Later-Round Catcher Fantasy Baseball Draft Sleepers, Values: Cheap Hitters With Upside

Link copied to clipboard!

Later-round catcher (C) fantasy baseball sleepers, breakouts predictions for 2026. These cheap catcher draft values with upside make for great late-round picks.

In This Article hide

Who Should I Draft Fantasy Baseball Tool

More Fantasy Baseball Analysis

RotoBallers, we are back with some more late-round fantasy baseball values and sleepers for your upcoming 2026 fantasy baseball drafts. Today, we focus on catchers. Although the catcher position has been deep in recent years, it can still be volatile, and every year viable catchers emerge as waiver wire options or later-round picks. Below we have five later-round catcher fantasy baseball sleepers and values to consider drafting.

The later rounds are where you can shoot for the moon and select players with league-winning upside, take a chance on an injured star, or even an emerging top prospect. If fantasy managers miss out on taking a top 12 catcher in their upcoming fantasy drafts, we have some late-round options who could pay off and be a tremendous value. Are their ADPs undervalued? Will these hitters provide a big return on their draft day cost? Read on to see our takes.

The five catcher fantasy baseball outlooks for 2026 below are meant to give you a taste of the in-depth analysis you receive with our industry-leading 2026 Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit. Be sure to save 30% on any MLB Package today to start reading all of our in-depth 2026 player outlooks and many other premium articles and tools, including Team Sync, the Live Draft Sync assistant, Custom Rankings Service, and so much more. Let's win some leagues in 2026!

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

Later-Round Values: Catcher Fantasy Baseball Sleepers

Carter Jensen, C, Kansas City Royals

After a breakout 2024 season in the Minors, Carter Jensen followed it up with an even better 2025 season. Jensen started 2024 in High-A but finished last year in the Majors as he impressed at each stop and became the Royals' top prospect along the way. Jensen also looked the part in the majors. In 20 games for the Royals, Jensen hit .300/.391/.550 with three home runs.

It's important not to get too carried away with such a small sample. But given he hit .292/.360/.420 with six homers at Double-A (68 games) and .288/.404/.647 with 14 homers at Triple-A (43 games) before his promotion last year, we can safely say his MLB numbers weren't a fluke. A .300 batting average might be a bit too big of an ask over a full season, but his bat looks major league-ready.

Royals manager Matt Quatraro on MLB's No. 18 prospect Carter Jensen:

“He's a rat. He's going to do everything in his power to be as good as he can be... you've gotta think sky is the limit [for him].”

MLB Network + @SageUSAmerica pic.twitter.com/0Bl2NrktJp

— MLB Network (@MLBNetwork) February 24, 2026

With Salvador Perez spending less time behind the plate, Jensen has a route to ample playing time, either catching or as the Royals' designated hitter. With the hitter-friendly changes to Kauffman Stadium, 2026 is set to be a productive year for hitters in Kansas City. Even with the catcher pool being deeper than ever in fantasy, Jensen should not be overlooked and could easily end the season as a top 10 fantasy catcher.

-- Jamie Steed - RotoBaller

Kyle Teel, C, Chicago White Sox

Chicago White Sox catcher Kyle Teel had a successful half-season in the Majors last year and will look to carry that momentum into the 2026 campaign. In 78 MLB games, Teel batted .273 with eight homers, 38 runs, 35 RBI, and three stolen bases. More impressively, he had a 12.5% walk rate, which helped him post a .375 on-base percentage that ranked second among all catchers with at least 100 plate appearances.

Teel posted double-digit walk rates at every minor league level, so he should get a boost in fantasy leagues that reward walks or OBP. From a batted-ball perspective, Teel checks all the boxes fantasy players love. His 9.6% barrel-rate was well above league average, and he ranked in the 91st percentile in pull-air rate.

The downside to Teel is simply his situation. The White Sox are not a great lineup, and Teel will need to split catching duties with Edgar Quero, who was a highly rated catching prospect in his own right. Playing time questions and the possibility of a sophomore slump make Teel a risky bet inside the top 200 picks in fantasy. However, if he slips past that average draft position, he does offer intriguing upside as a low-end starter in one-catcher leagues.

-- Mike Schwarzenbach - RotoBaller

Alejandro Kirk, C, Toronto Blue Jays

Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk turned in the best season of his big league career in 2025, posting a .282/.348/.421 (116 wRC+) slash line, along with career highs in home runs (15) and RBI (76). In addition, the 27-year-old catcher had the best quality of contact of his career with a 50.8% hard-hit rate and 10.1% barrel rate.

Kirk's calling card at the plate is his elite contact ability with a career 11.6% strikeout rate. There could also be untapped power potential with Kirk, as he ranked in the top 15 in the gap between his actual SLG (.421) and xSLG (.480).

Kirk provides a high floor at batting average that is hard to find at the catcher position, though it will likely come with somewhat underwhelming counting stats. Kirk offers no value in the stolen base category due to his poor speed, but he remains a solid option in the mid-100s of drafts as a third-to-fourth tier catcher with a strong batting average and moderate power upside.

-- Kyle McCarthy - RotoBaller

Samuel Basallo, C, Baltimore Orioles

The number of all-star caliber catchers for the Baltimore Orioles is about to double from one to two with Samuel Basallo set for his first full major league season in 2026. The powerful 21-year-old rookie backstop cranked 23 home runs in just 76 Triple-A games before adding four more in 31 games with the Orioles.

The quality of contact metrics truly stands out here with Basallo, who registered an impressive 56.9% hard-hit rate and 94.2 mph AVG EV in Triple-A last season, both of which ranked near the top of the Triple-A leaderboard. He also walked at a 13.7% clip while keeping the strikeout rate in check at 23.7%.

Even if his below-average contact rate keeps the batting average in check, Basallo's level of impact could allow him to keep the average in the .260 range while possibly pushing 25-30 home runs as a rookie. He's a great upside play if you want to wait on a catcher in your fantasy drafts.

-- Eric Cross - RotoBaller

Logan O'Hoppe, C, Los Angeles Angels

Los Angeles Angels catcher Logan O'Hoppe was a popular breakout candidate last year. That didn't materialise. In 119 games, the Angels catcher hit .213/.258/.371 with 19 home runs, 43 RBI, 35 runs, and two stolen bases. A significant drop off from his .244/.303/.409 slash line in 2024 (136 games) and 2023 emergence when O'Hoppe hit .236/.296/.500 in 51 games.

O'Hoppe's quality of contact last year was similar to 2024. His 13.3% Barrel% ranked in the 83rd percentile, and 46.9% HardHit% ranked in the 72nd percentile. O'Hoppe also had a solid .425 xSLG (expected slugging percentage), which ranked in the 52nd percentile. It's unlikely O'Hoppe will hit for a good average, given his .228 xBA in 2025. O'Hoppe also had a .318 BABIP in 2024, which will have helped him hit .244.

Logan O’Hoppe with a solid start to ST:

.333 AVG
2 HR
6 RBI
2 BB
1.467 OPS
pic.twitter.com/7hEeCD6P5p

— SleeperAngels (@SleeperAngels) March 2, 2026

The power is legitimate, and even though catcher is a position of more depth than we've seen for many years, only nine catchers hit more home runs in 2025 than O'Hoppe. The Angels' backstop played fewer games than all nine of them. In two catcher leagues, O'Hoppe is an ideal second option. Especially as ~20 catchers are being drafted before him. In deeper one-catcher leagues, if you skip on the top options, O'Hoppe should still be on your radar in the last couple of rounds.

-- Jamie Steed - RotoBaller