Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!

Lost password? [X]

Receive free daily analysis:


Already have an account? Log in here.


Forgot Password


Get Off My Lawn! Passing on Rookie RBs in Favor of Veterans

Did you just see what Saquon Barkley did against Washington!? Did you read Phillip Lindsay's last game stat line for the Broncos!? Did you know Nick Chubb racked up 176 yards in just his third game as a starting tailback!? Hold your horses with all this rookie-running back hype, please, and respect your elders. They deserve it, and I'm here to prove it.

The running game has been on a downtrend during the past few seasons. You just have to crack Twitter open and even if you just follow a couple of analytics-inclined users you'll see them mention how "every running back is replaceable" or how "the running game is totally overvalued". I'm not here to argue that. Numbers say it is, and I believe in numbers. What I'm here for today is to study how newcomers and veteran running backs perform in the NFL.

If there is an important position in fantasy football that is the RB one. Guys at the position not only run for yards, but they are also more and more capable of catching the ball each passing year. All-in-one tailbacks are the rave. But do they come prepared enough from the NCAA? Can you expect good outcomes drafting a rookie RB straight out of college instead of a proven veteran (for this article I'll consider a veteran any player on his second year or more)? Let's take a look at what data tells us and, well, (spoiler coming) give veterans the edge over the rookies as we should expect.

Editor's Note: Get any full-season NFL Premium Pass for 50% off. Our exclusive In-Season Lineup Tools, Lineup Optimizer and over 150 days of Premium DFS Research. Sign Up Now!


A Quick Look At Age And Rushing

Just before I delve deeper into this study I'd like to present the data I will be working with. Using I downloaded every RB-season from 2014 to 2018. The only filter, was for the player to have at least 10 rush attempts in the season, to avoid extreme outliers. That fetched 582 player-seasons. Of those, 119 belong to rookies.

This is how the seasons are spread in terms of age. The first chart depicts the average rushing attempts at each age, and the second the total attempts per each age-group:

Obviously, young rushers are prominent in the league and as they age they slowly start to leave the field. The kind of out-of-place peaks at age 30 and 33 in the top chart are mostly due to monster seasons by Adrian Peterson, LeGarrette Blount, Frank Gore and Matt Forte (all 200+ attempts efforts, raising the average for those ages a lot).

With this brief summary out of our way, we can start looking at some more interesting insights in the data.


There Aren't Many Elite-Production Rookie RBs

I'm not going to waste your time, and I'll jump straight into what should be the final point to tackle in the whole article. This is where the meat and potatoes of all of the dataset are: PPR points of rookie running backs (green circles) compared to PPR points of veteran RBs (yellow crosses), each of the five past years:

You shouldn't be surprised at the outcome. Yes, there have been tremendous rookie running backs here and there (we've welcomed no less than Ezekiel Elliott, Kareem Hunt, Alvin Kamara and Saquon Barkley in just the past three seasons), but on average, the best rushers tend to be veterans.

Barring the four aforementioned rookies, no other newcomer has gotten to 230 points (always on PPR leagues) other than Leonard Fournette (230.2 in 2017) and Jordan Howard (230.1 in 2016). On the other hand, 40 veterans have reached that mark in the past five seasons.

1-0 veterans when it comes to high-end production.


Teams Rely On Veterans, Veterans Give Back

If there is one thing of massive importance in fantasy football, that is opportunity. The more a player tries/is able to do something, the more chances he ends with points: the more a receiver gets targeted, the more chances he has to catch a ball and get yardage; the more a rusher attempts runs, the more chances he gets to pile up yards and score touchdowns. It is simple math. If a player doesn't get touches, he's not worth rostering.

Here is how veterans and rookies have fared in terms of touches from 2014 to 2018:

The rookies come in at lower values than veterans. It is normal and again expected. The highest-touch rookie in the dataset is Elliott with 354 in 2016. Nine veteran player-seasons surpassed that mark, with DeMarco Murray at the top (449 touches in 2014). The size of the dots represents the number of players to get X number of touches. As can be seen, not a lot of players get to a huge amount of touches (neither veterans nor rookies), but for rookies the numbers tend to be lower and stay more packed, telling us that they both get fewer touches than veterans and also that that is the case for most of the players.

Looking at how veterans and rookies produce, we get a similar output:

The veterans come out winners again. They have a higher median, their production is more spread and reaches higher levels, and the truly elite player-seasons from second-year players on are much better than those of rookies.

2-0 veterans when adding average production


Old But Gold

If you're still thinking about drafting a rookie running back, consider what I mentioned in the last section: opportunity. So far, I have not filtered the data in terms of minimum attempts or touches more than when I fetched it after setting a minimum of 10 rush attempts over the full season. Let's just focus on heavy-lifters now. I'm going to use data only from player-seasons of at least 200 touches.

Since 2014, only 16 rookies have logged more than 200 touches in a season (just a hair over 3 per season, 13% of the rookies' population from 2014-2018). That pales in comparison to the number of veterans to do so, a total of 105 (21 per season, 5% of the veterans population in the same span). In terms of percentages, of those supposed top-24 RBs per season, only 12% of them would have been/be rookies. The chances of drafting a rookie for your team and have him produce at a veteran level are minimal.

So, speaking of elite-level running backs, veterans edge rookies again by a wide margin. 3-0 oldies.


The Final Blow: A Quick And Dirty Statistical Rundown

At this point, I don't have much left to say and show you. I just thought it'd be interesting to throw out some raw stats out there split in rookie/veteran player-seasons. These are the numbers that matter for us fantasy owners at the end of the day: yards, receptions, touchdowns, and basically PPR points. Let's take a brief look at them (I've only considered player-seasons with at least 10 games to keep outliers at bay).

This table shows the production in each category for the average veteran/rookie in the dataset.

PPR PPR/G Att Yds/Att Rush TD Rec Yds/Rec Rec TD Yds Scm
Veterans 125.2 8.8 119.5 4.1 3.5 27.0 8.0 1.1 719.6
Rookies 108.4 7.5 109.3 4.4 3.0 21.4 7.8 0.8 648.5

After this, I guess we can close this case.

Of the nine considered categories, the veterans produce more in eight of them and the difference in the one they don't (Yds/Att) is not significant at all. It is not hard to think of reasons for this to be the case.

Veterans are proved players, and the fact that they've reached the "veteran" status means that they were once rookies and didn't fail to perform. Not many rookies can say that, and fewer of them can be considered elite talents from day one.

NFL teams, as they operate, are always going to be more comfortable giving touchdown-scoring chances to veterans than rookies (even some of those players are probably even "demanding" such opportunities as part of their deals; the so-called "touchdown vultures"). Quarterbacks are going to rely more on veterans than newcomers when it comes to throwing them the ball (the six-reception difference on average is actually staggering).

No matter what, even if the rookies had won this final round, they'd still trail the group of veteran RBs. They didn't, though, so the veterans win the RB competition by a massive 4-0.

Cold world, rookies.

At the end of the day, only the sure-thing rookies are worth a high draft pick. There are a lot of spots in fantasy rosters to fill when it comes to running backs. We're talking about two starters, another potential one in a flex position, and between three and six slots in the bench. If you want to bank on a rookie RB, do it only knowing he is a lock to turn into an elite tailback. If not, just wait to pick someone as a flier on the very late rounds of your draft, and bet on veterans instead during the earlier rounds.

They might not be so sexy, nor appealing to you, nor bring as much hype as the young bloods in the league, but if they are something, that is productive. And that is what you should be mainly focused on.

More Fantasy Football Analysis

More Recent Articles


Fantasy Football Starts and Sits: Matchups Analysis for Week 15

Welcome to our Week 15 matchup analysis and start/sit column for fantasy football. We'll be covering every single contest from the Sunday slate in one convenient location, helping you make the best decisions for your fantasy lineups. Be sure to check back regularly because this article will be updated as news comes in regarding injuries and other... Read More

Week 15 Fantasy Football Staff Rankings

Below you will find all of RotoBaller's fantasy football weekly rankings, tiers, player news and stats for the 2019 NFL season. Our Ranking Wizard displays our staff's rankings for various league formats, all in one easy place. Here's what you'll find: Weekly PPR Rankings Weekly Half-PPR Rankings Weekly Standard Rankings Dynasty League Rankings     Fantasy... Read More

Fantasy Football News and Injuries - Running Updates

Below is a quick-hit list of running notes on relevant injuries and player news, including pre-game reports and live in-game updates. Stay tuned for updates all throughout the week and on Sunday morning game day:   Week 15 JuJu Smith-Schuster is expected to miss another game this week. Evan Engram and Daniel Jones are not expected... Read More

All-Day For the Win: Why Adrian Peterson Matters Again

I don't think anyone could ever be happy at any sports player getting injured. It just makes no sense, so please leave the hatred out now and forever when it comes to that. That being said, though, we're talking about just a branch of sports here with fantasy football, and we all know what is... Read More

Fantasy Football IDP Rankings for Week 15 (Top 100)

One of the great things about implementing IDP in fantasy football is that it balances out some of the insanity that the offensive players produce in some weeks. If you started a lineup with Jimmy Garoppolo, Raheem Mostert, Boston Scott, A.J. Brown, Darius Slayton, and Noah Fant then you undoubtedly crushed your opponent while a... Read More

Fantasy Football Booms, Busts - Kenny Golladay, Kenyan Drake, James White

If there was ever a week to have more booms than busts in your fantasy football lineup, it’s this week. The playoffs are either underway or about to start in fantasy football leagues across the nation and around the world. If you are lucky enough to be the proud owner of a playoff team, then... Read More

Show Me The Money! Stashes That Could Win Your League

Success in the fantasy playoffs is all about planning ahead. Your bench is no longer a safe space for high floor players without much of a ceiling; they won't win you the big game. You need to look ahead and stash players with exploitable matchups in the weeks to come so that you don't get... Read More

Wide Receiver Snap Counts and Target Trends - Week 14 Analysis

Wide receivers are essential components toward your ultimate goal of securing league championships. If you are preparing for Week 15 matchups, an expanding collection of tools are available that can provide you with an extensive level of knowledge. Those results provide the foundation for this weekly statistical breakdown of the wide receiver position, which is designed... Read More

The King's Week 15 Lineup Rankings and Analysis (Premium Content)

Welcome back, RotoBallers! Below you will find my Week 15 fantasy football lineup rankings for the second round of your playoffs. The ranks are available in PPR, Half PPR, and Standard formats. They will be updated as needed, so make sure to check back for the latest versions, especially on the weekends. Skill Position analysis versus... Read More

Week 15 Stream Team - Free Agent and Bye-Week Streamers

Now that the playoffs are in full swing in most leagues and the final march for a championship has begun, streaming becomes a  necessary strategy. Knowing who to add and when to start them could be the ultimate difference-maker in a weekly matchup. Making the right streaming decisions could easily be the difference in winning... Read More

NFL Survivor Pool Picks (Week 15) - Targets and Avoids

Week 13 was a pretty chalky one with just three underdogs winning outright. The biggest upset was the Broncos absolutely annihilating the Houston Texans who were still celebrating their "Super Bowl" win against the Patriots the week prior. Three weeks remain and I'd be a fool to think there are hundreds who are reading this... Read More

The Tape Tells All - Robby Anderson Fantasy Outlook

Welcome to another edition of "The Tape Tells All," where I break down some film of an NFL's player performance and try to draw some fantasy football conclusions from that film. This week, I'm looking at New York Jets wide receiver Robby Anderson, who's shaken off a slow start to the 2019 season by going... Read More

Fantasy Football Risers, Fallers - Zach Ertz, Emmanuel Sanders, Robert Woods

Whether due to their own play, the play of others, or injuries, players' stock increases and decreases on a weekly basis. Perhaps more than any other, the NFL is a league that experiences ups and downs at a rapid pace. With only 16 games, there’s little room for error and seemingly endless opportunities for improvement.... Read More

Fantasy Football Disaster Recovery: Sit Your Studs?

Welcome to Disaster Recovery, where each week I'll examine why your studs played like duds. This isn't a place to find out why you should have sat a player for somebody else on your bench. Disaster Recovery is here to examine the guys who you didn't think twice about starting and to help you decide if you should... Read More

Week 15 Warning Signs: Matt Ryan, Carson Wentz, Julio Jones

You made the playoffs. Awesome. Now you have even won your first game. That is even better. But now what? There are many players, some of whom performed in the first round, who may not be so fortunate this week. Whether it is a bad matchup or injuries to key players around them, this could... Read More