X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Justin Upton Rankings Debate: Comparing RotoBaller's Rankers

This is the latest in a long-running series of articles debating the overall ranking of some of the most fantasy-relevant players of the 2018 baseball season.

RotoBaller's expert writers have come up with our consensus rankings for mixed leagues, but that doesn't mean we agreed on everything. In this space, we'll hear from rankers with the biggest differences of opinion on a well-known player and have them defend their position against each other.

In today's debate, Harris Yudin and Jeff Kahntroff argue over where Justin Upton should be drafted.  While Harris states he is worth the 31st overall pick, Jeff believes he should be selected a full two rounds later. Let's see which argument is most convincing.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

2018 Draft Rankings Debate - Justin Upton

Rank Tier Player Position Kyle Nick Pierre Jeff Harris Bill
38 4 Justin Upton OF 32 38 31 51 31 44

 

Harris Yudin's Ranking: #31 overall

Justin Upton is about as consistent as they come in terms of fantasy production, having hit 25 home runs with at least 160 combined runs and RBI in five consecutive years.

Perhaps five years is going back too far, though. Over the last three seasons, he has totaled 92 HR, 266 R, 277 RBI, 42 SB and a .256/.336/.487 slash line. Only five other players -- Mike Trout, Bryce Harper, Paul Goldschmidt, Anthony Rizzo, Brian Dozier -- have averaged 25 HR, 80 R, 80 RBI and 10 SB across that span.

Jeff ranks Upton behind Domingo Santana. The two corner outfielders had very similar 2017 campaigns, so Santana is essentially Upton minus the track record and guaranteed playing time, plus some questionable batted ball luck (30.9 HR/FB).

Give Me the Sure Thing Every Time

Upside is always exciting, but sometimes it’s better to go with the proven commodity. After all, aren’t you hoping the guy with upside will soon turn into the proven commodity? Outside of Rhys Hoskins -- and sure, throw Ronald Acuna in here -- there is no player who will be available beyond the top 30 whose upside is likely to surpass Upton’s yearly production.

The prospect of hitting in the middle of the Angels’ loaded lineup should entice fantasy owners to pull the trigger on the four-time all-star. Albert Pujols spent much of last season batting behind Trout, and managed to knock in 101 runs despite posting just a .286 OBP. Upton is projected to assume the No. 3 spot in the lineup, which will lead to a ton of run-producing opportunities.

There are no major red flags in Upton’s batted ball profile. The .341 BABIP, while significantly higher than it was in the previous two years, isn’t far off his career average. Sure, Angel Stadium is less hitter-friendly than Comerica Park, but Upton showed in a small sample size that he can produce there-- seven homers, .887 OPS in 115 plate appearances, despite his BABIP reading just .293 over that span.

Upton isn’t the sexiest pick simply because we know his ceiling, but count me in for a consistent, five-category contributor who should step into the box with Mike Trout on base more than 250 times.

 

Jeff Kahntroff's Ranking: #51 overall

Harris paints a picture of Justin Upton as Mr. Consistency over the past five years. Even though Upton has met some arbitrary measures of consistency, Harris is asking the wrong question. The proper questions are (1) what draft position does Upton's performance in years prior suggest is appropriate, and (2) is there any reason 2018 should be different?

What Draft Position Does Upton's Performance In Years Prior Suggest is Appropriate? 

Upton's 5x5 rankings over the past five years are 17th, 101st, 54th, 30th, and 56th. Upton's average rank over that span is 51.6. That is exactly where I ranked Upton. Harris ranked him two rounds higher.

Harris also suggests looking at a three-year span. Over that period, Upton's average rank is 57.3. Over the past two years, it is 64th. Unless you solely focus on last year, any average of Upton's prior rankings actually supports my ranking of 51st, not Harris's ranking of 31st. In fact, if you drafted Upton 31st each of the past five years, you would have received a one round surplus last year and been right on target in 2014. However, in 2016 you would have drafted him seven rounds too high, and in the other two years you would have drafted him more than two rounds too high.

Harris states that there are no players outside the top 30 whose upside could match Upton's yearly production, but that is clearly false. Because Justin Upton's average ranking over that span is 51.6, there have to be over 20 players outside the top 30 who can outperform his yearly production. Last year, there were nine players ranked outside the top 30 who outperformed even Harris's lofty ranking of Upton. While Harris disagrees with my ranking of Domingo Santana relative to Upton, I defended that position here, and thus will not repeat it.

Harris also portrays Upton as more valuable than he is by finding an arbitrary consistency categorization. In that grouping, Upton joins five far superior fantasy options: Mike Trout, Paul Goldschmidt, Bryce Harper, Anthony Rizzo, and Brian Dozier. While Harris's grouping is factually accurate, it is misleading. These are 5x5 rankings, and his categorization leaves out a batting average requirement. Batting average is Upton's weakest category. During that span, Upton batted .256.  Most of the others excel in that category. Over the prior three years, the average 5x5 rankings of these players are (Goldschmidt 7.0, Trout 13.3, Rizzo 27.0, Dozier 34.0, and Harper 44.0, Upton 57.3). During that span, their worst single season ranks are (Goldschmidt 9, Trout 29, Rizzo 36, Dozier 65, Harper 84, and Upton 101). Thus, let's not believe that Upton being in a group with these five players at all suggests that his value is near theirs.

Overall, Upton is a player who has stayed relatively healthy and thus put up somewhat consistent production. But, he has failed to record double-digit stolen bases in three of the prior five seasons. He also has struck out in over 30% of his at-bats during that span. He has never hit over .273 in that stretch. That is why his average ranking over that span is not as high as some may initially perceive it to be. Thus, my ranking is appropriate unless there is a reason to think that he should be better in 2018.

Is There Any Reason to Think that 2018 Should Be Better For Upton than His Prior Years' Averages

Harris did not explain why Upton's 2017 is more indicative of his true performance than his years prior. In fact, Harris even pointed out that Upton had an abnormally high BABIP last year. Upton also is coming off a career-high HR/FB ratio. Yes, his hard hit percentage climbed last year, but that has happened in the past with Upton and it dropped back down the following year.  Without a clear reason why Upton is a different hitter, I chose to keep him at his recent averages.

Moreover, Upton is moving to a worse park for righty power and average. He is not at an age where players typically improve. While he possibly moves to a spot behind Trout in the lineup (as we know lineups are susceptible to change), he also leaves a Tigers' offense that has been significantly better than the Angels' offense over the prior two years. Even though the Angels' lineup should improve this year, there is no guarantee it will be better than the Tigers' lineups in which he played the past two seasons.  In Upton's admittedly small sample with the Angels, he was on pace for fewer runs produced (runs + RBIs) than his 2017 numbers with the Tigers.

Conclusion

Harris's argument suggests that I am predicting Upton to be worse than he has been. But, I am not. Rather, my ranking for Upton is slightly better than Upton's average finish over the past two, three, four, and five years. I saw no reason to expect a significantly better performance from Upton in 2018, and Harris has failed to provide one. Thus, there is no reason that Upton's five-year average finish (51.6) is not an appropriate ranking for him in 2018.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Ryan Weathers16 mins ago

Will Open Season On Injured List
Seattle Seahawks17 mins ago

Seahawks Rework Uchenna Nwosu's Contract
Graham Ashcraft22 mins ago

Will Start Campaign In Relief Role
Michel Otañez29 mins ago

Michel Otanez Will Begin The Season On The Injured List
Michael Gallup32 mins ago

Commanders Add Michael Gallup To Receiver Room
Jose Trevino38 mins ago

Signs Extension With Cincinnati
Casey DeSmith54 mins ago

Starting On Thursday
DeAndre Carter1 hour ago

Browns Sign DeAndre Carter To One-Year Deal
Sergei Bobrovsky1 hour ago

Facing Columbus On Thursday
Jeff Petry1 hour ago

Traveling With The Team
Nick Jensen1 hour ago

Not Playing On Thursday
Zach Agnos1 hour ago

Likely To Begin In The Minors
Zac Veen1 hour ago

Pushing Hard For A Roster Spot
Erik Gustafsson1 hour ago

Does Not Practice On Thursday
Austin Gomber2 hours ago

To Open Season On Injured List
Alexander Romanov2 hours ago

Not Expected To Play On Thursday
Chase Dollander2 hours ago

Likely To Begin In Triple-A
Edwin Díaz2 hours ago

Edwin Diaz's Velocity Down This Spring
Max Scherzer2 hours ago

Plans To Pitch In A Game On Saturday
Zach Dezenzo2 hours ago

Returns To Grapefruit League Lineup
Luis Garcia2 hours ago

Shut Down With Elbow Soreness
Gary Payton II4 hours ago

Iffy For Thursday
Ja'Kobe Walter4 hours ago

Unavailable Thursday
Gradey Dick4 hours ago

Remains Out Against Warriors
Jakob Poeltl4 hours ago

Off The Injury Report Thursday
RJ Barrett4 hours ago

Misses Third Straight Contest
Marcus Garrett4 hours ago

Questionable Thursday
Moussa Diabaté4 hours ago

Moussa Diabate May Sit Out Thursday's Game
Cameron Johnson4 hours ago

Resting Against Pacers
Christian Cairo6 hours ago

Returning To Cleveland
Oscar Colás6 hours ago

Oscar Colas Optioned To Triple-A
Craig Yoho6 hours ago

Assigned To Minor-League Camp
Ben Rice6 hours ago

Keeps Cooking
Caleb Durbin6 hours ago

Expected To Make Opening Day Roster
Carson Williams6 hours ago

Sent To Minor-League Camp
Jordan Hicks6 hours ago

Bounces Back With Strong Start
Chandler Simpson6 hours ago

Assigned To Minor-League Camp
Kyle Wright7 hours ago

Takes Next Step
Matt Boldy7 hours ago

Strikes Twice In Victory
Filip Gustavsson7 hours ago

Shuts The Door On Kraken On Wednesday
Auston Matthews7 hours ago

Extends Goal Streak To Three Games
Joseph Woll7 hours ago

Stands Tall Against Colorado
Chandler Stephenson7 hours ago

Suffers Injury On Wednesday
Marco Rossi7 hours ago

Exits Early On Wednesday
Kansas City Chiefs15 hours ago

Chiefs Re-Sign Marlon Tuipulotu
Las Vegas Raiders15 hours ago

Raiders Sign Christian Elliss To An Offer Sheet
Detroit Lions15 hours ago

Lions Re-Sign Al-Quadin Muhammad To One-Year Deal
Miami Dolphins15 hours ago

Willie Gay Signs One-Year Deal With Dolphins
Houston Texans15 hours ago

Texans Make Danielle Hunter The Second-Highest-Paid Defensive End
Cedrick Wilson Jr.16 hours ago

Saints Rework Cedrick Wilson Jr.'s Contract
Noah Brown16 hours ago

Working His Way Back From Kidney Injury
Miles Bridges16 hours ago

Expected To Play On Thursday Night
Rondale Moore16 hours ago

Vikings Agree To Terms With Rondale Moore
LaMelo Ball16 hours ago

Probable Versus The Knicks
Stefon Diggs16 hours ago

Visiting With Patriots
Devin Duvernay16 hours ago

Bears Agree To One-Year Deal With Devin Duvernay
Gary Trent Jr.16 hours ago

Considered Probable For Thursday
Damian Lillard16 hours ago

Likely To Suit Up Against Lakers
Giannis Antetokounmpo16 hours ago

Probable For Thursday's Clash Against Lakers
Santi Aldama17 hours ago

Available Following Six-Game Absence
Scotty Pippen Jr.17 hours ago

Active On Wednesday
Christian Braun17 hours ago

Back For Nuggets Wednesday Night
Aaron Gordon17 hours ago

Good To Go Against Lakers
Jamal Murray17 hours ago

Unavailable Against Lakers
Nikola Jokić17 hours ago

Nikola Jokic Remains Out On Wednesday
Stephen Curry17 hours ago

Ready To Return Thursday
Trey Jemison III17 hours ago

Active Against Nuggets
Shea Theodore20 hours ago

Takes Full Contact In Practice
Cole Sillinger20 hours ago

Closing In On Return
Sean Monahan20 hours ago

May Return To Action This Week
Filip Gustavsson21 hours ago

Takes On Kraken Wednesday
Mackenzie Blackwood21 hours ago

Expected To Face Maple Leafs
Joseph Woll21 hours ago

Starts First Leg Of Back-To-Back Wednesday
Dmitry Orlov21 hours ago

On Track To Return Thursday
Houston Texans22 hours ago

Texans Sign Cam Robinson
Deebo Samuel Sr.22 hours ago

Commanders Rework Deebo Samuel Sr.'s Deal
Jake Knapp23 hours ago

Looks To Stay Hot At Valspar Championship
New England Patriots23 hours ago

Jack Gibbens Reuniting With Mike Vrabel In New England
Adam Hadwin23 hours ago

Looking To Bounce Back At Valspar Championship
Julius Chestnut23 hours ago

Titans Bring Julius Chestnut Back On One-Year Deal
Atlanta Falcons23 hours ago

Falcons Adding Safety Jordan Fuller
Cam Davis23 hours ago

Avoid Cam Davis At Valspar Championship
Denver Broncos23 hours ago

Punter Matt Haack Signing With Broncos
Los Angeles Rams23 hours ago

Ahkello Witherspoon Back With Rams On One-Year Deal
Will Levis23 hours ago

Titans Not Actively Shopping Will Levis, Could Make Deal On Draft Night
Josh Manson1 day ago

Expected To Miss At Least Three Weeks
Marcus Foligno1 day ago

Sitting On Wednesday
Sepp Straka2 days ago

Eyeing Victory At Valspar Championship
Sam Stevens2 days ago

Looking To Get Back Into Form At Valspar Championship
Jordan Spieth2 days ago

A Boom-Or-Bust Candidate At Valspar Championship
Alex Smalley2 days ago

Aims To Continue Strong Form At Valspar Championship
Adam Scott2 days ago

A Risky Play At Valspar Championship
Shane Lowry2 days ago

A Home Run Pick At Valspar Championship
Stephan Jaeger2 days ago

Looks To Continue Momentum At Valspar Championship
Thomas Detry2 days ago

Aims To Regain Form At Valspar Championship
Justin Thomas2 days ago

Continues To Spark But Hopes To Keep It Lit At Innisbrook
Michael Kim2 days ago

Looks To Rebound At Valspar Championship
Tom Kim2 days ago

Looking For Putter Form At Valspar Championship
Rasmus Hojgaard2 days ago

Looking For Form At Valspar Championship
Ben Griffin2 days ago

Needs To Find Ball-Striking Form Ahead Of Valspar Championship
Tommy Fleetwood2 days ago

Looks To Keep Short But Successful Run Going At Innisbrook
Eric Cole2 days ago

Needs To Find A Spark At Innisbrook
Sam Burns2 days ago

Looks To Rebound At Valspar Championship
Roman Dolidze3 days ago

Extends His Win Streak To Three
Marvin Vettori3 days ago

Suffers Back-To-Back Losses
Will Zalatoris3 days ago

Has Been Consistent At Least In 2025
Carson Young3 days ago

Makes The Cut In Second Straight Tournament
Elizeu Zaleski dos Santos3 days ago

Suffers Second-Round TKO
Chidi Njokuani3 days ago

Scores TKO Win At UFC Vegas 104
Kurt Holobaugh3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 104
Alexander Hernandez3 days ago

Wins Decision At UFC Vegas 104
Cody Gibson3 days ago

Submitted At UFC Vegas 104
Da'Mon Blackshear3 days ago

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Brendson Ribeiro3 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC Vegas 104
Diyar Nurgozhay3 days ago

Suffers His First Loss
MMA3 days ago

Seung Woo Choi Suffers First-Round TKO Loss At UFC Vegas 104
Kevin Vallejos3 days ago

Finishes Seung Woo Choi In Debut
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Solid Performance Is Derailed By Late Pit-Road Issues At Las Vegas
Ryan Blaney3 days ago

Struggles End In A Disappointing Exit Late At Las Vegas
Josh Berry3 days ago

Impressively Earns First Cup Series Win At Las Vegas
AJ Allmendinger3 days ago

Scores First Top-10 Finish Of Season At Las Vegas
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Leads The Most Laps, But Settles For A Top-10 Finish At Las Vegas
Ross Chastain3 days ago

Obtains A Hard-Fought Top-Five Finish At Las Vegas
Daniel Suarez3 days ago

Scores Career-Best Finish At Las Vegas, But Falls Short Of Winning
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Wrecks At Las Vegas But Shows Promising Speed
Alex Bowman3 days ago

Recovers From Loose Wheel To Finish Seventh
Austin Cindric3 days ago

Wins Stage 1, But Loose Wheel Foils Victory Bid
William Byron3 days ago

Loses Las Vegas Race On Strategy But Expands Points Lead
Ryan Preece3 days ago

Earns Best Career Non-Drafting Oval Finish At Las Vegas
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Quest For Four Wins In A Row Just Got More Difficult
Kyle Larson4 days ago

Should Contend For Another Win At Las Vegas
Ryan Blaney4 days ago

Once Again The Chalk DFS Pick At Las Vegas
Ross Chastain4 days ago

Fastest In Practice At Las Vegas
Chris Buescher4 days ago

Has Sneaky Upside This Weekend
Chase Elliott4 days ago

May Be A Sneaky DFS Option For Las Vegas Lineups
William Byron4 days ago

Expect William Byron To Compete For The Win At Las Vegas
Tyler Reddick4 days ago

Is One Of The Top DFS Options For Las Vegas
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Could Denny Hamlin Be A Quality Driver For DFS At Las Vegas?
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
J.K. Dobbins - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

J.K. Dobbins Top Landing Spots: Updated 2025 NFL Free Agency Outlook

J.K. Dobbins was coming off another devastating injury to begin the 2024 season. A torn Achilles tendon ended his 2023 season in Week 1. The veteran back had lobbied for a new contract in the run-up to the 2023 season, so this was an incredibly tough blow for Dobbins's prospects. He wound up signing a […]


Ashton Jeanty - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Best Dynasty Fantasy Football Formats: Five Ways To Set Up Your League

There are plenty of major fantasy football formats to play. You can play Daily Fantasy Sports cash games or season-long money tournaments. You can set up a casual redraft league with your friends. You can also play Dynasty, which is the preferred format of many of fantasy football's biggest fans. But there are plenty of […]


Breece Hall - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Top Dynasty Fantasy Football Risers and Fallers For 2025

Most players don't retain the rankings they had the year before in dynasty fantasy football. There could be a million reasons for this, but change is one of the only constants in the NFL. Whether due to injury, poor seasons, trades, or unrealistic expectations being adjusted as the reality of each player's situation set in […]


Jalen Milroe - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

2025 NFL Draft Rankings for Fantasy Football: Top 9 Quarterbacks

Last year's rookie quarterback class was special. The first three players drafted were all quarterbacks, with Caleb Williams going to the Bears at No. 1 followed by Jayden Daniels to the Commanders at No. 2, and Drake Maye to the Patriots at No. 3. Daniels won Rookie of the Year. Maye made the Pro Bowl. […]


Abdul Carter - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2025 NFL First-Round Mock Draft (Featuring Trades)

The 2025 NFL Draft is less than six weeks away. Every NFL team has different needs than they did two weeks ago because of free agency. There are still a few big-name players available on the open market. However, let’s dive into my first mock draft of the year for RotoBaller. This mock draft is […]


Josh Downs - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News Updates

2025 Fantasy Football Sleepers: Third-Year Breakouts

Patience can be tough, especially in fantasy football. We want instant production from rookies, but these players often take a while to get going. These youngsters need to adjust to the speed of the NFL and learn from their early struggles to break out fully. The third year in the NFL is oftentimes when things […]


J.J. McCarthy - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Draft Sleepers

Florio's Non-Free Agent Fantasy Football Winners and Losers

Free Agency takes over the football world every March. It is always such a fun week that shakes up the league. It is followed by plenty of analysis over which players ended up in good fits and which hurt their stock.  Free agents are not the only players whose value is shaken up this week, […]


Bucky Irving - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2025 Fantasy Football Rookie Regression Candidates: Potential Sophomore Slumps

No one, and especially not Dynasty fantasy football managers, wants to hear that their rookie breakout player is going to slump in their second season. Yet we see that happen pretty much every season with certain players. The best example from 2024 was quarterback C.J. Stroud. Stroud won the Offensive Rookie of the Year award […]


Tre Harris - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks, NFL Draft

Three Fantasy Football Rookie Wide Receiver Sleepers: Yards Per Route Run Analysis

In one of my first fantasy football articles covering NFL Draft prospects, we looked at three rookies who stood out via yards per route run. The landing spot and actual draft capital mattered since they showed how NFL teams value those players. That said, we will switch it up and examine the 11 wide receiver […]


Saquon Barkley - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Dynasty Fantasy Football RB Rankings Analysis: Saquon Barkley, De'Von Achane, Breece Hall

Dynasty startup drafts are in full swing. There’s nothing that quite matches the dopamine hit and adrenaline rush of beginning a new dynasty draft. As any good dynasty manager knows, running backs are critical elements when it comes to building a perennial contender. Some of the top backs available in startup drafts this year are […]


CeeDee Lamb - Fantasy Football Rankings, DFS and Betting Picks, NFL Injury News

Dynasty Fantasy Football WR Rankings Analysis – CeeDee Lamb, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Puka Nacua

The cool thing about dynasty fantasy football is that rankings change all the time. At this time last year, New York Giants wide receiver Malik Nabers and Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr. were being drafted in the first round of rookie drafts. Now, both wide receivers are top-15 dynasty assets.  Three wideouts whose […]


Davante Adams - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football Winners and Losers of 2025 NFL Free Agency

The biggest NFL free-agency frenzy of 2025, namely the first few days of free agency, is now in the books, so the majority of the biggest moves have been made by now. There are still a few big names that haven't signed yet, but most of the most coveted players have found new landing spots […]


Stefon Diggs - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Stefon Diggs Top Landing Spots: Updated 2025 NFL Free Agency Outlook

Stefon Diggs enjoyed a nice first season with the Houston Texans before he tore his ACL in Week 8. The veteran receiver was playing on a one-year deal and has yet to be signed by another team this offseason. Diggs enters his age 31 season in 2025 and has shown some signs of decline in […]