Mets, Blue Jays Engaged in Bidding War for Kyle Tucker

Jan 13, 2026, 7:29 PM ET

The New York Mets and Toronto Blue Jays are engaged in an active bidding war for free-agent outfielder Kyle Tucker. According to ESPN's Jesse Rogers, the Mets have offered Tucker a short-term deal believed to be worth roughly $50 million per season. Meanwhile, sources told ESPN that the Blue Jays have countered with a long-term contract carrying a lower average annual value. Tucker is the most prominent free agent still on the market, and he is hoping to land a contract that will carry him through the remainder of his career. Last season with the Chicago Cubs, the 28-year-old slashed .266/.377/.464 with 22 home runs, 25 doubles, and 25 stolen bases while striking out only 14.7% of the time across 597 plate appearances. However, the primary concern surrounding Tucker is durability. He missed time last season with a fractured finger and finished the year while managing a calf injury. In 2024, he also fractured his shin after fouling a ball off his leg. While there is no doubt about his talent, evaluators have raised questions about how well he will age, citing slower bat speed, declining sprint speed, and diminishing outfield range. Even with those concerns, Tucker remains one of the most valuable players in baseball. From a fantasy perspective, he projects as a top-20 overall pick in most formats, with the upside of a first-round bat. Wherever he lands, Tucker should remain a cornerstone player for years to come.--Marty Tallman
Source: Jesse Rogers