Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Player Comparisons
News and Alerts

What Went Wrong with Odell Beckham Jr?

"What Went Wrong?" is a Rotoballer offseason series exploring fantasy players who underperformed their ADP. We'll explain why they fell below expectations and try to determine what it means for their value going forward.

Finally free from the decrepit arm of Eli Manning and away from the torturous New York media, Odell Beckham Jr was expected to thrive his first year in Cleveland. With a young, fearless quarterback at the helm, fantasy owners dreamed of nothing but 50-yard bombs from Baker Mayfield taken to the house by a smiling, high-stepping Beckham.

His top-tier ADP of WR4 came with a willingness to forget his injury history, which to that point had caused him to miss more than a quarter of his career games. And yet, despite playing all 16 games for only the second time in his career, Beckham finished at a meager WR25 on the season. He finished as a top-12 WR only two weeks and only twice more was he in the top 24. That, by any definition, qualifies as a bust. So what went wrong?

Featured Promo: Looking for some fantasy football action? Join a dynasty startup league over at FFPC. Sign up today and get $25 off any FFPC league. FFPC is the leader in dynasty leagues and has standard, superflex and best ball formats. Dynasty not your thing? No worries, FFPC has Best Ball leagues as well. Join A League Today!


The Simple Stats

  • Cleveland had 539 passing attempts in 2019 (19th in the NFL). This dropped from 574 in 2018 (12th).
  • The Giants had 583 passing attempts in 2018 (10th).
  • Cleveland threw the ball 55.4% of the time in 2019, compared to 56.1% in 2018.
  • The Giants threw the ball 59.2% of the time in 2018.
  • Beckham's receptions per game dropped to 4.6 in 2019, compared to 6.4 in 2018, and his career average of 6.2.
  • Beckham posted more than 1,000 yards for the fifth time in his career (1,035).
  • Beckham averaged 64.7 receiving yards per game in 2019 (32nd among WRs), compared to 87.7 in 2018 (9th), and his career average of 86.8.


Transition To a New Team

Since 2009, excluding players who were traded midseason, there have been 13 wide receivers who have switched teams in the offseason and have played at least 13 games in each of those consecutive seasons. On average, those receivers' stats dropped by nine receptions, 99 yards, and two TD with their new team. Most importantly, their end-of-year fantasy finish dropped by 10 spots.

So we should have expected a bump down for Beckham in his first year with Cleveland. And he mimicked that narrative perfectly. Even though he played four more games in 2019 than he did in 2018, he dropped from WR15 to WR25 overall. On a points-per-game basis, it was a more drastic drop from WR7 to WR33.

The common thought was that since Baker Mayfield is a better and more opportunistic quarterback than Eli Manning at this stage in his career, it would be a significant upgrade for Beckham. Mayfield represented strength and moxie, whereas Manning was the poster boy for fragility. Therefore, there would be more opportunities for Beckham, and those opportunities would be more valuable. Win-win, right?


2018 vs 2019

Not so much. Fantasy owners overlooked the impact Jarvis Landry would have on Beckham's target share. Landry had an extravagant 25.96% target share in 2018 as the top receiving option on the Browns. With OBJ incoming, that number was expected to take a nosedive. Instead, it stayed nearly the same at 25.6%.

To be fair, Beckham commanded a healthy target share himself, eating up 24.7% of the Browns' total receiving pie. But that was still a notable decrease from his 28.3% target share in 2018 with the Giants. In fact, this was the second-lowest target share of his career.

Here's where things really start to go off the rails. He had just six games where he reached double-digit targets this year, compared to eight last year. Meanwhile, Beckham had nine games with fewer than nine targets this year, compared to just one last year. And again, he played four more games in 2019 than in 2018.

Worse, he had just two games with 100+ receiving yards. Even worse still, 25% of his yardage and touchdowns came in just two games. Because of all that, Beckham finished as a WR2 or better in just four games, and all of those came against bottom half passing defenses.

But there's another reason for Beckham's statistical downturn.


The Core Muscle Injury

Although he didn't miss any games, OBJ dealt with a core muscle injury throughout the season. Beckham suffered the injury in training camp, and it affected his play for the rest of the year.

For context, DeSean Jackson suffered a major core muscle injury in Week 2 season and subsequently missed the next six games. When he tried to return to play against the Bears in Week 9, he managed just four snaps and suffered a setback that sidelined him the rest of the season. Though, to be fair, Jackson's injury was significantly worse, as he actually tore his abdominal muscle off the bone. Beckham's injury wasn't to the same extent, but the comparison paints an important picture of how tough these injuries can be on a player.

Baker Mayfield commented that Beckham's injury situation "wasn't handled right," noting he was "not able to run as well as he should be able to." Mayfield said he could sense his teammate's frustration with it throughout the season. Beckham underwent surgery in January to repair it, so it hopefully shouldn't affect him next year.

But there were also outside factors that led to his down year.


Significant Changes To the Offense

Most are going to point to Kitchens' poor coaching job as the culprit for why Mayfield and his cohorts put up poor fantasy showings. But what's strange is Kitchens was actually credited for improving Mayfield's play in his rookie year after taking over from Hue Jackson halfway through the season. Mayfield ranked as the QB22 in fantasy while playing with Jackson, but jumped to QB10 once Kitchens took the reins.

In that stretch, Mayfield averaged 33 attempts, 286 yards and 2.4 touchdowns per game, with a 104.3 passer rating. Unfortunately, Kitchens couldn't help sustain those numbers in 2019. Despite still averaging 33 attempts per game, the TD average dropped to 1.4, the yards to 222, and Mayfield's passer rating plunged to 76.1.

How much of that was on Kitchens? And how much was due to shipping guard Kevin Zeitler to New York in the Beckham trade? After all, Cleveland had the 2nd-ranked offensive line according to PFF at the end of the 2018 season. Fast forward to the end of 2019, and PFF had them ranked 23rd.

The Browns' pass protection issues can't be overstated, as his protection rate (77.6%) ranked 30th among quarterbacks. Last year that rate (84.9%) ranked 11th. That's a large reason Mayfield didn't throw the ball as frequently as he did his rookie year, and why so many of his passes looked -- to put it as nicely as possible -- "off."


How Will It Go In 2020?

Even though Beckham will technically be involved in a "new" offense, as new head coach Kevin Stefanski and new offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt will retool the Browns offense.

Stefanski was the OC in Minnesota last year -- his only year in that position -- and produced a passing offense that ranked 30th in attempts, 23rd in yards and 14th in touchdowns. It yielded a WR26 finish for Stefon Diggs, and a WR44 finish for Adam Thielen on a points-per-game basis. For comparison, they finished WR11 and WR7, respectively, the previous year. It's a very limited sample size, but certainly one worth factoring into the overall picture.

Van Pelt was the QB coach in Green Bay from 2014-2017, and in Cincinnati from 2018-2019. While he had it easy with Aaron Rodgers, the Bengals passing offense was mediocre at best (and disastrous at worst) in those two years. Though when your quarterbacks are Andy Dalton, Jeff Driskel, and Ryan Finley, that's to be expected. His report card isn't necessarily predictive of how he'll impact this new offense.

The days of Odell Beckham Jr. being viewed as a top-five player at his position are gone. But a top-10 finish isn't completely out of reach for the talented receiver going into his age-27 season. If he can stay healthy, acclimate to the new coaching staff, continue building on his connection with Baker, and procure a large enough percentage of Stefanski's presumably modest passing attack, he can get back near the elite tier of receivers. A lot of things will have to go right, but there's room for him to re-ascend into the WR1 ranks.

More Fantasy Football Analysis


Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Player Comparisons
News and Alerts


Tim Anderson49 mins ago

Returning From Injured List Tuesday
Brett Baty2 hours ago

Could Start To Lose More Playing Time
Mark Hubbard2 hours ago

Trending Up Ahead Of Charles Schwab Challenge
Alejandro Tosti2 hours ago

Headed For Trouble At Colonial
Chan Kim2 hours ago

A Potential Value At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA2 hours ago

S.H. Kim A Sneaky Option At Colonial
Justin Suh2 hours ago

A Player To Avoid At Charles Schwab Challenge
PGA2 hours ago

Matthi Schmid Looks To Regain Form At Colonial
Yoshinobu Yamamoto2 hours ago

Tallies Fifth Win In Quality Start
Marcell Ozuna3 hours ago

Launches Two Homers Monday
Jarrett Allen4 hours ago

Has "Numerous Admirers" Among Rival Teams
Clint Capela4 hours ago

Linked With Move Away From Atlanta
Gordon Hayward4 hours ago

Disappointed With Stint In Oklahoma City
Josh Giddey4 hours ago

Desperate To Remain In Oklahoma City
Bruce Brown4 hours ago

Raptors Expected To Move Bruce Brown
Julius Randle5 hours ago

Teams "Monitoring" Julius Randle's Situation In New York
Rafael Devers13 hours ago

Brings Homer Streak To Six Games Monday
Taj Bradley13 hours ago

Fans 10 In Polarizing Loss Monday
Danny Jansen13 hours ago

Homers, Plates Five Monday
Ryan Helsley14 hours ago

Earns League-Best 14th Save Monday
Gunnar Henderson14 hours ago

Homers In Fourth Straight Game Monday
Colt Emerson15 hours ago

Could Miss Up To Four Weeks With Foot Fracture
Dustin May15 hours ago

Starts Throwing Off A Mound
Joey Ortiz16 hours ago

Getting X-Rays On His Foot
Joe Ross16 hours ago

Likely To Land On Injured List
Chas McCormick16 hours ago

Could Return Tuesday
Kristaps Porzingis16 hours ago

Remains Out For Game 1
Garrett Whitlock16 hours ago

May Need Elbow Surgery
Xavier Tillman16 hours ago

Sr. Questionable For Game 1
Bobby Miller16 hours ago

To Pitch In Another Sim Game Tuesday
Evan Phillips16 hours ago

Needs Multiple Rehab Outings
Bryce Young16 hours ago

Impressing During Offseason Workouts
Ryan Pepiot17 hours ago

Ready To Return Wednesday
Rhys Hoskins17 hours ago

Starts Running Program Monday
Daniel Jones17 hours ago

Takes Part In 7-On-7 Drills
Reese Olson17 hours ago

Exits After Taking Comebacker To Hip
Matthew Stafford17 hours ago

Present At Organized Team Activities
Tee Higgins17 hours ago

Not Anticipated To Attend OTAs
Pete Crow-Armstrong17 hours ago

Cubs Send Pete Crow-Armstrong To Triple-A
CeeDee Lamb17 hours ago

Still Not Expected To Attend OTAs
DeVante Parker18 hours ago

Calls It Quits
Filip Chytil19 hours ago

Appears Ready To Rock For Eastern Conference Finals
Jani Hakanpaa19 hours ago

Still Not Practicing
Roope Hintz19 hours ago

Skates Monday, Still Day-To-Day
Sam Lafferty19 hours ago

And Ilya Mikheyev Drawing Into Game 7 Lineup
Thatcher Demko20 hours ago

Unavailable For Game 7, Arturs Silovs Will Start
Brock Boeser20 hours ago

Out Indefinitely With Blood Clots
Antonio Gibson21 hours ago

Flashing Speed, Receiving Skills At OTAs
Justin Jefferson21 hours ago

Not Present At OTAs On Monday
JuJu Smith-Schuster23 hours ago

100 Percent Healthy
Joey Logano23 hours ago

Dominates All-Star Race
Ryan Fox23 hours ago

Continues Up-And-Down 2024
Denny Hamlin24 hours ago

Falls Short Of Victory At The All-Star Race
Ryan Blaney24 hours ago

Rallies For Fifth-Place Finish At North Wilkesboro
Jacoby Brissett24 hours ago

Takes First QB Reps Monday
Patton Kizzire24 hours ago

Showing Improvement The Past Month
Kyle Busch24 hours ago

Ricky Stenhouse Jr Punches Kyle Busch After Lap 2 Crash at All-Star Race
Kyle Busch24 hours ago

Wrecked Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. at All-Star Race, Then Said He "Sucks"
Kendrick Bourne24 hours ago

Won't Practice This Spring
Rashee Rice24 hours ago

To Participate In OTAs
Tua Tagovailoa24 hours ago

In The Building For OTAs
Christiaan Bezuidenhout24 hours ago

Likely To Bounce Back This Week
Keegan Bradley1 day ago

Attempts To Continue Momentum From Valhalla
Edson Barboza1 day ago

Lerone Murphy Dominates To Defeat Edson Barboza
Carlston Harris1 day ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Vegas 92
Khaos Williams1 day ago

Scores Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 92
Luana Pinheiro1 day ago

Loses Second Fight In A Row
Angela Hill1 day ago

Scores First Submission Win
NASCAR1 day ago

Bubba Wallace Exceeds Value In DFS At North Wilkesboro
Chase Elliott1 day ago

Finishes Eighth In All-Star Race
Aaron Gordon1 day ago

Quiet In Game 7 Loss
Jamal Murray1 day ago

Leads All Scorers In Game 7 With 35 Points
Nikola Jokic1 day ago

Ends Season With Another Huge Stat Line
Rudy Gobert1 day ago

Falls Just Short Of Double-Double In Crucial Win
Jaden McDaniels1 day ago

Continues To Roll In Game 7
Anthony Edwards1 day ago

Suffers Rough Shooting Night In Game 7
Karl-Anthony Towns1 day ago

Leads Timberwolves To Conference Finals
Vinicius Salvador1 day ago

Winless In The UFC
Adrian Yanez1 day ago

Returns To Win Column In A Big Way
Ramiz Brahimaj1 day ago

Doesn't Do Much In UFC Vegas 92 Loss
Themba Gorimbo1 day ago

Wins Lackluster Decision At UFC Vegas 92
Edson Barboza1 day ago

Falls Short At UFC Vegas 92
Christopher Bell1 day ago

Fades Back To 17th At North Wilkesboro
Chris Buescher1 day ago

Winds Up Third At All-Star Race
David Johnson2 days ago

Officially Retires
Josh Hart2 days ago

Can't Lift New York To A Win In Game 7
Donte DiVincenzo2 days ago

Surges On Sunday Afternoon
OG Anunoby2 days ago

Limited In Game 7
Pascal Siakam2 days ago

Plays Well In Game 7
Myles Turner2 days ago

Steps Up Defensively On Sunday
Tyrese Haliburton2 days ago

Leads Indiana To The ECF
Tyler Reddick2 days ago

What To Do With Tyler Reddick At North Wilkesboro?
Tank Dell2 days ago

Resumes Running
Joey Logano2 days ago

Will Start On The Pole In The 2024 NASCAR All-Star Race
Christopher Bell2 days ago

Should DFS Players Roster Christopher Bell At North Wilkesboro?
William Byron2 days ago

Aims For The Top 10 At North Wilkesboro
Denny Hamlin2 days ago

Is One Of The Top Favorites To Win The All-Star Race
Kyle Larson2 days ago

Will Start From The Rear At North Wilkesboro
Martin Truex Jr2 days ago

. Is One To Watch At North Wilkesboro
Chase Elliott2 days ago

Why Chase Elliott Is A Core Play In DFS This Weekend At North Wilkesboro
Kyle Busch2 days ago

Will Kyle Busch’s Recent Struggles On Short Tracks Continue This Weekend At North Wilkesboro?
Ricky Stenhouse Jr2 days ago

. Likely Not A Factor In All-Star Race
Michael McDowell2 days ago

Could Slide Back At North Wilkesboro
AJ Allmendinger2 days ago

May Struggle In All-Star Race
Michael Thomas3 days ago

Reportedly Contacted By Pittsburgh
Brian Robinson Jr.3 days ago

Still Considered "Top Back" By Some
Cam Akers3 days ago

Possibly Working Toward A Return
Tank Dell3 days ago

Running Routes
Gustav Forsling3 days ago

Sends Florida To Eastern Conference Finals
Jamie Benn3 days ago

Scores Big Goal In Series-Clinching Victory
Matt Duchene3 days ago

Ends Second-Round Series With Overtime Winner
Jake Oettinger3 days ago

Leads Stars To Western Conference Final
Sergei Bobrovsky3 days ago

Stellar In Game 6 Win
Anton Lundell3 days ago

Comes Up Huge In Series-Clinching Win
T.J. Hockenson4 days ago

Won't Put A Timeline On His Recovery
TOR4 days ago

Maple Leafs Bring In Craig Berube As New Head Coach
Nick Cousins4 days ago

Re-Enters Panthers Lineup Friday
Yakov Trenin4 days ago

Considered Day-To-Day
Tyler Seguin4 days ago

Good To Go Friday
Roope Hintz4 days ago

Remains Out For Game 6
Brad Marchand4 days ago

A Game-Time Call Friday
San Francisco 49ers4 days ago

Dre Greenlaw Ditches Walking Boot
Lerone Murphy4 days ago

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Carlston Harris4 days ago

Set For Co-Main Event
Khaos Williams4 days ago

Faces Carlston Harris In The Co-Main Event Of UFC Vegas 92
Angela Hill4 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 92
Luana Pinheiro4 days ago

Looks To Get Back In Win Column
J.T. Miller4 days ago

Scores Dramatic Game-Winner
Leon Draisaitl4 days ago

Extends Postseason-Opening Point Streak With An Assist
Ilya Mikheyev4 days ago

Dealing With Undisclosed Injury
Scottie Scheffler4 days ago

Detained By Louisville Police Following Traffic Incident
Vinicius Salvador5 days ago

Moves Up To Bantamweight At UFC Vegas 92
Adrian Yanez5 days ago

Looks To Snap Losing Skid At UFC Vegas 92
Themba Gorimbo5 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 92
Ramiz Brahimaj5 days ago

Ends Layoff At UFC Vegas 92
Edson Barboza5 days ago

Headlines UFC Vegas 92




Justin Fields - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Backup Quarterbacks To Stash in Superflex Leagues - 2024 Fantasy Football Analysis

Backup quarterback: The best job in all of sports. The fans love their unseen potential as they relax on the sideline and collect checks, free from menacing pass rushers and downhill middle linebackers. When the starter struggles, fans clamor for QB2. It's also a position not often given a second thought in fantasy football, at... Read More

Bucky Irving - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football Rookie Spotlight: Bucky Irving

There were questions about where Oregon running back Bucky Irving would go in the 2024 NFL Draft. He was a smaller back -- sitting 5-foot-10, 190 pounds -- but he was a player who put up big numbers in his final two seasons with the Ducks. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers eventually took a chance on Irving in the fourth... Read More

Fantasy Football Rookie Tight Ends You Must Have in 2024

With the draft and schedule release behind us, it’s time to try and pick out some potential sleepers and stashes we may be looking to add to our fantasy rosters this year. One position that historically underwhelms from a fantasy perspective during rookie campaigns is tight end. But, we saw Detroit rookie Sam LaPorta make... Read More

Kyren Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Early Fantasy Football ADP Analysis For FFPC Leagues: Running Backs

It is never too early to check on fantasy football Average Draft Position reports. High-stakes competitors have already started drafting in seasonal formats on the Fantasy Football Players Championship (FFPC) platform. In this feature, I focus specifically on early ADP trends at running back. I have highlighted 10 notable RBs to consider from completed early... Read More

Kendre Miller - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Fantasy Football Dynasty Price Check - Kendre Miller (2024)

The New Orleans Saints offense was supposed to take a step forward in 2023 with Derek Carr under center...until it didn't. Carr was essentially the same quarterback he's always been. It was the running game that held everybody back. The Saints averaged the second-fewest yards per carry (3.6) across the league, tallied just four carries... Read More

Fantasy Football Rookie Spotlight: Audric Estimé

We've heard the phrase running backs don't matter before. That's evident in the real-life NFL Draft, with only 12 running backs going in the first round since 2014. That list includes Clyde Edwards-Helaire, Josh Jacobs, Melvin Gordon, Todd Gurley, Saquon Barkley, Sony Michel, Leonard Fournette, Christian McCaffrey, Ezekiel Elliott, Najee Harris, Bijan Robinson, and Jahmyr... Read More

Jaylen Waddle - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL DFS Picks

Fantasy Football Dynasty Buys and Sells - Post NFL Draft Edition

When it comes to dynasty fantasy football leagues, one of the most intriguing aspects is the fluctuations in player value in the aftermath of the NFL Draft. Players once thought of as placeholders quickly rise draft boards, while stars who seemed secure become losers in an instant. Dynasty rankings were turned upside down following the... Read More

Fantasy Football Risers and Fallers: ADP Analysis for 2024

Fantasy football never sleeps at RotoBaller! With early 2024 best ball drafts already taking place, we're digging into the ADP of fantasy football's most impactful players. NFL Network contributor and RotoBaller analyst LaQuan dives into the early ADP of some popular fantasy options. Find out which notable fantasy football contributors are rising up 2024 draft... Read More


UFL Fantasy Football Rankings for Week 8: QB, RB, WR, TE Rankings and Analysis (2024)

Week 7's UFL action did not disappoint, as the game of the week between St. Louis and Birmingham came down to the wire and delivered some impressive fantasy outings. The Renegades grabbed their first win of the season in an explosive 47-point offensive showing, the Panthers featured two new quarterbacks, and the Brahmas won a... Read More


Free UFL Betting Picks - Best Bets, Odds, Predictions for Week 8

Another 5-3 week is nothing to be upset about. Plus, that was a fun week to kick back and watch from a results standpoint. The Renegades grab their first win of the season in dominant fashion, the Stallions beat the Battlehawks in a game that lived up to the expectations and gave positive tidings for... Read More

Christian McCaffrey - Fantasy Football Rankings, DFS and Betting Picks, NFL Injury News

Early PPR Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Football Drafts: Justin Jefferson, Josh Jacobs, Stefon Diggs, Trey McBride, Malik Nabers, Jaxon Smith-Njigba

Hey, RotoBallers! The 2024 NFL Draft is over, and it's an exciting time for football as players are starting to report to offseason workouts. The heart of fantasy football draft season is around the corner. Week 1 will be here before we know it, and it's never too early to start preparing for your fantasy... Read More

Jaylen Wright - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, RB, NFL Draft Sleepers

Fantasy Football Dynasty League Rookie/Free-Agent Draft Review: FFPC Deeper Targets

In the offseason and preseason, as soon as the NFL Draft is over, I eagerly jump into slow fantasy football drafts. I am a big fan of the slow draft format. It extends the fun over many days and always gives me something to look forward to throughout the day. Waking up to find out... Read More

Chase Brown - Fantasy Football Rankings, Waiver Wire Pickups, Draft Sleepers

Second-Year Fantasy Football Players Who Will Break Out in 2024 - Sophomore Bounce-Back Candidates

For many years, fantasy football players tried their best to avoid rookies in drafts. Recently, it's become more common for rookies to make an impact. We've seen players like Ja’Marr Chase, Ezekiel Elliott, and Saquon Barkley finish in the top five at their positions. Even last year, we saw C.J. Stroud and Puka Nacua emerge... Read More