NFL Rookie Report Card: Every Team's Best Rookie From The 2025 NFL Draft

February 12, 2026

A rundown of every NFL team's best rookie from the 2025 NFL Draft class. Who were the most impressive NFL rookie breakouts during the 2025 NFL season?

With the 2025 regular season in the books, it's time to take a look at every team's best rookie from the 2025 season.

Which rookies not only lived up to their draft position from last April but also surpassed all expectations when they made their NFL debuts?

Who was every NFL team's most impressive rookie from the 2025 NFL Draft Class? Let's dive in!

Arizona Cardinals

Denzel Burke, DB

The Cardinals drafted two solid defensive backs in 2025, Denzel Burke and Will Johnson. While both were quite productive and appear to be starting options heading into 2016, Burke will get the slight edge on this list. In his debut season, Burke totaled 49 tackles but made an impact, adding three interceptions.

His interceptions placed him ninth among cornerbacks this season.

Atlanta Falcons

Xavier Watts, S

The Falcons hit on most of their defensive selections, drafted linebackers James Pearce Jr. and Jalon Walker in the first round, who showed solid upside in the second half. However, their best pick came in the third round by selecting safety Xavier Watts. Watts finished his season with five interceptions and an elite 72.4 Overall Grade on PFF, placing him 19th among the 98 graded safeties.

He also added 72 solo tackles and 24 assisted tackles.

Baltimore Ravens

Malaki Starks, S

The Ravens bolstered their defense with their 2025 class, and the standout player was Georgia safety Malaki Starks. Starks saw a full-time role in the secondary, logging the ninth-most snaps among safeties according to PFF. He tallied 61 solo tackles and added 17 assists.

Starks forced two interceptions and finished with a 68.9 Overall Grade (per PFF). Expect Starks to remain a mainstay in the Baltimore secondary for the foreseeable future.

Buffalo Bills

Maxwell Hairston, DB

Even though their first-round pick out of Kentucky missed the first six games of the season, he was very impactful down the stretch, which earned him a spot on this list. Hairston would tally three interceptions with five pass deflections over his only 11 games of the season. During this stretch, Hairston would log 18 total tackles and miss only three tackles, placing him seventh at the position according to PFF.

Expect a massive sophomore season if he can stay on the field.

Carolina Panthers

Tetairoa McMillan, WR

Without a doubt, the rookie breakout will represent the Panthers on this list. Despite inconsistent QB play from Bryce Young, McMillan turned in a very impressive debut campaign as the Panthers' WR1. Across 17 games, the Arizona product brought in 70 passes for 1,014 yards and even touchdowns.

He showed big play ability, catching 17 passes for greater than 20 yards and even bringing in three passes of greater than 40 yards.

Tet McMillan's first career TD!

DALvsCAR on FOX/FOX Onehttps://t.co/HkKw7uXVnt pic.twitter.com/NfZMzn8i5f

— NFL (@NFL) October 12, 2025

Chicago Bears

Colston Loveland, TE

Despite a bit of a slow start, Colston Loveland's impact during the second half earned him his spot on this list. Over his first six games, the former National Champion caught only 11 passes for a mere 116 yards.

However, over his last 10, Loveland would emerge as a legit weapon in the offence, bringing in 47 of his 64 targets for 597 yards and six touchdowns. In the postseason, the Michigan standout would catch 12 of his 25 targets for 193 yards, which led all Chicago pass catchers.

Cincinnati Bengals

Demetrius Knight Jr., LB

Cincinnati's second-round pick immediately took on a large role in the defense and will likely represent them on this list. As a rookie, Knight would eclipse the 100-tackle mark. Through 17 games, Knight would total 106 tackles (58 solo)and add three sacks, two interceptions, and seven pass deflections.

He would see his production soar over his last six games, totaling all three sacks and one interception during this stretch.

Cleveland Browns

Carson Schwesinger, LB

While Quinshon Judkins and Harold Fannin Jr. made a strong case, the nod will instead go to linebacker Carson Schwesinger. Schwesinger would finish his debut campaign carrying an elite 74.4 Overall Grade on PFF. Across 16 games, the 22-year-old would be a high-impact player, tallying an eye-catching 166 tackles with 2.5 sacks, two interceptions, and two deflections.

According to PFF, Schwesinger's tackles placed him sixth among all linebackers.

Dallas Cowboys

Tyler Booker, OG

Without a doubt, the team's first-round selection will hold the spot on our ranking. The Cowboys selected Booker out of Alabama with the 12th overall pick, and he immediately made his presence felt on the Dallas offensive line. Booker would show Leite us due as a run blocker, earning the 5th-highest run-blocking grade among offensive guards on PFF.

He would hold an overall grade of 72.0, placing him 16th among all guards.

Denver Broncos

RJ Harvey, RB

RJ Harvey opened the season serving as the No. 2 option to J.K. Dobbins, but flashed high upside once Dobbins went down with an injury. From Weeks 8 through 17, Harvey would show high potential as both a rusher and receiver, scoring 10 total TDs and averaging 39.8 rushing yards with 26.8 receiving yards per game.

Despite seeing a limited workload, he would force 25 missed tackles and finish the season with a 68.3 Overall Grade on PFF.

Detroit Lions

Tate Ratledge, OG

Offensive guard Tate Ratledge was a full-time starter all season and will take the next spot on our list. The second-rounder was very effective, creating rushing lanes for Jahmyr Gibbs and David Montgomery as he earned an elite 73.5 run-blocking grade, placing him 12th among guards on PFF.

While he struggled as a pass blocker, Ratledge would finish with a strong 70.3 Overall Grade, the 24th best at his position.

Green Bay Packers

Anthony Belton, OT

The Packers did not have the most productive 2025 class. However, offensive tackle Anthony Belton made the greatest impact and will hold a spot on our list. The second-rounder out of Kansas State appeared in 14 games and served as a starter for most of this season.

According to PFF, Belton showed upside as a run blocker but struggled in passing situations as he posted a low 44.2 Pass Blocking Grade.

Houston Texans

Woody Marks, RB

While wideout Jayden Higgins began to show flashes in the second half, the team’s overall top rookie was running back Woody Marks. After beginning the season in a bit of a timeshare with veteran Nick Chubb, Marks took over the RB1 job down the stretch.

The fourth round pick out of ESC would finish his debut campaign with 703 rushing yards and 208 through the air. He would find the back of the end zone five times. He would enjoy his best game of the season during their Wild Card victory over the Steelers when he eclipsed the 100-yard mark for the first time in a single game.

Indianapolis Colts

Tyler Warren, TE

Even though his level of play took a bit of a dip down the stretch, Penn State TE Tyler Warren will hold the next spot on our list. Warren immediately took a lead role in this offense as he brought in 33 of his 45 targets for 439 yards and three scores over his first seven games.

Over his last 10, he would tally just 378 yards as his production took a massive dive once Daniel Jones was out for the season. Despite this, Warren finished his season with an above-average 67.6 Overall Grade per PFF (in relation to his position).

Jacksonville Jaguars

Travis Hunter, WR/DB

The Jaguars moved up to the No. 2 spot on draft day to select Heisman winner Travis Hunter out of Colorado. Even though his season was cut short due to a season-ending knee injury, Hunter’s impact in the first half earned him a spot on our list.

Through seven games, Hunter brought in 28 receptions for 298 yards and a score. In his final contest, Hunter began to just scratch the surface of his potential, totaling 101 yards and a score on 14 targets in their loss to the Rams. On defense, Hunter added 15 tackles with three pass deflections.

Kansas City Chiefs

Nohl Williams, DB

While offensive tackle Josh Simmons made a strong case, defensive back Nohl Williams will narrowly take the spot on the list. The Chiefs bolstered their secondary by drafting Williams in the third round of the 2025 draft out of California.

Per PFF, the defensive back was quite impressive in his debut campaign, earning an elite 74.5 Overall Grade, placing him 15th among all defensive backs. He logged 29 solo tackles and added one sack with four pass breakups.

Las Vegas Raiders

Ashton Jeanty, RB

The Boise State standout did not have the most impressive debut season, but was by far the most impactful rookie on the Las Vegas roster. In his rookie season, Jeanty did not have the best offensive environment, which hindered his upside as he ran for only 975 yards.

However, he added another 346 through the air and punched in 10 total TDs. He showed high upside as apure runner, forcing the fifth-most missed tackles among RBs (per PFF), suggesting Jeanty could take a massive step forward in his sophomore season.

Los Angeles Chargers

Omarion Hampton, RB

While Omarion Hampton missed time due to an ankle injury, when on the field, he showed his talent as a long-term solution at the RB position for the Chargers. The UNC product finished his season with 545 yards on the ground and another 192 through the air.

Before his injury, Hampton was averaging 4.8 YPC but saw that mark drop to 4.0 once he returned. His 77.4 Overall Grade on PFF (18th among RBs) suggest like Jeanty, he could be in store for a massive second season.

Los Angeles Rams

Terrance Ferguson, TE

The Los Angeles Rams did not have the most productive rookie class in 2025, but tight end Terrance Ferguson showed high upside down the stretch and will take the next spot on our list. After catching just five passes over his first 11 games, the rookie would bring in six of his 10 targets for 93 yards and two scores over his last three.

Despite his limited role, he showed intriguing big-play ability as seven of his receptions went for 20 or more yards.

Miami Dolphins

Kenneth Grant, DT

First-round rookie Kenneth Grant did not have an overly impressive debut season, but he will hold the next spot on our list. The 22-year-old out of Michigan appeared in all 17 games for the Dolphins and finished his season with 33 tackles and two sacks. He generated 29 total QB pressures, placing him 40th among DTs per PFF, and also added 20 stops, placing him 44th at his position.

Minnesota Vikings

Donovan Jackson, OG

Minnesota's first selection of the 2025 NFL Draft will represent them on this list. Jackson was selected with the 24thpick out of Ohio State. The offensive guard immediately took on a lead role throughout most of the season.

While he struggled as a run-blocker, earning a modest 50.2 Grade on PFF, he excelled as a pass-blocker, earning an elite 65.7 Grade, placing him 25th among all guards during the 2025 campaign.

New England Patriots

Will Campbell, OT

Even though the 22-year-old missed time during the second half, he lived up to his fourth-overall draft capital. Campbell, an LSU product, led the way as the team’s primary left tackle, earning a 72.6 Overall Grade on PFF, placing him 32nd among all tackles.

Much of his production came in the passing game as he played a key role in Drake Maye’s massive sophomore season. Per PFF, Campbell posted a dominant 76.1 Grade in pass block situations, placing him 23rd among the 89 tackles that were scored.

New Orleans Saints

Tyler Shough, QB

Tyler Shough opened the season as the team’s No. 2 option behind Spencer Rattler. However, as soon as the Saints tuned to their second-round pick, the entire offense took a massive step forward.

What a throw, what a catch.

Touchdown Saints 🫡#Saints | 📺 FOX pic.twitter.com/wJKYOToT33

— New Orleans Saints (@Saints) January 4, 2026

Shough would finish his debut season with 2,384 yards and 10 passing scores. With his legs, he punched in another three scores and totaled 186 yards. After throwing five interceptions over his first six games, Shough would post a promising 6:1 TD:INT over his last four contests.

New York Giants

Jaxson Dart, QB

The Giants had several rookies who overperformed their expectations, but the QB, Jaxson Dart, will take the spot on the list. Dart opened the season on the bench, similar to Shough, but completely changed the offense once he took over.

Even playing without his top wideout, Malik Nabers, Dart would throw for 2,272 yards with 15 scores nd only two interceptions. With his legs, Dart would add another 487 yards and nine scores. Dart looks like a potential franchise QB and a cornerstone piece the Giants hope to build around for years to come.

New York Jets

Armand Membou, OT

While some Day 3 selections on the defense made a strong case, especially safety Malachi Moore, the team’s first-round selection will represent them on our list. The Jets took their franchise left tackle, Armand Membou, with the seventh overall pick out of Missouri.

Membou had a full-time role on the offense all season and earned an above-average 72.7 Overall Grade on PFF, placing him 31st among all tackles. He was slightly more productive as a pass-blocker, earning a 73.8 Grade.

Philadelphia Eagles

Jihaad Campbell, LB

The Eagles traded up to select Jihaad Campbell with the 31st overall pick and potentially had the steal of the opening round. Campbell, an Alabama product, finished his debut campaign with 80 tackles, one forced fumble, and one interception.

However, his underlying metrics nuggets suggest he could enjoy an even more productive sophomore season. According to PFF, Campbell earned a stellar 76.2 Overall Grade, placing him 13th at his position. He was an elite tackler, missing just six, placing him ninth among all linebackers.

Pittsburgh Steelers

Jack Sawyer, LB

With Derrick Harmon (the team’s first-round selection) on the shelf for most of the season and third-round rookie RB Kaleb Johnson being a healthy scratch for most of the campaign, linebacker Jack Sawyer will take the spot on the list. The Steelers selected Sawyer in the fourth round of the draft out of Ohio State.

The 23-year-old was not an every-down player but did make an impact when on the field. He finished his season with 34 tackles, one sack, four deflections, and two interceptions, while logging just over 25% of the team’s total snaps.

San Francisco 49ers

Upton Stout, S

The third-round rookie out of Western Kentucky will hold the next spot on our list. Stout had a lead role in the defense for most of the season. He would finish his debut campaign with 82 tackles (43 solo), five pass deflections, and one sack.

His solo tackles placed him ninth at the position, per PFF. He logged the seventh-most Stops at the safety position and 10 Total Pressures, which were the most among safeties, according to PFF.

Seattle Seahawks

Nick Emmanwori, S

While offensive guard Grey Zabel (first-round pick) made a strong case, the nod will instead go to second-rounder Nick Emmanwori. The Seahawks selected Emmanwori with the 35th pick out of South Carolina.

In his debut season, Emmanwori took a prominent role in one of the sport’s top defensive units, earning an impressive 71.6 Overall Grade on PFF (21st best among safeties). Emmanwori logged 81 total tackles with one interception and an eye-catching 11 deflections.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Emeka Egbuka, WR

Despite his disappointing second half, wideout Emeka Egbuka will take the next spot on our list. Emeka Egbuka opened the season as the team’s WR1 as Mike Evans, Chris Godwin Jr. amd Jalen McMillan were all sidelined with numerous injuries.  Over his first nine games, Egbuka would score six TDs and average 75.2 yards per game.

3rd touchdown in 2 games for Emeka Egbuka!

TBvsHOU on ESPN/ABC
Stream on @NFLPlus and ESPN+ pic.twitter.com/XaloB7gM4S

— NFL (@NFL) September 15, 2025

However, over his last eight, Egbuka totaled a mere 32.6 yards per game with no touchdowns. He quickly reverted to the WR3/WR4 role on the offense once the proven options returned. Despite this, Egbuka is the future WR1 in Tampa Bay.

Tennessee Titans

Chimere Dike, WR

While QB Cam Ward took significant strides forward down the stretch, the nod for the Titans will go to WR/special team player Chimere Dike. Dike brought in 48 receptions for 423 yards and four scores. However, his biggest impact came on special teams.

The return man would tally an impressive 1,588 yards on kick returns and another 398 on punt returns. He would score two punt return touchdowns. While he will take time to develop as a WR, he showed immense upside as a retuner.

Washington Commanders

Jacory Croskey-Merritt, RB

The seventh-rounder out of Arizona will close out the ranking. Croskey-Merritt immediately earned a lead role in a wide-open backfield. In Week 1, Croskey-Merritt would total 82 yards and a score on just 10 carries.

While he enjoyed a few strong showings, he typically split work alongside Chris Rodriguez Jr., which limits his overall ceiling. However, he reclaimed the workhorse role in Weeks 15 through 17 and looked quite comfortable, averaging an elite 6.1 YPC with 226 yards and four TDs.

More Fantasy Football Analysis