When Is Payton Tolle Getting Called Up? Fantasy Baseball Prospect Outlook (Week 4 Update)

April 18, 2026

When is Payton Tolle getting called up? Will Payton Tolle pitch in April of this MLB season? Read about Payton Tolle's debut date and fantasy baseball prospect updates for 2026.

Boston Red Sox starting pitching prospect Payton Tolle has flashed elite upside at the Triple-A level and is establishing himself as an early-season top stash candidate.

Tolle has now turned in two strong starts in back-to-back weeks and appears to be on the verge of joining the Red Sox.

Should managers stash Tolle ahead of Week 4? When will he return to the majors? Let's dive in!

• BvP matchups data (Batter vs. Pitcher)
• PvB matchups data (Pitcher vs. Batter)
• Who should I start? Fantasy baseball comparisons
• Who should I pickup? Fantasy baseball comparisons
• Fantasy baseball trade analyzer
• MLB Props finder tool
• Fantasy baseball closer depth charts

Payton Tolle Prospect Update for Fantasy Baseball

Since surrendering four runs in his Triple-A season debut on March 29, Tolle has quickly rounded into form and is looking like one of the most dominant pitchers in the minor leagues. Over his last two outings, the hard-throwing southpaw has logged 11 innings of two-run ball (one earned) with just seven hits allowed, two walks, and an impressive 13 punchouts.

In his most recent start, Tolle tossed five shutout frames with six of these punchouts.

The Red Sox moved Tolle through the minor leagues very quickly last season, which allowed him to earn a short taste of the majors late in the second half. While he struggled during that short stint, which ultimately led to his move to Triple-A to open the 2026 season, the former TCU standout is flashing elite upside and showing he is more than capable of returning to the big leagues.

Nice outing for Payton Tolle today.

4 IP | 3 H | 0 ER | 0 BB | 5 K
11 Whiffs

Pitch Usage
4-Seam: 36%
Cutter: 28%
Sinker: 16%
Curve: 14%
Changeup: 5%

Love seeing the more diverse arsenal.pic.twitter.com/Jrf7Lxony3

— Eric Cross (@EricCrossMLB) March 17, 2026

Payton Tolle Outlook for Fantasy Baseball

Tolle made his professional debut at the start of the 2025 season and showed minimal growing pains as he moved through the Boston system. Tolle began with High-A, where he logged 49 2/3 innings to the tune of a 3.62 ERA and a 1.18 WHIP. During this stint, Tolle struck out 79 batters. He was then bumped up to Double-A, where he was even sharper, striking out 37 hitters while carrying a 16.7 ERA over 27 innings.

The southpaw then debuted at Triple-A Worcester, where he needed just three starts before earning the green light of debut in Boston. While he has allowed 11 earned runs over his 16 1/3 MLB innings, the 23-year-old has looked very comfortable at Triple-A this season and should bounce back in his second look,

While the Red Sox rotation appears to be full at the moment, Tolle is one injury away from becoming a fantasy mainstay due to his high-end strikeout upside. He is worth stashing in all 12-team leagues ahead of Week 4.

Six strikeouts through four scoreless innings for Payton Tolle in Triple-A pic.twitter.com/g6B4eydeyI

— Hunter Noll (@Hunter_Noll) April 12, 2026

Fantasy Baseball Redraft Prospect Stash Rankings

You can also check out the rest of Eric Cross's fantasy baseball redraft prospect stash rankings.

Promoted This Week: Noah Schultz (CHW)

Honorable Mentions (Hitters): Lazaro Montes (SEA), Harry Ford (WAS), Ryan Clifford (NYM), Kemp Alderman (MIA), Kevin Alcantara (CHC), Esmerlyn Valdez (PIT), Gabriel Gonzalez (MIN), Zac Veen (COL), Deyvison De Los Santos (MIA), Hector Rodriguez (CIN), Michael Arroyo (SEA), Pedro Ramirez (CHC), Blaze Jordan (STL), Ryan Ward (LAD), Luis Lara (MIL), Jacob Melton (TBR)

Honorable Mentions (Pitchers): Gage Jump (ATH), Carlos Lagrange (NYY), Elmer Rodriguez (NYY), Hagen Smith (CHW), Jaxon Wiggins (CHC), Trey Gibson (BAL), Brody Hopkins (TBR)

Top Prospect Dynasty Rankings

Looking for longer-term fantasy baseball prospect rankings? You can also check out RotoBaller's top dynasty prospect rankings from Eric Cross:

Prospect notes and analysis can be found below the rankings table.

Prospect Eligibility: Less than 130 MLB ABs or 50 IP (I'm ignoring service time)

Rankings Updated: March 2026

Who Should I Pickup Fantasy Baseball Tool

Trying to decide who to pick up off the waiver wire? Check the Who Should I Pickup tool:

Who Should I Pickup?

Roto Points

Compare up to four players and we'll tell you who to pickup...

Who To Pickup?

Reset

Choose From The Top Ranked Players

Overall

C

1B

2B

3B

SS

OF

SP

RP

Popular Searches

Overall

C

1B

2B

3B

SS

OF

SP

RP

2026 Player Decisions. Looking to pick up someone else instead? Today's focus is on specific players like Payton Tolle, Justin Crawford, Owen Caissie, Didier Fuentes, Mick Abel, Bryce Eldridge, Bryan Baker, Carter Jensen, Jake Burger. These are some common searches for 2026 fantasy baseball waiver wire pickups.

Using The Tool. This is a simple tool but very powerful. The first step is to enter the player names that you want to compare. In the first box, search for the first player's name. In the second box, search for the second player's name. Compare up to four MLB players at once, and then click the Who To Pickup? button to see who the recommended waiver wire pickups are based on fantasy baseball rankings, projections, and more.

Improvements For Who Should I Pickup? You may have noticed, our Who Should I Pickup? tool has gotten an overhaul. We've added lots of great features for you to give you as much information as possible to win on the waiver wire in 2026. You'll see MLB player tiles with stats, projections, and a slick new interface. We hope you enjoy!

How It Works. Our RotoBaller staff puts together their weekly fantasy baseball waiver wire rankings and projections based on their research, and updates them constantly throughout the week. That information is the core data that is powering the decision-making in this tool. When you search for player names, you will only see those players who are ranked.

Popular Player Comparison Searches - Who To Pickup

Looking to pick up someone else instead? Below are some popular searches and comparisons from our Who To Pickup tool for 2026 for players like Payton Tolle, Justin Crawford, Owen Caissie, Didier Fuentes, Mick Abel, Bryce Eldridge, Bryan Baker, Carter Jensen, Jake Burger:

More Fantasy Baseball Analysis