👉 TAP TO SAVE 30% WITH CODE NEW
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

MLB Dynasty Rankings for 2017: Top 25

All ranking projects are beasts, and the deeper we go, the more beastly they become. Ranking players at one position against players at another is easy enough. Shuffling the positions together to form a top 500 list can be unwieldy. Adding in the "dynasty" tag is the ultimate complication.

Before we hit the top 25, let's talk about methodology. Not all dynasty leagues are created equal - the term is understood to mean that owners keep most/all of their roster year-to-year. To some, it also means the league is very deep (over 800 players rostered). However, I get plenty of questions on twitter about 10-team, 23-player roster dynasties.

For the purposes of this ranking, I'm going to use an industry league as the model. It's a 20-team, 45-player roster format. It's up to you to mentally adjust the rankings to fit your own league depth and settings.

By the way, if you are interested in more MLB rankings columns, head on over to our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. Throughout the offseason, you will find tiered positional rankings, keeper values articles, our team prospect breakdowns, fantasy baseball prospect rankings, and more - all in one easy place.

 

My Dynasty Rankings Approach

For scoring, we'll use standard 5x5 stats. Since we're concerned with 2017 and beyond (a lot of the beyond), I tend to prioritize raw talent over counting stats like runs and RBI. A good player will get his opportunities over time. A bad player will eventually lose a favorable lineup role.

I'm mostly interested in how a player will perform over the next five years. While players with even longer term value should be acknowledged as possessing such, a LOT of things can go wrong between now and 2022. I might pay a penny for a dollar of 2022 value. That reflects my own personal preferences. I also place a disproportionate value on 2017 expectations. For established major league players, over half of my ranking reflects what they'll do this year. There are many exceptions for the young, old, and infirm.

Fortunately, we're using the same information to form our expectations about 2017 and beyond. So while other dynasty rankers may tell you they're doing an even 20 percent valuation of the next five seasons, it works out about the same as my method. There will only be a few notable differences.

Perhaps you've heard TINSTAAPP - There's No Such Thing As A Pitching Prospect. There's a dynasty corollary - there's no such thing as a reliable pitcher. Relative to position players, all pitchers have a massively elevated risk of injury, especially the career altering variety. As such, their dynasty value takes a big hit. Not even Clayton Kershaw is safe.

While, pitchers are riskier dynasty investments, you do need a full complement of hurlers to win a league. In general, I recommend building the foundation of your roster with hitters then diversifying to pitchers. It's also easier to find a free Robert Gsellman or Michael Montgomery than a comparably talented hitting prospect.

One last note...because this is such a large project, I have decided to take an iterative approach. Today, we talk about the top 25. Next week, I'll release the next 25 or 50 names. When I do so, I may have edits to make to the top 25. This will continue until we have a very long list of players. By then, the top of the list should polished smooth and shiny.

Shall we?

 

Top 25 Dynasty Assets for 2017

Rank Player Position Age
1 Mike Trout OF 25
2 Nolan Arenado 3B 25
3 Mookie Betts OF 24
4 Manny Machado SS/3B 24
5 Kris Bryant 3B/OF 25
6 Carlos Correa SS 22
7 Bryce Harper OF 24
8 Corey Seager SS 22
9 Trea Turner 2B/OF 23
10 Xander Bogaerts SS 24
11 Trevor Story SS 24
12 Jose Altuve 2B 26
13 Paul Goldschmidt 1B 29
14 Francisco Lindor SS 23
15 Christian Yelich OF 25
16 Nomar Mazara OF 21
17 Anthony Rizzo 1B 27
18 Clayton Kershaw SP 28
19 Josh Donaldson 3B 31
20 Miguel Cabrera 1B 33
21 Starling Marte OF 28
22 Jonathan Villar 2B/SS/3B 25
23 Robinson Cano 2B 34
24 Charlie Blackmon OF 30
25 Freddie Freeman 1B 27

 

I think you can see the general cadence of the list. First we have the very young, very awesome bats, all aged between 22 and 25. Then we move onto the very good veterans with a couple under-established youngsters shuffled in.

Trout's number one ranking requires no explanation. He's too consistently good to rank anywhere else, even if there are a couple players who might be better than him sometime around 2025. Just like in re-draft, the distance between Trout and the rest of the field is huge.

Coors Field offers an exception to the talent over counting stats rule. Arenado has posted consecutive 40 home run, 130 RBI seasons without even going wild. The lack of stolen bases is a shame, but he has upside to push 150 RBI in a perfect year. That's category shattering potential. There's still nothing wrong with preferring Betts, Machado, Bryant, or Correa. In fact, Correa's a good buy low opportunity after injuries slowed him in 2016.

To my eye, Harper's ranking is a tad high. For a brief moment, he burned brighter than any other player in baseball. The overall resume still reads as "good player with massive upside." There's volatility here. If I was merely considering the most likely outcome (the modal projection), Harper would be ranked between Goldy and Lindor. The super-high ceiling drags the average projection up to the #7. Your personal valuation of Harper should reflect your risk preferences.

Following Harper are four very good shortstops. Take your pick of profile. Seager and Bogaerts have the steady, high floor approach. Turner snags oodles of stolen bases and will have three eligibilities in 2017. Story may lead all shortstops in home runs over the next five seasons.

Here's where things get interesting. The next five players - Altuve, Goldy, Lindor, Yelich, and Mazara - offer the gamut of strategic choice for owners. Contend now with Goldschimdt, build for later with Mazara, or try to walk the line with the other trio.

Rizzo's ranking probably looks bearish at first glance. And honestly, it might be. I know I'd pick him after Goldschmidt but before Kershaw. Speaking of Kershaw, the appropriate place to take him is adjacent to older stars like Donaldson and Cabrera.

Rounding out the list are four reliable veterans and Villar. While the Brewers utility star is a regression risk, he should hit and run enough to provide big value over the next three years. As a late bloomer, he may fade faster than the typical 25-year-old. This is another instance where risk tolerance will decide your path.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Garrett Crochet

Ditches Changeup for Splitter
Yimi García

Yimi Garcia Has Been Throwing, Might be Ready for Opening Day
Deandre Ayton

Ruled Out Tuesday
Jakob Poeltl

Listed as Questionable for Wednesday
Ricky Tiedemann

Will be Stretched Out to Multiple Innings
Collin Murray-Boyles

Out Wednesday
Nicolas Claxton

Added to Injury Report
George Springer

Returning From Myriad of Injuries
Cedric Coward

Unlikely to Play Wednesday
Kazuma Okamoto

Will See Time at First Base
De'Anthony Melton

Iffy for Wednesday Night
Andrew Wiggins

Could Miss Wednesday's Action
Reese Olson

Won't Pitch in 2026
Pelle Larsson

Out Wednesday Against Pelicans
Tyler Herro

Ruled Out for 15th Straight Game
Tre Jones

Expected to Remain Out Wednesday
Malik Monk

Still Out With Illness
Zach LaVine

to Miss Third Consecutive Game
Domantas Sabonis

Unavailable Wednesday
Russell Westbrook

Won't Play Wednesday
Lauri Markkanen

Now Listed as Available for Wednesday
Klay Thompson

Won't Suit Up Tuesday
Keyonte George

to Miss Second Straight Game
Lauri Markkanen

Won't Play Wednesday Night
Egor Demin

Available for Wednesday's Matchup
Noah Clowney

Considered Probable for Wednesday
Bilal Coulibaly

Uncertain to Play vs. Cleveland
Jeff Hoffman

Not the Everyday Closer in Toronto?
Cody Bradford

Aiming for a May Return
Jordan Spieth

Looking For a Return to Form at Pebble Beach
Shane Bieber

to Open Season on Injured List
Bowden Francis

Done for the Year After Having UCL Reconstruction
Juuse Saros

Starting Wednesday
Anthony Santander

to Miss 5-6 Months Due to Shoulder Surgery
William Nylander

Iffy for Olympic Opener
Martin Necas

Ready for Thursday
Drake Maye

Says his Shoulder Injury was Significant
Grayson Rodriguez

Must Prove his Health to Earn Rotation Spot
Noah Schultz

Knee Not an Issue, Expects to Make MLB Debut in 2026
Austin Slater

Agrees to Minor-League Deal With Tigers
Brett Baty

a Candidate for Starting Role in Right Field?
Juan Soto

to Play Left Field for Mets in 2026
Kris Bryant

Heads to 60-Day Injured List
Shane Baz

Orioles Believe Shane Baz is a Cy Young-Caliber Pitcher
Xander Schauffele

Trying to Get the Motor Going at Pebble Beach
Francisco Lindor

to be Evaluated for Stress Reaction in Left Hamate
Justin Verlander

Tigers Agree to One-Year Deal
Hideki Matsuyama

Trying to Overcome Sunday Collapse
Michael Thorbjornsen

Showing Great Early-Season Form
Scottie Scheffler

Continues Hot Start Heading to ATT Pebble Beach Pro-Am
Rory McIlroy

Making First PGA Tour Start of 2026 Season
Robert MacIntyre

Returns to Action For ATT Pebble Beach Pro-Am
Si Woo Kim

Doesn't Appear to be Slowing Down Heading to ATT Pebble Beach Pro-Am
Rickie Fowler

Continues Great Start to 2026 Season
Matt Fitzpatrick

Continues Playing Well Heading to ATT Pebble Beach Pro-Am
Patrick Cantlay

is Playing Well but Needs to Find Putting Stroke
Ludvig Aberg

Needs a Strong Showing at ATT Pebble Beach Pro-Am
Kurt Kitayama

Looks to Build on Momentum at Pebble Beach
Coby Mayo

Could See Work in the Outfield
Ryo Hisatsune

a Scary Play at Pebble Beach Regardless of His Recent Performance
Chris Gotterup

Heads to Pebble Beach as the Hottest Player in Golf
Jason Day

Looks to Keep Long-Running Success Going at Pebble Beach
Pierceson Coody

to Keep Good Form Going at First Career Pebble Beach Appearance
Sam Burns

Needs a Good Showing at Pebble Beach to Shift Fleeting Momentum
Kenneth Walker III

Runs Away With Super Bowl MVP Honors
Vinicius Oliveira

Suffers His First UFC Loss
Mario Bautista

Gets Back In The Win Column
Kyoji Horiguchi

Dominates At UFC Vegas 113
Amir Albazi

Gets Dominated At UFC Vegas 113
Rizvan Kuniev

Earns His First UFC Win
Jailton Almeida

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 113
Marc-Andre Barriault

Loses Back-To-Back Fights
Michal Oleksiejczuk

Gets His Third Win In A Row
Las Vegas Raiders

Klint Kubiak Confirms he Will be Next Raiders Head Coach
Jonas Rondbjerg

Out for Olympics
Brad Marchand

Good to Go for Olympic Opener
Gabriel Landeskog

Healthy for Olympics
Jack Hughes

Cleared for Olympics
Jaxon Smith-Njigba

Returns to Super Bowl After Injury Scare
Jaxon Smith-Njigba

Being Evaluated for Concussion, Questionable to Return
James Pearce Jr.

Arrested Following Police Chase
Quinn Hughes

Enters Olympics in Red-Hot Form
NHL

Juho Lammikko Returns to Switzerland
Pavel Zacha

Misses Olympics
Travis Kelce

Undecided on Playing Future, Leaning Towards Returning in 2026?
CFB

Rutgers Hiring South Dakota Head Coach Travis Johansen as Defensive Coordinator
Vinicius Oliveira

Looks For His Seventh Consecutive Win
Mario Bautista

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 113
Kyoji Horiguchi

Set For UFC Vegas 113 Co-Main Event
Amir Albazi

Looks To Bounce Back
Rizvan Kuniev

Looks For His First UFC Win
Jailton Almeida

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Marc-Andre Barriault

In Dire Need Of Victory
Michal Oleksiejczuk

Looks For His Third Win In A Row
Michael Penix Jr.

Says he's Ahead of Schedule After Knee Surgery
Cleveland Browns

Jim Schwartz Resigns as Browns Defensive Coordinator
Malik Nabers

Says his Rehab has Been "Phenomenal"
CFB

Oklahoma Hiring Former NFL Defensive Lineman DeShawn Williams to Analyst Role
CFB

Jahmal Edrine Charged with Sexual Assault, No Longer Enrolled at Virginia
Jakob Chychrun

Makes Big Impact in Thursday's Win
Brandon Bussi

Shuts Out Rangers With 16 Saves
Anze Kopitar

Reaches 1,300 Career Points
Mark Stone

Becomes First Vegas Player With 100 Multi-Point Games
Daniil Tarasov

Injured in Battle of Florida
Andrei Kuzmenko

Hurt Versus Vegas
John Carlson

Suffers Lower-Body Injury
Matthew Stafford

Named 2025 NFL MVP, Will Return in 2026
Jaxon Smith-Njigba

Takes Home Offensive Player of the Year Honors
Christian McCaffrey

Named Comeback Player of the Year
Tetairoa McMillan

Named Offensive Rookie of the Year
Myles Garrett

Unanimously Wins Defensive Player of the Year Award
Brad Marchand

Evan Rodrigues Among Panthers Absentees Thursday
Calum Ritchie

Rejoins Islanders Lineup as Second-Line Center
Zach Benson

Sits Out Second Straight Game
Pierre-Luc Dubois

Available Against Predators
CFB

Houston, Vanderbilt, Tennessee Land Top-Three QBs in 2026 Class
Joe Mixon

Committed to Playing in 2026
CFB

Michigan Signs Top-15 Recruiting Class Despite Coaching Change
CFB

USC Finishes with No. 1 Signing Class in 2026
CFB

Trinidad Chambliss Denied Medical Redshirt Waiver By NCAA
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF