Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!


Receive free daily analysis


Already have an account? Log In


Forgot Password


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

ADP Cost Analysis - Jose Abreu vs Matt Olson

The exciting young gun versus the proven veteran. A sports debate older than fantasy baseball itself, and a decision we’re faced with at every draft pick. That’s why we’re comparing the young gun (Matt Olson) to the proven veteran (Jose Abreu), two first baseman within the same sub-elite yet startable tier that owners must decide between on draft day.

Abreu is going slightly higher in NFBC leagues at around pick 83, while Olson is going at pick 109. Is it worth forking up the extra 26 spots for Abreu, or can owners wait and get similar production from Olson?

RotoBaller is going to break down all the pressing ADP questions you need to know before draft day. Check out our take on the catcher position debate between Buster Posey and Danny Jansen right here.

Featured Promo: Get your MLB Premium Pass for 50% off the regular price with any full-season pass. Exclusive access to our Draft Kit, Nick Mariano's #1 accuracy rankings, Ariel Cohen's #1 accuracy ATC projections, customized advice in the Team Sync platform, Live Draft Assistant, 15 in-season lineup tools, customized rankings and much more! Go Premium, Win More!


Jose Abreu – The Proven Veteran

(ADP 83 Overall, 8 First Base)

Jose Abreu has been an offensive force since coming to the majors from Cuba, but 2018 was the closest thing he’s ever had to a down year. His .265 AVG, .798 OPS, and 114 wRC+ were all career lows, and Abreu struggled with injuries all year, even hitting the disabled list for the first time since 2014 due to emergency surgery in late August. The good news is that big power potential still lurks in Abreu’s bat. Despite his underwhelming surface stats, Abreu still pulverized the ball, posting a 91.3 MPH average exit velocity and 45.2% hard-hit rate in 2018. His expected stats suggest Abreu underperformed last season. He had a .284 xBA vs. a .265 BA, a .497 xSLG vs. a .473 SLG, and a .360 xwOBA vs. a .330 wOBA. Abreu’s .294 BABIP from last season falls within the normal range for the average batter, but Abreu had never had a BABIP below .327 before 2018.

Based on past seasons, we know that Abreu is a true talent .290 hitter and his disappointing 2018 was a combination of bad luck and health issues. Abreu isn’t showing signs of aging yet and is a safe bet as a bounce-back candidate. He is a fair value at his current ADP of 83 and has a good chance to return surplus value at his draft price.


Matt Olson – The Exciting Young Gun

(ADP 109 Overall, 11 First Base)

Olson made a huge impact as a rookie in 2017, putting up video game-like numbers for Oakland, where he hit .259 with 24 home runs and a .392 ISO in 216 PA. Everything was shaping up for Olson to be one of the league’s new premier power hitters, but his production slowed down in 2018. Olson was still solid last season, but his .207 ISO and 29 homers in 660 PA were a huge step back compared to his rookie campaign. Of course, what he did in 2017 was patently unsustainable. The foundation for his .392 ISO was a 41.4% HR/FB ratio, a ridiculously high rate for any ballpark, but especially in pitcher-friendly Oakland Coliseum.  He also hit just two doubles compared to 24 homers, a ratio that was sure to even out over time. But even when we take that correction into consideration, Olson still performed below expectations in 2018.

His power fall-off was an over-correction, as he still crushed the ball last season, posting an unreal 93.1 MPH average exit velocity and a 51.8% hard-hit rate. That ranked top-six in the league in both categories. With that kind of strength, Olson should have no problem producing, but was held back by a poor contact rate and exorbitant infield flyball rate. Olson had just a 74.2% contact rate last season along with a 15% infield flyball rate. Just one of those issues can be overcome, but combined they are batting average poison and will bring down his entire performance. Furthermore, Olson hit 33 doubles compared to 29 homers in 2018, another large over-correction from 2017. Thanks to his home ballpark, Olson will probably hit more doubles than the typical hitter of this profile, but not to such a degree. There is still 40-homer power potential with Olson, but he comes with several concerns, and will probably struggle to hit above .250. He is a decent value at 109 but is a better corner infielder than many first basemen in mixed leagues.



In a straight-up comparison, Abreu is the preferred player without question. Not only does he have more years of proven production under his belt, but should be a more all-around hitter (sans stolen bases) compared to Olson’s power-only profile. At cost, Abreu is still the preferred choice despite going nearly 30 picks higher than Olson in NFBC leagues. If healthy there’s no reason to think Abreu can’t bounce back to previous high-level production, while Olson has several warts on his profile Abreu can be trusted as a starting first baseman, if a low-end one, while Olson is more of a corner infielder in standard mixed leagues. Olson is still a solid pick at 109, but not an especially great value considering one could draft Abreu slightly higher or take Max Muncy at pick 108 and get similar if not better production.


Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts


Jakob Poeltl6 mins ago

Participates In Shootaround
Zion Williamson11 mins ago

Questionable With Foot Contusion
CJ McCollum20 mins ago

Questionable Against Pacers
Brandon Ingram28 mins ago

Questionable With Ankle Sprain
Beau Hossler33 mins ago

Looking To Keep The Good Times Rolling In Florida
Dereck Lively37 mins ago

II Probable Wednesday
Walker Buehler40 mins ago

Encouraged By His Progress
Luka Doncic41 mins ago

Probable Against Raptors
New England Patriots58 mins ago

Patriots Making The Rounds With QBs At Combine
Denny McCarthy60 mins ago

Looking To Heat Up At PGA National
Taylor Montgomery1 hour ago

Putting Together Solid Results
Jaylen Waddle1 hour ago

Dolphins Not Considering Trading Jaylen Waddle
Michael Pittman Jr.1 hour ago

Colts Not Planning On Letting Michael Pittman Jr. Go
Christiaan Bezuidenhout1 hour ago

Arrives To Florida In Stellar Form
DeVonta Smith1 hour ago

Not Worried About Extension
Luke List1 hour ago

On A Mission To Reverse Past Heartbreak
Tua Tagovailoa1 hour ago

Dolphins Hope To Extend Tua Tagovailoa This Offseason
Matthieu Pavon2 hours ago

Looking To Widen His Season-Long Lead
Zach Wilson2 hours ago

Jets Give Zach Wilson Permission To Seek A Trade
Travis Etienne Jr.2 hours ago

Touches To Be Scaled Back?
Shane Lowry2 hours ago

Leaning On Some Positive Florida Vibes
Ryo Hisatsune2 hours ago

Heads To Palm Beach Gardens For Debut
Brendon Todd2 hours ago

Takes Hot Putter To PGA National
Ben Griffin2 hours ago

Loves The Bermuda Grass
Chris Kirk2 hours ago

Looks To Defend Title At Cognizant Classic
PGA2 hours ago

Alex Noren A Player To Watch At PGA National
Stephan Jaeger2 hours ago

Closing In On First Tour Victory
Thorbjorn Olesen2 hours ago

A Contender At PGA National
Ryan Fox2 hours ago

In For A Tough Week At PGA National
Mason Miller3 hours ago

A's To Ease Mason Miller Into Closer's Role?
Thomas Detry3 hours ago

Trying To Shake Off Rough Event In Mexico
Nick Lodolo3 hours ago

Graham Ashcraft, Nick Lodolo Nearing Spring Debuts
Akshay Bhatia3 hours ago

Up And Down In 2024
Trevor Stephan3 hours ago

Shut Down For Three Weeks
Billy Horschel3 hours ago

Might Fare Better After Rest
Justin Rose3 hours ago

Putter Carrying Aging Justin Rose
Julio Rodríguez3 hours ago

Julio Rodriguez Likely To Play Again On Saturday
Sepp Straka3 hours ago

Struggling Since Sentry
PGA3 hours ago

Chris Gotterup Is Struggling So Far In His Rookie Season
Carlos Estévez3 hours ago

Angels Confirm That Carlos Estevez Is The Closer
Robert Stephenson3 hours ago

Dealing With Shoulder Soreness
Justin Verlander4 hours ago

Not Ready To Face Hitters Yet
John Konchar4 hours ago

Doubtful For Wednesday
Luke Kennard4 hours ago

Won't Play On Wednesday
Julio Rodríguez4 hours ago

Julio Rodriguez Feeling Much Better
Cam Reddish4 hours ago

Set To Return On Wednesday
Anthony Davis4 hours ago

On Track To Play Wednesday
Lonzo Ball4 hours ago

Still Not Sprinting
Detroit Pistons4 hours ago

Mike Muscala Getting Bought Out By Pistons
Deandre Ayton4 hours ago

X-Rays Clear On Deandre Ayton's Hand Following Tuesday's Exit
Marquez Valdes-Scantling5 hours ago

Chiefs Release Marquez Valdes-Scantling
Drake Maye15 hours ago

Not Throwing At Scouting Combine
Kansas City Chiefs15 hours ago

Chiefs Want To Sign Chris Jones To Long-Term Extension
Daniel Jones15 hours ago

Has Been Throwing
Blake Snell15 hours ago

Giants, Blake Snell Deal A "50-50" Possibility
Geno Smith15 hours ago

In The Team's Plans For Now
Brandon Aiyuk16 hours ago

49ers Seeking Extension With Brandon Aiyuk
Tee Higgins16 hours ago

Bengals Not Planning On Trading Tee Higgins
Derrick Henry16 hours ago

Unlikely To Return To Titans
Josh Jacobs16 hours ago

Raiders Will Explore Re-Signing Josh Jacobs
Jordan Montgomery17 hours ago

Red Sox Have Virtual Meeting With Jordan Montgomery
Matt Chapman17 hours ago

Giants Still A Potential Landing Spot For Matt Chapman
Cedric Mullins17 hours ago

Reportedly Back To 100%
Kyle Anderson18 hours ago

Exits Early On Tuesday
De'Aaron Fox18 hours ago

Listed As Questionable For Wednesday
LeBron James18 hours ago

Returns To Injury Report
De'Anthony Melton18 hours ago

Won't Return On Tuesday
Scoot Henderson18 hours ago

Expected To Miss Road Trip
CJ McCollum21 hours ago

Out Again On Tuesday Night
Zion Williamson21 hours ago

Good To Go On Tuesday
Isaiah Hartenstein21 hours ago

Will Not Suit Up On Tuesday
Kansas City Chiefs23 hours ago

Chiefs Plan To Franchise-Tag L'Jarius Sneed
Deshaun Watson23 hours ago

To Begin Throwing In March
Masyn Winn1 day ago

Still The Team's Starter At Shortstop
Jameson Williams1 day ago

To Push To Be Full-Time Starter
Rashod Bateman1 day ago

To Get The Ball "A Lot More"
Kyle Pitts1 day ago

Falcons Have A Lot Of Faith In Kyle Pitts
Travis Konecny1 day ago

Jamie Drysdale Without Timetables To Return
Matthew Tkachuk1 day ago

To Return Tuesday
Jack Eichel1 day ago

Returns To Practice Tuesday
Timothy Liljegren1 day ago

Out On Tuesday
Riley Greene1 day ago

Playing Outfield On Tuesday
Starling Marte1 day ago

To Make Grapefruit League Debut Wednesday
Evan Carter1 day ago

Back In Action Tuesday
Byron Buxton1 day ago

Playing Center Field Tuesday
Jesús Luzardo1 day ago

Jesus Luzardo To Start On Opening Day
Jackson Holliday1 day ago

Hitting Leadoff On Tuesday
Craig Kimbrel1 day ago

Expects To Make Spring Debut Thursday
Matthew Tkachuk1 day ago

Expected To Return On Tuesday
Clayton Keller1 day ago

Out On Tuesday
Connor McDavid1 day ago

Hits Special Milestone With Monday's Outing
Shane Pinto1 day ago

Notches Three Points In Losing Effort
David Pastrnak1 day ago

Tallies Three Points Versus Seattle
Jamie Drysdale1 day ago

Labeled As Week-To-Week
Bryan Rust1 day ago

Stays Behind As Penguins Start Road Trip
Scott Mayfield2 days ago

Listed As Day-To-Day
Brandon Royval2 days ago

Gets Back On Track With Decision Win
Justin Faulk2 days ago

Activated From Long-Term Injured Reserve
Brandon Moreno2 days ago

Loses Back-To-Back Fights
Nick Jensen2 days ago

Anthony Mantha, Nick Jensen Game-Time Decisions For Capitals Monday
Francisco Prado2 days ago

Drops A Decision At UFC Mexico City
T.J. Oshie2 days ago

Listed As Week-To-Week
Tyler Seguin2 days ago

Listed As Week-To-Week
Daniel Zellhuber2 days ago

Extends Win Streak To Three
Anthony Duclair2 days ago

Sharks Not Discussing Contract Extension
Sam Hughes2 days ago

Takes Decision Loss
Sam Hughes2 days ago

Yazmin Jauregui Defeats Sam Hughes
Logan Couture2 days ago

Not Close To Returning
Kyle Busch2 days ago

Frustrated Despite Finishing Third At Atlanta
Ryan Blaney2 days ago

After Runner-Up at Atlanta: "That Was So Fun"
Daniel Suarez2 days ago

Wins At Atlanta In Photo Finish
Calle Jarnkrok2 days ago

Aiming For Practice Return Next Week
Matt Murray2 days ago

Taking Shots In Injury Recovery
Timothy Liljegren2 days ago

Listed As Day-To-Day
Kaz Grala2 days ago

Rises To 14th By End Of Atlanta Race
Austin Cindric2 days ago

Enjoys Top 5 Result At Atlanta
Ross Chastain3 days ago

Outshone by Teammate, But Still Made Solid Recovery
Harrison Burton3 days ago

Electrifying Ford Speed Carries Harrison Burton to One of His Best Runs
Michael McDowell3 days ago

Finishes Eighth After Strong Atlanta Performance
Ty Gibbs3 days ago

Quietly Recovers From Crash For An Atlanta Top 10 Finish
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Starts 2024 Off With Back-To-Back Top Five Finishes
Todd Gilliland3 days ago

Despite Poor Finish, Todd Gilliland Has Big Day At Atlanta
Chris Duncan3 days ago

Gets Submitted Quickly At UFC Mexico City
Manuel Torres3 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Yair Rodriguez3 days ago

Gets Finished At UFC Mexico City
Brian Ortega3 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC Mexico City
Joey Logano3 days ago

Will Have to Serve Penalty at Start of Atlanta Race
Joey Logano3 days ago

the Favorite to Win at Atlanta
Ryan Blaney3 days ago

Can Win At Atlanta This Weekend
Chase Elliott3 days ago

a Core DFS Play at Atlanta
William Byron3 days ago

Looking To Win Again
Ross Chastain3 days ago

Has Aggressiveness Needed To Win At Atlanta
Ricky Stenhouse Jr3 days ago

. Looking To Build On Good Atlanta Runs
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Has Upside at Atlanta Despite Poor Record
Ryan Preece4 days ago

Is A Difficult DFS Recommendation For Atlanta
Brad Keselowski4 days ago

Is A DFS Favorite To Recommend At Atlanta
Brandon Royval5 days ago

Set For A Rematch
Brandon Moreno5 days ago

Looks To Get Back In Win Column
Francisco Prado5 days ago

Has A Tough Test In Front Of Him
MMA5 days ago

Daniel Zellhuber Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Yazmin Jauregui5 days ago

Hopes To Get Back In Win Column
Manuel Torres6 days ago

Looking To Remain Undefeated In The UFC
Chris Duncan6 days ago

Goes Into Enemy Territory At UFC Mexico City
Ricky Turcios6 days ago

A Big Underdog At UFC Mexico City
Raul Rosas Jr.6 days ago

Set For Fourth UFC Appearance
Brian Ortega6 days ago

Ends Layoff At UFC Mexico City
Yair Rodriguez6 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Mexico City