🦃 BLACK FRIDAY - TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE THANKS
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Champ or Chump: DJ LeMahieu & Xander Bogaerts

The end of most drafts is filled with quality, yet flawed talent. Chris Carter could hit you 30+ bombs when he's not torpedoing your batting average, while there seems to be a never ending supply of jackrabbits who can steal a bunch of bases if they can figure out how to hit a single. The best way to tap into this talent base is to have a strong team batting average that can absorb a weak performance or two.

Batting average can be difficult to invest in, however, as the BABIP gods make it more prone to fluctuate than any other offensive fantasy stat. Colorado's DJ LeMahieu won the NL batting title last year with a .348 mark, while Boston's Xander Bogaerts posted a very solid .294. Either creates a good batting average foundation for you to build upon, but is that worth their current price tags?

Editor's note: Be sure to also check out our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. It's already loaded up with tons of great rankings articles and draft analysis. Aside from our tiered staff rankings for every position, we also go deep on MLB prospect rankings, impact rookies for 2017, and dynasty/keeper rankings as well. Bookmark the page, and win your drafts.

 

The Fantasy Jury is Out

DJ LeMahieu (2B, COL) ADP: 87.7

LeMahieu's batting title was not without controversy, as he sat out the last week of games in order to preserve it. Still, his .348/.416/.495 triple slash line with 11 HR and 11 SB was very useful to fantasy owners last year. His seven CS were decisively less helpful. The resulting success rate suggests that he should not be counted on to produce much in the way of speed again.

His batting average was boosted by a .388 BABIP that seems unlikely to repeat even in Coors Field. His 26.6 percent LD% seems extremely high despite a similar rate in 2015 (26 percent), creating space for regression. He also enjoyed batted ball luck on grounders, which posted a .304 BABIP last season against a career mark of .264. Coors boosts BABIP because its spacious outfield leaves plenty of space for airborne baseballs to drop in safely, but this does not help grounders at all. LeMahieu seems likely to regress to his career BABIP of .352.

LeMahieu almost never strikes out (12.6 percent K%, 4.1 percent SwStr%), which when combined with his still-plus BABIP figures to produce a very strong AVG floor. The problem is that he does not really produce anything else. His HR/FB spiked to 10.2 percent last year to produce the 11 homers, but his career rate is only half that figure (6.4 percent). His 22.8 percent FB% (21.4% career) would not be enough to make anything of even a strong HR/FB, so power is a lost cause.

The second sacker offers no power or speed, meaning that batting average and runs scored are all he brings to the fantasy table. Effectively, this means that he is a top 100 draft pick because he plays at Coors, which heavily inflates both stats LeMahieu is strong in. Shouldn't a top draft choice have something going for them other than home park?

Verdict: Chump

 

Xander Bogaerts (SS, BOS) ADP: 28.3

Boston's SS is generally taken in the second or third round of most drafts, not surprising when last year's .294/.356/.446 line with 21 HR and 13 SB is considered. He finally muscled up in 2016, adding pop to the plus BABIP profile owners have come to expect from him.

He appears to have done this by selling out for power. He increased his FB% to 34.9 percent from 25.8 percent the year before, allowing an 11.4 percent HR/FB to produce decent power numbers. He also pulled more of his fly balls (28.1 percent) than in 2015 (16.7 percent), making it easier to believe in the sustainability of his increased HR/FB. His pop-ups spiked to an IFFB% of 17.8 percent while his strikeouts increased (17.1 percent K% last year vs. 15.4 percent in 2015) to complete the look of a guy who was trying to hit for power.

It sort of worked, as Bogaerts cracked 20 bombs for the first time last year. It also didn't, as that was a meh performance in 2016. The league average HR/FB was 12.8 percent last year, a number someone with the talent of Bogaerts should have crushed if he was concentrating on nothing else. While he still posted a .335 BABIP, the number may not be sustainable if he continues to hit pop-ups and fly balls at 2016 rates. We may have seen this regression in the second half, as his BABIP fell to .290 for a 92 wRC+.

Bogaerts's 13 steals were nice, but nowhere near enough to justify his current price tag if his average goes down with only middling power to compensate. Position scarcity is not much of a factor for shortstops anymore, either. Add in a Boston offense that looks much weaker than it did a year ago, and Bogaerts seems like a huge bust candidate.

Verdict: Chump




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Trendon Watford

Won't Return to NBA Cup Meeting with Orlando
Corey Kispert

Suffers Thumb Injury on Tuesday Night
DeVonta Smith

Listed as DNP on Tuesday
Vinnie Hinostroza

to Miss 4-6 Weeks
Pyotr Kochetkov

Dealing With Undisclosed Injury
Tristan Jarry

Expected to Be Available Wednesday
Evgenii Dadonov

Doubtful for Wednesday
J.T. Miller

Joins Team for Road Trip
Joel Kiviranta

Ready to Return Wednesday
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins

Expected to Return on Saturday
Marvin Bagley III

Ruled Out Versus Atlanta
Luke Kennard

Available on Tuesday Night
RJ Barrett

Unavailable Wednesday
Landry Shamet

Out for Wednesday
Nikola Jović

Nikola Jovic Questionable for Wednesday's Matchup With Milwaukee
Bogdan Bogdanović

Bogdan Bogdanovic Considered Questionable for Tuesday
Jauan Jennings

Won't be Suspended
Draymond Green

Will be Questionable for Wednesday Against the Rockets
Goga Bitadze

Downgraded to Questionable
Dereck Lively II

Will Miss At Least 7-10 Days
Paul George

Will Not Play Tuesday against the Magic
Tyrese Maxey

Will Play Tuesday Against the Magic
Omarion Hampton

Chargers Open Omarion Hampton's Practice Window
Joel Embiid

Ruled Out Against Orlando
Lamar Jackson

Returns to Practice
DK Metcalf

D.K. Metcalf Will Be Limited Early in the Week
Isiah Pacheco

Set to Return on Thursday
J.T. Realmuto

Red Sox Showing Interest in J.T. Realmuto
Sonny Gray

Red Sox Acquire Sonny Gray From the Cardinals
Brian Thomas Jr.

Expected to Make his Return in Week 13
Aaron Rodgers

Steelers Have "Great Optimism" Aaron Rodgers Will Play in Week 13
CFB

Jeremiah Smith, Makai Lemon, Skyler Bell Named Biletnikoff Award Finalists
Jayden Daniels

has Been Throwing, Return Timeline Unclear
NFL

As Many as Three NFL Teams Could Have Interest in Hiring Bill Belichick
Tre Johnson

Out Indefinitely With Hip-Flexor Strain
Goga Bitadze

Active Tuesday in Philadelphia
Wendell Carter Jr.

Cleared To Play Against 76ers
Jalen Suggs

Ready to Return Tuesday in Philadelphia
Luke Kennard

Uncertain For Tuesday's Game Against Wizards
Adem Bona

Will Not Play Tuesday Against the Magic
Marvin Bagley III

Listed as Questionable vs. Hawks
Sam Reinhart

Extends Scoring Streak With Three-Point Effort
Adam Fox

Delivers Two Assists in Monday's Win
Brandon Hagel

Tallies Three Points Against Flyers
Andrei Vasilevskiy

Extends Winning Streak With Shutout Performance
Logan Cooley

Erupts for Five Points in Monday's Win
Mathieu Olivier

Sustains Upper-Body Injury Monday
Zach Werenski

Hurt Against Capitals
Isiah Pacheco

Targeting a Return on Thursday
Shohei Ohtani

to Play for Team Japan in 2026 World Baseball Classic
Lamar Jackson

Now Dealing With a Toe Injury
Jake Walman

to Remain Out Tuesday
Ridly Greig

Still Out Monday
Baker Mayfield

Dealing With Low-Grade Shoulder Sprain
Thomas Chabot

Misses Monday's Matchup
Kirill Marchenko

Out Monday
J.T. Miller

Unavailable Monday
Brayden Point

Out Against Flyers
Nikita Kucherov

Good to Go Monday
Chris Godwin

Buccaneers Plan to "Ramp Up" Chris Godwin's Usage
Colorado Rockies

Warren Schaeffer to Stick Around as Rockies Manager in 2026
Ashton Jeanty

Ankle Injury isn't Severe
Jayden Daniels

to Practice This Week, Considered a Long Shot for Week 13
C.J. Stroud

Remains in Concussion Protocol
Mike Evans

Could Return Before End of Regular Season
J.J. McCarthy

in Concussion Protocol
Tyrod Taylor

to Remain the Jets' Starting QB
Shedeur Sanders

to Make Another Start for Browns in Week 13
CFB

Chris Bell Out for Rivalry Matchup Against Kentucky
Ryan Helsley

Tigers Eyeing Ryan Helsley as a Starter
Dan Hooker

Suffers Second-Round Submission Loss
Marcus Semien

Shipped to the Mets on Sunday
Arman Tsarukyan

Gets Submission Win
Brandon Nimmo

Traded to Texas
Belal Muhammad

Loses Back-to-Back Fights
Belal Muhammad

Ian Machado Garry Outpoints Belal Muhammad
Alonzo Menifield

Suffers First-Round Knockout Loss
Volkan Oezdemir

Gets Back In The Win Column
Jack Hermansson

Gets Knocked Out
Jack Hermansson

Myktybek Orolbai Knocks Out Jack Hermansson
Shamil Gaziev

Suffers First-Round Knockout Loss
Waldo Cortes-Acosta

Shines At UFC Qatar
Tagir Ulanbekov

Suffers Third-Round Submission Loss
Kyoji Horiguchi

Makes Triumphant UFC Return
Adolis García

Rangers Non-Tender Adolis Garcia on Friday
CFB

Beau Pribula Expected to Start Against Oklahoma
Dan Hooker

An Underdog At UFC Qatar
Arman Tsarukyan

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Ian Machado Garry

A Favorite At UFC Qatar
Belal Muhammad

Looks To Bounce Back
Alonzo Menifield

Looks For His Third Consecutive Win
Volkan Oezdemir

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Myktybek Orolbai

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Jack Hermansson

Makes His Welterweight Debut
Kyoji Horiguchi

Returns To The UFC
Elly De La Cruz

Played Through Partially Torn Quad to End 2025
Tarik Skubal

Tigers "Doubtful" to Trade Tarik Skubal

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP