X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Champ or Chump: What to Make of Kyle Gibson, Joc Pederson, and Corey Kluber

You know, I'm actually kind of upset that Omar Infante is not going to the All-Star Game. Don't get me wrong - there is no way he's actually worthy of an All-Star selection. If he made it, though, Yost would have needed to perform a roster miracle to get 14 other teams represented, compromising quality and allowing the NL to run away with the game.

If you're a NL fan like me, that would be a good thing. The absurdity of the situation also would have forced Commissioner Manfred to change something - either remove fan voting or turn the game back into an exhibition. That could also be a good thing.

On topic, this week we look at yet another Twins pitcher that is allergic to strikeouts, a Dodgers rookie that is not performing at all as he was supposed to, and the riddle wrapped in an enigma veiled by a mystery that is the Cleveland starting rotation's ace. Lets begin.

 

Kyle Gibson (SP, MIN)

Do the Twins collect guys like this? His 7-6 record with a 3.04 ERA is appealing in most fantasy formats, but his 4.14 FIP rooted in a pathetic 6.08 K/9 ruins his fantasy appeal. The fact that the Ks are a significant improvement over last year's 5.37 K/9 is almost incomprehensible. He also walks entirely too many - 2.87 per 9 innings. His strand rate seems way too high (80.4%), his BABIP too low (.270), and he's too homer prone (13.8% HR/FB) to sustain his current success.

Then you look at Pitch f/x data, which points to a slider that generates whiffs 20.1% of the time and a change with a 17.3% SwStr%. The slider is chased out of the zone 42.8% of the time, while the change is chased at a 52.9% clip. Both are actually decent strikeout pitches, and how Gibson could have both and not have even a league average K rate is puzzling. There is definitely room for improvement here - Gibson could break the Twin tradition and get punchouts.

The Twins seem to prefer guys that get grounders over Ks, and fantasy owners like the low slugging percentages associated with grounders too. Overall, Gibson has a 54% grounder rate fueled by a 2-seamer (64.2%) and changeup (65.6%) that post elite rates. Between grounders and the potential for Ks, Gibson actually has plus stuff if you don't count his fastball.

Gibson's heat is bad. No, its beyond bad - it is a joke. Major league hitters have a 35.4% LD rate against this pitch, and balls hit into the air against it have a HR/FB of 20%. Its whiff rate is a paltry 2.7%. Hitters kill this pitch, which is why I did not argue for regression to the power mean above. Still, it is possible to succeed in the majors without a fastball (think Collin McHugh) and Gibson has the potential as a first round draft pick to amount to something. That something is still likely to walk too many (no pitch is a strike more than 45.5% of the time) and have a hard time finding wins, but a breakout second half is a distinct possibility.

Verdict: Champ

 

Joc Pederson (OF, LAD)

Fantasy owners were always going to salivate over this guy - a 30/30, .300 average season at Triple-A the prior year will do that. His .230/.368/.496 triple slash line with 20 bombs before the All-Star break represents a third of what fantasy owners wanted - the power pace is better than anything he did in the minors. But where is the speed? And what happened to .300? Is the power sustainable?

First, the wheels - Pederson went 61-for-82 on the bases in two seasons in the high minors, a solid success rate. He started his major league career two-for-nine, however, prompting new Dodgers GM Andrew Friedman to give him a red light - sabermetrics do not support running with that kind of success rate. The manager, Don Mattingly, is more old school, however, and I think he will let the kid run again now that he has seen major league moves. Judging from minor league history, he should have a better success rate. Friedman is not completely adverse to running - look at the Tampa teams he put together - and will allow him to go in the second half.

The batting average conjecture is not quite as rosy. He strikes out too much with a 14.4% SwStr%, but he walks as well (above average 26.8% O-Swing%) so it is not a complete disaster. More concerning are his BABIP tendencies. Over his minor league career (minimum 300 PAs), Pederson has posted the following BABIPs: .403, .350, .327, and .385. In the majors this year, its .276. That might seem due for correction, but his opposite field percentage is just 17.4%. That makes him shift bait, doomed to have a lower than expected BABIP until he changes his approach. In the minors, there is not as much data on tendencies - pulling the ball hard consistently means plus BABIPs. In April, Pederson had a major league BABIP of .406, continuing his minor league success before the scouting report was well known. The weakness has been exposed, and as a result his average likely caps out at .260 with .240 being more realistic. A more optimistic projection could use his low 17% liner rate - a stat known for random fluctuation - to correct going forward. However, his liners have a BABIP of just .614 and his speed could justify his high minor league BABIPs without significant liner contributions. He might not be a line drive guy.

Finally, his 27% HR/FB in Dodger Stadium is almost surely a mirage - he has power, but not more than Giancarlo Stanton. Still, luck does not even out such that he'll have a below average rate going forward to get to a normal rate for the year. Rather, he will have a normal rate going forward and a plus rate overall when the first half is included. He probably has 10 more bombs in him, and he should swipe 20 bags before the year is done. That is 30/20 - who cares about average?

Verdict: Champ

 

Corey Kluber (SP, CLE)

Kluber has gone 4-9 with a 3.45 ERA this season, and fantasy owners expected more out of the second pitcher off the board in many preseason drafts. His 18-9, 2.44 ERA last season was certainly impressive, but it also came from nowhere. Last season's strand rate of 78.6% was high, this year's 70.9% is normal. Last year's 7.4% HR/FB was low, this year's 9% figure is closer to normal. His best K rate in the High Minors was 9.98/9 in 122.3 AA innings. At Triple A, it was closer to a flat 9. Last year broke double digits in the majors (10.27). Where did that come from? Last year's 235.3 IP were a career-high by a substantial margin (previous best: 188.1 in 2012). If you believe Tom Verducci, that was a red flag heading into the year. Honestly, I was surprised that everyone bought into the breakout campaign so completely, with no hedge based on the fact that he had only done it once.

Yet he still has the Ks, as his K/9 is actually up to 10.63 this season. He also continues to walk no one, allowing just 1.87 BB/9 so far this year. These factors combine to give him a still elite 2.42 FIP, inspiring many to continue to be confident in the under performing ace. The strikeouts look legit - his 13.9% SwStr% is nearly two full points better than last year's already excellent 12% mark. According to Pitch f/x, he also has elite strikeout stuff, including a slider (49% O-Swing%, 22.4% SwStr%), curve (50.3%, 18.8%), and change (37.9%, 24.4%). Most pitchers would love to have that kind of arsenal.

With so many weapons, you would think that pitch selection would not really matter - but I think it does. His 2014 breakout campaign was rooted in a clear change in pitch selection that saw his fastball plummet in usage from 24.1% to just 3.4% and a sinker pick up the slack from 29.1% to 48.8%. This year, the fastball is up to 12% while the sinker is down to 36.7% - partially undoing what worked so well last season. He is also experimenting with a 2-seamer, cutter, and splitter that he really has no need for. The sinker does not generate Ks at all (3.5% SwStr%), instead getting hit on the ground at an above average rate. Striking out more batters is the direct result of throwing it less often, but that does not mean that he is a better pitcher without it - sometimes you need an AB to end in a pitch or two. The fact that he thinks he needs to strikeout everybody may be a condemnation of Cleveland's defense.

Cleveland's defense is bad, and Kluber's BABIP suffers for it. Already a pretty high .316 in his breakout campaign, it has jumped to .338 this season. Nearly all of Kluber's offerings are affected despite continuing to generate strong K numbers, so this is not like Gibson's worthless fastball. Yet it also will not correct, as the Indians employ bad fielders and this is not likely to change. Kluber's FIP will remain elite, but his fantasy stats do not have the luxury of being fielding independent.

Finally, I think Kluber may walk more going forward as only two of his pitches are consistently strikes - the fastball (52.7%) and sinker (53.6%). He really relies on opposing hitters going out of the zone, and they may be able to adjust to that as word spreads he wants to strikeout everyone. Kluber's Ks make him fantasy relevant for the foreseeable future, but his ERA will be dragged down by his team and wins will be hard to come by as well. Most of his owners would probably take King Felix or Max Scherzer where they took Kluber now, and there is no way to get preseason value for him in a trade. While far from bad, Kluber has burned his owners and for that reason I must call him . . .

Verdict: Chump

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Green Bay Packers

Nate Hobbs Will Miss the Rest of the Preseason
Matthew Stafford

has Not Practiced, but Rams Not Concerned
Joe Burrow

Will Play Several Series on Thursday
Jaylen Warren

Listed as Steelers Starting Running Back
DeMario Douglas

Has Been Patriots Second-Best Receiver in Training Camp
Cade Otton

Missing Practice on Tuesday
Teddy Bridgewater

Visiting Buccaneers, Expected to Sign
Tyler Goodson

Opens Preseason As The RB2 in Indianapolis
NHL

Jimmy Vesey Moves Abroad
ANA

Sam Colangelo Signs Two-Year Extension
NYI

Matthew Schaefer Signs Entry-Level Contract With Islanders
NBA

Brandon Boston Jr. Inks Deal with Fenerbahce
NBA

Jeff Dowtin Jr. Joins Six-Time EuroLeague Champions
NBA

Lonnie Walker IV Agrees to Three-Year Contract with Maccabi Tel Aviv
Neemias Queta

Working Back From Knee Surgery
Johnny Juzang

Links Up with Timberwolves
Ricky Council IV

Joins Nets on One-Year Contract
Aaron Judge

To Return To Yankees On Tuesday
Michael King

Could Make Next Start With Padres
Michael Soroka

To Go On Injured List
Atlanta Falcons

Kaleb McGary Agrees to Extension With Falcons
Jordan James

Back at Practice
Jake Moody

Wins 49ers Kicking Job
Antonio Gibson

Returns to Practice
Christian Watson

Moving Well During Rehab
Kayshon Boutte

Consistently Impressing At Training Camp
Nick Lodolo

Exits Early With Blister
DeVonta Smith

Stock on the Rise
Joshua Palmer

Back at Practice Monday
Roman Anthony

Dealing With Back Tightness
Nikola Vučević

Nikola Vucevic Not a "Buyout Candidate"
Spencer Rattler

Leading Saints Quarterback Derby
Giannis Antetokounmpo

Still Undecided About Future in Milwaukee
New York Jets

Jets No. 2 Receiver Role "Up for Grabs"
Mason Taylor

Misses Practice With Ankle Injury
Tyler Huntley

Signing With Browns
Max Muncy

Activated and Starting on Monday
Ladd McConkey

Still Not Practicing
Grayson Rodriguez

to Undergo Season-Ending Surgery
Isaac Paredes

Won't Have Surgery, Hoping to Return This Year
Daniss Jenkins

Agrees to Two-Way Deal Wth Detroit
Jaylen Martin

Waived by Wizards
De'Aaron Fox

Inks Extension With Spurs on Monday
Tatsuro Taira

Gets Submission Win
HyunSung Park

Undefeated No More
Mateusz Rębecki

Mateusz Rebecki Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 108
Chris Duncan

Wins Three In A Row
Elves Brener

Loses Three In A Row
Esteban Ribovics

Returns To The Win Column
Nora Cornolle

Gets Dominated At UFC Vegas 108
Karol Rosa

Outclasses Nora Cornolle
J.J. Spaun

Finishes Tied for 23rd at Open Championship
Justin Thomas

Finishes Tied for 34th at Open Championship
Xander Schauffele

Finishes Tied For Seventh at Open Championship
Hideki Matsuyama

Finishes Tied for 19th at Wyndham Championship
Si Woo Kim

Misses The Cut at Wyndham Championship
Tommy Fleetwood

Finishes Tied for 16th at Open Championship
Wyndham Clark

Finishes Tied for 12th at 3M Open
Sam Burns

Finishes Tied for 61st at 3M Open
Elizeu Zaleski dos Santos

Suffers TKO Loss
Austin Riley

Braves Place Austin Riley Back on Injured List
Neil Magny

Gets Back In The Win Column
Danny Silva

Suffers His First UFC Loss
Kevin Vallejos

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
NASCAR

Bubba Wallace Charges Back to Sixth at Iowa
Chase Briscoe

Finished Second Despite Being Trapped a Lap Down and Causing Two Wrecks
Brad Keselowski

Arguably Had the Best Drive at Iowa but Finished Third
Austin Dillon

Earns a Quiet Top Ten at Iowa
Kyle Larson

Poor Pit Strategy and Clash with Teammate Foil Kyle Larson at Iowa
William Byron

Stretches His Fuel to His Second Victory of 2025 At Iowa
Ryan Blaney

Continues A Strong Run of Success At Iowa
Ryan Preece

Eventful Race at Iowa Results In A Top-5 Finish
Denny Hamlin

Struggled Massively At Iowa
Tommy Edman

Likely Going on 10-Day Injured List
Austin Riley

Leaves With Abdominal Pain
Aaron Judge

on Track to Return Tuesday
Max Muncy

Could Return as Early as Monday
Chase Briscoe

Could Chase Briscoe be A Sneaky Play for Iowa Lineups?
Denny Hamlin

Is A Top Driver to Consider for DFS At Iowa
Ryan Blaney

Is A Favorite to Go Back-To-Back With Iowa Victories
Tyler Reddick

has Plenty of Upside for Sunday's Race at Iowa
Carson Hocevar

What Should Fantasy Players do with Carson Hocevar at Iowa?
Chris Buescher

Is Chris Buescher Worth Rostering For Iowa DFS Lineups?
Ty Gibbs

Could Be A Solid DFS Option for Iowa
Logan Henderson

Recalled, Starting Sunday
Jacob Misiorowski

Placed on 15-Day Injured List
Ryan Preece

Offers Plenty of Upside For DFS Lineups At Iowa On Sunday
NASCAR

A.J. Allmendinger Will Start in the Top 10 for the Second Week In A Row at Iowa
Austin Dillon

Could Austin Dillon Be A Decent DFS Option for Iowa?
Michael McDowell

Is Michael McDowell Worth Rostering for Iowa DFS Lineups?
Zane Smith

Should DFS Players Roster Zane Smith At Iowa?
NHL

Jakub Lauko Returns to Czechia
Nicholas Robertson

Signs One-Year Contract with Maple Leafs
Alex Laferriere

Kings Re-Sign Alex Laferriere to Three-Year Deal
Duop Reath

Has Salary Guaranteed by Portland
Luka Dončić

Luka Doncic Agrees to Contract Extension with the Lakers
William Contreras

Goes Deep in Five-Hit Night
Jeremy Peña

Jeremy Pena Exits Early Friday, Expects to Play Saturday
Randy Rodríguez

Randy Rodriguez Named New Giants Closer
Jaden Springer

Signs Exhibit-9 Deal with New Orleans
Julian Champagnie

has Salary Guaranteed by San Antonio
Jackson Chourio

Could be Out a Month
Aaron Judge

Yankees Eyeing Return for Aaron Judge Next Week
Juan Soto

Back in Lineup Against Giants
Conor McGregor

Enters UFC Testing Pool
HyunSung Park

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Tatsuro Taira

Set For UFC Vegas 108 Main Event
Mateusz Rębecki

Mateusz Rebecki Looks For His Second Consecutive Win
Chris Duncan

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Elves Brener

Looks For His Fourth UFC Win
Esteban Ribovics

Set For UFC Vegas 108 Main Card Bout
Elizeu Zaleski dos Santos

Elizeu Zaleski Dos Santos Aims To Bounce Back
Karol Rosa

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Mikal Bridges

Signs Extension with Knicks
Connor McDavid

Oilers Hope to Finalize Connor McDavid's Contract Extension Soon
BUF

Devon Levi Re-Signs With Sabres for Two Years
Martin Pospisil

Signs Three-Year Extension
Dario Šarić

Dario Saric Hoping to Have Meaningful Role with Kings
Donte DiVincenzo

to Skip EuroBasket Due to Injury
Ayo Dosunmu

Set to Remain in Chicago
Malevy Leons

Signs Exhibit 10 Deal With Thunder
Daeqwon Plowden

Kings Pick Up Daeqwon Plowden on Two-Way Deal
Gary Woodland

Eyeing Strong Finish to Reach Playoffs
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF