Top 50 Catcher Fantasy Baseball Rankings: February Updates

Link copied to clipboard!

Top 50 catcher (C) fantasy baseball rankings, draft tiers for roto leagues (February updates). Nick Mariano's tiered catcher fantasy baseball draft rankings.

In This Article hide

Fantasy Baseball Catcher (C) News

Who Should I Draft Tool

More Fantasy Baseball Analysis

Depending on where you live, your area may have been hit with a ton of snow recently. The good news is we are inching closer to spring and Opening Day for baseball. At Rotoballer HQ, we wrap up our positional rankings series with the catcher position. In this article, you will find our updated 2026 fantasy baseball catcher rankings and tiers for roto leagues (5x5 category mixed leagues). These February rankings cover the top 50 catchers for 2026 to help fantasy managers out for their upcoming drafts, especially in two-catcher formats.

Now that most players have reported to spring training, fantasy managers should expect to hear a lot of news, rumors, and hype this offseason on trendy picks or even a player having a hot spring. When should you take a chance on a catcher who is on the rise, a top prospect, a player returning from injury, or a C who is set to bounce back this season? Find out where key catchers such as Shea Langeliers, Drake Baldwin, Ivan Herrera, Kyle Teel, Carter Jensen, and Logan O'Hoppe are listed below in the latest rankings.

The catcher rankings below are specifically designed for traditional roto leagues, put together by RotoBaller's lead MLB forecaster Nick Mariano. We're also writing fresh articles all throughout the off-season for fantasy baseball prospects, fantasy baseball dynasty, and so much more. Win more in 2026!

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and resources:

Updated Fantasy Baseball C Rankings (February)

Tier	Rank	Player	Position
1	1	Cal Raleigh	C
2	2	Ben Rice	C/1B
2	3	William Contreras	C
3	4	Agustin Ramirez	C
3	5	Shea Langeliers	C
3	6	Hunter Goodman	C
3	7	Drake Baldwin	C
4	8	Salvador Perez	C/1B
4	9	Will Smith	C
4	10	Yainer Diaz	C
4	11	Ivan Herrera	C
4	12	Alejandro Kirk	C
5	13	Adley Rutschman	C
5	14	Kyle Teel	C
5	15	Samuel Basallo	C
5	16	Gabriel Moreno	C
5	17	Francisco Alvarez	C
5	18	Carter Jensen	C
5	19	Dillon Dingler	C
5	20	J.T. Realmuto	C
6	21	Austin Wells	C
6	22	Logan O'Hoppe	C
6	23	Carlos Narvaez	C
6	24	Tyler Stephenson	C
6	25	Ryan Jeffers	C
6	26	Carson Kelly	C
6	27	Moises Ballesteros	C
6	28	Edgar Quero	C
6	29	Bo Naylor	C
6	30	Freddy Fermin	C
6	31	Keibert Ruiz	C
6	32	Harry Ford	C
6	33	Danny Jansen	C
6	34	Joe Mack	C
7	35	Miguel Amaya	C
7	36	Liam Hicks	C/1B
7	37	Joey Bart	C
7	38	Kyle Higashioka	C
7	39	Sean Murphy	C
7	40	Dalton Rushing	C
7	41	Victor Caratini	C/1B
7	42	Patrick Bailey	C
7	43	Pedro Pages	C
8	44	Jimmy Crooks	C
8	45	Jonah Heim	C
8	46	Adrian Del Castillo	C
8	47	Henry Davis	C
8	48	Jeferson Quero	C
8	49	Connor Wong	C
8	50	Cooper Ingle	C
8	51	Nick Fortes	C
8	52	Josue Briceno	C/1B
8	53	Gary Sanchez	C

Fantasy Baseball Catcher (C) News

Dillon Dingler, Detroit Tigers

Detroit Tigers catcher Dillon Dingler (elbow) is working through a return-to-play throwing progression this week and is quickly approaching his return. The backstop is expected to be a full-go for Opening Day. Dingler had a delayed start to the offseason after undergoing arthroscopic surgery in January.

Managers should continue to monitor the 27-year-old's status, but he appears well-positioned to avoid a delayed start to the regular season. Last summer, Dingler spent the entire campaign in the majors and did not disappoint, posting a .278/.327/.425 line with 21 doubles and 13 home runs.

Under the hood, Dingler generated an elite .290 xBA with a 42.3% LA sweet-spot%, which placed him in the 98th percentile among qualified hitters. When active, managers should expect Dingler to carry solid No. 2 catcher upside, as he should see most of the starting opportunities in Detroit.

Moises Ballesteros, Chicago Cubs

Chicago Cubs catching prospect Moises Ballesteros officially reported to camp on Sunday. The young backstop had his start to the 2026 campaign delayed by visa issues, but was finally able to join the Cubs. The 22-year-old is expected to immediately begin the season in a lead role on the offense, likely serving as the primary designated hitter.

Last season, Ballesteros made his MLB debut and held a solid .298/.394/.474 slash line with two doubles, one triple, and two home runs across a 20-game stint. At Triple-A, Ballesteros was one of the most productive hitters in the minor leagues, posting a .316/.385/.473 line with 29 doubles, 13 home runs, and a strong .858 OPS.

Fantasy managers should continue to monitor his status in camp and should view him as a solid C2 in all formats with the solid power upside. If he is able to fully claim the DH role, he could carry starting-caliber upside in standard leagues.

Elias Diaz, Kansas City Royals

The Kansas City Royals announced on Friday that they agreed to a minor-league contract with free-agent catcher Elias Diaz. The Royals expect him to join their major-league camp next week. Diaz, a former All-Star game MVP, will provide the Royals with extra catching depth going into the 2026 season behind Salvador Perez and Carter Jensen.

The 35-year-old Venezuelan veteran backstop will most likely begin the year at Triple-A Omaha if he's still with the team. Diaz slashed .204/.270/.337 with a .607 OPS, nine home runs, 29 RBI, and 34 runs scored in 106 games with the San Diego Padres in 2025 while splitting time behind the plate with Martin Maldonado for most of the year.

His batting average and strikeout rate (26.1%) were the worst marks of his career, although he has an above-average glove on defense. Diaz is going to need some injuries to find playing time in KC.

Mitch Garver, Seattle Mariners

Free-agent catcher Mitch Garver and the Seattle Mariners agreed on a minor-league deal on Wednesday, sources told Jeff Passan of ESPN. The 35-year-old veteran backstop spent the last two seasons with the Mariners and will compete for the backup job in 2026 to American League MVP runner-up Cal Raleigh.

In his two years in the Pacific Northwest, Garver hit a measly .187/.290/.341 with a .632 OPS, but he did contribute 24 home runs, 81 RBI, and 66 runs scored in 201 regular-season games over 720 plate appearances.

His primary competition for the No. 2 job will be Andrew Knizner, with Jhonny Pereda also in the mix this spring. Garver's average was up a bit (.209) last year in 87 games, but his power (nine homers) was down. Because his glove is below-average, it will be an uphill battle for playing time in Seattle if he wins the backup job.

Francisco Alvarez, New York Mets

New York Mets catcher Francisco Alvarez is unlikely to appear in the first week of the Grapefruit League as the team looks to slow-play him, according to Will Sammon and Tim Britton of The Athletic. Alvarez is expected to be ready to go for Opening Day in late March, but the Mets are going to be cautious with the 24-year-old backstop after he had thumb surgery at the end of last season.

In addition to a torn UCL in his right thumb last August, Alvarez also got a late start in 2025 due to a left-hand fracture. The injuries limited the Venezuelan catcher to 76 games in his fourth year in the majors.

In 277 plate appearances for the Mets, Alvarez hit .256/.339/.447 with a career-high .787 OPS, 11 home runs, 32 RBI, and 32 runs scored. Alvarez's injury history is concerning, but he'll be the team's primary catcher, and he's pretty intriguing for his power upside at the cost of a backup fantasy catcher.

Alejandro Kirk, Toronto Blue Jays

Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk had arguably his best MLB season in 2025, hitting .282/.348/.421 with 15 home runs, 76 RBI, 45 runs scored, and one stolen base across 506 plate appearances. Kirk posted an elite 11.7% strikeout rate, in line with his career mark of 11.6%.

However, the 27-year-old made major strides in terms of contact quality, upping his barrel rate from 6.7% in 2024 to 10.1% in 2025 and posting the best hard-hit rate (50.8%) of his career. Speed will never be an asset for Kirk, as he's logged one career stolen base. His poor base-running ability also impacts him in terms of runs scored, as he's never recorded more than 59 runs in a season and has racked up 45 runs or fewer in three straight years.

Still, Kirk's ability to make contact makes him one of the best options for batting average at the catcher position in all of fantasy. If he can hold the power gains he made in 2025, Kirk should be a solid power and RBI producer relative to his position as well. With a current average draft position of pick 150, Kirk profiles as a high-floor, low-end starting catcher for fantasy managers.