👉 TAP TO SAVE 30% WITH CODE NEW
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Props Tool
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

MLB DFS: Cash Game And 50/50 Strategies For Draftkings And FanDuel

This is a free article from our MLB premium DFS strategy series. See the rest of our premium DFS strategy articles here.

Hey RotoBallers! Hopefully by this point you're loving your investment in our premium content, and why wouldn't you be?! This is some of the best DFS advice on the web. However, all of this research and preparation is for nothing if you can't make a DFS profit. As you may have found out already, "cash games" (contests in which close to or exactly 50% of entries get paid) are the easiest way to do that. However, just because cash games give you a better chance to make some money doesn't mean it's going to be a walk in the park. Let me lay down the law in terms of what you'll need in order to profit playing cash games in MLB DFS this season.

 

Pay Up For Pitching

While high risk/high reward lineups bring home the dough in GPPs (Guaranteed Prize Pools), you don't need to beat everyone to be successful in a cash game. Therefore, you want a safe play whenever possible in hopes that you can stay with the pack. The key here is that landing the right pitcher(s) in cash games is almost necessary. While it won't guarantee you money, having your pitcher(s) get shelled will nearly guarantee a loss.

So, if landing the right pitcher(s) is necessary, then just pick on the worst offense every night, right? Well, not always. Most of the time I will take the proven ace in an average matchup over the pitcher who is third or fourth in his rotation with a seemingly easy matchup. The baseball season is very, very long. Outliers happen more often than in other sports. The Phillies, while potentially holding the worst offense in baseball, can still score eight runs on any given night. It happens, so pay up for the ace.

Most times that choice will be obvious, but it will be tempting to go with a lesser-skilled pitcher against a seemingly worse team in order to spend more money on hitters. While that will work some of the time, the odds say you're better off finding value in hitters and paying up for the sure thing at the pitching spot.

The game changes a bit on sites like DraftKings that require two pitchers (notice I was typing "pitcher(s)" above). It's not always sensible to roll out two aces in cash games. One of them may under perform, and that would likely leave you on the outside looking in. On these sites, you need to have one ace, but you should probably pair that ace with the safest value pitcher possible. Scott Kazmir at home against the Brewers seems like an example of one that would make sense.

In summation, you want safety at the pitching spot. Whether it's occupied by one player or two, good pitching is not going to guarantee you a cash game win. A bad pitching performance, however, will lead to a bad DFS night 90% of the time.

 

Choose Your Hitters Like Billy Beane Would

The reason why paying up for the elite pitchers rather than the elite hitters is because the elite pitchers have a higher presumed floor. Even in a rough outing they're probably going to go five or six innings and get their share of strikeouts.

Elite hitters go 0-for-4 and 0-for-5 all the time. It happens. It happens even more often when you're a Pedro Alvarez-type player who is only good for that one home run each game. So, if you want to follow the trend of being safe like we did with pitchers, you are probably never rostering a player like Alvarez in your cash games

Instead, focus on players who are capable of getting on base often. No hitter has a guaranteed floor. Everyone is going to go hit-less and walk-less once in a while. But the key is to find the players who will rarely kill your team like that. Sure, the potential for home runs is intriguing and should play a small role, but you need security whenever possible in cash games.

On base percentage becomes very important in this process. Batters at the top of the order are likely OBP guys in the eyes of their managers, so use that to your advantage. If my outfielder goes 0-for-2 with two walks and a run, that's perfectly fine by me. If Chris Davis and Jose Altuve are the same price, I'm going to pay up for Altuve and find a cheaper first baseman who is more likely to not finish the game in the negatives (maybe an Eric Hosmer). Get it? OK cool.

 

Be Careful of Stacking

Our last emphasis for today will be on a strategy that kills cash game beginners all too often. In the game of MLB DFS, you'll hear the word "stacking" (using multiple players from the same team) thrown around in almost every piece of analysis available. Be aware of the fact that stacking is a tournament strategy only. Stacking in cash games is going to hurt you more often than not.

While it may seem logical to use all four batters at the top of the Cubs lineup when they are playing at Coors Field against a poor pitcher, this is not a safe cash game strategy. As I mentioned earlier, baseball is a fickle sport. It's still possible that Jordan Lyles has an OK game and only let's up one home run. In that case, three of your four hitters probably didn't meet your expectations. Even if Lyles gets shelled, it doesn't mean your particular players were a part of the run parade. Stacking is a very difficult strategy to nail down, which is why doing it successfully can win you thousands of dollars in big tournaments.

If your research leads you to believe that both Anthony Rizzo and Kyle Schwarber are the best players at their positions on a given day, then fine. Use those two. I would stop there. You're better off finding a safe option elsewhere. That way, a surprise stellar outing from Lyles won't completely derail your cash game lineups. Find the best values at each position, and if the same team keeps popping up, pick your two favorite. That golden rule won't always be the best approach, but it keeps you from getting burned when the Rockies somehow beat the Cubs 2-1. It's baseball; it happens.

 

Don't Test Mother Nature

OK so I lied. I have to emphasize this point too. MLB DFS is unique in the sense that weather matters. If there is a possibility for severe thunderstorms in a certain game, stay away. In tournaments it may be worth the risk, as ownership will likely be low, but in cash games you can't afford a postponed game leaving you with a zero, or a pitcher not coming out after a two hour rain delay that started in the third inning. There are countless ways to monitor weather these days, so don't ignore Mother Nature.

 

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

#1 Expert Projections
Save 30% Now
Import Your Leagues
Props Tool
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

NFL

Can Zacharia Branch Actually Succeed for Fantasy Managers?
Cade Otton

Could be at Risk on Day 1 of NFL Draft
Connor Bedard

Has Two Assists in Season Finale
Claude Giroux

Sends Out Two Assists in Battle of Ontario Win
Tetairoa McMillan

It's Possible That Tetairoa McMillan Has Only Shown His Floor
Tye Kartye

Registers First Career Three-Point Game
T.J. Hockenson

Should Still Have More to Give
Owen Power

Records Two Assists Wednesday
Jordan Love

a Middle-of-the-Road Superflex Option
Esa Lindell

Tallies Two Points in Regular-Season Finale
Reilly Smith

Produces Three-Point Performance Wednesday
Shane Wright

Returns With a Goal Wednesday
Bennedict Mathurin

Leads Clippers in Scoring Wednesday Night
Kristaps Porzingis

Impresses in Play-In Win
Stephen Curry

Leads Warriors to Vital Victory With 35 Points
Desmond Bane

Scores Game-High 34 Points in Play-In Loss
Tyrese Maxey

Guides 76ers Into Playoffs With 31-Point Effort
LaMelo Ball

Receives $60,000 Fine for Tuesday's Actions
Thomas Bryant

Practices in Limited Capacity Wednesday
Spencer Jones

Limited at Wednesday's Practice
Peyton Watson

Limited to Non-Contact Work at Practice
Bam Adebayo

NBA Investigating LaMelo Ball's Trip of Bam Adebayo
Isaiah Jackson

Cleared for Wednesday
Terrance Ferguson

Can Terrance Ferguson Establish a More Consistent Role in 2026?
Dalton Schultz

Could See a Reduced Role in Houston in 2026
Kimani Vidal

Playing Time in Los Angeles an Open Question Heading into 2026
Juwan Johnson

Looking to Build on Breakout 2025 Campaign
Chuba Hubbard

Set to Re-Emerge as a Top-24 Running Back?
Gunnar Helm

Poised for Expanded Role in 2026
Immanuel Quickley

Remains Day-to-Day After Workout
Isaiah Jackson

Probable to Return for Play-In Game
Tyler Kolek

Returns to Practice Ahead of Playoffs
Trendon Watford

Active on Wednesday
Jonathan Isaac

Ruled Out for Play-In Game Wednesday
Dylan Harper

Expected to Suit Up for Game 1 on Sunday
Franz Wagner

to Remain on Minutes Restriction Wednesday
Shohei Ohtani

Will Pitch on Wednesday, But Won't DH
Nick Pivetta

Confident he'll Pitch Again This Year
Alex Lyon

Expected to Miss Playoff Opener
Jett Howard

Good to Go on Wednesday
Zach Hyman

Set to Return Thursday
Sam Steel

Back in Action Wednesday
Gustav Forsling

Sits Out Season Finale
OG Anunoby

Practices on Wednesday
Matthew Tkachuk

Rejoins Panthers Lineup Wednesday
TB

Max Crozier Available Against Rangers
Brandon Hagel

Returns for Regular-Season Finale
Trevor Story

Carries Red Sox With Five RBI on Wednesday
Sam Antonacci

Officially Called Up by White Sox
Jorge Soler

Suspension Reduced to Four Games
Harrison Bader

Giants Place Harrison Bader on 10-Day Injured List With Hamstring Strain
Matthew Golden

Packers "Clearing the Way" for Matthew Golden on WR Depth Chart
CFB

Michigan Lands Commitment From Quarterback Kamden Lopati
Arizona Cardinals

Ty Simpson Visiting With Cardinals on Wednesday
De'Von Achane

"Not Available for Trade"
Travis Hunter

Will Still Play Receiver in 2026
Ketel Marte

Serving as Designated Hitter on Wednesday
Kevin McGonigle

Tigers, Kevin McGonigle Agree to Eight-Year Contract Extension
Sahith Theegala

Brings Strong Form Into Harbour Town
Kansas City Chiefs

Jordyn Tyson in Play for Chiefs at No. 9 Overall in NFL Draft?
Wyndham Clark

Needs Putter to Show Up at RBC Heritage
Ryan Weathers

Allows Four Homers, Strikes Out 10 on Tuesday
Byron Buxton

Sets the Tone for Twins With Two Homers on Tuesday
Hunter Goodman

Homers Twice in Loss to Astros
JJ Wetherholt

Goes Yard Twice in Win Over Guardians
Colston Loveland

Could Colston Loveland Emerge as the Dynasty TE1?
Khalil Shakir

Has Khalil Shakir Fallen Too Far in Dynasty Rankings?
Christian Watson

How High is the Ceiling for Christian Watson?
Pat Freiermuth

Can Pat Freiermuth Become More Than a Depth Piece Again?
Cale Makar

Returns With Three-Assist Performance
Jimmy Snuggerud

Records First Career Four-Point Game
Tua Tagovailoa

How Much Value Does Tua Tagovailoa Offer as Falcons' Starter?
Jeremy Swayman

Ends Losing Run With Shutout Performance
Oliver Moore

Won't Play Wednesday
Nils Lundkvist

Returns for Regular-Season Finale
Roope Hintz

to Miss First Two Playoff Games
Pavel Zacha

Will Be Available for Start of Playoffs
Jalen Green

Scores Team-High 35 Points During Play-In Loss
Jacob Bridgeman

Looks to Return to Elite Form at Harbour Town
J.J. Spaun

a Volatile Option at RBC Heritage
PGA

Sungjae Im Offers High-Upside Value at RBC Heritage
Matt Fitzpatrick

Set for Another Strong Showing at RBC Heritage
Jason Day

Eyes Bounce-Back After Sunday Struggles at the Masters
Akshay Bhatia

Looking to Rebound at Harbour Town
Ketel Marte

Diamondbacks Expect Ketel Marte to Return on Wednesday
Cameron Young

Hoping to Secure Second Win of Season at RBC Heritage
Scottie Scheffler

Looks to Win Again at RBC Heritage
Shane Lowry

Has Disappointing Final Round at Masters
Viktor Hovland

Hoping to Build on Final Round at Masters
Brian Harman

Struggling For Consistency Heading to RBC Heritage
Chris Gotterup

Putting Together Outstanding 2026 Season
Emilio Pagán

Emilio Pagan Getting Hamstring Checked After Earning Save on Tuesday
Justin Thomas

Looks to Defend in Hilton Head
Jordan Spieth

in Search of Improved Putting at RBC Heritage
Willson Contreras

Exits Early on Tuesday Due to Lower-Back Tightness
Marco Penge

May Continue Up-and-Down Ride at the RBC Heritage
Xander Schauffele

Could Get The Job Done at RBC Heritage
Jake Knapp

Keeps Building Strong Results in 2026
Kurt Kitayama

Trying to Regain Form From Florida
Collin Morikawa

Continues to be a Scary DFS Play at RBC Heritage
Triston Casas

Shut Down With Abdominal Strain
Wyatt Langford

is Returning on Tuesday
Ketel Marte

Scratched on Tuesday With Back Tightness
Nick Pivetta

Heads to 15-Day Injured List With Elbow Inflammation
Gabriel Moreno

Diamondbacks Put Gabriel Moreno on 10-Day Injured List With Oblique Strain
Cole Ragans

Returning to the Mound on Tuesday Against Tigers
CFB

Tramell Jones Jr. Outperforms Aaron Philo During Florida's Spring Scrimmage
CFB

Keelon Russell Flashes in Alabama's Spring Game
Ty Gibbs

Holds off the Field for His First Cup Series Victory at Bristol
Ryan Blaney

Earns His First Runner-Up Finish at Bristol
Kyle Larson

Dominant Performance At Bristol Falls Short of Victory
Tyler Reddick

Matches his Career-Best Finish at Bristol
Alex Bowman

Crashes Early at Bristol in Return From Injury
Carlos Ulberg

Is The New Light Heavyweight Champion
Jiří Procházka

Jiri Prochazka Suffers First-Round Knockout Loss
Azamat Murzakanov

Suffers His First Loss
Paulo Costa

Wins Back-to-Back Fights
Curtis Blaydes

Drops Decision At UFC 327
Josh Hokit

Remains Unbeaten
Carson Hocevar

Is Carson Hocevar A Worthy DFS Option for Bristol Lineups?
NASCAR

Could Bubba Wallace Be A Solid DFS Option for Bristol Lineups?
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF