With the first half of the season in the books, it’s time for one last RotoBaller rankings update. As with our May edition, these rest-of-season rankings come from yours truly and my esteemed colleague Kyle Bishop. We’re each talking about one position per day through Sunday (yesterday was catcher and first base), with today being my turn to stand in at the hot corner.

Check out all of our updated rankings. Adjust your league size, and export your rankings. Tiers, auction values, prospects, news and more. It's all free.

Shall we?

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:

• Fantasy baseball injury reports
• Fantasy baseball trade analyzer
• Daily MLB starting lineups for fantasy baseball
• Fantasy baseball BvP matchups data (Batter vs. Pitcher)
• Fantasy baseball PvB matchups data (Pitcher vs. Batter)
• Who should I start? Fantasy baseball player comparisons
• Fantasy baseball closer depth charts, bullpens, saves
• Fantasy Baseball live scoreboard, daily leaderboards

 

2017 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Third Basemen (Midseason Update)

Ranking	Tier	Player	Position	Kyle	Nick	Composite
1	1	Nolan Arenado	3B	16	6	11
2	1	Kris Bryant	3B/OF	11	14	12.5
3	1	Jose Ramirez	3B/OF	17	25	21
4	2	Manny Machado	SS/3B	27	30	28.5
5	2	Josh Donaldson	3B	28	29	28.5
6	2	Miguel Sano	3B	23	52	37.5
7	2	Anthony Rendon	3B	40	44	42
8	2	Justin Turner	3B	52	39	45.5
9	2	Jake Lamb	3B	33	61	47
10	3	Matt Carpenter	1B/2B/3B	66	54	60
11	3	Travis Shaw	1B/3B	44	82	63
12	3	Adrian Beltre	3B	56	80	68
13	3	Mike Moustakas	3B	72	69	70.5
14	3	Todd Frazier	3B	78	90	84
15	4	Kyle Seager	3B	121	101	111
16	4	Evan Longoria	3B	113	128	120.5
17	4	Ryon Healy	3B	105	198	151.5
18	4	Eugenio Suarez	3B	168	145	156.5
19	4	Chris Taylor	3B	141	185	163
20	4	Alex Bregman	3B	190	146	168
21	4	Jonathan Villar	SS/3B	128	218	173
22	4	Nick Castellanos	3B	221	156	188.5
23	4	Jedd Gyorko	2B/3B	225	166	195.5
24	4	Mark Reynolds	3B	186	223	204.5
25	4	Eduardo Nunez	SS/3B	161	254	207.5
26	5	Joey Gallo	3B	247	193	220
27	5	Brandon Drury	3B/OF	272	184	228
28	5	Hernan Perez	3B/OF	236	298	267
29	5	Maikel Franco	3B	226	318	272
30	5	Chase Headley	3B	#N/A	280	280
31	5	Yangervis Solarte	3B	271	296	283.5
32	5	Danny Valencia	1B/3B/OF	293	#N/A	293
33	5	Yulieski Gurriel	3B	282	305	293.5
34	6	David Freese	1B/3B	#N/A	295	295
35	6	Yunel Escobar	3B	#N/A	306	306
36	6	Yoan Moncada	3B	349	302	325.5
37	6	Martin Prado	3B	#N/A	335	335

 

Midseason Third Base Rankings Analysis

Tier 1

Nevermind that I just traded for Kris Bryant in a desperate get-me-out-of-the-cellar move in the RotoBaller writer’s league, I would still rather have Nolan Arenado the rest of the way. I realize that Sharknado’s raw power totals are a sizeable notch below the 40-homer form of the last two seasons, but Bryant’s own fantasy value has been zapped not by his own hand -- the .928 OPS is wonderful -- but by the lineup around him.

And this is where Arenado continues to derive his value, as his 70 RBI are nearly double KB’s 38. Nolan has one fewer round-tripper thus far and Bryant’s five additional steals don’t give me the confidence to shake Arenado. They cover up one of the brighter ascensions we’ve seen in 2017, as Jose Ramirez has taken his game to a whole new level of funky fresh. He kept the speed, kept the average and upped the power. With a strong year and a half of growth under him, I’m ready to cut him his check.

Tier 2

Here’s where two of the bigger disappointments of ’17 reside, as Manny Machado may still have a shot at notching 35 dingers for the third straight season here but his average has fallen from .294 in ’16 to .230. His BABIP has fallen 70 points despite his hard-hit rate rising by about five percentage points thanks to a line-drive rate that has plummeted from 20 percent to a career-worst 13.9 percent. Meanwhile Josh Donaldson got hurt and has seen his strikeout rate rise from 17 percent to 23.3 percent alongside a 31-point drop in wOBA. The pop and ability to draw walks are still there, but his contact skills are just off.

The rest of the tier is full of happy news, though! Miguel Sano has mastered the three-outcome approach, Anthony Rendon is still streaky but Washington’s offense is just so good, Justin Turner is rocking an insane .377/.473/.583 slash line and Jake Lamb has gone yard 20 times and is tied for the fifth-most RBI in the Majors (67). Of course, Lambchop has to prove that last season’s second-half cold streak was due to injury, and not his own bat.

Tier 3

We could talk about the ever-so-reliable Matt Carpenter doing his thing, the upstart Travis Shaw blossoming in hitter-friendly Miller Park, the legendary Adrian Beltre finally back at full strength or Todd Frazier coming back to life in June. But let’s discuss the meteoric rise of Home Run Derby-participant Mike Moustakas.

After showing strong signs of a breakout in 2016 only to suffer a season-ending knee injury after 27 games, Moose has obliterated his career high in homers (22) with 25 moonshots in his first 329 plate appearances of ’17. His HR/FB rate checked in at 11.2 percent in ’15, then spiked to 19.4 percent in those 27 games in ’16 and currently sits at 20.8 percent now. Do you believe that his 42.5 percent O-swing rate -- the fourth-highest mark in the Majors -- and extreme power approach can hold? We do. Seems like he was made for the year of the fly ball.

Tier 4

Kyle Seager was supposed to be this bastion of consistency, and yet here we are sitting with him trending toward career lows in both homers and average (not counting his short 2011 campaign). Why has his HR/FB rate dropped from 14.6 percent to 7.8 percent? His hitting poorly against southpaws was seen last season (.227 vs. LHP, .307 vs. RHP), except even then he still connected for the long ball with a .204 ISO against them. That mark currently sits at .093.

Last year, his HR/FB rate never sat below 11 percent in any month. He hasn’t cracked 11 percent in any month this season. He hit just .097 against sliders last season, and he’s struggling again in ’17 (.137). His average exit velocity is down from 90.1 mph to 89.2 mph, as his rate of striking balls at 95-plus mph has sunk from 42.4 percent to 34.3 percent. He is simply incrementally worse across the board, but it’s hard for me to dismiss his stellar track record just yet.

There are many other names worth looking at, such as the upstart Chris Taylor (who I should probably swap slot-for-slot with recent Twitter big-boy Alex Bregman). The also-flailing Jonathan Villar, who I have given up hope on. Nick Castellanos is another xwOBA-wOBA wonderchild, but he’s socked six homers while hitting at a .311 clip so we’re cool now.

Tier 5

So, it looks like I really like Brandon Drury and dislike Maikel Franco more than Kyle. That’s fair. Drury has shown basically zero growth from last season and appears on track for an unspectacular 60/15/75/.285 line, but I also have to weigh up his versatility and I honestly just love getting pieces of top-tier offenses. Without a humidor in sight, I’m still in.

As for Franco, I guess I’m just amazed at how he’s improved his raw contact skills (Z-contact rate up two percentage points, strikeouts down over three percentage points) only to see his BABIP fall off from .271 to .215 with a three-percentage-point drop in hard-hit rate. That 27.7 percent hard-hit rate checks in at 146^th out of 166 qualified hitters, and thus, I check out on Franco.

Tier 6

With the White Sox trading away Jose Quintana, it appears the dominoes are finally falling for the rebuild effort and soon enough we should see Yoan Moncada. While his overall 53/11/32/16/.278 slash line at Triple-A looks healthy enough, he is on a bit of a cold streak over his last 10 games (8-for-37 with two homers, 14 strikeouts and caught stealing twice on three attempts). I doubt the South Siders will let that dissuade them from their plans, but the point is that he isn’t exactly pressing them into a callup at the moment either. Please note, I’m still excited to see him play, but prepare for some serious rookie turbulence.

 

More Rankings & Analysis