X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Join the Best Live Fantasy Chat Community!

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

2016 Fantasy Baseball Tiered Rankings: Catcher (February)

As pitchers and catchers report, I too am here to report with another round of catcher rankings analysis. The analysis focuses on one-catcher standard leagues.

In deeper and two-catcher leagues, you will want to prioritize the safer options. You'll also want to drop the higher-risk/higher-reward options lower in your rankings, as the waiver wire will be less fruitful. As you will see below, outside of the top two players, catcher is a position where I would wait on and seek value depending on my risk tolerance.

By the way, in case you've been living under a rock, be sure to also check out our 2016 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard, which is already loaded up with lots of great articles. Aside from staff rankings across all positions, we also dig into MLB prospect rankings, and dynasty/keeper rankings as well. With that said, onto the specific analysis we now go.

 

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings Analysis: Catchers

Unsurprisingly, Buster Posey is in the top tier by himself. Posey has been remarkably consistent at a position where such consistency is rare. In each of his five years with 108 games played or more (four of them between 147 and 150 games), he has hit between .294 and .336, with 15-24 homers. Over the past four years, he has averaged 72 runs and 90 RBIs. He will not hit the most homers at the position and likely will not steal bases, but he will be a large boost to your average while contributing at three of the four remaining categories.

Now, if you ditch the high performing model and go with the sexy option, the one man second tier is for you. That tier is comprised of Kyle "Hulk" Schwarber, who has lived up to that moniker with his overall performance as well as an epic shot last postseason. As the current option in left field, he should (1) get a full plate of games and (2) have dual eligibility, although it is unlikely that you would use him as an outfielder.

While he only played 69 games, his 162 game adjusted numbers are .246/38/122/101/7. Moreover, in nine postseason games, he hit 5 homers with 6 runs, 8 RBIs and a .333 batting average. Schwarber also hit extremely well at each level of the minors. While pitchers will now have a book on him, he is the guy to select if you are seeking enormous upside. However, Posey's numbers and reliability still place him ahead of Schwarber in each of our rankings.

Once you get past the first two tiers, the best plan is to start searching for value. The Rotoballer tiers 3-5 are as follows: third (Russell Martin, Jonathan Lucroy, Travis d'Arnaud and Brian McCann); fourth (Yasmani Grandal, Devin Mesoraco and Salvador Perez); and, fifth (Matt Wieters, Stephen Vogt, Yan Gomes). However, I have them all close together (except Vogt) and would draft based on my risk tolerance, and within that grouping, wait for the player who slipped rather than being one of the first few to select from this group. I split this large group into (a) low risk, (b) 2015 injury but moderate risk, and (c) relatively higher injury risk. The injury risks are fairly subjective, but this is how I see them. In deeper leagues, groups (a) and (b) hold more value relative to group (c) than in shallower leagues

Group (a) consists of Martin, McCann and Perez. McCann has hit between .230 and .232 three of the past four years, with homers ranging from 20-26. Last year, his RBIs spiked to 94 and his runs to 68, whereas in the prior three years they ranged from 57-75 and 43-57. With a good Yankee lineup, his run production totals should stay on the high end if healthy. Martin hit .240/23/76/77/4 last year, and those numbers seem reasonable going forward. Perez seems like another similar option who will likely post a better average but lag in the other categories.

Group (b) consists of Wieters, Lucroy and Gomes. Wieters is now almost two years removed from his Tommy John surgery, and heated up at the end of last year. In three seasons before his Tommy John, he hit 22 or 23 homers each year. His career average is .258. Likely batting around sixth in a powerful Orioles' lineup, his run production could also be good. He is one of my favorite value plays being drafted as the eighth catcher overall. He could produce value similar to McCann and Martin.

Lucroy is coming off a down year battling back from injury, but is not worth his average draft position of the third catcher. While he batted .320, .280, and .301 before his injury-plagued season last year, and .289 after the break last year, his run production is limited in a weak lineup, and he likely will not steal more than a few bases. A high average with average power and run production is what one should expect.

Gomes hit .294 with 11 homers in 88 games in 2013, and followed up with .278/21/61/74 in 2014. Last year he posted .231/12/38/45 in 95 games in an injury-riddled season After the break, however, he hit .241 with 9 homers in 54 games. While he is less valuable than the other two, he is enough in the neighborhood that he could be a value play at his 11th overall catcher draft position.

Group (c) consists of Grandal, d'Arnaud and Mesoraco. I include them here as Grandal and Mesoraco are coming off of significant injuries, and d'Arnaud has had multiple injuries. Grandal put up a first half line of .282/14/35/36. He fought through a shoulder injury later in the season before having offseason surgery. Mesoraco broke out in 2014, posting .273/25/54/80 in 114 games. He suffered a hip injury last season, however, and put up poor numbers before shutting it down. d'Arnaud likewise suffered an injury last year. In 67 games (approximately half a season of at bats for a catcher), he posted .268/12/31/41. These are true high risk, high reward options.

Among the deeper tiers, Nick Hundley, Welington Castillo, and Wilson Ramos could be worth a look. Ramos, who has been unsuccessfully picked to breakout in the past, hit 15 homers in 128 games last year with 68 RBIs, and is only 28 this year. He is the 21st catcher off of draft boards. Hundley posted a .301/10/45/46 line in Colorado last year, despite playing in only 103 games; his health is worth monitoring in the spring, and he could rise from currently being the 19th catcher selected. Castillo broke out last year after landing in Arizona; in 80 games, he posted an extraordinary .255/17/34/50 line. He is being selected 13th overall.

 

Catcher Tiered Fantasy Baseball Rankings (February)

Ranking Tier Name Brad Max Kyle Nick Harris Jeff Bill
1 1 Buster Posey 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
2 2 Kyle Schwarber 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
3 3 Russell Martin 3 4 3 3 3 3 3
4 3 Jonathan Lucroy 5 3 6 5 6 6 4
5 3 Travis d'Arnaud 4 5 4 4 5 7 6
6 3 Brian McCann 6 6 5 6 4 4 5
7 4 Yasmani Grandal 7 8 7 9 7 10 10
8 4 Devin Mesoraco 8 7 8 7 8 11 9
9 4 Salvador Perez 9 11 9 8 11 8 8
10 5 Matt Wieters 17 9 14 10 16 5 7
11 5 Stephen Vogt 13 15 11 11 12 15 12
12 5 Yan Gomes 16 17 10 12 17 9 11
13 6 Derek Norris 10 10 18 16 9 14 19
14 6 Nick Hundley 14 16 17 13 13 12 14
15 6 Francisco Cervelli 11 12 13 17 14 17 16
16 6 Blake Swihart 12 14 12 18 15 16 13
17 6 Welington Castillo 15 19 15 15 19 13 18
18 6 J.T. Realmuto 19 13 16 14 18 20 20
19 6 Miguel Montero 22 18 19 19 10 21 21
20 7 JR Murphy 18 20 20 23 23 18 23
21 7 Yadier Molina 24 21 22 20 22 22 15
22 7 Wilson Ramos 21 22 28 22 20 19 17
23 7 Robinson Chirinos 20 26 24 21 25 24 22
24 7 Dioner Navarro 23 27 24 24 24 23 27
25 8 Cameron Rupp 27 29 23 25 28 25 24
26 8 Hank Conger 25 23 25 26 34 28 25
27 8 A.J. Pierzynski 29 24 21 27 29 30 -
28 8 Jason Castro 30 25 30 28 26 26 30
29 8 James McCann 26 28 29 30 30 27 26
30 9 Chris Iannetta 28 30 32 31 21 29 28
31 9 Caleb Joseph - 32 26 29 36 - -
32 9 Jarrod Saltalamacchia - 31 27 32 37 - -
33 9 Curt Casali - 37 - - 27 - -
34 9 Tyler Flowers - 33 - - 38 - 29
35 9 Josh Phegley 31 34 31 - 39 - -
36 9 Kurt Suzuki - 35 - - 33 - -
37 9 Alex Avlia - 36 - - 32 - -
38 9 Carlos Perez - 39 - - 31 - -
39 9 Carlos Ruiz - 38 - - 35 - -
40 9 Geovany Soto - 40 - - 40 - -

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Jesper Fast15 mins ago

Remains Out On Thursday
Matt Martin24 mins ago

A Game-Time Call Thursday
Anton Lundell32 mins ago

Takes Over As Second-Line Center Thursday
Deebo Samuel38 mins ago

49ers Have Discussed Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk In Trade Talks
Ryan Lomberg39 mins ago

Ruled Out For Game 3
Chicago Bears1 hour ago

Bears Willing To Trade Down From Ninth Pick
Zack Gelof2 hours ago

A's Place Zack Gelof On 10-Day Injured List
Alec Marsh2 hours ago

Lands On Injured List
Keibert Ruiz2 hours ago

Back From The Injured List
Jackson Merrill2 hours ago

Scratched With Groin Tigthness
Nolan Jones3 hours ago

Remains Sidelined Thursday
Los Angeles Rams3 hours ago

Rams Trying To Move Into Top 10
Max Muncy4 hours ago

On The Bench Thursday
Drake Maye4 hours ago

Giants Trying To Trade Up For Drake Maye
Alex Vlasic4 hours ago

Inks Six-Year Extension With Blackhawks
Kyle Okposo4 hours ago

To Suit Up In Game 3
William Nylander4 hours ago

Reportedly Dealing With Migraine Issue
Framber Valdez4 hours ago

To Start Sunday
Brett Pesce4 hours ago

Tony DeAngelo To Replace Brett Pesce
Cal Raleigh4 hours ago

Back In The Lineup Thursday
J.P. Crawford4 hours ago

Heading To The Injured List
Sam Bennett4 hours ago

To Miss At Least A Week
Ceddanne Rafaela5 hours ago

The Team's Everyday Shortstop
Vaughn Grissom5 hours ago

Unlikely To Return This Weekend
Rafael Devers5 hours ago

Likely To Return To Third Base On Saturday
Corey Seager5 hours ago

Serving As Designated Hitter Against Seattle
Jonathan India6 hours ago

Back In Action Thursday
Bryce Harper6 hours ago

Back From Paternity List
Jack Eichel7 hours ago

Makes NHL History In Game 2 Win
Brad Marchand7 hours ago

Racks Up Three Points In Game 3 Victory
Leon Draisaitl7 hours ago

Posts Two Assists In Wednesday's Loss
Anze Kopitar7 hours ago

Completes Three-Point Night With Overtime Game-Winner
Mason Marchment7 hours ago

Exits With Injury Wednesday
Radek Faksa7 hours ago

Injured In Game 2
Trey Murphy7 hours ago

III Cools Off In Game 2
CJ McCollum8 hours ago

Blows Hot And Cold In Game 2
Brandon Ingram8 hours ago

Overcomes Cold Start In Game 2
Jonas Valanciunas8 hours ago

Leads Pelicans In Scoring Wednesday
Jalen Williams8 hours ago

Contributes In All Areas Wednesday
Chet Holmgren8 hours ago

Sets The Tone For Thunder In Game 2
Uros Medic8 hours ago

A Massive Favorite At UFC Vegas 91
Tim Means8 hours ago

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 91
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander8 hours ago

Leads Thunder To Victory
Austen Lane8 hours ago

Searching For First UFC Win
Jhonata Diniz8 hours ago

Making UFC Debut
Bogdan Guskov8 hours ago

Gets Ranked Opponent At UFC Vegas 91
Ryan Spann8 hours ago

Looks To Snap Losing Skid At UFC Vegas 91
Garrett Whitlock17 hours ago

Still Not Cleared For Mound Work
Max Scherzer17 hours ago

Serves Up Two Homers In Rehab Start
John Means17 hours ago

Could Start Sunday
Alec Marsh17 hours ago

X-Rays Come Back Negative On Alec Marsh
Francisco Lindor17 hours ago

Comes Alive With Two Long Balls
Shohei Ohtani17 hours ago

Three Doubles For Shohei Ohtani
Naz Reid19 hours ago

Named Sixth Man Of The Year
Mitchell Robinson19 hours ago

Questionable For Game 3
Joel Embiid19 hours ago

Questionable For Game 3
Bam Adebayo20 hours ago

Looks Good In Win Over Boston
Kristaps Porzingis20 hours ago

Struggles Offensively In Game 2
Jayson Tatum20 hours ago

Has A Decent Showing On Wednesday
Jaylen Brown20 hours ago

Leads The Way In Game 2
Tyler Herro20 hours ago

Gets It Done On Wednesday Night
Dallas Cowboys21 hours ago

Cowboys Pick Up Micah Parsons' Fifth-Year Option
Ezekiel Elliott22 hours ago

Cowboys Meeting With Ezekiel Elliott
Cincinnati Bengals22 hours ago

Trey Hendrickson Requests A Trade From Bengals
Nic Claxton23 hours ago

Nicolas Claxton The "No. 1 Priority" For Nets In Offseason
Grayson Allen23 hours ago

Not Ruled Out For Game 3
Nikola Jovic23 hours ago

Available For Game 2
Ryan Lomberg24 hours ago

Could Be Back For Game 3
Cam Talbot1 day ago

Starts Game 2 For Kings
Logan Thompson1 day ago

Heads Out For Another Win Wednesday
Jake Oettinger1 day ago

Tries To Bounce Back Wednesday
Jani Hakanpaa1 day ago

Remains Out On Wednesday
Tyler Myers1 day ago

Battling The Flu
Michael Penix Jr.1 day ago

Could Be Among Top-Four Quarterbacks Selected
Jared Goff1 day ago

No New Deal “Imminent” For Jared Goff
J.J. McCarthy1 day ago

Broncos Interested In J.J. McCarthy
Detroit Lions1 day ago

Penei Sewell Becomes Highest-Paid Offensive Lineman
Justin Fields1 day ago

Steelers Not Expected To Pick Up Justin Fields' Fifth-Year Option
Rashod Bateman1 day ago

Ravens Sign Rashod Bateman To Contract Extension
Ja'Marr Chase1 day ago

Bengals Exercise Ja'Marr Chase's Fifth-Year Option
Amon-Ra St. Brown1 day ago

Lions Agree To Four-Year Extension With Amon-Ra St. Brown
James Harden1 day ago

Settles For 22 Points In Game 2
Luka Doncic1 day ago

Leads All Scorers With 32 Points In Game 2
Damian Lillard1 day ago

Scores 34 Points In Losing Effort
Brandon Aiyuk2 days ago

Trade Remains "Very Much In Play"
Denver Broncos2 days ago

Broncos Pick Up Fifth-Year Option On Patrick Surtain II
New England Patriots2 days ago

Patriots Haven't Received "Serious" Offers For No. 3 Pick
Kadarius Toney2 days ago

Still In Chiefs' Plans
Jake Browning2 days ago

Bengals Re-Sign Jake Browning
Brandon Aiyuk3 days ago

49ers Have Received Calls Regarding Brandon Aiyuk
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Survives At Talladega For First Win Of 2024
Brad Keselowski3 days ago

Finishes Second At Talladega After Last-Lap Wreck
Anthony Alfredo3 days ago

Gets Best Finish For Beard Motorsports Since 2022
Todd Gilliland3 days ago

One Of The Strongest At Talladega
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Finishes 36th At Talladega Superspeedway
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Fails To Deliver Value In DFS At Talladega
NASCAR4 days ago

Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Finishes Fourth At Talladega
Noah Gragson4 days ago

Surprisingly The Most Consistent Driver At Talladega
Shane Van Gisbergen4 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen Acquits Himself Nicely In Drafting Debut
Michael McDowell4 days ago

Ends Talladega Wrecked From The Lead
Alex Bowman4 days ago

Quietly Captures Top-Five Finish At Talladega
Daniel Hemric4 days ago

Surges To Ninth-Place Result At Talladega
Harrison Burton4 days ago

Squeezes Into Top 10 At Talladega
NASCAR4 days ago

Bubba Wallace Will Start 14th For the GEICO 500
Tyler Reddick4 days ago

Avoid Rostering Tyler Reddick At Talladega?
John Hunter Nemechek4 days ago

Should DFS Players Roster John Hunter Nemechek At Talladega?
Joey Logano4 days ago

Expect Joey Logano To Compete For The Win At Talladega
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Is Denny Hamlin Recommended For Talladega?
Justin Haley4 days ago

Is A Top DFS Value At Talladega
William Byron4 days ago

Is One Of The Top Favorites To Win Talladega
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Is Best Suited As A Tournament Play At Talladega
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
Kyler Murray - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft - Why Do The Bears, Cardinals, and Vikings Have Two First-Round Picks?

The NFL Draft is always one of the most exciting days for organizations and fans, but fans of teams with more than one first-round pick are even more excited and overjoyed. In the 2024 NFL Draft, three teams have multiple picks on Day 1. Landing two studs on the first day of the event can... Read More


Brian Thomas Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft: What Time Is The NFL Draft Tonight? How To Watch Thursday's Draft Picks

It’s finally here, RotoBallers! After months of waiting and speculation, the 2024 NFL Draft starts tonight. Along with the Super Bowl and the Kickoff Game that starts the season, Draft Day is one of the most exciting days on the NFL calendar. The anticipation is over and it is time to get things rolling. It... Read More


Darius Slayton - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft - Veterans With The Most Fantasy Football Value To Lose On Draft Night

It's almost here! The first round of the 2024 NFL Draft will take place tonight in Detroit, with 32 players set to join their first NFL team after all is said and done. But those players aren't just being drafted into empty roster spots. The NFL is a zero-sum game. For every new player that... Read More


2024 NFL Draft: Biggest Fantasy Football Questions

Football never sleeps at RotoBaller! The 2024 NFL Draft is upon us and anticipation is high for what could be a wild edition that will likely have huge fantasy football implications for the season ahead. RotoBaller's David Rispoli digs into the biggest fantasy football questions of the 2024 NFL Draft. What draft decisions could have... Read More


2024 NFL Draft Mock Spectacular - Woo Fantasy Podcast

Rotoballer analyst Brandon Murchison (@RotoSuperstar) is joined by co-host Nick Hefley (@therealffgoat) as they dive into their final first-round mock for the 2024 NFL Draft. With what is expected to be a wild and crazy night of selections and potential moves, where will the most coveted players for fantasy managers land? They discuss landing spots... Read More


2024 NFL Draft: Three Shocking Predictions for Round 1

Football never sleeps at RotoBaller! The 2024 NFL Draft is upon us and anticipation is high for what could be a wild First Round. RotoBaller's David Rispoli drops three bold predictions for what could happen in Round 1 of the NFL Draft on Thursday night. Win MORE in 2024 with RotoBaller! Be sure to tune... Read More


Marvin Harrison Jr. - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, WR, NFL Draft Sleepers

2024 NFL Mock Draft: Rounds 1, 2, 3 Predictions (Final Mock)

It is the most magical week of the year, when the mysticism of Gandalf, Harry Potter, and all the power of your aunt's healing crystals cannot combine to match the aura surrounding NFL Draft week! With the best week of the year here and just a few days until the actual NFL Draft begins, it... Read More


Malachi Corley - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft - Ranking the Top-10 Small School Prospects

While many of the top NFL players came from large colleges, there's always some talented players that slip through the cracks in recruiting and wind up at either a Group of Five school or an FCS school. Some of the NFL's top stars didn't come from the Power 5. Randy Moss played at Marshall. Khalil... Read More


Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

2024 Fantasy Football Rookie Mock Draft - Last Look Before Draft Day

There's a lot of people who wait until after the NFL Draft to do their fantasy football rookie drafts. It makes sense -- knowing where a player ends up is a huge part of what helps determine their fantasy football value. Still, it can be fun to do a last-minute rookie draft before we know... Read More


Laiatu Latu - NFL, Draft, EDGE, Prospect, DST, Defense, Rankings

2024 NFL Draft - Who Will Be The First Defensive Player Selected?

It is now finally time for the 2024 NFL Draft. With a plethora of offensive talent available, this feels like one of the more loaded draft classes in recent memory from an offensive point of view. Quarterbacks and skill players have gotten most of the headlines, but there are still players on the defensive side... Read More


Adonai Mitchell - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2024 NFL Draft: Top 100 Prospect Rankings (Final Update)

With the NFL Draft just a day away, it’s time to submit my final rankings for this class. Below, you will find the top-100 prospects on my board for 2024. There will be some changes from last month, as well as some surprises. Feel free to criticize my choices and views on the platform formerly... Read More


Rome Odunze - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

Final 2024 First-Round NFL Mock Draft - Predictions for all 32 Teams

It's Christmas Eve. The NFL Draft is my favorite day of the year, and the picks made tomorrow night will have an enormous impact on the future of the NFL. With the Chicago Bears expected to select Caleb Williams at No. 1, the real draft begins at No. 2, where the Washington Commanders' pick remains... Read More


Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, College FB, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

2024 NFL Draft - Brandon Murchison's First-Round NFL Mock Draft

In the realm of fantasy football, anticipation and strategy reach a fever pitch as the NFL Draft approaches. Every selection, every pick holds the potential to reshape not only the fortunes of real-life franchises but also the fantasy landscape for millions of enthusiasts. As the curtain rises on this year's first-round NFL Mock Draft, fantasy managers... Read More