👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE CHAMP
X
or
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X
or

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


Who To Start for Fantasy Football?

Compare up to four NFL players, and we'll give you fast advice. All free!

We'll help you decide who to start for fantasy football. Drill down and compare rankings, projections, recent news and strength of schedule side-by-side. Other websites require paid memberships to compare more than two players at once, but at RotoBaller it's all free!

Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold or Geno Smith: Who Should I Start for Week 11?

Start Over
Who to Start
Summary
Strength of Schedule
Stats and Projections
News
TB
QB
Bye Week: 10
@ DET · Sun 1:00 PM
 
X
Ranking
Rank 298
P-Rank 19
ADP 151
Projections - Rushing and Passing
PTS 15
PASS ATT/GM 33.1
YDS/CMP 10.8
TOTAL YDS 241
PASS ATT 4
TD 1
RUSH YDS / ATT 4.7
2026 Season - Rushing and Passing
PTS 50.88
PTS / GM 8.5
P-RANK 35
GP 6
PASS ATT 142
ATT/GM 23.7
FUM 6
YDS/CMP 10.7
CMP% 60.6%
INT 4
SACKS 18
YDS / ATT 4.7
TOTAL YDS 1002
TD 4
QBR 74.91
Recent News
Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield (foot) is expected to play Sunday against the Detroit Lions, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport. Mayfield has been dealing with a plantar fascia injury in his foot (per The Ringer's Tom Pelissero) and will wear a special cleat in order to play. During the week, the veteran quarterback began as a non-participant but upgraded to limited participation on Thursday and Friday. Even though he carried a questionable tag into the weekend, he is on track to suit up this afternoon. Before their Week 10 bye, Mayfield put up his best outing of the season, from a yardage perspective, throwing for 243 against the Bears. However, he did not throw a TD pass and added two interceptions. This season, Mayfield is averaging 153.7 passing yards per game and has yet to throw multiple passing touchdowns in a contest. Even though he faces an inconsistent Lions secondary, Mayfield has mid-end QB2 value given his modest production this season.
17@CIN
7CLE
1MIN
5GB
30@DAL
9PIT
10@CAR
24ATL
22@CHI
BYE
32@DET
10CAR
11LAC
15@BAL
11NO
24@ATL
7LAR
11@NO
NYJ
QB
Bye Week: 13
@ LAC · Sun 4:05 PM
 
X
 
Ranking
Rank 299
P-Rank 20
ADP 277
 
Projections - Rushing and Passing
PTS 14.8
PASS ATT/GM 32.5
YDS/CMP 11.0
TOTAL YDS 250
PASS ATT 2
TD 1
RUSH YDS / ATT 3.6
2026 Season - Rushing and Passing
PTS 136.44
PTS / GM 13.6
P-RANK 16
GP 10
PASS ATT 292
ATT/GM 29.2
FUM 4
YDS/CMP 11.4
CMP% 67.1%
INT 3
SACKS 29
YDS / ATT 2.2
TOTAL YDS 2280
TD 12
QBR 99.2
 
Recent News
New York Jets quarterback Geno Smith (ankle) practiced in full Friday after being limited Thursday and listed as limited on Wednesday's estimated report. He carries no injury designation and will start Sunday against the Los Angeles Chargers. Smith completed 13 of 21 passes for 148 yards before leaving last week's loss to Buffalo. He threw for 165 yards at Kansas City the week before, and the Jets went without a touchdown in both games. RotoBaller ranks him QB20 for Week 11, putting him in play as a second quarterback in Superflex. Los Angeles gave up 340 passing yards to Jacoby Brissett on Monday, though he needed 49 attempts and threw no touchdowns. According to the Jets, Smith has completed 48% of his passes that traveled at least 20 yards in the air, the sixth-best rate in the NFL. His last multi-touchdown game came in Week 8, when he threw for 290 yards against Las Vegas. Those downfield completions can lift his yardage even if New York keeps converting red-zone trips into touchdowns at its league-low rate of 37.9%.
 
30@TEN
5GB
32@DET
22@CHI
7CLE
21@NE
13MIA
28LV
3@KC
13BUF
11@LAC
13@MIA
BYE
17DEN
29@ARI
21NE
1MIN
13@BUF
SEA
QB
Bye Week: 11
BYE
Injury Status: Quadriceps
X
QUESTIONABLE Quadriceps
Ranking
Rank
P-Rank
ADP -
QUESTIONABLE Quadriceps
QUESTIONABLE Quadriceps
QUESTIONABLE Quadriceps
 
 
 
RotoBaller’s fantasy football summary
RotoBaller’s fantasy football
RotoBaller’s fantasy football
RotoBaller’s fantasy football
Add Another Player From The Top Rankings
Overall
QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DST
Rookies
Our pick: start Baker Mayfield (QB19) over Geno Smith (QB20) and Sam Darnold, based on RotoBaller's Week 11 PPR rankings.







Who Should I Start? Fantasy Football Start/Sit Tool

Who should I start for fantasy football? This is a common question we all ask ourselves each week during the fantasy football season when setting lineups. RotoBaller provides this great free start/sit tool for comparing players, which can help you make your tough lineup decisions every week. Whether you're comparing quarterbacks, running backs, tight ends vs. wide receivers, or any other combination - we give you our player projection for that week based on a variety of factors including the team's opponent. This start/sit tool is updated regularly, starting on Wednesday each week, based on injury reports and staff ranks.



Recent Improvements For Who Should I Start?

You may have noticed, our Who Should I Start? tool has gotten an overhaul this year. We've added lots of great features for you to give you as much information as possible to win your fantasy football matchups each week. You'll see NFL player tiles with team logos and bye weeks, enhanced search results with data to compare, and a slick interface. We hope you enjoy!



How To Use Who Should I Start?

Tough lineup decisions to make? Can't decide between a few players? Not sure who to start? Compare up to four NFL players and see which player is recommended for your fantasy football lineups based on projections and rankings. Whether you're comparing quarterbacks, running backs, tight ends vs. wide receivers, or any other combination of fantasy football players - our Who Should I Start? tool gives you advice on who to start or sit.



Selecting Players In Who Should I Start?

You can select NFL players to compare by using the search boxes, or selecting player names from the top rankings lists. You can also click on popular searches that other readers make in the start/sit tool.



Fantasy Football Lineups Advice and Start/Sit Recommendations

Once you compare NFL players, the start/sit tool provides you with our fantasy football recommendation on who you should start or sit. When comparing the players, we show you our rankings, projections, recent news and strength of schedule side-by-side for you to compare each player.



How Many Players Can I Compare?

You can select up to four NFL players at once, and compare them to see who you should start for fantasy football. It's 100% free! Other websites require paid memberships to compare more than two players at once, but at RotoBaller it's all free. Win big with RotoBaller.



Who To Start for Quarterbacks

When deciding between two quarterbacks with similar outlooks, analyzing the potential game script is key. Quarterbacks who are likely to face negative game scripts will traditionally attempt more passes in an effort to come from behind. On the flip side, a quarterback on a team that is a heavy favorite could be relegated to handing the ball off and killing the clock in the second half of games.

Quarterbacks with limited rushing upside on teams with elite defenses are likely to be low-volume passers, and the lack of rushing production makes it difficult to put together consistent fantasy-friendly outings. A quarterback on a team with a bad defense, facing a team with a good offense, will have to pass all game to keep up.

Other factors to consider:
  • Weather
  • Health of pass-catchers
  • Health of offensive line
  • Projected game total


Who To Start for Running Backs

To decide between two running backs with similar outlooks and rankings, the format of your league is key. Some running backs are primarily early-down grinders, while others are great pass-catchers but do not get many short-yardage or goal-line opportunities.

Third-down backs benefit from negative game scripts, and early-down grinders benefit from positive game scripts. Pure runners are better in standard leagues, and pass-catching running backs can be cheat codes in PPR setups.

Not all touches are created equal, and a committee running back on a great offense with a plus matchup often outscores a high-touch workhorse on a bad offense that is unlikely to move the chains often and score touchdowns.

Other factors to consider:
  • Recent usage
  • Health of offensive line
  • Matchup (pass-funnel vs run-funnel defense)


Who To Start for Wide Receivers

Like quarterbacks, wide receivers reach ceiling outcomes when passing volume is high, meaning you want to choose a wide receiver who is expected to be in a high-scoring game or face a negative game script.

Some wide receivers are valuable in PPR leagues if they catch short passes in high volume, even on a struggling offense. This type of wide receiver production is not as valuable in standard and half-PPR formats, as yards and touchdowns carry a higher premium in those leagues.

Other factors to consider:
  • Cornerback matchup
  • Health of offensive line
  • Health/caliber of quarterback


Who To Start for Tight Ends

The tight end position is always the thinnest in fantasy football, meaning they present the trickiest start-or-sit decisions. If you do not have a must-start stud, identifying a tight end in an above-average offense with a red zone role is key.

If you don’t have the ability to start a highly-targeted tight end, identifying a player who has a strong chance to score a touchdown is the next best option.

Other factors to consider:
  • Caliber of opposing safeties/linebackers
  • Quarterback health
  • Missing wide receiver teammates
  • Defense red zone stats


Who To Start for FLEX

As mentioned with QB, RB, WR, and TE, finding a Flex option on a strong offense is the first step. In general, when comparing RBs and WRs with similar rankings and projections, choose an RB in standard and half-PPR formats, and choose a WR in PPR formats.



Who To Start for Defense (D/ST)

To identify high-upside defenses, determine which streamer-level units have plus matchups each week. Target defenses that are facing offenses with high turnover rates, high sack rates, low scoring numbers, and injuries (especially at quarterback)

Avoid bottom-dweller defenses even in plus matchups, as offense often trumps defense when both units are bottom-tier.



Who To Start for Kickers

Kickers attached to strong offenses present the most fantasy upside, and kickers with consistent accuracy and 50-yard-plus range are the safest fantasy football options. Consider targeting kickers set to play indoors, or at least avoid kickers slated to play in poor weather conditions, such as high wind, rain, or snow.

It’s also worth noting that many kickers are denied opportunities if the weather is a factor or if a head coach is more aggressive than most on fourth downs.



Making Tough Start/Sit Decisions Between Players - Tiebreakers

  • Matchup strength: look up fantasy points allowed by position
  • Recent target/touch trend: determine positive or negative opportunity trend
  • Red zone/goal-line role: analyze the number of high-value touches
  • Injury risk: pre-game game designation and recent practice reports
  • Quarterback health and quality: target strong quarterback play
  • Snap share and route participation: determine positive or negative opportunity trend
  • Weather: analyze game conditions
  • Indoors vs outdoors: favor the player indoors as a tie-breaker
  • Game script: predict whether a player will likely be trailing or leading
  • Floor vs. Ceiling: lean toward boom-or-bust player if you’re a heavy underdog, consider floor player as favorite