Role in Game 5 Win
RJ Barrett

Records First Double-Double of the Season
Austin Reaves

Contributes 22 Points Off the Bench in Game 5 Loss
LeBron James

Regains Scoring Touch Wednesday
Paolo Banchero

Scores 45 Points in Game 5 Loss
New York Jets

Jets Pick Up Will McDonald's Fifth-Year Option
Azeez Al-Shaair

Texans, Azeez Al-Shaair Agree to Three-Year Extension
KC Concepcion

Looking to Build Chemistry With Second-Year QB
Deshaun Watson

"Looks Great," Leading QB Battle After First Minicamp?
George Pickens

Signs the Franchise Tag on Wednesday
Cade Cunningham

Helps Pistons Survive With 45-Point Effort
Jock Landale

to Remain Unavailable in Game 6
Peyton Watson

to Remain Out Thursday
Austin Reaves

Cleared to Return Wednesday
Luka Dončić

Luka Doncic Remains Without Timetable for Return
Brandon Nimmo

Leaves Wednesday's Game With Hamstring Tightness
Brandon Ingram

Won't Play in Second Half Wednesday
Aaron Gordon

Questionable for Game 6
Josh Hart

Iffy for Game 6
Joel Embiid

Likely to Play in Game 6
Bones Hyland

Could Miss Game 6
Kevin Huerter

Not Available for Game 5
Jonathan Isaac

Remains Out for Game 5
Franz Wagner

Won't Play in Game 5
MLB

Phillies-Giants Postponed on Wednesday Due to Rain
Nils Lundkvist

to Remain Out Thursday
Jonas Brodin

Uncertain for Game 6
Matvei Michkov

Expected to Rejoin Flyers Lineup Wednesday
Noah Ostlund

Set to Miss "a Period of Time"
Viktor Arvidsson

Doubtful for Game 6 Against Sabres
Barrett Hayton

Close to Returning
Charle-Edouard D'Astous

a Game-Time Call Wednesday
Brandon Aiyuk

Decision Could Come in Late May
Bryce Young

Panthers Pick Up Bryce Young's Fifth-Year Option
MLB

Orioles-Astros Game Postponed Due to Inclement Weather on Wednesday
Gary Woodland

Riding Momentum Into Cadillac Championship
Jordan Spieth

Brings Boom-or-Bust Potential to Cadillac Championship
Adam Scott

Looks Poised for Another Strong Finish at Doral
Maverick McNealy

Needs Approach Game to Click at Doral
George Springer

Being Activated From Injured List, Won't Start on Wednesday
Wyatt Langford

Expected to be Activated on Saturday
Garrett Crochet

Goes on Injured List With Shoulder Inflammation
CFB

Jameson Williams Files Lawsuit Against NCAA, SEC, Big Ten
Junior Caminero

Back in Wednesday's Lineup After Injury Scare
Harry Hall

Volatility Continues at Cadillac Championship
Tommy Fleetwood

Looks to Rebound at Trump National Doral
Pierceson Coody

a Risky Value Play at Cadillac Championship
Deebo Samuel Sr.

Will Deebo Samuel Sr. Find a New Team Before Training Camps Open?
Jalen Johnson

Collects Second Playoff Double-Double
Akshay Bhatia

Offers Upside with Risk at Cadillac Championship
Elic Ayomanor

Dynasty Stock Way Down After NFL Draft
Jalen Brunson

Pours 39 Points on Hawks in Game 5
Darius Slayton

Dynasty Value Fading After Busy Giants Offseason
David Njoku

With the NFL Draft Over, David Njoku Could Soon Find a Team
Tyler Warren

a Major Offseason Winner
Connor McDavid

Extends Multi-Point Streak Tuesday
Justin Thomas

a Scary Proposition at Cadillac Championship
Nikolaj Ehlers

Hurricanes Hope to Have Nikolaj Ehlers Back for Second Round
Alexander Nikishin

Could Be Available in Round 2
Victor Hedman

Logs Full Practice
Scottie Scheffler

The Leading Favorite at Cadillac Championship
Noah Ostlund

Likely to Miss Time Due to Lower-Body Injury
Arttu Hyry

Unlikely to Play Thursday
Collin Morikawa

Still a Smash Play at Cadillac Championship
Jonas Brodin

Spotted Using Crutches After Game 5
Viktor Hovland

Showed at Augusta He Can Finish Well
Sepp Straka

Attempting to Finish Better in Miami
PGA

J.J Spaun Enduring Roller Coaster Start to 2026
Min Woo Lee

Seeks to Make Adjustments at Cadillac Championship
Max Homa

May Struggle at Old Doral This Weekend
Ben Griffin

Rebounds From Rough Stretch as Miami Looms
Shane Lowry

Searching For Answers at Cadillac Championship
Russell Wilson

Jets Host Russell Wilson for a Visit, Considering him as Backup Option
Russell Henley

Daunting Test at Doral Likely Not a Place For Russell Henley
Jonathon Brooks

Fully Cleared for Offseason Program
Christian Gonzalez

Patriots Exercise Christian Gonzalez's Fifth-Year Option
Tyler Allgeier

One of the Biggest Losers After NFL Draft
Justin Rose

Returns to Action After Finishing Third at Masters Tournament
Hideki Matsuyama

Has The Approach Game to Win at Cadillac Championship
Junior Caminero

Suffers Jaw Contusion on Tuesday, Considered Day-to-Day
Pete Fairbanks

Going on Injured List With Nerve Irritation
Spencer Strider

to Make Season Debut This Weekend
Roope Hintz

Likely to Miss Entire First-Round Series
Luis Robert Jr.

Out on Tuesday With Back Tightness
Juan Soto

Dealing With Forearm Tightness, Serving as DH on Tuesday
CFB

Brendan Sorsby Facing Potential Permanent Loss of Eligibility
Manny Machado

Departs Early With Undisclosed Injury on Monday
Philadelphia Phillies

Phillies Fire Manager Rob Thomson
Elmer Rodríguez

Yankees to Promote Top Pitching Prospect Elmer Rodriguez
Pete Fairbanks

Pulled on Monday With "Unusual Sensation" in his Thumb
Giancarlo Stanton

Heading to Injured List With Calf Strain
Travis Bazzana

Guardians Calling Up Former First Overall Pick Travis Bazzana
Will Smith

Back in Action in Series Opener Against Marlins
Carson Hocevar

Scores his First Career NASCAR Cup Series Victory at Talladega
Chris Buescher

Misses out on Winning at Talladega by Finishing Second
Alex Bowman

Earns First Top-Five Finish at Talladega Since Returning From Injury
Chase Elliott

Scores A Fourth-Place Finish at Talladega
Zane Smith

Nabs First Top-Five Finish of the 2026 Season at Talladega
CFB

Texas Tech Quarterback Brendan Sorsby Enters Rehab
Youssef Zalal

Suffers Unanimous-Decision Loss
Aljamain Sterling

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Norma Dumont

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 116
Joselyne Edwards

Scores Upset Win
Alexander Hernandez

Gets Dominated
Alexander Hernandez

Rafa Garcia Dominates Alexander Hernandez
Adrian Luna Martinetti

Unsuccessful In His UFC Debut
Davey Grant

Gets Back In The Win Column
Denny Hamlin

Is Denny Hamlin Worth Rostering for Talladega?
NASCAR

Is Bubba Wallace Playable in Talladega DFS Lineups?
Tyler Reddick

Stay Away From Tyler Reddick at Talladega
Ryan Blaney

Can Ryan Blaney Shake Off The Bad Luck at Talladega?
Austin Cindric

Could Contend For Another Talladega Win
Kyle Busch

an Easy DFS Pick at Talladega
Ricky Stenhouse Jr

. a High-Risk, High-Reward Pick at Talladega
Todd Gilliland

a Sleeper to Watch at Talladega
Brad Keselowski

Is Brad Keselowski Worth Rostering for Talladega Lineups?
Chase Briscoe

Could Chase Briscoe be A Sneaky Tournament Play for Talladega Lineups?
Christopher Bell

Should DFS Managers Trust Christopher Bell at Talladega?
Ty Gibbs

Is A DFS Risk for Talladega Lineups
Youssef Zalal

Set For UFC Vegas 116 Main Event
Aljamain Sterling

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 116
Joselyne Edwards

Set For UFC Vegas 116 Co-Main Event
Norma Dumont

Looks To Extend Her Win Streak
Alexander Hernandez

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 116
Rafa Garcia

Looks For His Third Consecutive Win
Adrian Luna Martinetti

Set For His UFC Debut
Davey Grant

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF